Forums > Critique > Cut to the bone! for a stronger portfolio.

Photographer

Dennis Zeitz

Posts: 98

Melbourne, Victoria, Australia

"thanks" are nice, but feedback is better, and it's great when I got back see a much stronger portfolio!

comments, tags on my port and friend requests are great too!

Jun 24 13 08:19 am Link

Photographer

KEKnight

Posts: 1876

Cumming, Georgia, US

Dennis Zeitz wrote:
Here, like this, cut everything else, and BAM! you have a killer portfolio.

Thanks for looking over my port.  You really do mean to the bone.   
I agree that half my pictures need to go but do I really need to cut these?

https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/070408/12/461912fd12193_m.jpg
and

https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/080206/09/47a9ca0cda1b8_m.jpg

Jun 24 13 02:20 pm Link

Photographer

Norman Ding

Posts: 68

New York, New York, US

Would love to hear your opinion

Jun 24 13 07:39 pm Link

Model

E L I N

Posts: 199

Montreal, Quebec, Canada

Dont have much but could keep only four! Let me know.

Jun 24 13 07:51 pm Link

Photographer

Dennis Zeitz

Posts: 98

Melbourne, Victoria, Australia

KEKnight wrote:
Thanks for looking over my port.  You really do mean to the bone.   
I agree that half my pictures need to go but do I really need to cut these?

https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/070408/12/461912fd12193_m.jpg
and

https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/080206/09/47a9ca0cda1b8_m.jpg

Thanks for the feedback!!  I try to spend as much time as I can, but I have to go pretty quick, it helps me to know what you guys think, and let me know if I missed something.

they are both good, I thought about those two but:
the first one the eyes are blurry/milky looking and no catch light. it's too bad there is not more detail in the skin like I can see on the shoulders. OR crop a bit closer and burn out the shoulders,  it's a great concept, how much post work did you do? 
Second. it doesn't fit in the the rest of the images. Show those type of images you want to shoot more of.
good portfolio! Let me know when you update it.

I had another look through, and I like her expression more this time, and you did a good job. uncut : )
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/080505/00/481e8f376035c_m.jpg

Jun 24 13 08:01 pm Link

Photographer

Dennis Zeitz

Posts: 98

Melbourne, Victoria, Australia

Norman Ding wrote:
Would love to hear your opinion

Great shot! I like the french tilt. could you put your water mark on the lower half?, it's distracting. Also it's a tiny thing but the little black spot at the on the lower left edge catches the eye, I'd PS it out.
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/120610/09/4fd4c653a60ee_m.jpg

I was going to tell you cut this when I looked at the thumbnails, but seeing it full screen, it works. good one!
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/120610/09/4fd4c71da5352_m.jpg

really good shot! good model, knows how to look.
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/130604/19/51aea5b94f26d_m.jpg

her expression, cut, got any others?
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/130217/11/51212e5377de0_m.jpg

same, her expression, cut, got any others?
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/130611/20/51b7e7c740375_m.jpg

Jun 24 13 08:23 pm Link

Photographer

JWC54321

Posts: 50

Atlanta, Georgia, US

Me please

Jun 24 13 08:40 pm Link

Photographer

Norman Ding

Posts: 68

New York, New York, US

Dennis Zeitz wrote:
Great shot! I like the french tilt. could you put your water mark on the lower half?, it's distracting. Also it's a tiny thing but the little black spot at the on the lower left edge catches the eye, I'd PS it out.
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/120610/09/4fd4c653a60ee_m.jpg

I was going to tell you cut this when I looked at the thumbnails, but seeing it full screen, it works. good one!
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/120610/09/4fd4c71da5352_m.jpg

Thank you so much for the compliments and critiques!
really good shot! good model, knows how to look.
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/130604/19/51aea5b94f26d_m.jpg

her expression, cut, got any others?
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/130217/11/51212e5377de0_m.jpg

same, her expression, cut, got any others?
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/130611/20/51b7e7c740375_m.jpg

Thank you so much for the compliments and critiques!

Jun 24 13 08:46 pm Link

Photographer

J Quest

Posts: 5

Saint Petersburg, Florida, US

I'm new to MM. Might as well get that deep cut critique!

Jun 24 13 09:08 pm Link

Photographer

Dennis Zeitz

Posts: 98

Melbourne, Victoria, Australia

Please give me feedback!  I try to spend as much time as I can, but I have to go pretty quick, it helps me to know what you guys think, and let me know if I missed something.

"thanks" are nice, but feedback is better, and it's great when I got back see a much stronger portfolio!

comments, tags on my port and friend requests are great too!

