Forums >
Off-Topic Discussion >
Do you believe in reincarnation/past lives?
I will come back and write more later, but I wanted to pose the question... P.S. Here is an interesting link dealing with personal stories about the subject: http://www.beyondreligion.com/su_person … -index.htm Apr 30 13 10:04 pm Link EvaScarlet wrote: really? like how much later? Apr 30 13 10:08 pm Link I'm more or less agnostic, I do pray to God or at least something like it on occassion, and I'm far from what you would consider religious, but I don't believe in reincarnation at all. Maybe that's a hold out from being raised in Christianity, I don't know. But I've always kinda felt like the whole concept of reincarnation made life pointless-- who wants to keep starting over from ground zero, on a never ending loop? At least with the concept of an 'afterlife' there's the expectation that you take your memories and experiences with you along for the ride, and you're just you, in a new place, not you plus three hundred versions of you that came before, forced to live out life over and over with no respite. *shrug* Apr 30 13 10:23 pm Link It is an interesting topic. I'm very skeptical of all paranormal stuff but I enjoy learning about it and keeping an open mind. I have seen several TV shows on the H2 Network dealing with very young children having memories of past lives. As parents research the past lives they find amazing evidence that cannot be ignored. It is very interesting stuff but at the end of the day I have a hard time accepting it. Coming back to do it again just seems wasteful. Apr 30 13 10:32 pm Link Tim Little Photography wrote: amazing how most of these folks were egyptian, mesopotamian or roman royalty, isn't it? Apr 30 13 10:35 pm Link EvaScarlet wrote: GK photo wrote: and how will we know it is you? Sorry couldn't resist. Apr 30 13 10:43 pm Link Tim Little Photography wrote: Unless you are to come back until you get it right, whatever IT is. Apr 30 13 11:09 pm Link Paul Tirado Photography wrote: no shit. what's the code word? Apr 30 13 11:12 pm Link GK photo wrote: Actually not a single child was Egyptian, Mesopotamian or Roman Royalty. Far from it actually. I think you may be confusing a bogus "reading" from a so called Medium telling a person they were so and so in a past life. The events I am speaking of a something totally different and serious minded researchers are becoming involved in their investigation. Apr 30 13 11:24 pm Link Tim Little Photography wrote: http://www.deathisanillusion.com/page.pl?id=2&cid=3 Apr 30 13 11:35 pm Link I'd like to see a study done with rigorous scientific protocols, by broadly respected experimenters. When one is done, and the researchers conclude that the existence of past lives is the likeliest explanation, I'll start leaning toward believing. Of course, I'd like to see that study replicated by other researchers, as well. The James Randi Educational Foundation has a standing offer of $1 million to anyone who can prove anything paranormal. There is a test, and a pre-test. To date, no one has even passed the pre-test. http://www.randi.org/site/index.php/1m-challenge.html So, I remain skeptically awaiting persuasive evidence. Ps. - I was going to post a joke: "I used to believe in reincarnation, but that was in a previous life." But I decided against it. May 01 13 08:09 am Link I watched "The Reincarnation of Peter Proud" (which sounds like a dirty movie but isn't), but it turned out just to be enjoyable fiction. I'm open to believing in it (or anything else) if there's evidence beyond retold anecdotes, but I haven't seen it. May 01 13 08:14 am Link I believe that either reincarnation exists or memories are somehow passed through DNA. Not really sure which one of those scenarios exists, but I'm positive one of them does. May 01 13 08:17 am Link I would have to say no to this. Simply, and just my own opinion but if we are all reincarnated then doesn't that mean there's a finite amount of humans at any given time. Yet new people are born every day. So where are those "new" souls coming from? If we're reincarnated shouldn't those births be the recycled people who have died? May 01 13 08:19 am Link AdelaideJohn1967 wrote: That's actually the general idea. May 01 13 08:31 am Link No May 01 13 08:32 am Link I'm currently surfing on another wave of "Who the hell knows?" right now. I get like this from time to time. I've never been opposed to the idea of Reincarnation. It's a lovely idea if it is true. Almost lovelier than the concept of heaven (which sometimes seems a little not-so-great when I think about it too much). A part of me leans toward it and hopes that reincarnation is the case. May 01 13 08:34 am Link AdelaideJohn1967 wrote: The Mormons believe that women in heaven are permanently pregnant and they supply the new souls. I guess there is a lot of weird ideas