Forums > Critique > Your single best image

Photographer

Joel Belmont

Posts: 138

Rochester, Washington, US

If all your images were going to be destroyed, and you could only save ONE - which one would you save - and why that image? What qualities does it have that makes it stand out above the rest?

Please post the one image below, and why you like it best.  A photographer should know their best work, even if you have a lot of favorites.

Feb 21 19 09:10 am Link

Photographer

Jorge Kreimer

Posts: 3716

San Cristóbal de las Casas, Chiapas, Mexico

Joel Belmont wrote:
If all your images were going to be destroyed, and you could only save ONE - which one would you save - and why that image? What qualities does it have that makes it stand out above the rest?

Please post the one image below, and why you like it best.  A photographer should know their best work, even if you have a lot of favorites.

https://www.gershonkreimer.com/index/void#9 This one, I think.

I see it as a summary of all of my work. My interest with minimalism, coloration, asymmetric composition, irrationality of pose, censorship of the body, censorship of the identity, and the fantastic texture of the hair.

It's also a 48" x 64" print.
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/180905/19/5b908e5a8f188.jpg

Feb 21 19 09:14 am Link

Photographer

Joel Belmont

Posts: 138

Rochester, Washington, US

Though I have a lot of favorites, this is my single best image: https://www.modelmayhem.com/portfolio/pic/269436

1) It has simplicity: in the scene, composition, tones, poses
2) It conveys an idea to me: progress, and care by others, even when we don't want help
3) It excludes personality
4) It includes the nude in a way that's not sexual or personal
5) It has shallow depth of field, which reduces the image more to idea than replication of reality

The beauty of this exercise, which was a question originally posted by John Paul Caponigro, is that the qualities you can define in your best image, are those that make a recipe for success in creating new images.

In my case, I would want to create images with simplicity, convey an idea, exclude personality, include the nude but exclude sensuality, and use my tools to make is less about replication of reality... again, more about idea.

Feb 21 19 09:19 am Link

Photographer

Joel Belmont

Posts: 138

Rochester, Washington, US

Jorge Kreimer wrote:
Minimalism, coloration, asymmetric composition, irrationality of pose, censorship of the body, censorship of the identity, and fantastic texture of hair.

Sounds like a good recipe for creating images that interest you!

Feb 21 19 09:21 am Link

Photographer

sospix

Posts: 23769

Orlando, Florida, US

Of the ones I have posted in my port, this is the one  .  .  .

https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/140325/09/5331a9f17c164.jpg

.  .  .  it was the model's first ever shoot, and she wasn't a surfer at all, but it captures the exact energy and look I was after for a period surf piece, and Carrie looks like a real shredder  .  .  .  I ended up pushing the original image a bit (and converted it to B&W), to get the relative coarseness of a pushed 400 asa, Tri-X film image of that time period  .  .  .  really enjoy the way it came out, it's a commercial piece, but I have a framed print of this version on my office wall  .  .  .

SOS

Feb 21 19 02:03 pm Link

Photographer

Joel Belmont

Posts: 138

Rochester, Washington, US

sospix wrote:
Of the ones I have posted in my port, this is the one  .  .  .

https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/140325/09/5331a9f17c164.jpg

.  .  .  it was the model's first ever shoot, and she wasn't a surfer at all, but it captures the exact energy and look I was after for a period surf piece, and Carrie looks like a real shredder  .  .  .  I ended up pushing the original image a bit (and converted it to B&W), to get the relative coarseness of a pushed 400 asa, Tri-X film image of that time period  .  .  .  really enjoy the way it came out, it's a commercial piece, but I have a framed print of this version on my office wall  .  .  .

SOS

Another reason it works well is it almost follows the golden ratio compositionally.  It's something that's not talked about often (people revert to the generic rule of thirds) but is something I teach religiously.  It has more to do with increasing size spaces from the subject to the edge of the frame to create visual momentum. 

Nicely seen!

Feb 21 19 03:24 pm Link

Photographer

FIFTYONE PHOTOGRAPHY

Posts: 6597

Uniontown, Pennsylvania, US

In My MM portfolio? today it's this one.

https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/161030/07/58160558ea37a_m.jpg

A dime a dozen now, back when the image was shot (2016) the Wardrobe was a real challenge to source, the Model new and a challenge in Herself, although She provided makeup and decorated the Bat, to a T. 
(Thanks Vivi)    smile 

The pre-shoot prep was time consuming and mentally exhausting, the shoot, rewarding.

I'd like to hang on to it as a reminder of how a little hard work and dedication to making it happen paid off.

Feb 21 19 03:56 pm Link

Photographer

sospix

Posts: 23769

Orlando, Florida, US

Joel Belmont wrote:

Another reason it works well is it almost follows the golden ratio compositionally.  It's something that's not talked about often (people revert to the generic rule of thirds) but is something I teach religiously.  It has more to do with increasing size spaces from the subject to the edge of the frame to create visual momentum. 

Nicely seen!

Glad you enjoyed it Mr. J  .  .  .  I shoot almost exclusively for commercial purposes at this point, so "white" space for copy and logos is always at a premium in an image, having an image have a flow that brings the viewers eye to what the client thinks is important is the paramount goal, the setting and the model just enhance the message (at least in the client's eyes)  .  .  .  all that being said, I still try and produce quality images that can stand alone when I'm shooting, and this one really caught that essence of that  .  .  .  easily one of my all time favorites!  Thanks for the look  .  .  .

SOS

Feb 22 19 06:47 am Link

Photographer

Wandering Eyebubble

Posts: 323

Toronto, Ontario, Canada

Joel Belmont wrote:
If all your images were going to be destroyed, and you could only save ONE - which one would you save - and why that image? What qualities does it have that makes it stand out above the rest?

