Forums > Critique > Serious Critique > Please Critique

Photographer

Jeff Rulifson

Posts: 6

Palo Alto, California, US

As I say in my Profile, I'm practicing natural, fun, dynamic, expressive portraiture in the hopes I will learn ways to do a good job fast. Each folder has all the images the model received for the shoot. Some shoots went much better than others. I've included everything so you can see when happens when things do not go so well. Please critique. Thanks, Jeff

Aug 06 15 04:21 pm Link

Photographer

JLC Images

Posts: 11615

Phillipsburg, New Jersey, US

If you are going to use natural light you should at least add a reflector to reduce the shadows on the face.  It will also help to pop the subject away from the background.  I would also watch your camera position in relation to the model to avoid body distortions. 

While I enjoy a tight crop I think some of the images can do with a little breathing room so they don't look like they are in a box. 

I would say nice start!

Aug 06 15 06:47 pm Link

Photographer

Lee_Photography

Posts: 9863

Minneapolis, Minnesota, US

https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/150725/12/55b3dd98dabf2_m.jpg
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/150725/12/55b3de46575fe_m.jpg

These two photos cover quite a bit of ground
Questions:
Do you see the difference in the light on models face?
[One looks golden and the other looks pale]
Notice the composition, which looks better to have the empty space in front of model or behind model?
As far as the background good job, you have blurred it, so it is not distracting.

https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/150709/15/559ef00b51615_m.jpg
Looking at this image notice how straight her arms are, she is also pushing her shoulders up which is shortening appearance of neck.
Eyes seem dark, here is where a reflector can help add light
Great smile and connection with model

https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/150509/20/554eced928bca_m.jpg
Not a fan of the lighting [the hot areas of nose and cheek] you could use a scrim between sun and model.
Lens selected for photo may be too wide, notice how nose dominates image


https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/150614/14/557df53d467bd_m.jpg
As this stands very strong image composition
Down side is sun on models nose


https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/150614/14/557df66322bb0_m.jpg
This is a distracting background, model does not seem to be in focus

https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/150725/12/55b3df20ab137_m.jpg
Shoot in full shade or use a scrim, dappled light on models face

In most cases you have a good background bluer,  and a good connection with model

Suggestions, use of a scrim and reflector will help you control light better, check out some guides on composition.

I wish you well, good luck with the hip surgery.

Aug 07 15 04:25 am Link

Photographer

Julietsdream

Posts: 868

Burbank, California, US

Hi Jeff...You have waaay too many pics in your portfolio....personally, I wouldn't show the client(or the world)....all the pics from each shoot....you need to 'cherry pick' the *Best* shots from each shoot...maybe only 1-3 shots max....all the shots, where the model has spotted sun on her face, should go...or too dark, should go....only post the Very *Best* shot(s) from each shoot...!!....*Good Luck*

Aug 07 15 05:22 am Link

Photographer

noel marrero

Posts: 475

Menlo Park, California, US

Julietsdream wrote:
Hi Jeff...You have waaay too many pics in your portfolio....personally, I wouldn't show the client(or the world)....all the pics from each shoot....you need to 'cherry pick' the *Best* shots from each shoot...maybe only 1-3 shots max....all the shots, where the model has spotted sun on her face, should go...or too dark, should go....only post the Very *Best* shot(s) from each shoot...!!....*Good Luck*

+1 billion.

Keep the port to shots that are your strongest.   If there's something wrong with a picture in your port, we can let you know.  But if you fill your port with the ones that even you think didn't turn out right, then everyone is wasting their time.   As it is, I don't have time to look at 300+ shots to critique you.  smile      If you want to show your clients everything, go stick that on smugmug or something.

Putting in less than your best brings down the total strength of your port, and makes it less likely people with work with you.

Aug 08 15 09:39 pm Link

Photographer

David Kirk

Posts: 4852

Ottawa, Ontario, Canada

Ensure you have good light on the model's face.  Everything else can be sacrificed if need be, but the light on the face is paramount.  I would encourage you to learn the classical facial lighting styles and practice to be able to create them in natural light settings.

Aug 09 15 09:01 am Link

Photographer

David Kirk

Posts: 4852

Ottawa, Ontario, Canada

whoops...double post

Aug 09 15 09:01 am Link

Photographer

Jeff Rulifson

Posts: 6

Palo Alto, California, US

Thanks to everyone. I have some homework to do. Jeff

Aug 15 15 01:17 pm Link

Photographer

Krpphoto

Posts: 197

Cape Coral, Florida, US

As far as the first two of the gal--- the one with her hand along her face is absolutely the choice . You don't want to obstruct any part of the face  at all and the hand is more gracefully curved and therefor more elegant looking. The lighting is nicer too - brighter with a golden glow . The hair is backlit and her head is tilted -  which is almost always far better than a straight on facial view. The more background blur the better

Aug 18 15 09:37 pm Link