I've got a new pin-up to go up so an old one needs to come down, which one should go?

I'd say this one



It just doesn't do the model justice

I don't like these, mostly lighting issues:

Ditch this and keep the similar one with the parasol
http://www.modelmayhem.com/portfolio/pic/31588879

Also the cowgirl mentioned above doesn't work for me

I agree with omitting the dog.
The others mentioned have an extremely dated feel.
Unless you're actually wanting to market yourself as a photographer of 80s glamor images, I'd remove those.

This is actually the one I think you should nix, it's very cute but the lighting and editing don't do the pose or outfit any justice.

http://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/10 … f583_m.jpg


If I had to choose i'd say this one. Your lighting seems very flat in all your images , I'd work on that. But that's a fun style and looks like you have agood start. Best of luck and look forward in seeing more.

Thanks for the feedback and suggestions, major changes made based on your input.