Forums > Critique > Serious Critique > which is the better photo?

Model

Sam Aotaki

Posts: 178

Los Angeles, California, US

i have been asking around and i can't seem to get a straight answer on which photo is a better photo, please let me know, i would really appreciate your opinion thank you!

http://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/130829/20/52200d2856145_m.jpg

http://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/130911/01/52302fc66b87b_m.jpg

Sep 11 13 01:55 am Link

Photographer

Rex Maverick

Posts: 3176

Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, US

I think your face looks slimmer in the first shot.

Sep 11 13 03:56 am Link

Photographer

Gallery de Aphrodite

Posts: 343

Toronto, Ontario, Canada

I like the 2nd one better.

Sep 11 13 05:38 am Link

Model

ammie

Posts: 32

Sydney, New South Wales, Australia

Sam Aotaki wrote:
i have been asking around and i can't seem to get a straight answer on which photo is a better photo, please let me know, i would really appreciate your opinion thank you!

http://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/130829/20/52200d2856145_m.jpg

http://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/130911/01/52302fc66b87b_m.jpg

They are both good in their own way, in the first i think your giving good energy but look a little tense (try relaxing and lengthening your neck), in the second I think that you look lovely but my critique would be that maybe you look a little angry. If you want to choose between them it depends on what your style is. I think the second one shows you of better. A.

Sep 11 13 06:01 am Link

Model

D Nick Falana

Posts: 15

Los Angeles, California, US

The bottom is more sultry. I don't see anger at all. The first is more neutral. On first pass, my instinct said the first but looking more closely, I prefer the second because it feels more natural. The first feels more stiff. They both make you look stockier then any other shot in your port so I don't know that they're the most accurate representation of you in your port.

Sep 11 13 12:10 pm Link

Model

GingerMuse

Posts: 369

STUDIO CITY, California, US

not a big fan of either, but if I had to pick one, the bottom one. It looks like you have no neck in either, but the bottom one might be a little better neck-wise. I'm also not a fan of the armpit crease and bra strap in the top, so I'd go w/the bottom.

Sep 11 13 12:18 pm Link

Photographer

Photos by James Michael

Posts: 2

Roscoe, Illinois, US

I like the bottom one the best. She has the illusion of wearing no top, her face appears thinner to me and I like her hair better.

Sep 11 13 06:46 pm Link