Forums > Model Colloquy > Disabled models, what do you think of this?

Model

Biana_Libertine

Posts: 3458

Brooklyn, New York, US

David Shinobi wrote:
Any persons disability SHOULD have no affect what-so-ever.

Well, that's not quite true.  I have no personal bias against disabled people, my grandfather is disabled and he's has and is leading a very fulfilling life.  But as far as modelling goes, certain disabilities can hinder a person and aspiring model as it can effect the way they pose and they may not necessarily be able to pose in the way the client wants.

Dec 05 10 07:45 pm Link

Model

Miss Marianna

Posts: 202

Groningen, Groningen, Netherlands

Biana_Libertine wrote:

Well, that's not quite true.  I have no personal bias against disabled people, my grandfather is disabled and he's has and is leading a very fulfilling life.  But as far as modelling goes, certain disabilities can hinder a person and aspiring model as it can effect the way they pose and they may not necessarily be able to pose in the way the client wants.

but they can find a comfortable pose and give someone a chance!

Dec 10 10 02:54 am Link

Photographer

Jose Martin CFP

Posts: 284

Melbourne, Victoria, Australia

I would love to shoot with you...

Dec 10 10 03:08 am Link

Model

Miss Marianna

Posts: 202

Groningen, Groningen, Netherlands

with who?

Dec 10 10 03:25 am Link

Model

311Shawna

Posts: 39

Fort Myers, Florida, US

JoJo wrote:
I don’t see a disabled model, I see a model in a wheelchair. To me there is a major difference.

A disabled car is one sitting at the side of the road.

You are not sitting at the side of life, you are living it. Go for it!

This is exactly why I just love you JoJo! You sooo ROCK!...I've seen physically challenged people accomplish things that plenty of perfectly "normal" whatever the hell that actually means, not even attempt from fear of failure! I give you major props on following your dreams! Best wishes!

Dec 11 10 07:48 am Link

Model

Jenn aka Miss Rayne

Posts: 286

Broadmoor, California, US

I have a different disability...its from series of events in my life...I am ok physically...but suffer from PTSD...

There are so many things that can be considered a "disability" but to me, the people that I consider truly disabled, are the ones who are too ignorant, or too judgemental to see the beauty in PEOPLE. No matter what, physical, mental, emotional disabilities...it doesnt make anyone any different...we all bleed red, we all feel, we all hurt, cry, and love...I see you and I see a beautiful woman. I don't see a disabled woman...Youre beautiful. Best to you...Jenn aka MIss Rayne

Dec 11 10 08:00 am Link

Photographer

Wysiwyg Photography

Posts: 6326

Salt Lake City, Utah, US

Biana_Libertine wrote:

Well, that's not quite true.  I have no personal bias against disabled people, my grandfather is disabled and he's has and is leading a very fulfilling life.  But as far as modelling goes, certain disabilities can hinder a person and aspiring model as it can effect the way they pose and they may not necessarily be able to pose in the way the client wants.

This is true... I have worked with a model that literally cannot open up her left hand... it's in a constant fist formation... will not open...

So I had to work around it.. not a problem, but if there was actually a paying client then their might have been an issue if they wanted a certain pose.

Side note though:
There is a difference between mentally disabled and physically disabled like has been mentioned throughout this thread.. I have no problems working with a physically disabled person for the right concept, even pay them...

But I will treat a mentally disabled model as I would someone under +18... someone of sound mind to sign my model release.

Dec 11 10 09:03 am Link

Model

Miss Marianna

Posts: 202

Groningen, Groningen, Netherlands

Wysiwyg Photography wrote:

This is true... I have worked with a model that literally cannot open up her left hand... it's in a constant fist formation... will not open...

So I had to work around it.. not a problem, but if there was actually a paying client then their might have been an issue if they wanted a certain pose.

Side note though:
There is a difference between mentally disabled and physically disabled like has been mentioned throughout this thread.. I have no problems working with a physically disabled person for the right concept, even pay them...

But I will treat a mentally disabled model as I would someone under +18... someone of sound mind to sign my model release.

i agree!

Dec 17 10 03:20 pm Link

Photographer

Martins Photo Place

Posts: 4

Leeuwarden, Friesland, Netherlands

I am trying to show something of a girl's heart in my photography ... many of my "models" are mothers of 4 or 40yo+ girls or very thin or just chubby ... to me it matters what is coming from the eyes to me. When that is nice, I prefer far more that so called "less perfect" than the girls that for example Louis Vuitton wants to make you believe are beautiful. From those photos, even though technical 1,000 x better than mine, I feel only sadness. So, yes you can and all girls who like to model can!

