Forums > Critique > The "oh no I have a weekend" critique

Photographer

Rik Williams

Posts: 4005

Melbourne, Victoria, Australia

retired light reflector wrote:

These are head and shoulders above the rest:

https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/150228/21/54f2a513683d2_m.jpghttps://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/121012/23/50790bc79d9ec_m.jpg
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/100719/00/4c4400e75a965_m.jpghttps://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/110804/06/4e3a9c4120351_m.jpg

There is something "off" about each of these images that MAKE the image- a hot light in the background, lack of face, etc.

Thank you smile

Aug 16 15 03:39 am Link

Model

Layla_B

Posts: 411

Eindhoven, Noord-Brabant, Netherlands

retired light reflector wrote:
I can tell you know how to move, I think you should focus on creating shots that are more motion-focused.
I'm thinking along these lines..

Thankyou! I like your suggestions, very much appreciated smile
From some of the examples I do have something similar in my port, just not in my selection here on mm.
All the best to you!

Aug 16 15 01:01 pm Link

Photographer

Risen Phoenix Photo

Posts: 3779

Minneapolis, Minnesota, US

retired light reflector wrote:

You have an abundance of good work; it is hard to single out an image that I dislike. However, the sheer amount of work means that the GREAT images can get lost in the crowd. If I had to choose your 4 truly standout images:

https://www.modelmayhem.com/portfolio/pic/37124496 18+ - powerful and dynamic, again wonderful tones and composition; there is a certain mystery to this image that would make me keep returning to it
https://www.modelmayhem.com/portfolio/pic/36711348 18+ - another powerful woman, and I just love the depth of skintone and background
https://www.modelmayhem.com/portfolio/pic/36485813 18+ - great dynamic image, I love the expression; this is a cat in the air away from the iconic image of Salvador Dali wink
https://www.modelmayhem.com/portfolio/pic/26426681 18+ - a great contrast between a calm face and moving hair; there is a wonderful push-pull to the image

Thanks your words mean an awful lot to me

Aug 16 15 01:53 pm Link

Photographer

tentacula-org

Posts: 1

Marino, Lazio, Italy

I'm always open for receiving rough feedback. We Finns are not touchy  :-)

I haven't updated the gallery since a while so I know there's irrelevant things in there, but do bring it on if you have a moment.

Aug 16 15 02:13 pm Link

Model

Nat has a username

Posts: 3590

Oakland, California, US

tentacula-org wrote:
I'm always open for receiving rough feedback. We Finns are not touchy  :-)

I haven't updated the gallery since a while so I know there's irrelevant things in there, but do bring it on if you have a moment.

You have a great sense of mood and story telling:
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/090529/19/4a2096dcf06ad_m.jpghttps://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/090529/19/4a2095f5d5dd4_m.jpghttps://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/090529/19/4a20961decc0f_m.jpg

I think that is your strength.

I think you should choose one camera, and for a month shoot every day with just that. Focus on the technical- how do you achieve a high contrast image vs. low contrast image? What does f 1.4 look like vs. f 16? Once the technical things become second nature, it's like you have more vocabulary to tell stories with images. You have a good sense of story, just need more words to draw from.

Aug 16 15 06:22 pm Link

Photographer

TDSImages

Posts: 1017

Salt Lake City, Utah, US

retired light reflector wrote:

These two are my favorites:
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/120320/07/4f6893c8a5340_m.jpghttps://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/110407/08/4d9dda44e4ef0_m.jpg

However, I wish that they weren't so perfectly in focus. I feel like you should have mirrored the general styling of the images and taken a different angle, maybe added a little motion blur or shallower focal length, and/or more dramatic lighting; something to keep the mystery and complete the image.

Thank you for your observations!

Aug 16 15 07:50 pm Link

Model

Nat has a username

Posts: 3590

Oakland, California, US

bumpin for scary cat compels me

scary

Sep 01 15 08:09 pm Link

Model

Emmie Wong

Posts: 50

Freiburg, Baden-Württemberg, Germany

Me please smile

Sep 01 15 08:13 pm Link

Model

Nat has a username

Posts: 3590

Oakland, California, US

Emmie Wong wrote:
Me please smile

I think with the right creative team you could pull off some really great concepts. Don't be afraid to go overboard with makeup, styling, facial expressions, etc. I know for myself at least, there is a certain comfort and freedom in being a character.

This is my fave: https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/150605/16/55722be0c21ce_m.jpg

You're young, have great energy, and I think you should keep modeling as long as it is a fun and positive experience for you. Best of luck in school!

