Forums > Critique > Feedback on the first 3 photos specifically please

Model

Andiel

Posts: 122

Reading, England, United Kingdom

Hi there,

I've just a shoot focused on movement so I would like some feedback on the first 3 photos please.

Thanks.

Apr 29 16 05:26 am Link

Photographer

thiswayup

Posts: 1136

Runcorn, England, United Kingdom

You're getting your head and jaw angle right in all of them, which is hard. So your ballet training shows!

This one is interesting

https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/160429/05/572351e2df2c8_m.jpg

Looks fine in mini-view but forced and inelegant when enlarged - it's the right leg; the shots been taken at a moment when it is too locked. It looks like you couldn't really have been walking at that moment and the brain goes "Wrong!" But has the best angle and proportion of any of them, so it's the one I'd study most for insight.

The combination of pose, camera angle and perspective aren't optimal in any of them - you must be aware that curvier figures are harder to shoot both from below and from close. More diagonal is better if it can look natural, and so is finding places where you can shoot from low with a longer lens - a 200mm equivalent or more. That will lets you shoot from further away, which will give a more natural perspective. Not an easy shooting set up to find, though!

Anyway, what you're working on is hard and these shots show real promise and movement skills.

Apr 29 16 05:53 am Link

Photographer

Mark Salo

Posts: 11725

Olney, Maryland, US

To me, you look unhappy in the first two and troubled in the third.

You have several other images that I prefer.

Apr 29 16 06:24 am Link

Model

Andiel

Posts: 122

Reading, England, United Kingdom

Thanks for your encouragement thiswayup and thanks for feedback both. With the third, the idea was that I was running scared from something so that why I look in distress.

I have swapped one out for a different one if that works better? Still happy to hear opinions.

Apr 29 16 06:42 am Link

Photographer

Lee_Photography

Posts: 9863

Minneapolis, Minnesota, US

https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/160429/06/572363afb24e6_m.jpg
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/160429/05/572352142ceb9_m.jpg
Not a fan, the dress is not working well, it is flaring at the mid section so your shape is being lost.
Your hair seems lifeless, the background is also very distracting.
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/160416/12/571297c1e396b_m.jpg
In this photo your hair and dress choice come across much stronger.

https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/160429/05/572351b4434dc_m.jpg
The blurry right foot and hand are not working for me.
[Motion blur in a photo of you running is OK, but in this image it is distorting their shape.]

I wish you well

Apr 29 16 07:40 am Link

Photographer

Mark Salo

Posts: 11725

Olney, Maryland, US

Andie08 wrote:
Thanks for your encouragement thiswayup and thanks for feedback both. With the third, the idea was that I was running scared from something so that why I look in distress.

The caption helps.  Did I miss a caption before?
You could come up with a short reason why you are running.  Like "There is that stalker again!"

Andie08 wrote:
I have swapped one out for a different one if that works better? Still happy to hear opinions.

Your expression in the new image is not as intense as the first and I think that your foot placement in the first was better.  (If I remember correctly.)

Apr 29 16 10:11 am Link

Photographer

Mark Salo

Posts: 11725

Olney, Maryland, US

Since other members are commenting on various images, these are my favorites:

A lovely head shot!
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/141004/04/542fddb662739_m.jpg

So happy!
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/120530/07/4fc631512b08e_m.jpg

Apr 29 16 10:15 am Link

Photographer

Account Dead dead dead

Posts: 243

London, England, United Kingdom

Hi Andie,

Well done for asking for advice.It can be tough starting up a portfolio.

Your portfolio is simply functional at the moment. The photographers you are working with in my opinion lack technical ability but most importantly, lack any creativity or creative sense. This isn't your fault, it's theirs.

I don't know how many photographers there are in Reading but to get a bit of creativity in your port you may have to look east - London's not that far from you smile

Good luck

May 05 16 01:37 am Link