about this going around. If every last person was reincarnated, the math wouldn't really add up if you think about it, especially with how massive the population is now. May 01 13 08:36 am Link I'm Irish, so of course I do . . . but then, I also believe in leprechauns and Santa . . . SOS May 01 13 08:40 am Link Yes. My spiritual views fall in line with yogic philosophy. I believe in the cycle of karma and reincarnation. May 01 13 08:46 am Link If you want to get really deep in critical thinking on the subject, here is a great free Yale course Phil 176 DEATH video/audio: http://oyc.yale.edu/philosophy/phil-176 course description: About the Course There is one thing I can be sure of: I am going to die. But what am I to make of that fact? This course will examine a number of issues that arise once we begin to reflect on our mortality. The possibility that death may not actually be the end is considered. Are we, in some sense, immortal? Would immortality be desirable? Also a clearer notion of what it is to die is examined. What does it mean to say that a person has died? What kind of fact is that? And, finally, different attitudes to death are evaluated. Is death an evil? How? Why? Is suicide morally permissible? Is it rational? How should the knowledge that I am going to die affect the way I live my life? May 01 13 08:51 am Link AdelaideJohn1967 wrote: BorderlineBunny wrote: If there was a human bottleneck of a few thousand at a given time in our past history, and we're at billions now, how do new lives get generated? May 01 13 10:10 am Link Nope I believe when you go you go that's it. You only get one life in this body. May 01 13 10:21 am Link Do you believe in reincarnation/past lives? No. May 01 13 10:29 am Link Yes, I do. May 01 13 10:34 am Link Lisa Andresen wrote: I think reincarnation provides a second body......coming back in this body would be zombie related. May 01 13 10:35 am Link Not yes.....not no. I will say this topic pauses me for thought.....sometimes I really wonder. May 01 13 10:36 am Link Definitely. Don't believe in much else, though. May 01 13 10:40 am Link 1000% Yes! I have no doubt...Through life experiences and only through experiences in this lifetime can I say this. Not all things are meant to be proven by science but through experiences only...Those that know, KNOW...Those that really seek to and are ready to know, will hear the call and see what direction to take to find the answer but trying too hard will make it harder...Those that don't believe at all might never know but will know in a future lifetime it's inevitable, energy is forever in all forms and levels of exsistence,Imho...No direspect to anyone's beliefs,that's just the best short way I could describe my reason for my answer. Best wishes to all! May 01 13 04:51 pm Link no May 01 13 04:52 pm Link My initial response was always no. Never thought about it too much. At one point, I had a roommate who was very interested in past life regression, etc, and I read a number of his books. The stuff that I've read (books and internet), is fascinating to ponder...and, if true, is definitely cause to ponder. Is it 100%, beyond a shadow of a doubt, utterly and verifiably true? Of course we don't know that. Is it 100%, beyond a shadow of a doubt, utterly and verifiably not true? Well, we don't know that either... I think it's a fascinating thing to read about and study, and if it were true, would definitely help to explain a lot of things... May 01 13 07:53 pm Link No. This is all we get. We all want to live forever in one way or another. I think this is due to the preservation instinct. Those that don't have this strong instinct have died off. This is why we want to believe in reincarnation and the afterlife. Neither of which I believe to be true. May 01 13 08:28 pm Link No. Heard too many claims of past lives as nobility or warriors under famous generals, no claims of having been malnourished, short-lived shovelers of pig-shit. May 01 13 08:38 pm Link I think that after-life ideas arise in large part because we have a hard time imagining ourselves dead. May 01 13 10:37 pm Link Maybe Jimmy Hoffa or Judge Crater could come back and tell us who killed them and where their bodies might be found. May 01 13 11:36 pm Link Orca Bay Images wrote: From my OP: May 01 13 11:38 pm Link EvaScarlet wrote: The new fad: After everyone wore out the "I was a courtesan in the court of Louis XIV" routine, now there's an attempt at credibility by going the other direction. May 02 13 12:03 am Link GK photo wrote: That's 'cos your common serf wasn't asked what he thought about the possibility of life after death or life before birth. hence there is no record of what he orshe may have thought. May 02 13 12:11 am Link I don't, no. And I don't believe that after a person dies, some part of them lives on, either. May 02 13 02:38 am Link |