Sep 01 15 08:30 pm Link

Photographer

DespayreFX

Posts: 1481

Delta, British Columbia, Canada

Hit me... but not like you're my ex. smile

Sep 02 15 12:43 am Link

Photographer

Santiago Alvarez

Posts: 91

Fort Lauderdale, Florida, US

I'm curious

Sep 02 15 02:59 pm Link

Model

Nat has a username

Posts: 3590

Oakland, California, US

DespayreFX wrote:
Hit me... but not like you're my ex. smile

If I treated you like an ex I'd delete every photo of you in my phone and not talk to you tongue

I feel like you're still searching for what you want to do. I don't see a cohesive theme, idea, or look to your portfolio. Maybe narrow in on a project, keep it simple, and see what happens.

Sep 02 15 06:55 pm Link

Model

Nat has a username

Posts: 3590

Oakland, California, US

Bed of Chaos Imaging wrote:
I'm curious

Pretty much same sentiment as above.

If I were a model, I would have no idea what to expect from a shoot. Maybe upload only things that you would like to currently work on with people from here.

Sep 02 15 07:02 pm Link

Photographer

Roy Nelson Photos

Posts: 286

West Hollywood, California, US

My ego hasn't been dented in a while.  New photos on top, old friends on the bottom.

Sep 02 15 07:48 pm Link

Model

Nat has a username

Posts: 3590

Oakland, California, US

Roy Nelson Photos wrote:
My ego hasn't been dented in a while.  New photos on top, old friends on the bottom.

I think you need to go back to tweak your studio lighting setup, because this is not good lighting for portraits:
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/150807/13/55c51928d179f_m.jpghttps://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/150513/20/55541c73938cc_m.jpg

This should be cropped to a horizontal because all my eye is doing is searching for the nipple tbh and not focusing on the face or product, cropping will better direct the eye
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/150707/21/559ca66db0b6d_m.jpg

The bottom of this image is awkward. Why did you crop at that part of the leg? Why are her hands like that?
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/150224/18/54ed2d73b624d_m.jpg

If you want any other advice ask away, that was the long and short of it smile

Sep 02 15 08:04 pm Link

Model

Pauline Yee

Posts: 406

Calgary, Alberta, Canada

me please!

Sep 02 15 08:44 pm Link

Model

Nat has a username

Posts: 3590

Oakland, California, US

Pauline Yee wrote:
me please!

More stuff like this:
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/150611/23/557a811a16fa1_m.jpg

You have a great look for stock and commercial work, I think that's what you should focus your portfolio on.

Sep 02 15 09:03 pm Link

Model

Pauline Yee

Posts: 406

Calgary, Alberta, Canada

retired light reflector wrote:

More stuff like this:
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/150611/23/557a811a16fa1_m.jpg

You have a great look for stock and commercial work, I think that's what you should focus your portfolio on.

Thank you very much

Sep 02 15 09:16 pm Link

Photographer

Roy Nelson Photos

Posts: 286

West Hollywood, California, US

Thanks, sometimes you need a wake up call.

Sep 03 15 05:29 am Link

Photographer

-fpc-

Posts: 893

Boca Raton, Florida, US

would love your thoughts if you are still going...

Sep 03 15 04:24 pm Link

Model

Nat has a username

Posts: 3590

Oakland, California, US

-fpc- wrote:
would love your thoughts if you are still going...

Portraits are your strength
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/130816/16/520eb99fb525e_m.jpghttps://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/150506/16/554aaaf83f9a8_m.jpg
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/120924/08/506082a26a774_m.jpghttps://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/131228/16/52bf6681c6069_m.jpg

You understand how to compose a frame and when to click the shutter
Keep exploring and creating more

Sep 03 15 11:29 pm Link

Photographer

-fpc-

Posts: 893

Boca Raton, Florida, US

thanks for looking
I do need to get out of the box more..

Sep 04 15 03:17 am Link

Photographer

dLight

Posts: 10

Zurich, Zurich, Switzerland

I'd like to hear your opinion too.

Sep 04 15 06:03 am Link

Model

Nat has a username

Posts: 3590

Oakland, California, US

dLight wrote:
I'd like to hear your opinion too.

*pulls out retired ballerina badge*

This shot bothers me greatly:
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/140219/15/530537e733ba4_m.jpg
The angle of the foot is not pleasing to the eye, and the ribbons are tied in the wrong area. Unless you have a very experienced ballerina, I would recommend not using pointe shoes with models, since they require years of training and experience.

If you want to use an image from this shoot, search through the other images, or maybe crop out the foot. The face and the hand in this shot are great.

Sep 04 15 10:19 pm Link

Photographer

One Woman Show Photo

Posts: 7

Austin, Texas, US

I would love a critique.  I am very new to photography.  I have been a wig maker, makeup artist, and hair and wardrobe stylist for years.

I am trying to learn photography so I bring the images in my head to life as I see them.

Do I seem to be headed in a good direction?

Thank you so much for your time!

Sep 05 15 06:39 pm Link

Model

Nat has a username

Posts: 3590

Oakland, California, US

Paint and Powder Pix wrote:
I would love a critique.  I am very new to photography.  I have been a wig maker, makeup artist, and hair and wardrobe stylist for years.

