ModelMayhem.com - i LIST your best

main browse casting/travel forums shout contests

shop
- prints
- mm wear
- new gear
- marketplace
edu
- library

Forums > Critique > i LIST your best - You pick my weakest	Search Reply
12 3 4 5 last

Photographer

Goat Farm Project
Posts: 299
Atlanta, Georgia, US

Which pics have to go? Tell me straight up and I will LIST your best pic.

Leave a comment on my best pic and i will return the favor.

Oct 22 12 12:31 pm Link Quote

Photographer

SPV Photo
Posts: 570
Los Angeles, California, US

I don't think you really have any truly awful shots in there, but here's my least favorite one.

http://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/121014/20/507b7f1a3b12b_m.jpg

Oct 22 12 12:38 pm Link Quote

Photographer

Image Magik
Posts: 609
New Orleans, Louisiana, US

http://www.modelmayhem.com/portfolio/pic/28802511#28802511.JPG

Composition doesn't work for me.

don't have this in image paste thing workin yet
http://www.modelmayhem.com/portfolio/pi … 1#28802511

Oct 22 12 12:43 pm Link Quote

Photographer

Chris Maxwell
Posts: 648
Sterling, Virginia, US

I'd drop this one.....

http://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/120605/07/4fce1cb5d3231_m.jpg

Pose and crop doesn't work for me.

Oct 22 12 12:43 pm Link Quote

Photographer

Pantelis Palios
Posts: 178
Birmingham, England, United Kingdom

Interesting idea.

I have chosen:

http://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/120730/04/50166c3ab4798_m.jpg

Only because I have to choose one and I don't really like logos on photographs. Too many photographers have no idea about type.

Oct 22 12 12:45 pm Link Quote

Photographer

L Raye
Posts: 4,754
Petaluma, California, US

Your worst:

Oct 22 12 12:46 pm Link Quote

Photographer

ID Imaging
Posts: 42
Chesterfield, England, United Kingdom

In my opinion this is your worst:

I just find this image too busy, and I'm not a fan of the harsh shadows.

Despite that, you do have some really awesome images in your port smile

Oct 22 12 12:50 pm Link Quote

Photographer

JohnsPhotos
Posts: 38
Coconut Creek, Florida, US

this image has an awkward expression and pose, not sure what the story here is and I am not intrigued to find out. some nice images in your port otherwise.
http://www.modelmayhem.com/portfolio/pi … 9#28652809

Oct 22 12 12:53 pm Link Quote

Model

Dina Khrapko
Posts: 23
NEWTON HIGHLANDS, Massachusetts, US

number 14

Oct 22 12 01:59 pm Link Quote

Photographer

Goat Farm Project
Posts: 299
Atlanta, Georgia, US

SPV Photo wrote:
I don't think you really have any truly awful shots in there, but here's my least favorite one.

Thanks! My fav of yours:

Oct 23 12 02:55 pm Link Quote

Photographer

Goat Farm Project
Posts: 299
Atlanta, Georgia, US

Image Magik wrote:

Composition doesn't work for me.

don't have this in image paste thing workin yet
http://www.modelmayhem.com/portfolio/pi … 1#28802511

Thanks for responding. This one is awesome:

Oct 23 12 02:58 pm Link Quote

Photographer

Goat Farm Project
Posts: 299
Atlanta, Georgia, US

Chris Maxwell wrote:
I'd drop this one.....

Pose and crop doesn't work for me.

Love this one:

Oct 23 12 03:01 pm Link Quote

Photographer

Goat Farm Project
Posts: 299
Atlanta, Georgia, US

Pantelis Palios wrote:
Interesting idea.

I have chosen:

Only because I have to choose one and I don't really like logos on photographs. Too many photographers have no idea about type.

Appreciate it! This one was easy:

Oct 23 12 03:04 pm Link Quote

Photographer

Personal Photograph
Posts: 112
Davenport, Iowa, US

http://www.modelmayhem.com/portfolio/pic/29500354

This one could go.

