Stanley L Moore

Posts: 1681

Houston, Texas, US

On another forum is a discussion of what you think about models re-editing photographer's already edited photos. I am unsure how to approach this. Is it improper to critique the edits? Here are a couple examples of what two models think improves on my efforts.

If it is improper feel free to comment and critique on my versions alone.

18+ my version:
The model's idea of how to make it better:

Here is another couple examples:
My version, minimal edits, gray scale, minor brightness change:
His edits:

Notice the veins are more prominent in his version.

Sep 13 13 01:53 pm Link


Guss W

Posts: 10830

Clearwater, Florida, US

It would be improper to offer comments on someone else's work when not requested by that person, but I will say that your version is within the bounds of good taste.

Sep 13 13 02:38 pm Link