Forums > Critique > Serious Critique > I'll tell you exactly how your port is

Model

Madison P Cook

Posts: 136

Miami, Florida, US

Hey! I'm not sure if you're willing to do one more but I'd love some critique

Jun 08 13 11:32 am Link

Model

Melanie Rose

Posts: 46

New York, New York, US

Can you help me choose my strongest photos and need a book/comp card for NY open calls next week?

you're welcome to go through all the images, or just look in 'portfolio' folder for my top favorites

see link:
http://www.flickr.com/photos/22517982@N … 916011207/

thank you so much for any input, your favorites will help me narrow them down!

Jun 08 13 01:15 pm Link

Photographer

Kyle Payne Imaging

Posts: 3

San Diego, California, US

I would love to hear from you.

Jun 08 13 01:53 pm Link

Model

agnuzele

Posts: 2

Alytus, Alytaus, Lithuania

yes, please smile

Jun 10 13 01:25 pm Link

Photographer

Nate C Photography

Posts: 43

Toowoomba, Queensland, Australia

Please do let me know smile

Jun 10 13 07:54 pm Link

Model

winking_wonder

Posts: 5907

New York, New York, US

Sure!

Jun 11 13 10:18 am Link

Model

Carlysle M

Posts: 11

Seattle, Washington, US

Would like to know

Jun 12 13 06:44 am Link

Model

W I L L O W

Posts: 344

Portland, Oregon, US

Please and thank you!!

Jun 12 13 07:59 am Link

Model

amb300

Posts: 218

Murfreesboro, Tennessee, US

Jun 12 13 01:07 pm Link

Photographer

JWrightPhotography

Posts: 20

Twentynine Palms, California, US

I'm really green with models but give me best advice.

Jun 12 13 01:44 pm Link

Model

Lizzy Takahashi

Posts: 54

Tulsa, Oklahoma, US

Ok!

Jun 13 13 12:03 am Link

Model

Onyx Divine

Posts: 23

York, Pennsylvania, US

would appreciate it....

Jun 13 13 05:37 pm Link

Photographer

Annette Maichen

Posts: 1

Kingman, Arizona, US

I'm a newbie I'm sure can use it. Thank You!

Jun 13 13 06:26 pm Link

Model

W I L L O W

Posts: 344

Portland, Oregon, US

I would love to hear your opinion!

Jun 14 13 04:09 pm Link

Photographer

zz4z4zz444

Posts: 9

Montgomery, Massachusetts, US

Yes, would appreciate you taking a look at a new MMer's portfolio.

Thanks.

BH

Jun 16 13 11:41 am Link

Model

Malina van Leuven

Posts: 86

Brussels, Brussels, Belgium

Yess, please!

Jun 17 13 06:44 am Link

Photographer

zz4z4zz444

Posts: 9

Montgomery, Massachusetts, US

Since I'm new to the MM world I would be curious to hear what you have to say.
Many thanks.
BH

Jun 17 13 08:09 am Link

Photographer

Ron McKinney

Posts: 458

Chicago, Illinois, US

Billy Hughes wrote:
Since I'm new to the MM world I would be curious to hear what you have to say.
Many thanks.
BH

Billy, welcome to MM.  I hope you stick around.

When I look at all your images as a collage, I see the same thing, ad nauseum.   You have some good pictures, albeit even 1-to-1 lighting.  What I would want to see from you is some diversity.  Let's see you use some dramatic lighting.  Let's see you shoot on location and do environmental portraits that focuses on your model.

As for your current port, I love the eyes in your shot of Evangeline, but I want the image to pop more with more contrast and saturation -- but that's my style, not necessarily yours.  I also really like your shot of Sumiah.  Great work, keep it coming.

Jun 19 13 04:49 pm Link

Photographer

Ron McKinney

Posts: 458

Chicago, Illinois, US

Malinaa wrote:
Yess, please!

Hey Malinaa, you've got a wonderful, sensual look.   Some of the shots in your port really bring that out.  I love this head shot:

https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/1 … b4c8_m.jpg

I really love your artistic, creative shots.  You have some really good diversity in your port.  In terms of a port, you could really use some full body shots that really shows off your body.  You're off to a great start, can't wait to see more!

Jun 19 13 04:53 pm Link

Photographer

Ron McKinney

Posts: 458

Chicago, Illinois, US

W I L L O W wrote:
I would love to hear your opinion!