Oct 23 12 03:08 pm Link Quote

Photographer

Brett Hunt
Posts: 899
Washington Court House, Ohio, US

<img src='http://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/120730/04/50166c3ab4798.jpg' />
great port I chose this because you made me

Oct 23 12 03:17 pm Link Quote

Photographer

Brownlager Photography
Posts: 135
BOISE, Idaho, US

I love most of your work there, this one seems a bit unexciting for me though, compared to how well you do amazing photo themes. I know it's probably suggesting "relaxed" but feels a bit...too relaxed if you will..

Oct 23 12 03:18 pm Link Quote

Photographer

DEREX Art
Posts: 203
Paterson, New Jersey, US

There is no "worst"; however, the red dress doesn't seem to go with the other images in your collection.

http://www.modelmayhem.com/portfolio/pi … 7#29598657

Oct 23 12 03:18 pm Link Quote

Photographer

Goat Farm Project
Posts: 299
Atlanta, Georgia, US

L Raye wrote:
Your worst:

Thanks for responding. I really like this 18+ one.
<img src='http://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/100617/12/4c1a79b14f3fb.jpg' />

Oct 23 12 05:02 pm Link Quote

Photographer

Goat Farm Project
Posts: 299
Atlanta, Georgia, US

ID Imaging wrote:
In my opinion this is your worst:

I just find this image too busy, and I'm not a fan of the harsh shadows.

Despite that, you do have some really awesome images in your port smile

Good point, thanks. Love this one:

Oct 23 12 05:05 pm Link Quote

Photographer

Goat Farm Project
Posts: 299
Atlanta, Georgia, US

JohnsPhotos wrote:
this image has an awkward expression and pose, not sure what the story here is and I am not intrigued to find out. some nice images in your port otherwise.
http://www.modelmayhem.com/portfolio/pi … 9#28652809

Thanks! This is awesome. Wish i took it:

Oct 23 12 05:07 pm Link Quote

Photographer

Goat Farm Project
Posts: 299
Atlanta, Georgia, US

Dina Khrapko wrote:
number 14

Thanks! This is my favorite:

Oct 23 12 05:12 pm Link Quote

Photographer

Revenge Photography
Posts: 1,029
Melbourne, Victoria, Australia

Not because its particularly bad, for some reason it doesn't really grab me, maybe its the blown sky. I can't really put my finger on it.

Oct 23 12 05:18 pm Link Quote

Model

Gita Lei
Posts: 39
Austin, Texas, US

The photo in the first reply was in my humble opinion by far the worst. Cute girl, cute concept but it has no place in your port. Also the last one in your portfolio.. Something about it strikes me as inherently wrong. Her expression or maybe how large the frame is compared to her body. Great concept wonderful colors but it still seems very.. Blegh and off for some reason. Other than that you have a beautiful vibrant portfolio!

Oct 23 12 05:51 pm Link Quote

Model

Cynthia Serrano
Posts: 11,121
Newark, New Jersey, US

SPV Photo wrote:
I don't think you really have any truly awful shots in there, but here's my least favorite one.

I agree with this but you can also afford to toss this one

Just doesn't quite measure up to the rest of your port and will make it stronger IMO big_smile

Oct 23 12 07:15 pm Link Quote

Photographer

Jorge Kreimer
Posts: 1,363
Los Angeles, California, US

http://www.modelmayhem.com/portfolio/pi … 1#28888321

I can't put my finger on it, but something bothers me about this one.

Oct 23 12 08:00 pm Link Quote

Photographer

Goat Farm Project
Posts: 299
Atlanta, Georgia, US

Personal Photograph wrote:
http://www.modelmayhem.com/portfolio/pic/29500354

This one could go.

Okay, thanks. Love this one.

Oct 23 12 08:39 pm Link Quote

Photographer

Goat Farm Project
Posts: 299
Atlanta, Georgia, US

Brett Hunt wrote:
<img src='http://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/120730/04/50166c3ab4798.jpg' />
great port I chose this because you made me

lol, thx! This one my favorite:
<img src='http://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/110817/04/4e4ba9227618c.jpg' />

Oct 23 12 08:41 pm Link Quote

Photographer

Goat Farm Project
Posts: 299
Atlanta, Georgia, US

Brownlager Photography wrote:
I love most of your work there, this one seems a bit unexciting for me though, compared to how well you do amazing photo themes. I know it's probably suggesting "relaxed" but feels a bit...too relaxed if you will..

