Forums > Critique > Want some good old fashioned critique?

Model

NothingnesssEver

Posts: 194

New York, New York, US

If you are still going. Thanks a lot!
If you think there are pics that I should take down, kindly let me know as well. Much appreciated.

May 07 14 03:18 pm Link

Photographer

JWC54321

Posts: 50

Atlanta, Georgia, US

Hit me. Thanks.

May 07 14 04:58 pm Link

Photographer

cvltblood

Posts: 7

Chicago, Illinois, US

Pretty interested

www.cvltblood.com

May 07 14 05:56 pm Link

Photographer

camilo

Posts: 794

Miami, Florida, US

Kendrah Astira wrote:
I've got to know! Trying to improve before my move!

I like your first row... not so much the second.

May 07 14 06:59 pm Link

Photographer

camilo

Posts: 794

Miami, Florida, US

May_Bee wrote:
Please tell me smile

I really really like your look, however May bee you can edit a few ones out that don't really stand up to the others.

May 07 14 07:00 pm Link

Photographer

camilo

Posts: 794

Miami, Florida, US

Phan Nguyen Nguyen wrote:
If you are still going. Thanks a lot!
If you think there are pics that I should take down, kindly let me know as well. Much appreciated.

https://www.modelmayhem.com/portfolio/p … 4#34844430
That must go!
Love the one of you "floating" a take it back on filters and photoshop a little.

May 07 14 07:02 pm Link

Photographer

camilo

Posts: 794

Miami, Florida, US

JWC54321 wrote:
Hit me. Thanks.

I really like your style... I would take out one or two pics, and try increasing the black levels a tad...

May 07 14 07:04 pm Link

Photographer

camilo

Posts: 794

Miami, Florida, US

cvltblood wrote:
Pretty interested

www.cvltblood.com

Something about them I really like.

May 07 14 07:05 pm Link

Model

Lily Sunbird

Posts: 18

Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, US

I love to hear your opinion!

May 07 14 08:00 pm Link

Model

May_Bee

Posts: 226

Basel, Basel-Town, Switzerland

cmonmor wrote:

I really really like your look, however May bee you can edit a few ones out that don't really stand up to the others.

Thank you a lot for taking your time! If you could link me those few ones, I would really appreciate that smile
Maya

May 09 14 05:57 am Link

Photographer

Bricksss

Posts: 28

Montpellier, Languedoc-Roussillon, France

Ok, I'd like to know what you think about my work wink

May 09 14 03:09 pm Link

Model

Jaye Ashay

Posts: 11

Sacramento, California, US

Please give me some critique, I could really use some fresh feedback.

May 10 14 06:33 pm Link

Photographer

glamourit

Posts: 161

Toronto, Ontario, Canada

Any impressions... Milomo.

May 10 14 07:45 pm Link

Photographer

camilo

Posts: 794

Miami, Florida, US

Lily Sunbird wrote:
I love to hear your opinion!

You even seem to have a selfie... No professional work yet.. Seems like the best you have so far is someone who bought a "pro camera" and is now a photographer. Find a decent photographer and try again.

May 12 14 06:38 am Link

Photographer

camilo

Posts: 794

Miami, Florida, US

Bricksss wrote:
Ok, I'd like to know what you think about my work wink

Its pretty... but nothing really stands out...

May 12 14 06:40 am Link

Photographer

camilo

Posts: 794

Miami, Florida, US

Jaye Ashay wrote:
Please give me some critique, I could really use some fresh feedback.

First whole row is the same shoot same shot actually just cropped at different points... You need more work on there. And edit down what you have.

May 12 14 06:41 am Link

Photographer

camilo

Posts: 794

Miami, Florida, US

glamourit wrote:
Any impressions... Milomo.

I've done you before.

May 12 14 06:42 am Link

Photographer

Kane

Posts: 1647

London, England, United Kingdom

cmonmor wrote:
feelings will get hurt

Hurt me baby.

May 12 14 06:44 am Link

Photographer

Streammer

Posts: 34

Homjel', Homjel', Belarus

What will you tell about my retouch?

May 12 14 08:59 am Link

Photographer

camilo

Posts: 794

Miami, Florida, US

kane wrote:

Hurt me baby.

I love your shit! I can't hurt you!

May 13 14 07:58 am Link

Photographer

camilo

Posts: 794

Miami, Florida, US

Streammer wrote:
What will you tell about my retouch?

Nothing special... What is special is the pictures of yourself... They are creepy as hell! posting pictures of yourself makes you look creepy!

May 13 14 07:59 am Link

Model

Julia Weber

Posts: 48

Indianapolis, Indiana, US

cmonmor wrote:
So I miss the good old fashion critique we used to do at school. Would you like some of that? I'll try to be as objective and to the point as possible, that means feelings will get hurt, oh and please feel free to do the same with my work.

UPDATE:
So I've already had two or three messages telling me what a son of a bitch I am, and how big of an asshole I am... I repeat, if you want an honest critique, I will do it, if you want an ego boost, look elsewhere.

