Silver Spring, Maryland, US
I'm new to Lightroom, I'm trying to find and understand a workflow order from between the two. What do I do in LR, or should do in LR vs. PS. And what should I do in PS vs. LR? I usually do all my retouching in PS. But I'm eager to learn LR as well. The main reason I got LR is to shoot tethered. So help please. I finally workflow starting to finish would be excellent.
Dec 26 12 10:57 am Link
Fort Jones, California, US
I'm fairly new - so don't put to much weight on this, but I use LR for most any kind of lighting problem ie. exposure, levels-type adjustments, noise reduction, camera profile adjustments, gradient filter, white balance, and sometimes a B&W conversion. The only other thing I commonly use it for is eyes. I like the red eye removal better the PS and I also use a bit of the "Iris enhance" local brush adjustment. Just for fun, I'll use it for duetones, or the existing presets to get additional looks. So far I have not used any of the presets in my final image.
Hope this helps!
Dec 26 12 11:16 am Link
Syracuse, New York, US
The only thing I do in PS really is skin work and maybe some cloning/patch work if its needed.
Lightroom I do all color, exposure, crop, etc. I like making my own presets to use and batch processing. So much quicker and easier in LR over Photoshop IMO.
Dec 26 12 11:35 am Link
West Des Moines, Iowa, US
If you are starting with jpegs, I don't think there is much advantage in using LR/ACR.
If you are starting with raw files, Lightroom (and ACR) is slightly superior at global tone controls - camera profiles, white balance, exposure, highlight and shadow recovery, etc.
LR/ACR is also a bit better than Photoshop at noise reduction and sharpening (capture sharpening, but probably not creative or output sharpening). Although many argue that 3rd party plugins are better than either.
Adjusting color and saturation is a more complicated issue. Sometimes LR/ACR has an advantage, sometimes Photoshop is superior. For example, the basic saturation and vibrance sliders in LR/ACR are inferior to the various methods available in Photoshop. Yet LR/ACR has some targeted color controls that are not available in Photoshop. The LR/ACR pallet for HSL has 8 color controls, including a valuable orange slider that is uesful on skin tones. Photoshop's Hue/Sat has only 6 color controls, Selective Color has only 5.
The most important difference between LR/ACR and Photoshop comes in masking, where Photoshop has a dominant superiority. Not only in hand painting masks, but in generating complex custom masks. Specifically, luminosity masks and saturation masks available in Photoshop can not be made in LR/ACR.
So, my advice, do as much as you can with global tone adjustments, sharpening, and noise reduction in LR/ACR. Then move to Photoshop for fine tuning of tones and colors, plus any cloning healing.
When doing global tone adjustments in LR/ACR I always leave a little room in the histogram for the further processing in Photoshop. If you push the highlights and shadows to their max in LR/ACR, then you may have problems with clipping in Photoshop.
Dec 26 12 12:49 pm Link
Toronto, Ontario, Canada
Dec 26 12 01:51 pm Link
Silver Spring, Maryland, US
Dec 27 12 05:37 pm Link