Jun 24 13 09:15 pm Link

Photographer

Dennis Zeitz

Posts: 98

Melbourne, Victoria, Australia

JWC54321 wrote:
Me please

you should use this for your avatar, by far your best shot.
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/130622/17/51c63c26835f8_m.jpg

this could work, but the crop is off. look at body croping guides.
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/130602/19/51abfcaa7dc5c_m.jpg

keep this for now.
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/130516/15/519561d319a39_m.jpg

cut the rest.  I know it's hard, but having only a few great shots is better.  I only have 4 good model shots I can show right now, I'm trying to arrange a studio for shoots for next month.

cut, shooting in full daylight is hard.. take practice and learning about light.
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/130516/15/519562614a71b_m.jpg

Jun 24 13 09:39 pm Link

Model

Nicki Micki

Posts: 270

Charleston, South Carolina, US

Dennis Zeitz wrote:

Great shot. who took this? see if they will take more.. and cut everything else.
If I saw this one shot I would hire you, if I saw the others I wouldn't, you need a photog who can get the best out of you.
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/130220/19/512597ec7f468_m.jpg

try a search in your area for photogs who TF and pick a good one, a quick seach turned up these as possible:

https://www.modelmayhem.com/585061
https://www.modelmayhem.com/1877442


cut, your hand makes your neck looks odd.
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/130622/20/51c670243fab0_m.jpg

Well thank you for the Advice and I took the photo myself when I had my camera big_smile

Jun 24 13 09:51 pm Link

Photographer

Dennis Zeitz

Posts: 98

Melbourne, Victoria, Australia

J Quest  wrote:
I'm new to MM. Might as well get that deep cut critique!

best shot
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/130612/06/51b871b074aae_m.jpg

good shot but bad crop. give her room to breath, too much empty space on left, need more on right.
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/130612/06/51b8728c29510_m.jpg

good job, nice light balance. you picked the right time of day, but using on camera flash means the light on her is flat. get a TTL flash cable, about $35 on ebay.
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/130612/06/51b870f51c1c7_m.jpg


cut, they both look mad and awkward,  see if you can find about 5 more to cut.
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/130623/21/51c7cff04fd40_m.jpg

Jun 24 13 09:57 pm Link

Photographer

Dennis Zeitz

Posts: 98

Melbourne, Victoria, Australia

Nicki Micki wrote:

Well thank you for the Advice and I took the photo myself when I had my camera big_smile

wow, get a camera again. what did you think of the photog links I sent?

Jun 24 13 10:04 pm Link

Model

Nicki Micki

Posts: 270

Charleston, South Carolina, US

Dennis Zeitz wrote:

wow, get a camera again. what did you think of the photog links I sent?

If I had the money I would... And I message the first one the 2nd one hasn't logged on since 2011

Jun 24 13 10:53 pm Link

Photographer

Dennis Zeitz

Posts: 98

Melbourne, Victoria, Australia

Nicki Micki wrote:
If I had the money I would... And I message the first one the 2nd one hasn't logged on since 2011

practice with any cam, even cell phone.  You might have to pay a photog to get the shots you need. it looks like there aren't many TF in your town,  but I did that search for Compensation set to "TF" but lots of others photog put any, but still do TF. so try other searches.  also make it clear that you will show up and are reliable, because that can be a big problem.   

watch this, a good camera is not important:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZUkKtkEZNjs

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zh6zr3wKRV0&hd=1

Jun 24 13 11:11 pm Link

Photographer

Dennis Zeitz

Posts: 98

Melbourne, Victoria, Australia

MIND BLOWN! check out this killer port, NSFW
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZUkKtkEZNjs

https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/120105/10/4f05e8813f7fd_m.jpg

Jun 24 13 11:31 pm Link

Photographer

Anvanya Photography

Posts: 26

Breda, Noord-Brabant, Netherlands

I'd like to hear your opinion on my port, I'm looking to cut some since I've got some of new (I think better ones) waiting.. smile

Jun 25 13 06:22 am Link

Photographer

Dennis Zeitz

Posts: 98

Melbourne, Victoria, Australia

Anvanya Photography wrote:
I'd like to hear your opinion on my port, I'm looking to cut some since I've got some of new (I think better ones) waiting.. smile

great shot, was there something wrong with the color that you made this B&W?
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/130518/13/5197e938df95e_m.jpg

good!
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/120820/14/5032ad2c4d0e2_m.jpg

whats up with these crops? people need headspace,and more space on the direction they are looking.
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/110725/14/4e2de69ba2b70_m.jpg

https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/130514/08/51925bb44dff5_m.jpg

I see you love cutting off peoples hands, cut or re-crop any hand cuts.
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/120820/14/5032a7f766dfb_m.jpg

here's a useful guide
http://lifehacker.com/5991733/avoid-amp … heat-sheet

I hope that helps, let me know when the new shots are up.

