Forums > Critique > Would I recommend you based on your top row?

Photographer

Thatcher Photography

Posts: 1033

Fort Worth, Texas, US

Cole Morrison wrote:
?

Yes

Feb 03 13 07:47 am Link

Photographer

Thatcher Photography

Posts: 1033

Fort Worth, Texas, US

Emily Smiles wrote:
me please?

Yes - The tear sheets almost killed it for me though. Tear sheets are cool but I would try to use the real image so it is all about you. Then put the tear sheet on your profile page.

Feb 03 13 07:49 am Link

Photographer

Thatcher Photography

Posts: 1033

Fort Worth, Texas, US

Art Silva Photography wrote:
I'm game smile

Yes - 2nd and 4th won it for me. The 1st and 3rd would have been a no due to the amount/style of post work.

Feb 03 13 07:51 am Link

Photographer

Thatcher Photography

Posts: 1033

Fort Worth, Texas, US

Kerri Jean wrote:
I'm game as well. smile

No - If your models set better moods it would be a yes.

Feb 03 13 07:52 am Link

Photographer

Thatcher Photography

Posts: 1033

Fort Worth, Texas, US

DRaskin Photography wrote:
Sure, take a look and let me know.

Tough call!

No - More like your 1st one and then a yes.

Feb 03 13 07:54 am Link

Photographer

Thatcher Photography

Posts: 1033

Fort Worth, Texas, US

Kanahara23 wrote:
I am up for game

No - Finished out looks and a pro team would help.

Feb 03 13 07:55 am Link

Photographer

Neil Snape

Posts: 9473

Paris, Île-de-France, France

I leave the recent ones at the top, they are not necessarily my best rows. And if you have view all on , it's mens first..

Anyway tell me.

Feb 03 13 07:58 am Link

Photographer

Thatcher Photography

Posts: 1033

Fort Worth, Texas, US

BCADULTART wrote:
Love to read your thoughts.  All images are +18

Thanks,
Chuck

No - More like the 3rd shot would help.

Feb 03 13 08:00 am Link

Photographer

Thatcher Photography

Posts: 1033

Fort Worth, Texas, US

Paul Tirado Photography wrote:
Take a look and let me know.

YES

Feb 03 13 08:00 am Link

Photographer

Thatcher Photography

Posts: 1033

Fort Worth, Texas, US

Amelia Rouge wrote:
How about me?

No - Better photographers would help.

Feb 03 13 08:01 am Link

Photographer

Thatcher Photography

Posts: 1033

Fort Worth, Texas, US

APS-Chicago wrote:
Hmmmmm, what do you say?

Yes - However the post/burn on the 1st and 3rd almost killed it. It is very obvious on the maternity one.

This one should be up there.
http://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/120319/19/4f67f137f11a6_m.jpg

Feb 03 13 08:08 am Link

Photographer

Thatcher Photography

Posts: 1033

Fort Worth, Texas, US

Trey Fleming wrote:
Sure

No - More range of mood would make it a yes. I think a laughing or smile shot would have done the trick. Love the 4th one though!

Feb 03 13 08:11 am Link

Photographer

Rev James B Photography

Posts: 4

Bullhead City, Arizona, US

What about mine?

Feb 03 13 08:11 am Link

Photographer

Thatcher Photography

Posts: 1033

Fort Worth, Texas, US

Project4145 wrote:
If you're still going. 

Your work is terrific.

Yes - 1st and 3rd won me over.

Feb 03 13 08:13 am Link

Photographer

Thatcher Photography

Posts: 1033

Fort Worth, Texas, US

Jeannie Kayla wrote:
Agree, let's have some fun. Thanks.

Yes

Feb 03 13 08:14 am Link

Photographer

Thatcher Photography

Posts: 1033

Fort Worth, Texas, US

MidnightSun Designs wrote:
yes

No - But if you moved these up yes. I do dig the 4th one though.

http://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/120301/18/4f5033f4bf2d9_m.jpg

http://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/120511/18/4fadb67b3fda5_m.jpg

Feb 03 13 08:17 am Link

Photographer

Thatcher Photography

Posts: 1033

Fort Worth, Texas, US

Arya-Tara wrote:
I want to play smile

No - More mood and separate shoots would help.

These would have made it a yes.

http://www.modelmayhem.com/portfolio/pic/31037083 18+

http://www.modelmayhem.com/portfolio/pic/31037080 18+

Feb 03 13 08:22 am Link

Photographer

Maria Panina

Posts: 139

New York, New York, US

Would you?

Feb 03 13 08:23 am Link

Photographer

Thatcher Photography

Posts: 1033

Fort Worth, Texas, US

Mike Williams Photo wrote:
I'm in. Hit me.

No - Cute model, nice shots - Putting up your strongest shot from each shoot would make this a yes.

