DivaEroticus wrote: Opera is my degree. I sang on the stage professionally. I do not like Wagner. Especially Der Ring.
I have been a musician of sorts all my life but admittedly, never listened to much opera. So I'll give Wagner a go and maybe learn a bit in the process.
I have been a musician of sorts all my life but admittedly, never listened to much opera. So I'll give Wagner a go and maybe learn a bit in the process.
I never was a fan of opera... classical music... absolutely, ballet... yeah... okay... but somehow, never opera.
However, I liked the Rind der Nibelungen and read it in Mittelhochdeutsch... medieval German.
Rind is certainly tasty. I like a good Rumpsteak mit Bratkartoffeln.
I'm surprised they have never done a good movie adaption of the Nibelungen saga. It could be epic like the Lord of the Rings.
It's kind of sad that the Nazis have forever spoiled the Germanic cultural heritage for modern Germans. Most don't even know about the Nibelungen nor have they read it, although it's easily as significant for their culture as Beowulf is for the British or the Illiad for the Greeks.
DivaEroticus
Posts: 12,560
Fayetteville, Arkansas, US
udor wrote:
I never was a fan of opera... classical music... absolutely, ballet... yeah... okay... but somehow, never opera.
However, I liked the Rind der Nibelungen and read it in Mittelhochdeutsch... medieval German.
One of the reasons is mostly because there are no real arias for individuals. There are brief bits for singers, but nothing substantial, other than in a few operas. Plus, he's just too heavy for me. I'm the same way about Richard Strauss...too heavy, though I do like a lot of his Lieder. Especially "Zweignung."
One of the reasons is mostly because there are no real arias for individuals. There are brief bits for singers, but nothing substantial, other than in a few operas. Plus, he's just too heavy for me. I'm the same way about Richard Strauss...too heavy, though I do like a lot of his Lieder. Especially "Zweignung."
DivaEroticus
Posts: 12,560
Fayetteville, Arkansas, US
Katarina N. wrote:
Rind is certainly tasty. I like a good Rumpsteak mit Bratkartoffeln.
I'm surprised they have never done a good movie adaption of the Nibelungen saga. It could be epic like the Lord of the Rings.
It's kind of sad that the Nazis have forever spoiled the Germanic cultural heritage for modern Germans. Most don't even know about the Nibelungen nor have they read it, although it's easily as significant for their culture as Beowulf is for the British or the Illiad for the Greeks.
I've found that opera doesn't translate well to the silver screen. It loses its impact without the singing. I may not like Wagner, but I think it would do his work a great disservice to turn it into a movie.
DivaEroticus wrote: I've found that opera doesn't translate well to the silver screen. It loses its impact without the singing. I may not like Wagner, but I think it would do his work a great disservice to turn it into a movie.
I am not talking about Wagner, but about the Nibelungen saga - of which Ring der Nibelungen is but an interpretation.
It's an epic saga in its own right, much like Beowulf. If it wasn't about Germans, it would have probably already been given the Hollywood treatment. Hollywood prefers them as one thing only though: Evil Nazis. Epic Germanic heroes wouldn't go over well with the Jewish top brass in the studios.
DivaEroticus
Posts: 12,560
Fayetteville, Arkansas, US
Muff Rider wrote: Wagner is a genius, thats why he is hard to comprehend (listen to)...
I just don't like the heavy nature of the music. It's not hard to comprehend (listen to), I just don't like it. I also wouldn't call him a genius. His leitmotifs were groundbreaking, but his predecessors were the geniuses from whom he borrowed and learned.
DivaEroticus
Posts: 12,560
Fayetteville, Arkansas, US
Katarina N. wrote:
I am not talking about Wagner, but about the Nibelungen saga - of which Ring der Nibelungen is but an interpretation.
It's an epic saga in its own right, much like Beowulf. If it wasn't about Germans, it would have probably already given the Hollywood treatment. Hollywood prefers them as one thing only though: Evil Nazis.
Ah, misunderstood your post, then. Yes, the saga itself would be a great screenplay.