Jun 25 13 08:54 am Link

Photographer

Dennis Zeitz

Posts: 98

Melbourne, Victoria, Australia

Please give me feedback!  I try to spend as much time as I can, but I have to go pretty quick, it helps me to know what you guys think, and let me know if I missed something.

"thanks" are nice, but feedback is better, and it's great when I got back see a much stronger portfolio!

comments, tags on my port and friend requests are great too!

Jun 25 13 08:58 am Link

Model

Shelly Foster

Posts: 53

Abbotsford, British Columbia, Canada

Bring it on smile

Jun 25 13 08:10 pm Link

Photographer

Anvanya Photography

Posts: 26

Breda, Noord-Brabant, Netherlands

Thank you very much for you critique and for the link.

1st photo:
Thank you! I just really love black and white and I thought my port could use a nice B&W. No big reason apart from that.

2nd photo:
Thanks! I was actually considering scrapping this one, now I'm a bit in doubt, lol! smile
Good to get your opinion! 

3/4rd photo:
I totally agree with looking direction in most cases, in these shots it was a conscious decision to ignore it though. But could well be it didn't work out as well as I imagined. wink Thanks for the feedback!

5th photo:
Lol, it's not because of a big love for hand amputation but I agree it's cropped wrong. It's the fast movement of the model that made it a bit hard to get it right, but I should have just zoomed back more and cropped after taking the shot.
But in all honesty even without the movement I have made shots where there cropping wasn't spot on and the link you posted is really nice and clear! Thanks!!

Even though I admit I am not always great at getting criticism, it's really useful so I appreciate it. Thanks for taking the time!
A lot of these shots need to get scrapped soon to make room for new the ones, so I'll take this in account.
Two new shots are/where up, more soon. smile

Jun 26 13 03:04 pm Link

Model

Raven Blake

Posts: 58

Amundsen-Scott - permanent station of the US, Unclaimed Sector, Antarctica

Would love your opinion.

Jun 26 13 05:33 pm Link

Photographer

Dennis Zeitz

Posts: 98

Melbourne, Victoria, Australia

Shelly Foster wrote:
Bring it on smile

very good port.

girl on train track is done so often, but I think you nailed it.  your hand is cut off, but whatever : ) I guess cropping into a square would fix it.
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/121120/10/50abd285aa046_m.jpg

great smile! this would have been one of your best, if it was in focus, and there was a catchlight in your eyes. Your foot is cut off, your leg leading to the corner lead your eye out of the photo. you did your part, but the photog let you down.
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/121120/11/50abd38a3e01b_m.jpg

if you're in profile don't try to look at the camera, look off to the horizion. cut
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/130418/20/5170bca390150_m.jpg

cut, the highlights are burned out, not sure about your expression.
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/130313/13/5140dec21d654_m.jpg

Jun 26 13 08:39 pm Link

Model

E L I N

Posts: 199

Montreal, Quebec, Canada

Skipped sad

Jun 26 13 09:15 pm Link

Model

Miss Bond

Posts: 1507

Toronto, Ontario, Canada

oki:)

Jun 26 13 09:25 pm Link

Photographer

Dennis Zeitz

Posts: 98

Melbourne, Victoria, Australia

Raven Blake wrote:
Would love your opinion.

Search for  a good photographer with a proper studio and pay them to get the kind of shots you want.  then don't do TF for just anyone who asks, look for good photogs that will help you build a portfolio.

Jun 27 13 07:51 am Link

Photographer

Dennis Zeitz

Posts: 98

Melbourne, Victoria, Australia

Gabrielle Ann  wrote:
Skipped sad

oops, sorry!
I think you have potential but you've got to find better photogs. sometimes when you do TF you get what you pay for. spend some time searching or pay a top shooter to get something really good.  also work on expressions, practice with self portraits and any cam or cellphone. 

ok, but could be so much better.  there's a lot more too it that just pressing the button.
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/130619/18/51c25aa95dc24_m.jpg

Jun 27 13 08:11 am Link

Model

Camille Smooch

Posts: 2

Woodland Hills, California, US

I'm curious

Jun 27 13 08:12 am Link

Photographer

Dennis Zeitz

Posts: 98

Melbourne, Victoria, Australia

Miss Bond wrote:
oki:)

Awesome portfolio! professional and great expressions. Love it!
How many James Bond jokes do you get?

