Forums > Digital Art and Retouching > DAR Critiques > Overall critique for newbie retoucher, please

Retoucher

Nariade

Posts: 35

Lisbon, Lisboa e Vale do Tejo, Portugal

Can you please help me and criticise the retouche i've made in these photos?

Hope you can help me get better.

Photo A
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/140912/10/54132e2529f07.jpg


Photo B
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/140912/10/54132ded3c92b.jpg


Photo C
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/140912/10/54132d80364b4.jpg


Photo D
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/140912/10/54132cb38d687.jpg


I hope you can help me. Thanks

Sep 14 14 06:25 pm Link

Digital Artist

Ana-Maria Nedelea

Posts: 120

Oneşti, Bacău, Romania

Hi,

Sometime I'm wondering myself if Ill meet in person one of my retouches what will be my reaction?

Sep 14 14 09:38 pm Link

Retoucher

BoazR

Posts: 129

Jerusalem, Jerusalem, Israel

The first few things that came to mind when I saw this are:
1. I really really like what you did with the colours of the first and last photos.
2. The skin looks somewhat waxy, and I'm not sure how to explain why.
3. In at least 3 of the photos, the edit of the iris made the pupil look like it sinking in - and it looks unnatural and somewhat creepy.

and remember, practice makes perfect smile

Sep 15 14 04:43 am Link

Retoucher

OTTO poste1

Posts: 207

Montreal, Quebec, Canada

All your skin work is a bit lazy cos you are not using the right technic and it shows. The skin looks waxy cos there is a loss of information and it makes it look really unnatural. It's a big nono if you want to work seriously.

Have you been doing a split frequency and blurred the low layer, or colored on an empty layer between high and low? Or maybe used some kind of filter?

Learn how to dodge and burn, this is the right technic to get the most natural results. There is a variety of ways to do this, check it on youtube. Your work will greatly improved if you spend the time practicing this.

Also, you need to look out for colour consistency. In the photo where the girl has braided hair, the face is saturated and the body is desaturated and of a different colour.

Keep practicing!

Sep 15 14 12:32 pm Link