today saw those images in fashiongoneroge and fell in love with
when began to see with more attention, saw that they have been "painted" a bit roughly,
now, my question is
IS THAT ACCEPTABLE? I MEAN, are MAGAZINES ACCEPTING THE COLOUR BANDING USUALLY, or this was just an exception?
don t want critisize the work, just wondering, if it was the intention of the editor
GlamourBiancaBalti5 por hola soy wanda, en Flickr
522104_10152412217672837_1084632708_n por hola soy wanda, en Flickr
Apr 21 13 03:54 pm Link
Columbus, Ohio, US
I wouldn't say they were painted.
Looks more like there's an issue with color banding in the shadows.
Apr 21 13 04:01 pm Link
Adelaide, South Australia, Australia
Looks like color separation or banding issues to me. Poor form really. I doubt it was the intention of the editor.
Apr 21 13 04:02 pm Link
Santa Cruz, California, US
Paul Snyder wrote:
Apr 21 13 04:09 pm Link
so, it s a normal practice? it s a print fault?
Apr 21 13 04:12 pm Link
Buffalo, New York, US
I'm going to assume the 99.9% of other people looking at this really don't give a shit.
Apr 21 13 05:12 pm Link
Duluth, Georgia, US
Apr 21 13 06:59 pm Link
Seattle, Washington, US
Apr 21 13 07:05 pm Link
Raleigh, North Carolina, US
That can also come from adding too much contrast or too much saturation to the scene.
Apr 21 13 07:25 pm Link
Sevilla, Andalusia, Spain
I think it is when change to CMYK without the gamut warning.
Apr 22 13 10:04 am Link
Tarragona, Catalonia, Spain
Definitely not painted!!
Apr 22 13 12:39 pm Link
Amsterdam, Noord-Holland, Netherlands
I can imagine the client gives a sh&*&t...
Apr 25 13 09:04 pm Link
Columbus, Ohio, US
If you have noticeable color banding, I can attest that they will, in fact, "give a sh*t"
Apr 25 13 11:21 pm Link
Tel Aviv-Yafo, Tel Aviv, Israel
Usually something like this will happen when trying to recover shadowed areas.
Why? how can a magazine approve? did no one notice?
Well, there are many possible answers for that. but it doesnt matter. In this industry you have to make short term calls, and stick to it. Do whatever you can with the time given you.
May 01 13 03:33 am Link
if you pulled this image from the website, dont be suprised as it will be a jpeg as the image doesnt look very hi res
oh yes, they are from the website,
May 01 13 08:12 am Link
i would bet then the colours were fine in the print and its just jpeg issues.
May 01 13 08:18 am Link
Sibiu, Sibiu, Romania
I don't think that on print there is the problem like the preview showed, i think thats a web problem.
May 01 13 03:03 pm Link
Naperville, Illinois, US
May 01 13 03:12 pm Link