I am up for it, bring it on asshole! wink

May 13 14 08:02 am Link

Photographer

Ahmad Amin Photography

Posts: 9

QUEENS VILLAGE, New York, US

I'm in!

May 13 14 08:07 am Link

Model

jat

Posts: 4

Murfreesboro, Tennessee, US

I'd love some constructive criticism!

May 13 14 11:10 am Link

Photographer

camilo

Posts: 794

Miami, Florida, US

Julia Weber wrote:

I am up for it, bring it on asshole! wink

https://www.modelmayhem.com/portfolio/p … 4#35649123
That need to come off!! you are very pretty... you look a little mentally challenged on that one... They are really nice yearbook pics, but they are all the same... You have a long way.

May 13 14 02:33 pm Link

Photographer

camilo

Posts: 794

Miami, Florida, US

Ahmad Amin Photography wrote:
I'm in!

Its nice but too repetitive... some models I would just get rid of. And for fucks sake change your profile! A picture of your "studio" with the disclaimer on there actually has the complete opposite effect of what you are trying to achieve... It just makes you sound creepy as shit.

May 13 14 02:36 pm Link

Model

Melanie Littleman

Posts: 8

College Station, Texas, US

Count me in!

May 13 14 02:40 pm Link

Photographer

Knight Vision Imaging

Posts: 54

Toronto, Ontario, Canada

Would love to know your thoughts.   I know I have too many images and esp too many similar ones, working on that.   smile

thanks.

May 13 14 02:54 pm Link

Photographer

camilo

Posts: 794

Miami, Florida, US

Jill Tedford wrote:
I'd love some constructive criticism!

I can't say I have any complaints... love your first pic... and although I like the pic of you in the sweater on the stairs, there is something about the way you are sitting that  I don't like.

May 13 14 03:14 pm Link

Photographer

camilo

Posts: 794

Miami, Florida, US

remisue16 wrote:
Count me in!

Nothing special... a Little cheesy actually... Specially the one on the bike... Those are assured to be cheesy...

May 13 14 03:16 pm Link

Photographer

camilo

Posts: 794

Miami, Florida, US

Knight Vision Imaging wrote:
Would love to know your thoughts.   I know I have too many images and esp too many similar ones, working on that.   smile

thanks.

You are right. You have 90 pics up, and I feel you could showcase with 15. Some cool concepts, but you can't do them with every model you shoot... Edit down, and on your profile you state you have "limited equipment"... Don't say that, no one gives a shit. It is really the terrible photographers that will list the equipment they use... I honestly only do natural light, and a 50mm lense... I have a shitload other things, but never ever use them...

May 13 14 03:18 pm Link

Photographer

Ahmad Amin Photography

Posts: 9

QUEENS VILLAGE, New York, US

cmonmor wrote:

Its nice but too repetitive... some models I would just get rid of. And for fucks sake change your profile! A picture of your "studio" with the disclaimer on there actually has the complete opposite effect of what you are trying to achieve... It just makes you sound creepy as shit.

Thanks. I'm still pretty new to photography and is still developing a portfolio that I'm comfortable with.

And regarding the studio shot on my profile, I never though of it like that. I thought it would make models aware of the my shooting situation rather than them having to find out later on and not being comfortable with it then.

May 13 14 04:13 pm Link

Photographer

Rich Olson

Posts: 96

DENVILLE, New Jersey, US

Go for it!

May 13 14 04:53 pm Link

Photographer

camilo

Posts: 794

Miami, Florida, US

Rich Olson wrote:
Go for it!

its not that it is bad... But I just don;t like it at all... Kind of cheesy for my taste and very repetitive... And the models are just trying too hard.

May 13 14 07:04 pm Link

Model

jat

Posts: 4

Murfreesboro, Tennessee, US

cmonmor wrote:

I can't say I have any complaints... love your first pic... and although I like the pic of you in the sweater on the stairs, there is something about the way you are sitting that  I don't like.

I can see that..
Thank you for your feedback!

May 13 14 07:06 pm Link

Photographer

John Downward

Posts: 30

Manchester, England, United Kingdom

feel free to pull my portfolio apart always helpful to know where to improve

May 14 14 01:43 am Link

Photographer

camilo

Posts: 794

Miami, Florida, US

John Downward wrote:
feel free to pull my portfolio apart always helpful to know where to improve

Its actually quite good! However, first or second pic has to go... They are the same... The choice is yours my friend.

May 14 14 07:30 am Link

Model

Alexandra Beck

Posts: 175

Los Angeles, California, US

I would love your opinion!

May 14 14 07:37 am Link

Model

Frederique Goud

Posts: 30

Purmerend, Noord-Holland, Netherlands

Love to hear some good old fashioned critique of you wink

May 14 14 07:51 am Link

Photographer

NAZM0

Posts: 63

Cape Town, Western Cape, South Africa

Do it smile

May 14 14 09:03 am Link