Thanks! This one is really nice:

Oct 23 12 08:44 pm Link Quote

Photographer

Goat Farm Project
Posts: 299
Atlanta, Georgia, US

DEREX Art wrote:
There is no "worst"; however, the red dress doesn't seem to go with the other images in your collection.

http://www.modelmayhem.com/portfolio/pi … 7#29598657

True. Thanks! Love this one:

Oct 23 12 08:46 pm Link Quote

Photographer

Goat Farm Project
Posts: 299
Atlanta, Georgia, US

Revenge Photography wrote:

Not because its particularly bad, for some reason it doesn't really grab me, maybe its the blown sky. I can't really put my finger on it.

Thanks! Nice lines on this one:

Oct 23 12 08:48 pm Link Quote

Photographer

Goat Farm Project
Posts: 299
Atlanta, Georgia, US

Gita Lei wrote:
The photo in the first reply was in my humble opinion by far the worst. Cute girl, cute concept but it has no place in your port. Also the last one in your portfolio.. Something about it strikes me as inherently wrong. Her expression or maybe how large the frame is compared to her body. Great concept wonderful colors but it still seems very.. Blegh and off for some reason. Other than that you have a beautiful vibrant portfolio!

Thank you for the feedback smile

This pic is fantastic:

Oct 24 12 05:16 am Link Quote

Photographer

Face the Light
Posts: 94
Olivet, Michigan, US

Goat Farm Project wrote:
Which pics have to go? Tell me straight up and I will LIST your best pic.

Curious what you think. I'll edit this with my thoughts in a moment.

I think the first one should go, even though I actually like it. It doesn't seem to fit what you're trying to do. It looks like a nice "no makeup, unretouched" picture a model would use, while you seem to be aiming for something different.

This one is pretty "natural" looking, but still more polished. I really like it.

Oct 24 12 05:18 am Link Quote

Photographer

Pixyst
Posts: 334
Phoenix, Arizona, US

Go for it! I say this one because there doesn't appear to be a clear message:

Oct 24 12 05:32 am Link Quote

Photographer

Drew Smith Photography
Posts: 3,141
Nottingham, England, United Kingdom

Of what's left undeleted, this would be my suggestion:

http://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/120615/08/4fdb4e21dbf94_m.jpg

Oct 24 12 05:42 am Link Quote

Photographer

Goat Farm Project
Posts: 299
Atlanta, Georgia, US

Cynthia Serrano wrote:

I agree with this but you can also afford to toss this one

Just doesn't quite measure up to the rest of your port and will make it stronger IMO big_smile

Great feedback! This is awesome:

Oct 24 12 06:59 am Link Quote

Photographer

Pantelis Palios
Posts: 178
Birmingham, England, United Kingdom

Goat Farm Project wrote:

Appreciate it! This one was easy:

http://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/120524/04/4fbe155377626_m.jpg

Thank you.

It was hard choosing a bad one from your portfolio.

Oct 24 12 07:18 am Link Quote

Photographer

Goat Farm Project
Posts: 299
Atlanta, Georgia, US

Jorge Kreimer wrote:
http://www.modelmayhem.com/portfolio/pi … 1#28888321

I can't put my finger on it, but something bothers me about this one.

Probably increased vibrancy too much???

This is my favorite, really nice:

Oct 24 12 10:28 am Link Quote

Photographer

Goat Farm Project
Posts: 299
Atlanta, Georgia, US

Face the Light wrote:

Curious what you think. I'll edit this with my thoughts in a moment.

I think the first one should go, even though I actually like it. It doesn't seem to fit what you're trying to do. It looks like a nice "no makeup, unretouched" picture a model would use, while you seem to be aiming for something different.

This one is pretty "natural" looking, but still more polished. I really like it.