Forums > Critique > New Editing Technique Critique

Photographer

A Flud

Posts: 6

Chicago, Illinois, US

Hi All!

I was wondering thoughts on a new editing style I was trying.

www.modelmayhem.com/portfolio/pic/36427690   (my current avatar)

The more I look at it the more I think it could use a little more contrast?

Thanks!

Jul 12 14 01:50 pm Link

Photographer

sospix

Posts: 23775

Orlando, Florida, US

What's the "new" part of it?????  Want to make sure I comment on the right thing  .  .  .

SOS

Jul 12 14 02:04 pm Link

Photographer

A Flud

Posts: 6

Chicago, Illinois, US

I was trying to go for a more "dreamy" look.  I did a painted light leak kind of thing on this, messed with color curves for the first time and tried modifying the background with color levels.

All my other photos have been basic curves and using a color gradient from the side with some sort of overlay setting.

Jul 12 14 02:18 pm Link

Photographer

Sad Movie Photography

Posts: 214

Indian Head, Saskatchewan, Canada

A Flud wrote:
Hi All!

I was wondering thoughts on a new editing style I was trying.

www.modelmayhem.com/portfolio/pic/36427690   (my current avatar)

The more I look at it the more I think it could use a little more contrast?

Thanks!

I too have a hard time committing to presenting a photograph that doesn't have a d-max near black and a d-min near white but that said this isn't bothering me too much. I do find though that, in my opinion that it could use a tighter crop taking some space off the top and putting her eyes into a third. For me that's an even harder rule to break.

Jul 12 14 09:10 pm Link

Photographer

Images by MR

Posts: 8908

Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada

Not sure about the retouching, but I do find the background distracting.

Jul 12 14 09:26 pm Link

Photographer

Lee_Photography

Posts: 9863

Minneapolis, Minnesota, US

https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/140712/13/53c19be7a4984_m.jpg
For me crop wise too much space above her head, skin looks too light no detail, and hair a bit messy. The white areas of background are a bit distracting

Wish you well

Jul 13 14 04:30 am Link

Photographer

Eyes Wide Shut Images

Posts: 20

Melbourne, Victoria, Australia

Images by MR wrote:
Not sure about the retouching, but I do find the background distracting.

and the stray hair on the left eye.

Jul 13 14 04:35 am Link

Photographer

PhotoLexography

Posts: 54

Papillion, Nebraska, US

I hate fly-away hair. lol
First, I think experimentation is a great thing, and essential to the "Art" of photography. For me, the result here is a little too washed out. There's a lack of texture. Maybe that's what you were trying to achieve - don't know. I'd also adjust the crop and apply the rule of thirds, minimizing the background.

Jul 13 14 04:51 am Link

Photographer

A Flud

Posts: 6

Chicago, Illinois, US

Thanks for all the input, I was trying to make it more "dreamy" so lighter and "washed out" was kind of the goal.  I think the background wouldnt be so distracting had I added a bit more contrast to it or change the colors of the white flowers to something else a bit more flattering to the photo.

Any tips on how to edit out all the stray hairs?  I have never had luck on doing that.

Jul 13 14 10:34 am Link

Photographer

Don Garrett

Posts: 4984

Escondido, California, US

Shutter Photographics wrote:

and the stray hair on the left eye.

That stray hair could have been painted out in seconds, I would have done that after looking at the image.
-Don

Jul 13 14 10:46 am Link

Photographer

Photographic Adventures

Posts: 326

Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, US

A Flud wrote:
Any tips on how to edit out all the stray hairs?  I have never had luck on doing that.

Take a look at frequency separation.  I can remove stray hairs quickly and painlessly using that technique.  No indication the a hair was ever there is a few seconds.  Once you learn how to do and assuming you're using Photoshop, record the setup procedure to an action.  I can't recommend frequency separation strongly enough.

Jul 13 14 11:11 am Link

Photographer

International2014

Posts: 97

Ashburn, Virginia, US

A Flud wrote:
Hi All!

I was wondering thoughts on a new editing style I was trying.

www.modelmayhem.com/portfolio/pic/36427690   (my current avatar)

The more I look at it the more I think it could use a little more contrast?

Thanks!

Overall, not too bad at all - I'd just tighten up the minor details.

I also don't mind the large background as much as others mentioned above. But I'd try for more contrast/separation between background/subject (though the higher res version, the contrast doesn't really bother me as much).

If I were to nit-pick, I'd note the following things:

-blotchy patch of make-up on cheek (image right side)

-stray hairs are distracting, I would not get rid of all the stray hairs completely, I think it adds to the outdoor effect, but the majority need to be gone and the rest softened.

-skin needs more blemish/wrinkle correction (subjective, also depends on the look you're going for)

-Need more definition in nose bridge areas, this area looks too flat,

-slight contrast adjustments

Jul 14 14 01:17 am Link