Dec 20 10 10:36 am Link

Model

Divya

Posts: 135

Miami, Florida, US

you know, I think this is the coolest thread I've seen on here.  I mean, sure, for obvi reasons most people will say you can enjoy it, but don't count on it.  i dunno, I think people can do whatever they want in life.  I'm a huge optimist int hat sense.  i think people that've made it with the greatest physical hurdles are people like padma lakshmi and josie maran with their massive scars.  it'll be hard for you to make a mark VERY hard, but you have a great attitude that could get your far.  you just need to find someone willing to take up your cause.  now THAT is going to be hard, 'cos people enjoy living in their boxes.  anyway, POWER TO YOU!  get 'em!

Dec 20 10 06:46 pm Link

Photographer

Art by Jason Rogers

Posts: 5

Arad, Arad, Romania

Im a (not so) young and up and coming photographer and, even though Ive never worked with any disabled models I would have no problem whatsoever with this. Furthermore, I believe we, as photographers, have a responsible role to play. Social acceptance, intergration and the quashing of prejudice are issues which can be brought to the publics attention by means of imagery and thus, a thousand words may be spoken.

Deeper questions could also be asked, such as; do you have to be beautiful to be a model? And, what is beautiful?

Anyway, for fear of going off at a tangent, Ill stop writing and Ill say YES, anyone can be a model.

Dec 21 10 08:10 am Link

Model

Miss Marianna

Posts: 202

Groningen, Groningen, Netherlands

but why don't i appear on most sites from photographers i've worked with? it doesn't 
feel right.

Dec 21 10 09:56 am Link

Model

Miss Marianna

Posts: 202

Groningen, Groningen, Netherlands

so can anyone reply on that?

Jan 15 11 02:08 pm Link

Photographer

Woody Oh

Posts: 423

Shelby, North Carolina, US

JoJo wrote:
I don’t see a disabled model, I see a model in a wheelchair. To me there is a major difference.

A disabled car is one sitting at the side of the road.

You are not sitting at the side of life, you are living it. Go for it!

You're fantastic, JoJo... 

My observation is that a models' presence is all about their ability to capture the space in the image, and make it their own.  The look & feel generated by a model (and captured by the photographer) is what our art is all about, and it does take all kinds to create it!

Jan 15 11 02:29 pm Link

Photographer

Woody Oh

Posts: 423

Shelby, North Carolina, US

Miss Marianna wrote:
but why don't i appear on most sites from photographers i've worked with? it doesn't 
feel right.

*This is a guess on my part*

When developing our craft (as I am), I look forward to opportunities to practice and get better.  When my work is good enough, I hope my models choose to put it on their site, as I will have it on mine.  Each of us (model & photographer, alike) chooses our portfolio that represents us the best.  The fact is, if we're lucky enough to work with those whose skills are exceptional, and make our collaboration that much better, the result still may not be good enough to make THEIR portfolio better, even though it improves our own.  I intend to keep at it, and improve every chance I get, as I think all of us here on MM do.  I hope you do, too!

Jan 15 11 02:40 pm Link

Photographer

AJB Photography

Posts: 16

Sioux Falls, South Dakota, US

I was looking through your port and I must say that I would love to work with you. It is a shame you live half a world away.

Jan 15 11 02:50 pm Link

Photographer

Evil Genius Photo

Posts: 47

Hedley, Texas, US

I spent a lot of time making fun of diabled people as a kid and it wasnt until I broke my back and couldnt hardly walk for 2 years that i understood what it is to be diabled and i aplaud anyone with a disability who models. Im a disabled photographer if i can work why cant you. I think you are beautiful!

Jan 15 11 09:45 pm Link

Photographer

Herman Surkis

Posts: 10856

Victoria, British Columbia, Canada

Sorry i don't get it?
If the look is appropriate, what does disabled have to do with anything?

Jan 16 11 03:50 am Link

Photographer

Aaron Lewis Photography

Posts: 5217

Catskill, New York, US

Absolutly fine, Run with it. You have some great shots in your port.

Jan 16 11 09:31 am Link

Model

Debra Jeanne

Posts: 18

Fort Lauderdale, Florida, US

Jay-John wrote:
Furthermore, I believe we, as photographers, have a responsible role to play. Social acceptance, intergration and the quashing of prejudice are issues which can be brought to the publics attention by means of imagery and thus, a thousand words may be spoken.