Feb 03 13 08:25 am Link

Photographer

Thatcher Photography

Posts: 1033

Fort Worth, Texas, US

Jeff Cohn wrote:
sure why not

No - the lack of mood from your top 4 models killed it. Great camera/post work though!

This would have made it a YES!

http://www.modelmayhem.com/portfolio/pic/29706347 18+

Feb 03 13 08:30 am Link

Photographer

Thatcher Photography

Posts: 1033

Fort Worth, Texas, US

The Alternative Image  wrote:
I am interested.

No - More mood and feeling in the eyes of your models would make this a yes. Love the funk factor!!

Feb 03 13 08:35 am Link

Photographer

The Alternative Image

Posts: 4129

London, England, United Kingdom

Thatcher Photography wrote:

No - More mood and feeling in the eyes of your models would make this a yes. Love the funk factor!!

Thanks, I will take that on board.

Feb 03 13 08:39 am Link

Photographer

Thatcher Photography

Posts: 1033

Fort Worth, Texas, US

Neil Snape wrote:
I leave the recent ones at the top, they are not necessarily my best rows. And if you have view all on , it's mens first..

Anyway tell me.

View all - Yes - The 2nd and 3rd shot won me over. At first I was going to say no because I felt like the 1st and 4th shots were not very strong.

I really wanted to see more on this shot. I pulled it up and blocked out the surrounding light making a hand viewfinder and you sold me big time on a yes. Ha!!
http://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/100319/02/4ba3489819093_m.jpg

Feb 03 13 08:46 am Link

Photographer

arootphotography

Posts: 92

Thornton, Colorado, US

me?

Feb 03 13 08:49 am Link

Photographer

Thatcher Photography

Posts: 1033

Fort Worth, Texas, US

Holy Shoots wrote:
What about mine?

No - I think shots with less post work would help.

Feb 03 13 08:49 am Link

Photographer

Thatcher Photography

Posts: 1033

Fort Worth, Texas, US

Maria Panina wrote:
Would you?

No - More like this would make it a yes.

http://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/120708/16/4ffa170751af3_m.jpg

Feb 03 13 08:50 am Link

Model

angel emily

Posts: 1020

Boston, Massachusetts, US

Curious, thanks! smile

Feb 03 13 08:50 am Link

Photographer

Art Silva

Posts: 9451

Santa Barbara, California, US

Thatcher Photography wrote:
Yes - 2nd and 4th won it for me. The 1st and 3rd would have been a no due to the amount/style of post work.

Thanks... just fyi, Only did traditional dodge and burn vignetting  and in the case of #3 an added textured overlay... Thats it, I don't like sitting in front of PS all day, my "style" stems from old darkroom printing techniques

Feb 03 13 09:52 am Link

Photographer

Steve Wall

Posts: 623

Sydney, New South Wales, Australia

I'm in!

And by the way, just looked at your portfolio, hell yeah!

Feb 03 13 12:13 pm Link

Photographer

RachelReilly

Posts: 1730

Washington, District of Columbia, US

Ill play!
Edit- I just read the top first row part lol
They're all the same

Feb 03 13 03:31 pm Link

Photographer

Garry k

Posts: 27189

Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada

how bout my second row ... i think its my best

Feb 03 13 03:37 pm Link

Photographer

Barely StL

Posts: 911

Saint Louis, Missouri, US

Barely StL wrote:
Would you?

Thatcher Photography wrote:
No - Show more range in your top shots (I do love the 3rd one though). It looks like you want to get out of the studio. Give it a shot!

I will - as soon as we get some warmer weather.

We had 3 inches of snow last night. I know a model wno wants to do a nude snow angel shoot - but she couldn't get to St. Louis before most of the snow melted today.

Feb 03 13 04:50 pm Link

Model

Ceci L

Posts: 235

Villena, Valencia, Spain

Will??

Feb 03 13 04:57 pm Link

Retoucher

MSL Retouch

Posts: 244

Miami, Florida, US

Interested!

Feb 03 13 04:59 pm Link

Model

Maggie Xia

Posts: 452

Atlanta, Georgia, US

what do u think? smile

Feb 03 13 05:31 pm Link

Model

C A T H Y

Posts: 5464

Anaheim, California, US

I'd like to know smile

Feb 03 13 05:38 pm Link

Model

Kayla199

Posts: 40

Auckland, Auckland, New Zealand

???

Feb 03 13 05:42 pm Link

Model

Ashlyn Orion

Posts: 35

Ashland, Oregon, US

?

Feb 03 13 05:47 pm Link

Photographer

David Kirk

Posts: 4501

Ottawa, Ontario, Canada

I'll play too!

Feb 03 13 05:48 pm Link

Photographer

Thatcher Photography

Posts: 1033

Fort Worth, Texas, US

arootphotography wrote:
me?

No - More like this would make it a yes.

http://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/120701/09/4ff0817a8d209_m.jpg

Feb 03 13 09:17 pm Link