Forums > Critique > Serious Critique > Newbie Please critique

Photographer

Zachary Epstein

Posts: 9

Mission Viejo, California, US

Hi please critique my images I used for my MM Profile
1/2 Film 1/2 digital from fashion editorials, lifestyle campaign, and personal. Thank you!

Aug 26 14 03:40 pm Link

Photographer

Lee_Photography

Posts: 9863

Minneapolis, Minnesota, US

https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/140826/08/53fcae12217af_m.jpg
Your strongest image
Level the horizon

https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/140826/08/53fcae3539874_m.jpg
Another interesting capature
Wish shadow photo bottom left were not there
Wish all of models arm shadow was there

https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/140826/09/53fcafdd2ae06_m.jpg
This for me has harsh lighting
Model too centered

https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/140826/08/53fcaec5dde1b_m.jpg
Too much cliff not enough model

Aug 26 14 03:55 pm Link

Photographer

garrinevan

Posts: 120

Atlanta, Georgia, US

https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/140826/08/53fcaef29fc46.jpg
In general I really like what you're doing, or at least the direction you're heading in. This shot isn't working for me though. She's attractive, she's nude, okay...but she's incredibly under-exposed. And the image is blurry. Doesn't belong in your port.

https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/140826/08/53fcadcf67639.jpg
I love this shot. It's weird, humorous, quirky....above all, interesting. Can't say I've seen anything like this in recent memory. I'm curious about what she's about to do though...the story behind the concept. Is she going to brand this half man half beast? Or feed him some steak? Hmmmm

https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/140826/08/53fcad83bdc49.jpg
Not feeling this one so much. The blown out highlights bother me. It's just really really bright. When you look at it, where does your eye go 1st? If there was something else in the shot that was interesting to look at, great color, great expression, etc, then maybe it could be passable (although unlikely)...I would toss this one.

https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/140826/09/53fcaf8c3eda2.jpg
I like this shot. It's elegant. I don't like the claw-like position of her fingers however. The paintings are a bit lost...better color/contrast needed on that back wall. The light bulb showing through the lamp - would retouch that out. The shadow being cast by the lamp - not liking that so much. The sliver of wall (far right) lit by the window...would crop that out.

https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/140826/08/53fcae52e35e9.jpg
I really want to like this shot. I love the color. But I don't see her arms, and that's bothering me. Strikes me as art photography, not at all fashion (not sure what you intended). Seems like it belongs in a gallery or coffee table book, as part of a series, along with other art photos.

https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/140826/09/53fcafdd2ae06.jpg
Highlights are a little too hot (her hand especially), but this could easily be fixed. The rock in the foreground is a distraction. Model's center position is okay, but feel like her pose and composition in general could use some work.

Sep 28 14 07:14 pm Link

Model

Ty Chen

Posts: 45

Los Angeles, California, US

I personally really enjoy your work. I agree with what others are saying about too much cliff, not enough model, etc. but I understand the direction you're going for. Still, it's something to bear in mind, but I'm sure you can frame the photo however you want to depending on your client.

Secondly, I have to disagree with what everyone is saying about harsh lighting/overexposed/underexposed etc.

https://i.imgur.com/NrtkRzp.jpg
https://cdn03.cdn.justjaredjr.com/wp-content/uploads/headlines/2013/01/emma-stone-w-mag.jpg

Personally, I LOVE that kind of lighting and you see it in fashion magazines all the time. I'm not a huge fan of perfectly-lit portrait-style photography. I think, if done right, it can look really cool. If done wrong, it can look really tragic and amateurish, but that's not what your portfolio looks like.

None of your photos are overly blown out or anything, and even in the photo where your model is in the shadow, you can see her clearly, and I think because everything else is kind of washed out around her, the fact that she's in the dark makes her stand out.

Sep 29 14 10:20 am Link