Forums > Critique > Want me to rate you on a scale of 10?

Photographer

Joe Albright

Posts: 222

Fort Wayne, Indiana, US

OK, I'm in.

May 16 14 06:06 pm Link

Makeup Artist

Wigs and Makeup Allison

Posts: 290

Costa Mesa, California, US

I'll take the leap.
Your critiques are thoughtful and your longevity impressive!

May 16 14 07:34 pm Link

Photographer

Digital Blitz

Posts: 2773

Gaithersburg, Maryland, US

Karl JW Johnston wrote:
hit me

Though you have some outstanding pictures in your website - the rating below is strictly based on the only 7 pics in MM. Personally, I did not like the exposure in your avatar or in this one https://www.modelmayhem.com/portfolio/pic/35970811. I am sure with a bigger and better port - these rating will be lot hour.

Port:5
Lighting: 5
Conceptualization: 6
Camera angles: 7

Overall: 5.5

May 18 14 05:48 am Link

Photographer

Digital Blitz

Posts: 2773

Gaithersburg, Maryland, US

Garry k wrote:
I will play game

If your pictures are so good as a newbee - I wonder what you will produce when you have 10 years of experience.

Port: 8
Lighting: 8
Conceptualization: 6.5
Camera angles: 8

Overall: 8

May 18 14 05:52 am Link

Model

Blonde Brazilian

Posts: 4

Marietta, Georgia, US

Me smile

May 18 14 07:05 am Link

Photographer

Gavin Poh

Posts: 239

Melbourne, Victoria, Australia

PLease, count me in.

May 19 14 04:13 pm Link

Model

nickiij

Posts: 16

Saint Helens, England, United Kingdom

Count me in smile

May 20 14 01:47 am Link

Photographer

Digital Blitz

Posts: 2773

Gaithersburg, Maryland, US

nickiij wrote:
Count me in smile

Nicki:
Its important to see the correct vital stats in a model's port. A 9 lbs and 34-0-0 stats do not help.

I like the expressions. ANd your implied nude is awesome.

Port: 6.5
Looks: 7
Figure: 5
Expressions: 7.5

Overall: 6

May 20 14 03:51 am Link

Photographer

Digital Blitz

Posts: 2773

Gaithersburg, Maryland, US

Joe Albright wrote:
OK, I'm in.

Your work is different. But I like the pictures in your website more. I would suggest you diversify your port a little.

Port: 5
Lighting: 6.5
Conceptualization: 7.5
Camera angles: 7

Overall: 6

May 20 14 04:48 am Link

Photographer

Digital Blitz

Posts: 2773

Gaithersburg, Maryland, US

Wigs and Makeup Allison wrote:
I'll take the leap.
Your critiques are thoughtful and your longevity impressive!

Allison:
Exceptional wigs. And I thought wigs are what you get in a store - pardon my ignorance.

Wigs: 9
Makeup: 8
Port: 8.5

Overall: 8.5

May 20 14 04:50 am Link

Photographer

John Downward

Posts: 30

Manchester, England, United Kingdom

Digital Blitz wrote:

John:
Other than your name - nothing is downward in your port, especially for a hobbyist photographer. This one is awe inspiring - https://www.modelmayhem.com/portfolio/pic/35967533


Port: 8
Camera angles: 8
Conceptualization: 7
Lighting: 8

Overall: 7.5

Thank you for the kind words :-)

May 20 14 06:08 am Link

Model

nickiij

Posts: 16

Saint Helens, England, United Kingdom

Digital Blitz wrote:

Nicki:
Its important to see the correct vital stats in a model's port. A 9 lbs and 34-0-0 stats do not help.

I like the expressions. ANd your implied nude is awesome.

Port: 6.5
Looks: 7
Figure: 5
Expressions: 7.5

Overall: 6

thanks smile very kind off you and I know about my stats im in the middle off sorting it out smile

May 20 14 06:26 am Link

Photographer

MidnightSun Designs

Posts: 363

WINSTON SALEM, North Carolina, US

go for it!

May 20 14 11:09 am Link

Model

Vinny

Posts: 96

Harrisburg, Pennsylvania, US

Go ahead!

May 20 14 11:54 am Link

Photographer

Digital Blitz

Posts: 2773

Gaithersburg, Maryland, US

Misha Berry wrote:
Me smile

NIce diverse port and good ex[ressions.

Port: 8
Expressions: 7
Looks: 7
Figure: 7.5

Overall: 7

May 22 14 02:32 am Link

Photographer

Merry

Posts: 1678

London, England, United Kingdom

If you're still going, go for it! big_smile

May 22 14 02:53 am Link

Photographer

Vivendi Studio

Posts: 249

Los Angeles, California, US

here we go..

May 22 14 01:45 pm Link

Retoucher

Nellie Anger Designs

Posts: 37

Dallas, Texas, US

I am in! Rate me! smile

May 22 14 05:58 pm Link

Photographer

Project Vain Images

Posts: 83

San Diego, California, US

I am in

May 22 14 06:04 pm Link

Photographer

Distinct Edges

Posts: 30

San Diego, California, US

Digital Blitz wrote:

Distinct:
You need to diversify your port. Good luck in CA.

Port: 5.5
Camera angles: 7
Lighting: 6
Conceptualizations: 6.5

Overall: 6

I updated my port....can I get another one of your lovely opinions! You're amazing!