Willow, please come to Chicago, I would love to do a shoot with you!

Your port is very strong with a wide diversity of looks.  If I were you, I'd only go with one shot from your new set of concept shots.  You look really great in red, I might add!  The tilts don't really help your portfolio, but that's obviously the photographer's style, just too heavy with it.  I'd probably go with the one of you on the piano.

Just keep modelling, love your stuff.  And come to Chicago!   :-)

Jun 19 13 04:58 pm Link

Makeup Artist

Leanne Harpin

Posts: 222

Fairfield, Connecticut, US

What about my port?

Jun 20 13 10:50 am Link

Model

C a m i l a

Posts: 119

New York, New York, US

what do I need to toss out?

Jun 20 13 11:23 pm Link

Model

SHIRA

Posts: 46

Spartanburg, South Carolina, US

So, tell me. I would love to know your thoughts. Thanks in advance smile

Jun 27 13 12:13 pm Link

Model

Raven Blake

Posts: 58

Amundsen-Scott - permanent station of the US, Unclaimed Sector, Antarctica

If your still critiquing, would love to hear from you smile

Jun 27 13 10:05 pm Link

Photographer

Worlds Of Water

Posts: 37732

Rancho Cucamonga, California, US

OoooooK... wink

Jun 27 13 10:09 pm Link

Photographer

Gary Altman Photography

Posts: 3

Columbia, South Carolina, US

Ron,

If you're still game, I've got only semi-thick skin.  ;-)   Let 'er rip.

Ed. Note - I've been shooting 2 1/2 years and the later stuff uploaded is better than the earlier stuff. 
Poses were all mine, so good bad or in between that falls on me, so if they missed it's on me.

Thanks in advance,
Gary

Jun 27 13 10:20 pm Link

Model

Paige Morgan

Posts: 4060

New York, New York, US

If you are still going, I'm quite thick skinned, and always find fresh eyes useful.

Jun 27 13 11:07 pm Link

Model

Nicholas Record

Posts: 89

West Jordan, Utah, US

How is my port for a beginner

Jun 28 13 12:02 pm Link

Model

Molly Connolly

Posts: 4

Louisville, Kentucky, US

Hi I would really like a critique of my port. Especially what kind of photos I should add.
Thanks

Molly

Jul 12 13 07:43 pm Link

Model

Kurly Smith

Posts: 89

Georgetown, Ontario, Canada

Me please!!

Jul 13 13 10:57 am Link

Photographer

Massi

Posts: 28

Los Angeles, California, US

Would be great to receive some constructive feedback on my port.  Photography is mostly a hobby for me, but I take it seriously and try to constantly improve.

Jul 13 13 11:21 am Link

Model

Paige Thomley

Posts: 573

West Bend, Wisconsin, US

Sure, why the heck not.

Jul 13 13 11:27 am Link

Photographer

Ron McKinney

Posts: 458

Chicago, Illinois, US

Paige Thomley wrote:
Sure, why the heck not.

Hi Paige.  We're practically neighbors. 

Let me start with I like in your port.  No. 1, I really like the range of work shown here.  Nudes, conceptual fashion, head shots, a little on the weird, a lot on the weird, and some bordering on normal, traditional sots.  I really like most of your shots.  The avatar is great, blue dress, white dress on grass, the classical medieval painting scenes with the apple, shot on the wood pile, head shot fourth row on the right, and fifth row on the left (both just killer), nudes in dramatic shadows work well for me.  I could keep going.

What I don't like: not much.  You've got two blown out shots, far right, fourth and fifth rows.  You don't need both.  The hair in the fifth row shot works better.  Probably should've included that in the shots I really like.  Head shot with the funny face/wink, not so great.  fifth row, right hand on chest, doesn't really work for me.  fifth row, both hands on chest making great cleavage, totally works.  Beach shot with you next to big rocks, looks like an amateur P&S shot.  Some of the older shots don't really work for me either.

Too bad I didn't have more time, totally would dig coming up to Wisconsin and doing a conceptual shoot with you.

Jul 14 13 11:36 am Link

Photographer

Ron McKinney

Posts: 458

Chicago, Illinois, US

Kurly Smith wrote:
Me please!!