I am trying to learn photography so I bring the images in my head to life as I see them.

Do I seem to be headed in a good direction?

Thank you so much for your time!

These are fabulous!

https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/150831/20/55e52123cc4f6_m.jpg
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/150729/22/55b9b4de8c02b_m.jpg
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/150729/22/55b9b3aaaf799_m.jpg

I love the styling, hair, makeup; there is a definite mood/feeling to each image. Some of your other images seem closer to snapshots, but I'm sure you could pick out which ones they are. Keep shooting, keep learning how to make your ideas happen through different techniques. You're off to a really great start!

Sep 06 15 05:03 pm Link

Photographer

Don Garrett

Posts: 4984

Escondido, California, US

OK, I guess I'll have to try this !
-Don

Sep 06 15 05:41 pm Link

Model

Nat has a username

Posts: 3590

Oakland, California, US

Don Garrett wrote:
OK, I guess I'll have to try this !
-Don

I love the range of tones here:
https://www.modelmayhem.com/portfolio/pic/14157680 18+

I can see you doing a figure series and unifying them with that effect. I think you should pick one treatment of an image, post only that one, and stick to it. Too many options weakens the stronger image.

I am not a fan of HDR outside of landscape photography, but I think that is more of a personal taste thing.

Hope this was helpful smile

Sep 06 15 05:52 pm Link

Photographer

One Woman Show Photo

Posts: 7

Austin, Texas, US

Thanks so much!  It is so helpful to get feedback when taking Ina new aspect of the biz. :-)

Sep 07 15 06:18 am Link

Model

MatureModelMM

Posts: 2843

Detroit, Michigan, US

I'm curious, please let me know your thoughts smile

Sep 07 15 06:49 am Link

Photographer

dLight

Posts: 10

Zurich, Zurich, Switzerland

retired light reflector wrote:

*pulls out retired ballerina badge*

This shot bothers me greatly:
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/140219/15/530537e733ba4_m.jpg
The angle of the foot is not pleasing to the eye, and the ribbons are tied in the wrong area. Unless you have a very experienced ballerina, I would recommend not using pointe shoes with models, since they require years of training and experience.

If you want to use an image from this shoot, search through the other images, or maybe crop out the foot. The face and the hand in this shot are great.

Thanks for the observation.
Yeah, true neither her nor me had any clue on how to tie those thingies... wink

Sep 07 15 10:21 am Link

Photographer

Don Garrett

Posts: 4984

Escondido, California, US

dLight wrote:
Thanks for the observation.
Yeah, true neither her nor me had any clue on how to tie those thingies... wink

But, I doubt it takes years of training to learn how to tie them, or model with them. It DOES take years of practice to dance like a pro, though.
-Don

Sep 07 15 10:28 am Link

Model

Nat has a username

Posts: 3590

Oakland, California, US

MatureModelMM wrote:
I'm curious, please let me know your thoughts smile

You're a great example of a fine art model, truly.

Great proportions, classic face, and timelessness to your overall look.

I'm biased and a fan tongue

Sep 07 15 03:47 pm Link

Model

Nat has a username

Posts: 3590

Oakland, California, US

bumping.

Sep 25 15 08:11 pm Link

Photographer

HarryLII

Posts: 13

Chicago, Illinois, US

Hope Im not late:)

Sep 27 15 10:02 am Link

Model

Nat has a username

Posts: 3590

Oakland, California, US

HarryLII wrote:
Hope Im not late:)

Nope but I'll tag you since I took a few days lol

You have a great eye, what are you focused on working on right now with models from MM? I think having a project to focus on (or 2 or 3) would help you find the right models and help you as an artist have a clearer sense of what to work on when shooting.

Overall I think you have a great sense of composition/ the big picture and tones, but small details can sometimes bring an image down. Example of what I mean:
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/150923/18/56034dd85f82d_m.jpg
GREAT textures, depth to the image, and overall composition; however, the eyes kill it for me.

Sep 30 15 07:27 pm Link

Photographer

Cinema Photography

Posts: 4488

Boulder, Colorado, US

Sure, have a go at me smile

Sep 30 15 11:15 pm Link

Model

Djordjev

Posts: 6

Baltimore, Maryland, US

Me please! It's my first photoshoot ever so you might have a lot to say.

Oct 02 15 05:25 pm Link

Model

Nat has a username

Posts: 3590

Oakland, California, US

Bumping; if the two that posted above me want to post again go for it, but I won't answer posts from months ago

scary

Dec 02 15 02:19 am Link

Photographer

Paige Addams

Posts: 21

Brugge, West Flanders, Belgium

Go for it :p
Feel free to point out any photo you feel is less strong among the rest.

Dec 03 15 03:30 pm Link