Forums > Critique > Hmmm...Is this picture working?

Photographer

Sad Movie Photography

Posts: 214

Indian Head, Saskatchewan, Canada

What to do in an abandoned schoolhouse with a bunch of basket balls.

Thoughts?

https://www.modelmayhem.com/portfolio/pic/36682069

Aug 13 14 08:37 pm Link

Photographer

GER Photography

Posts: 8463

Imperial, California, US

The concept is cool, but the double exposure looking bits hurt it IMHO.

Aug 13 14 08:56 pm Link

Photographer

KEKnight

Posts: 1876

Cumming, Georgia, US

GER Photography wrote:
The concept is cool, but the double exposure looking bits hurt it IMHO.

FWIW .... I agree.  hmm

Aug 13 14 08:59 pm Link

Photographer

Sad Movie Photography

Posts: 214

Indian Head, Saskatchewan, Canada

GER Photography wrote:
The concept is cool, but the double exposure looking bits hurt it IMHO.

thanks....I think I have another exposure so I can replace that. Trying to decide what level of weird is working.

Aug 13 14 09:01 pm Link

Photographer

Sad Movie Photography

Posts: 214

Indian Head, Saskatchewan, Canada

KEKnight wrote:

FWIW .... I agree.  hmm

Thank you!

Aug 13 14 09:02 pm Link

Model

Sandra Vixen

Posts: 1561

Las Vegas, Nevada, US

This is how I would have done it.

It's an abandoned room, so make it look haunted.

Put the camera on a tripod and have it take one picture with no balls or model.

Then throw in the balls and model and take a second picture with the same positions.

In post, overlay the first image to create a ghostly affect.

The only thing I don't like with the one you have is that the model's right ankle appears broken.

Aug 13 14 09:24 pm Link

Photographer

Lee_Photography

Posts: 9863

Minneapolis, Minnesota, US

https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/140813/20/53ec2d22c16c2_m.jpg
The basket balls do not have corresponding shadows

Yes, that double exposure is a bit disturbing

Too many subjects, what is the main subject?

Different crop, if you crop at the bottom of the trunk, [eliminating ground level stuff] the image becomes stronger in my opinion

Love your work and off the wall ideas

Aug 14 14 05:33 am Link

Photographer

Sad Movie Photography

Posts: 214

Indian Head, Saskatchewan, Canada

Sandra Vixen wrote:
This is how I would have done it.

It's an abandoned room, so make it look haunted.

Put the camera on a tripod and have it take one picture with no balls or model.

Then throw in the balls and model and take a second picture with the same positions.

In post, overlay the first image to create a ghostly affect.

The only thing I don't like with the one you have is that the model's right ankle appears broken.

haha...that's almost exactly what we did here but I didn't want the balls ghostly and see through. Anyway...it was a lot of fun.

Aug 14 14 08:04 am Link

Photographer

Sad Movie Photography

Posts: 214

Indian Head, Saskatchewan, Canada

Lee_Photography wrote:
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/140813/20/53ec2d22c16c2_m.jpg
The basket balls do not have corresponding shadows

Yes, that double exposure is a bit disturbing

Too many subjects, what is the main subject?

Different crop, if you crop at the bottom of the trunk, [eliminating ground level stuff] the image becomes stronger in my opinion

Love your work and off the wall ideas

Yeah...I might try cropping it up a bit higher to bring the model more into the lower third. The plan originally was to remove the trunk and table but I ended liking them enough that I thought it was more unique than another mysteriously floating model. I'm already just cutting off a table leg so maybe a bit more of a cut would be tolerable.

The balls actually do have corresponding shadows but only from one of the flashes which was high and very to the left so the shadows are a good deal away and often missing from the balls. I think I'll fake in more that correspond to both flashes.

Thanks for your comment!!

Aug 14 14 08:11 am Link