Killer shot, I saw that in a magazine.
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/130319/14/5148dc239e2d6_m.jpg


If you want to updated it, you could cut these and put in the shot of you sitting on the grass in the black dress, and the one on the leather coutch with plaid shirt. they are so much better.

https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/130312/08/513f4eb005e55_m.jpg

https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/130319/14/5148dbff64f32_m.jpg

Jun 27 13 08:28 am Link

Model

Uber Dami

Posts: 5551

New Haven, Connecticut, US

hit me

Jun 27 13 08:41 am Link

Photographer

MCB Imagery

Posts: 148

Portland, Oregon, US

Would like your thoughts - thanks!

Jun 27 13 09:00 am Link

Model

Luna Diosa

Posts: 13242

Elizabeth, New Jersey, US

curious as to what I should toss so once I start shooting again I know what to get rid of

Jun 27 13 09:12 am Link

Photographer

sospix

Posts: 23769

Orlando, Florida, US

Blast away, what looks like crap and hasta go  .  .  .  wink

SOS

Jun 27 13 09:27 am Link

Model

Miss Bond

Posts: 1507

Toronto, Ontario, Canada

Dennis Zeitz wrote:

Awesome portfolio! professional and great expressions. Love it!
How many James Bond jokes do you get?

Killer shot, I saw that in a magazine.
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/130319/14/5148dc239e2d6_m.jpg


If you want to updated it, you could cut these and put in the shot of you sitting on the grass in the black dress, and the one on the leather coutch with plaid shirt. they are so much better.

https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/130312/08/513f4eb005e55_m.jpg

https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/130319/14/5148dbff64f32_m.jpg

Thank you very much:)

Jun 27 13 12:57 pm Link

Photographer

Dennis Zeitz

Posts: 98

Melbourne, Victoria, Australia

Über Dami wrote:
hit me

I'm not a good choice to cirtique this type of work because I don't know anything about it, but these stand out as your best to me.  what's up with the chainsaw?

https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/060711/12/44b3dbbb855ab_m.jpg

https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/070427/20/46329b87ecf27_m.jpg

https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/060911/14/4505b93b858ae_m.jpg

Jun 27 13 09:12 pm Link

Photographer

Dennis Zeitz

Posts: 98

Melbourne, Victoria, Australia

MCB Imagery wrote:
Would like your thoughts - thanks!

I can see how much you've improved at getting the best out of the models!, it's all great until I got to the bottom.

cut, and everything below it.
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/130115/20/50f629e232400_m.jpg

Jun 27 13 09:23 pm Link

Photographer

Dennis Zeitz

Posts: 98

Melbourne, Victoria, Australia

Please give me feedback!  I try to spend as much time as I can, but I have to go pretty quick, it helps me to know what you guys think, and let me know if I missed something.

"thanks" are nice, but feedback is better, and it's great when I got back see a much stronger portfolio!

comments, tags on my port and friend requests are great too!

Jun 27 13 09:25 pm Link

Photographer

Dennis Zeitz

Posts: 98

Melbourne, Victoria, Australia

Camille Smolucha wrote:
I'm curious

BEST!
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/130627/08/51cc55d27a85f_m.jpg

cut
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/130627/08/51cc56242c626_m.jpg

cut
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/130325/17/5150e76601ad8_m.jpg

Jun 28 13 09:19 pm Link

Photographer

Dennis Zeitz

Posts: 98

Melbourne, Victoria, Australia

Anvanya Photography wrote:
Thank you very much for you critique and for the link.

1st photo:
Thank you! I just really love black and white and I thought my port could use a nice B&W. No big reason apart from that.

2nd photo:
Thanks! I was actually considering scrapping this one, now I'm a bit in doubt, lol! smile
Good to get your opinion! 

3/4rd photo:
I totally agree with looking direction in most cases, in these shots it was a conscious decision to ignore it though. But could well be it didn't work out as well as I imagined. wink Thanks for the feedback!

5th photo:
Lol, it's not because of a big love for hand amputation but I agree it's cropped wrong. It's the fast movement of the model that made it a bit hard to get it right, but I should have just zoomed back more and cropped after taking the shot.
But in all honesty even without the movement I have made shots where there cropping wasn't spot on and the link you posted is really nice and clear! Thanks!!

Even though I admit I am not always great at getting criticism, it's really useful so I appreciate it. Thanks for taking the time!
A lot of these shots need to get scrapped soon to make room for new the ones, so I'll take this in account.
Two new shots are/where up, more soon. smile

thank you, for taking the time to comment!

Jun 28 13 09:21 pm Link