This is such a wonderful way of putting this..and the precise reason why this is important to me...as an aspiring model with a disability..

Thank you for starting this discussion..the "words" need to be spoken..and I also intend to start speaking them. smile

Jan 16 11 09:41 am Link

Photographer

Mani - poplifePhoto

Posts: 323

Oakland, California, US

Miss Marianna wrote:
but why don't i appear on most sites from photographers i've worked with? it doesn't 
feel right.

I've had hundreds of photoshoots....not everyone goes into the portfolio.
There are a lot of aspects/considerations, who the model is and how they look aren't always primary consideration. 

I wouldn't take it personal, really.

Jan 16 11 09:46 am Link

Makeup Artist

Ms Samantha Marie

Posts: 1377

San Francisco, California, US

Personally I dont see a major issue. You have a beautiful gorgeous face. I especially love the first black & white photo you have in your port smile
I think if someone feels insecure about a part of their body, use it as an opportunity to get creative. Add props, feathers, a shawl, leafs, an interesting cloth or design. Everyone & every aspect of a shoot is what makes it come together.

Jan 16 11 09:47 am Link

Model

Red McCord Springfield

Posts: 76

Chattanooga, Tennessee, US

Marianne Michaela wrote:

Miss Marianna wrote:
\

But a model to me is someone who gets paid work and is agency signed (although I am willing to admit that there are some amazing models who are freelance and get a lot of paid work) and is industry standard (although, again, there are acceptions to the rule, but they are very rare and are extraordinary good models).

I started out in this industry "normal". My "handicap" was my lack of heigth (lol) but was able to make good money, this was also back before I had children and when agencies used printed comp cards and look books on a regular basis, and opposed to online resources. Since then... I will admit being "sick" has made working more difficult. I have a HAE, (hereditary angioedema) which makes working often painful, or sometimes impossible.

It's possible to be a model, it's a little more difficult to WORK as a disabled model. You really have to be determined, LOVE what you do, and be willing to face reality when you aren't what the client needs (but they aren't gonna tell you that but it's obvivious) because of your disability. Think out of the box and be willing to try new avenues.

Jan 21 11 01:00 am Link

Model

Jennie Martinico

Posts: 5

STATEN ISLAND, New York, US

Hi all just wanted to say how much I love this thread. As a new model in a wheelchair living with CP reading everyone's kind words gave me hope that I can still do well in modeling even tho I'm disabled. smile

Jan 26 11 09:37 pm Link

Photographer

Travabiliy

Posts: 1

Melbourne, Victoria, Australia

Jay-John wrote:
I believe we, as photographers, have a responsible role to play. Social acceptance, intergration and the quashing of prejudice are issues which can be brought to the publics attention by means of imagery and thus, a thousand words may be spoken.

That is extremely well put. Imagery is a very powerful thing. A great friend of mine said limitations exist only in the mind. We are quick to judge what someone cant do instead of using our creative talents to produce stunning results out of what people can and want to do.

Feb 14 11 08:52 pm Link

Model

Laureate

Posts: 1074

Chicago, Illinois, US

I have schizoeffective disorder, and I am very open about it. I have auditory and visual hallucinations, but I am usually extremely functional and nobody notices it. I joke with those who do know...tell them that my voices are arguing again, ask them if the blaring bell I'm hearing is real...I laugh it off. It took me a long time to get to this point, but I sure feel free today. I have found my own way not only to deal with my mental illness, but also to use it to my advantage. In fact, many of the "darker" concepts in my port are based off of what I have seen or heard that aren't real. I'm banking on my supposed disability!

Disabilities don't have to be limiting...they are assets because they make us stronger. I go by Laureate, not "schizoeffective disorder." I am a person, and my mental illness is only one part of my life and who I am.

Feb 14 11 09:01 pm Link

Photographer

OpenMinds

Posts: 886

Paradise Valley, Arizona, US

Fifi wrote:
I'm not understanding the question. Are you asking if disabled models can model? If so, I will say yes. That's like asking if a short person can model.

However, in both cases Fifi, there is a difference between "can model", and being a working professional model.    Hell, my cat "can model", but I'm not seeing her on the Cat Chow bag anytime soon

Feb 14 11 09:09 pm Link

Model

Miss Marianna

Posts: 202

Groningen, Groningen, Netherlands

OpenMinds wrote:

However, in both cases Fifi, there is a difference between "can model", and being a working professional model.    Hell, my cat "can model", but I'm not seeing her on the Cat Chow bag anytime soon

but when can you say 'yes, she can model'?

