Forums > Critique > First In-Studio Shoot, Feedback Appreciated

Photographer

Mike McGee Photography

Posts: 75

San Francisco, California, US

I'm really new to shooting portraiture in-studio, as nearly all of the shots from my portfolio have been outdoors. On Sunday, this was my first time truly shooting in-studio. I would love some feedback on these shots, and how I can improve, etc.

1.
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/151124/16/5654fd215b24a_m.jpg

2.
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/151124/16/5654fd12d3b58_m.jpg

3.
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/151124/16/5654fd38173ea_m.jpg

4.
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/151124/16/5654fd2cd26b1_m.jpg

Any feedback is appreciated, thanks.

Nov 24 15 04:34 pm Link

Photographer

WCR3

Posts: 1414

Houston, Texas, US

You should stay indoors. Just kidding - your location/natural light stuff is very nice. But if this is really your first studio work, you're way ahead of the curve.

Nov 25 15 07:38 pm Link

Photographer

Thomas Van Dyke

Posts: 3233

Washington, District of Columbia, US

MMMPhoto wrote:
...feedback on these shots, and how I can improve...

Mike impressive illumination... kickers are nicely balanced with key...

This rendering is compellingly fierce...
Excellent choice of neutral grays for wardrobe elements...
Brings out this talents rich warm skin tone...
And works in harmony with the gray seamless...
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/151124/16/5654fd12d3b58.jpg

Albeit would suggest in the future when integrating eye glasses into a narrative please consider removing the lenses and simply add just a touch of haze in post to simulate the presence of glass... That way you don't have to deal with inappropriate flare...  I actually have a box of empty frames for this nature of narrative, however all you need is an assortment of jeweler's screwdrivers... practice makes perfect... hopefully not coming up the curve on a client's eye-wear... lol 

Another intriguing rendering... elegant pose dynamic... beautiful radiant smile...
Again excellent choice of wardrobe components... wonderful colour harmonies...
btw, have you thought of cropping this a tad higher?
A bit much arm below the elbow in my humble estimation...
Never good to crop close to a joint i.e. wrist in this case...
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/151124/16/5654fd2cd26b1.jpg

However the makeup artist didn't adequately address harsh surface sheen on forehead and T-Zone...
Both MAC and Urban Decay make a superb anti-shine primer... it would have been appropriate here...
Also an application of translucent matte powder would further kill all traces of harsh shine...
This is certainly a compelling reason to collaborate with a tenured MUA...
They can male your illumination task of so much easier and effective...

Hope this helps...
Thank you for sharing...

All the best on your journey Mike...

Nov 25 15 07:47 pm Link

Photographer

J O H N A L L A N

Posts: 12221

Los Angeles, California, US

Watch your hotspots.

Nov 25 15 07:56 pm Link

Photographer

Mike McGee Photography

Posts: 75

San Francisco, California, US

I sincerely appreciate the feedback, everyone!

And Thomas, your comments especially are very well received. Great idea about taking the lenses out and then creating a simulation in post. I love the idea of having a big box of lenses without frames. That's brilliant. I really need to do this in the future!

Great suggestions you've made all around, especially key points to to avoiding those hot spots and things to notice in conjunction with the MUA. I sincerely appreciate all of your input. Thanks!

Nov 28 15 12:13 am Link

Photographer

Mike McGee Photography

Posts: 75

San Francisco, California, US

Thanks again for the suggestions all. In particular for the second photo with the lens reflection under his eye, this was a great suggestion to clear up. So I cleared it up in post and the shot looks MUCH better.

BEFORE:
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/151124/16/5654fd12d3b58_m.jpg

AFTER:
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/151128/13/565a1fa4580cc_m.jpg

Thanks again!

Nov 28 15 01:47 pm Link

Photographer

Mary Durante Youtt

Posts: 520

Barnegat, New Jersey, US

Nice work,  glad you fixed the hot spot, now it is perfect!

Nov 28 15 02:14 pm Link

Photographer

Iktan

Posts: 879

New York, New York, US

damn dude, for being the first studio session your like all ahead of everyone else. Well done!

Nov 29 15 01:13 am Link

Photographer

cheshiredave

Posts: 394

Oakland, California, US

Like others have said, really nice work for your first time shooting in the studio! And lots of other great work in your port. Good to know a talented neighbor I can recommend when I can't take on a gig.

Agreed with the previous comment about hotspots. Always good if you can have a makeup artist on hand to take care of shine. But also, depending on which lights you're using, you may be able to add a deflector between the bulb and the diffuser so that it reduces whatever more concentrated light from the bulb makes it through the diffuser in the center of where it's hitting your subject, in this case her forehead.

Keep up the great work!

Nov 29 15 09:38 pm Link

Photographer

lukezsmith

Posts: 25

Kingston Upon Thames, England, United Kingdom

Good work!

Some really quick things you could improve (bear in mind this is only my personal opinion):
- glare on the glasses, but you've fixed that already wink
- hot spots are intense at times, counter this by using more diffused light
- this is extremely subjective but I'm going to mention it anyway, the backdrop for me is too dull. You could perhaps spill some light onto it to create a gradient just to add a little bit more interest.

Nov 30 15 05:30 am Link

Photographer

Mike McGee Photography

Posts: 75

San Francisco, California, US

I sincerely appreciate the kind words and suggestions. Great info and I will try to add these suggestions to my next studio shoot. So much to learn, but it's also so much fun! Thanks again for the feedback.

Dec 01 15 12:44 am Link