I already mentioned one image in the other thread you made in this regard, but just reposting it would be repetitive, so I'll add this one to the USB key I'm desperately copying photos into as the flames engulf my home:

https://www.reimeika.ca/page/portfolio/DSX_21125.jpg

I like that there's a bit of a mystery to it, and the colour palette (in contrast to the previous photo I posted which could only really work in B&W). The model, Kotomi, is not on MM, but she was a trooper when we took this snapshot in dreadful weather.

Feb 22 19 08:08 am Link

Photographer

Jerry Nemeth

Posts: 33355

Dearborn, Michigan, US

I won't post my best image because I'm sure it will be stolen!

Feb 22 19 01:05 pm Link

Photographer

Jorge Kreimer

Posts: 3716

San Cristóbal de las Casas, Chiapas, Mexico

Never mind...

Feb 22 19 01:07 pm Link

Clothing Designer

GRMACK

Posts: 5436

Bakersfield, California, US

https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/141203/08/547f3cdec1ac5.jpg

Mainly 'cause I made everything she is wearing from cane to hat.

Feb 22 19 05:11 pm Link

Photographer

Jerry Nemeth

Posts: 33355

Dearborn, Michigan, US

GRMACK wrote:
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/141203/08/547f3cdec1ac5.jpg

Mainly 'cause I made everything she is wearing from cane to hat.

I like this image!

Feb 23 19 07:55 am Link

Photographer

Joel Belmont

Posts: 138

Rochester, Washington, US

Wandering Eyebubble wrote:
I already mentioned one image in the other thread you made in this regard, but just reposting it would be repetitive, so I'll add this one to the USB key I'm desperately copying photos into as the flames engulf my home.

Which other thread? I’ve only asked this question one other time I can think of, and it’s in a private mastermind group for our Dynamic Nude Masterclass, so not sure that you would have seen it there.

The things you like about it... muted color pallete, impersonality... these are a good recipe for creating more images you really like. 👌

Feb 23 19 05:04 pm Link

Photographer

Gelsen Aripia Images

Posts: 230

Toronto, Ontario, Canada

I'm very fond of this one, as it appeals to my aesthetic:  https://www.modelmayhem.com/portfolio/pic/37480865

In it's original form, it was an unusable image, very dark.  The model was posing for the actual photographer at the shoot, and I was just hanging around taking whatever I possibly could whilst helping out around the set.  The lights were set up for his camera, not mine.  I played with it in Lightroom until I was happy with it, and now it's my avatar.

Feb 23 19 08:35 pm Link

Photographer

dcsmooth

Posts: 1349

Detroit, Michigan, US

Even though other images I have done get more views and comments, I have always been very pleased with this one which captures a sensitive moment between two friends:

https://www.modelmayhem.com/portfolio/pic/40141321  18+ nudity

Both of them are very experienced MM models.  To me, the body language of the pose, the light, and their expressions come together to make it appealing.

Feb 24 19 08:36 am Link

Photographer

Orca Bay Images

Posts: 33877

Arcata, California, US

My avatar image.
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/120620/02/4fe19c9e627e3_m.jpg

This model (Cece, aka Chipo) was so easy and pleasant to work with on multiple levels. And she required so little editing. I had a lot of fun punching up the shine on that dress, the jewelry, her hair, her lips, her eyes, but that complexion is all hers. She has one of the most perfect complexions I've ever seen.

We had total access to a bridal/prom shop and I'd long been aching to do something with sequins.

Feb 24 19 01:05 pm Link

Photographer

Wandering Eyebubble

Posts: 323

Toronto, Ontario, Canada

Joel Belmont wrote:
Which other thread? I’ve only asked this question one other time I can think of, and it’s in a private mastermind group for our Dynamic Nude Masterclass, so not sure that you would have seen it there.

This one:

https://www.modelmayhem.com/forums/post/973544

The framing of your question was essentially the same ("if you could only save one image...")

The things you like about it... muted color pallete, impersonality... these are a good recipe for creating more images you really like. 👌

Thanks! smile

Feb 24 19 01:25 pm Link

Photographer

Joel Belmont

Posts: 138

Rochester, Washington, US

Wandering Eyebubble wrote:
https://www.modelmayhem.com/forums/post/973544

The framing of your question was essentially the same ("if you could only save one image...")

Ah yes, that was last summer. I was using it more as a criteria as which image to submit for a critique.

The intent here is not critique, but to elucidate qualities for each photographer that give them the possibility to create more images that have as much impact as their favorite image.

Good memory.

Feb 24 19 05:14 pm Link

Photographer

PhillipM

Posts: 8049

Nashville, Tennessee, US

https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/110417/12/4dab410e6aaa2.jpg

One of my favs in the portrait genre.  Meeting him in the parking lot behind the shop one summer afternoon, and asking him to come in so I could grab this.  The guy was having a tough day to say the least.  I paid him what I could for his time.

I remember it like it was this afternoon. 

Photo edit: Pictus MM # 1750485

Feb 24 19 05:36 pm Link

Photographer

Joel Belmont

Posts: 138

Rochester, Washington, US

PhillipM wrote:
One of my favs in the portrait genre.  Meeting him in the parking lot behind the shop one summer afternoon, and asking him to come in so I could grab this.  The guy was having a tough day to say the least.

What are the qualities it has that make it special to you, aside from the backstory/your experience making the image?

Feb 25 19 06:10 pm Link

Photographer

PhillipM

Posts: 8049

Nashville, Tennessee, US

I feel the pain.

Feb 28 19 05:54 pm Link