Feb 15 11 02:32 pm Link

Photographer

Wysiwyg Photography

Posts: 6326

Salt Lake City, Utah, US

OpenMinds wrote:
However, in both cases Fifi, there is a difference between "can model", and being a working professional model.    Hell, my cat "can model", but I'm not seeing her on the Cat Chow bag anytime soon

That may be...

It also depends on the disability as have been stated through out the thread.

Someone with a mental disability are treated like people under 18 (what ever your rules are on that, they are your own.) and of course depending on what the mental disability is... if it's down syndrome or something else?

Someone with a physical disability (wheelchair, crutches, missing limbs, etc), are fair game and can shoot what ever she/he wants.

Feb 15 11 04:38 pm Link

Model

JadeDRed

Posts: 5620

London, England, United Kingdom

Wysiwyg Photography wrote:
Side note though:
There is a difference between mentally disabled and physically disabled like has been mentioned throughout this thread.. I have no problems working with a physically disabled person for the right concept, even pay them...

But I will treat a mentally disabled model as I would someone under +18... someone of sound mind to sign my model release.

Oh dear, did I miss something.

Feb 16 11 05:41 am Link

Photographer

Wysiwyg Photography

Posts: 6326

Salt Lake City, Utah, US

JadeDRed wrote:

Oh dear, did I miss something.

You are going to have to clarify by "miss something"

I can clarify my statement though on the "models that are mentally disabled"

I'm talking about people that are not of sound mind, that are like children mentally (not physical age) people that have down syndrome or other like conditions that would require a parent or guardian to sign my model release where the model would not be able to.

it's pretty much a case by case...

Feb 16 11 05:59 am Link

Photographer

bastardartist

Posts: 287

Los Angeles, California, US

I choose to seek out ladies that are a bit different from the norm.
They have a lot of character, are mentally stronger and they don't let their shortcomings get in the way of what they want out of life.

smile

Feb 16 11 06:27 am Link

Photographer

bastardartist

Posts: 287

Los Angeles, California, US

+1

Herman Surkis wrote:
Sorry i don't get it?
If the look is appropriate, what does disabled have to do with anything?

Feb 16 11 06:32 am Link

Model

Miss Marianna

Posts: 202

Groningen, Groningen, Netherlands

bastardartist wrote:
I choose to seek out ladies that are a bit different from the norm.
They have a lot of character, are mentally stronger and they don't let their shortcomings get in the way of what they want out of life.

smile

yesss, that is sooo true!!

Feb 16 11 07:50 am Link

Model

Tara Kim

Posts: 94

Fort Lauderdale, Florida, US

I've had more photographers actually want to work with me more because of my disability. They find it inspiring I guess and since I am disabled I work even harder to supply them with what they desire. If it works it works and if it doesn't well that's life somethings dont' work.

Feb 16 11 11:08 am Link

Photographer

Benjamen McGuire

Posts: 3991

Portland, Oregon, US

Miss Marianna wrote:
but why don't i appear on most sites from photographers i've worked with? it doesn't 
feel right.

Because your appearance makes most people uncomfortable.

Feb 16 11 11:54 am Link

Model

Miss Marianna

Posts: 202

Groningen, Groningen, Netherlands

C s p i n e wrote:

Because your appearance makes most people uncomfortable.

well, that's not the reason i think 'cause most of the pictures are not full bodies. if it is 
the reason then they just won't be confronted with reality!

Feb 18 11 01:30 am Link

Photographer

Solas

Posts: 10390

Toronto, Ontario, Canada

Doesn't make a difference to me!

smile


Karl Johnston

www.karljohnston.com

Feb 18 11 01:31 am Link

Model

Miss Marianna

Posts: 202

Groningen, Groningen, Netherlands

Karl Johnston wrote:
Doesn't make a difference to me!

smile


Karl Johnston

www.karljohnston.com

what do you mean?

Feb 18 11 01:50 am Link

Photographer

Solas

Posts: 10390

Toronto, Ontario, Canada

Miss Marianna wrote:
what do you mean?

It doesn't make a difference to me if the model is disabled. Client is a client.

I didn't read the other pages, just the first post.


Karl Johnston

www.karljohnston.com

Feb 18 11 02:02 am Link