May 22 14 07:29 pm Link

Photographer

Allen Carbon

Posts: 1532

Wellington, Wellington, New Zealand

seems fun

May 23 14 06:21 am Link

Model

Lily James

Posts: 3

Dallas, Texas, US

I want to play as well. I will be updating my port soon, so advance critiquing would be beneficial.

May 27 14 12:23 pm Link

Model

Toxxsynn

Posts: 23

Yonkers, New York, US

I would love some honest critique!

May 27 14 12:45 pm Link

Model

Morgan_Rose

Posts: 407

Brooklyn, New York, US

By the time you get to me I'll be 21, I think. Birthday is on May 30th. smile

May 28 14 12:07 pm Link

Photographer

Digital Blitz

Posts: 2773

Gaithersburg, Maryland, US

Toxxsynn wrote:
I would love some honest critique!

Need improvements in the port and expressions.
Port: 5.5
Looks: 7
Figure: 7.5
Expressions: 6

Overall: 6

May 29 14 04:29 am Link

Photographer

Digital Blitz

Posts: 2773

Gaithersburg, Maryland, US

Gavin Poh wrote:
PLease, count me in.

Gavin:
Your port needs little bit of weeding in my opinion. Some not-so-good pictures are weakening the effect of your otherwise awesome work. I am a big fan of this picture: https://www.modelmayhem.com/portfolio/pic/30942647. In my list now.

Port: 6.5
Lighting and Shadows: 9
Camera angles: 7
Post production: 7.5

Overall: 7.5

May 29 14 04:36 am Link

Photographer

Digital Blitz

Posts: 2773

Gaithersburg, Maryland, US

MidnightSun Designs wrote:
go for it!

Midnight:
Some very nice work. Just a little more variety please smile

Port:7
Conceptualization: 9
Camera Angles: 8
Post production: 7

Overall: 7.5

May 29 14 04:40 am Link

Photographer

Digital Blitz

Posts: 2773

Gaithersburg, Maryland, US

Vinny  wrote:
Go ahead!

Vinny:
Some awesome work in your port.

Port: 8
Looks: 7
Expressions: 6.5
Figure: 7

Overall: 7

May 29 14 04:45 am Link

Photographer

Digital Blitz

Posts: 2773

Gaithersburg, Maryland, US

Merry wrote:
If you're still going, go for it! big_smile

Merry:
Beautiful work.

Port: 7.5
Lighting: 8
Camera Angles: 7.5
Conceptualization: 8

Overall: 8

May 29 14 04:49 am Link

Photographer

Digital Blitz

Posts: 2773

Gaithersburg, Maryland, US

Nellie Anger Design wrote:
I am in! Rate me! smile

Nellie:
I would suggest you change your avatar to one of your outstanding before and after pictures - all of which are outstanding. I will also add some more in this album (Before and After).

Port: 7.5
Enhancement: 8
Background modification: 8
Overall: 8

May 29 14 04:57 am Link

Model

Max Reiter

Posts: 7

Long Beach, California, US

Can you break my number virginity!

May 29 14 04:59 am Link

Photographer

Digital Blitz

Posts: 2773

Gaithersburg, Maryland, US

Lily James wrote:
I want to play as well. I will be updating my port soon, so advance critiquing would be beneficial.

For someone with several years of experience - your port is very weak. There are a couple of good pictures in your credited section. Some room for improvement in your expressions department as well.

Port:3
Looks: 7
Figure: 7
Expressions: 4

Overall: 5

May 29 14 05:17 am Link

Photographer

Digital Blitz

Posts: 2773

Gaithersburg, Maryland, US

Vivendi Studio wrote:
here we go..

Vivendi
Some great outdoors pictures. How about a few more indoor ones as well?

Port:7.5
Camera Angles: 7.5
Port:7.5
Post production: 7

Overall: 7.5

May 29 14 05:19 am Link

Photographer

Digital Blitz

Posts: 2773

Gaithersburg, Maryland, US

Project Vain Images wrote:
I am in

A good start in your MM port. Nice outdoors. Give us some variety please.

Port: 6.5
Lighting: 7
Conceptualization: 6
Camera ANgles: 7.5

Overall: 6.5

May 29 14 05:21 am Link

Photographer

Digital Blitz

Posts: 2773

Gaithersburg, Maryland, US

Allen Carbon wrote:
seems fun

SOme nice outdoor captures. Good Luck. Create more.

Port: 6
Lighting: 6.5
Conceptualization: 7
Camera Angles: 7

Overall: 6

May 29 14 05:24 am Link

Photographer

NAZM0

Posts: 63

Cape Town, Western Cape, South Africa

Added quite a few new shoots, so why not smile

May 29 14 08:54 am Link

Photographer

Crmphotography

Posts: 22

Hillsborough, New Jersey, US

Sure why not

May 29 14 08:58 am Link

Photographer

Digital Blitz

Posts: 2773

Gaithersburg, Maryland, US

Max Reiter wrote:
Can you break my number virginity!

Port:4

Looks:7

Figure:6

Expressions: 5

Overall: 5.5

May 30 14 04:34 am Link

Photographer

Digital Blitz

Posts: 2773

Gaithersburg, Maryland, US

Morgan_Rose wrote:
By the time you get to me I'll be 21, I think. Birthday is on May 30th. smile

Happy Birthday - your port doesn't say you are 21 yet.

May 30 14 04:35 am Link

Model

Sakura Love

Posts: 49

Hong Kong, Hong Kong, China

All righty, have a go!

May 30 14 06:45 pm Link