Forums > Critique > New here, would appreciate feedback

Photographer

Creative Visuals

Posts: 12

Medford, Massachusetts, US

I'm rather new to MM, to taking pictures of models and to portraits. I had two photoshoots thus far, both of models who are new to this.
I would appreciate constructive feedback - what did I do well, what I should improve, what would you suggest I focus on in my next "gig."

Much appreciated!

Tal

Nov 21 18 07:17 pm Link

Photographer

FIFTYONE PHOTOGRAPHY

Posts: 6597

Uniontown, Pennsylvania, US

The site requires 4 images to maintain a Portfolio. I would cull what You currently have to show only the very best (1) from each set.

Too repetitive,  less is more.

fwiw

Nov 22 18 04:24 am Link

Photographer

Creative Visuals

Posts: 12

Medford, Massachusetts, US

Thank you for your feedback - much appreciated! I feel that before I do some prunning, I need to have more stuff remaining after I do...

Nov 22 18 06:43 am Link

Photographer

JT Life Photography

Posts: 624

Toronto, Ontario, Canada

Be careful of the waterline, usually you want to keep it horizontal.
Be careful of the background being a distraction, open up the aperture as much as possible to reduce the depth of field.
Centering a model can work if the background is absolutely symmetrical, if it isn't use the rule of thirds or even fifths.
Be careful of 'walking in' rather than 'walking out' of a photo. Our brains seem wired to prefer the former. I think this also applies to the direction the model is looking.
Be brutal in what you decide to display. It is commonly said that a portfolio is only as strong as it's weakest image.
Good luck,
JT

Nov 23 18 07:30 am Link

Photographer

Creative Visuals

Posts: 12

Medford, Massachusetts, US

Thank you so much for the feedback. You're making great points. I truly appreciate your time and your insights.

Nov 23 18 10:37 am Link

Photographer

Wandering Eyebubble

Posts: 324

Toronto, Ontario, Canada

Creative Visuals wrote:
Thank you for your feedback - much appreciated! I feel that before I do some prunning, I need to have more stuff remaining after I do...

I actually concur with keeping just the one best shot from any given set. It forces you to evaluate the images more carefully and think a bit more deeply about why some images work and others don't in spite of their similarities (not to say that at times none may work). I would say quantity should be the least of your concerns.

You seem to be building good relationships with your models, which is vital. Since you are mostly working with newer models I would suggest to encourage them to engage more with the camera. In every single shot of Yaya, for example, she's looking off-frame towards (my) left.

Good luck!

Nov 23 18 11:25 am Link

Photographer

Creative Visuals

Posts: 12

Medford, Massachusetts, US

I appreciate the feedback - thanks!

Nov 23 18 12:07 pm Link

Photographer

Shadow Dancer

Posts: 9782

Bellingham, Washington, US

Nov 23 18 02:38 pm Link

Photographer

TEB-Art Photo

Posts: 605

Carrboro, North Carolina, US

I love this one:

https://www.modelmayhem.com/portfolio/pic/44836328

Beautiful model, interesting stuff going on with the stripes. Background nicely out of focus.

Agree with "JT Life" on the technical stuff.

With regards to "Wandering..."; most of the time, your model should NOT be looking at the camera. When I shoot, I ask the models to vary it or I make a specific request. Direct-at-camera looks can be powerful and engaging, but keep it in moderation. In agreement with "Wandering...", a lot of your models look to your left. Unless there's a bridge or something. Portrait photographers will tell you most models have a "better side" (perhaps due to how she parts her hair, or her default facial expression). Next time you have a model, stop a moment and see what you think about that.

I like that most of your shots have honest expressions, rather than forced smiles or whatever.

Nov 24 18 08:00 am Link

Photographer

Lee_Photography

Posts: 9863

Minneapolis, Minnesota, US

https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/181107/03/5be2cf7f14a4c_m.jpg
Great photo, excellent background blur
[I can not see long lovely fingers of models left hand]

https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/181105/14/5be0c7809ae7d_m.jpg
Remove
Forehead over exposed, shoot as vertical and include all of models right hand fingers
Model too centered in this photo [the fix simply crop a bit off from right side of photo]

https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/181105/14/5be0c7755dcd0_m.jpg
Models expression is lacking emotion, trees in background are distracting

https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/181105/14/5be0c769d4344_m.jpg
Interesting model, nice relaxed pose
Down side is models midsection look large due to gathering of fabric
Good model position in photo

https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/181105/14/5be0c75ee5888_m.jpg
Remove
Crouching model will make them appear short
Distracting background

https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/181105/14/5be0c74801165_m.jpg
Cool photo full of life

https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/181017/07/5bc748a7686d0_m.jpg
Snap shot, busy background
[Open up f-stop to place background out of focus]

https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/180823/23/5b7fa46118510_m.jpg
Photo is tilted [top is toward photo left]
Like the juxtaposition of girl on top of pillar and red headed girl

https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/180823/23/5b7fa4404d29d_m.jpg
Better photo would have been if his feet were included

https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/180927/08/5bacf23e804ed_m.jpg
Over all image seems flat [no 3d effect from the lighting] use a fill flash or reflector from side
[Its all about details, looks like paint or something under models right breast]
Not a fan of the background

I wish you well

Nov 25 18 08:13 am Link

Photographer

Creative Visuals

Posts: 12

Medford, Massachusetts, US

Hi everyone who replied,

Thank you for all of your insights. This is excellent. Much appreciated.

Tal

Nov 25 18 10:21 am Link

Photographer

Wandering Eyebubble

Posts: 324

Toronto, Ontario, Canada

TEB-Art Photo wrote:
With regards to "Wandering..."; most of the time, your model should NOT be looking at the camera. When I shoot, I ask the models to vary it or I make a specific request. Direct-at-camera looks can be powerful and engaging, but keep it in moderation.

Well, of course, I wasn't suggesting every single photo should have the model looking straight at the lens. My point was that, if the model is constantly looking sideways, encourage them otherwise.

Nov 26 18 02:23 pm Link

Photographer

BMA PHOTO

Posts: 53

Pawtucket, Rhode Island, US

I'd keep an eye out for fingers elbows and knees for they distract and start cropping tighter, Too much headroom or bad cropping take away from the image energy.

Any practice and study is good and remember just because you see a pose doesn't mean it's effective.

Have fun!

May 29 19 11:17 am Link

Photographer

Creative Visuals

Posts: 12

Medford, Massachusetts, US

It's been some time since I started this thread, some of the pictures on my portfolio remained as-is, but many were replaced with new ones.

I would appreciate any further feedback any of you would have. No fragile ego here - voice it as you see it.

Tal

Jan 16 20 06:56 am Link