Kurly, not a lot to say here.  Looks like you've worked with three photographers.  No offense to jetude or Hollingsworth, but they're really not helping you.  You have a really look, but a great photographer (along with stylist/mua/hair) will transform you to a whole 'nother level.  You go in that direction with your shots from Pura-Vida.

You're 16 years old.  There's no better time than now to get really serious about your modeling.  It takes a lot of work, perseverance, and learning the skill set, to make it.  But foremost on there is to find photographers who can bring out the best in you.  You ever come to Chicago, let me know and I'll see if I can free up some time.  But for the meantime, be more discerning who you are working with.  You wanna be a pro model, find photographers with those same aspirations/qualities to photograph you.

Jul 14 13 11:43 am Link

Photographer

Ron McKinney

Posts: 458

Chicago, Illinois, US

Molly Connolly wrote:
Hi I would really like a critique of my port. Especially what kind of photos I should add.
Thanks

Molly

Hi Molly, you've only 7 pics in your port, so not a whole lot to talk about.  Look at the first pic in your port, far left first row, shot by David Charles.  Now go to 2nd row, 2nd pic, shot by Stephanie Anne.  See how your facial structure changes between these two shoots.  Really talented fashion photographers know how to bring out the most in your facial structure and help you look your best.  But right now, you need to tackle more shoots.  Get in as many TFP shoots as you can, and as you feel yourself getting comfortable, then start focusing in on better photographers.  Good luck!

Jul 14 13 11:57 am Link

Photographer

Ron McKinney

Posts: 458

Chicago, Illinois, US

Massi wrote:
Would be great to receive some constructive feedback on my port.  Photography is mostly a hobby for me, but I take it seriously and try to constantly improve.

Massi, you've got some interesting looks going on in your port.  But your work with light, both natural light and studio strobes (or speedlights) need some fine-tuning.  I think you do a really nice job of creating some scenes that are fitting for the concept of the shot.  The parasol shot is very nice, just don't like how the bushes behind them with the blown highlights pulls your attention away from the models.  Otherwise, very soft light on your models, creating a beautiful pastoral scene.  Shot of the redhead on the scene, you've got to learn how to harness the light even in those conditions.  Trying to save it in Photoshop doesn't usually work, and it didn't work here.  Girl in long skirt/purple shirt, trash that shot immediately.  She's under a tree with spotted direct sunlight coming down through the trees.  The Great Gatsby shot is an example of what works.  Trees shots look good, some of the others, not so.  With your studio lighting, be careful with your hot spots.  Really good studio lighting is like painting lighting onto your subject, whether you're going for a soft, feathered lighting, or harsh, dramatic lighting.  Control it, make it do what you want.

Jul 14 13 12:07 pm Link

Photographer

Ron McKinney

Posts: 458

Chicago, Illinois, US

I'm sorry for those of you that I skipped, but I have no idea if you're still following this thread, and I put some time and thought into this, just don't want to waste it.  Feel free to respond again, and I'll try to get it done more timely.

Jul 14 13 12:14 pm Link

Model

C A T H Y

Posts: 5464

Anaheim, California, US

Go for it.

Jul 14 13 12:23 pm Link

Model

Axioma

Posts: 6822

Antwerp, Antwerp, Belgium

Ron McKinney wrote:
I'm sorry for those of you that I skipped, but I have no idea if you're still following this thread, and I put some time and thought into this, just don't want to waste it.  Feel free to respond again, and I'll try to get it done more timely.

hienvy

Jul 14 13 12:25 pm Link

Model

Kurly Smith

Posts: 89

Georgetown, Ontario, Canada

Ron McKinney wrote:
Kurly, not a lot to say here.  Looks like you've worked with three photographers.  No offense to jetude or Hollingsworth, but they're really not helping you.  You have a really look, but a great photographer (along with stylist/mua/hair) will transform you to a whole 'nother level.  You go in that direction with your shots from Pura-Vida.

You're 16 years old.  There's no better time than now to get really serious about your llamaing.  It takes a lot of work, perseverance, and learning the skill set, to make it.  But foremost on there is to find photographers who can bring out the best in you.  You ever come to Chicago, let me know and I'll see if I can free up some time.  But for the meantime, be more discerning who you are working with.  You wanna be a pro llama, find photographers with those same aspirations/qualities to photograph you.

Thanks for the advice.  I am trying to find those photographers!  I would love to shoot with you if I ever get to Chicago . . . Who knows?

Jul 14 13 02:18 pm Link