Forums > Digital Art and Retouching > How would you correct this?

Photographer

Penumbra Photography

Posts: 593

Sacramento, California, US

I recently had a creepy shoot, and the model was painted all white with dark black features. The white paint was super reflective and kept coming out very over exposed. I tried turning down my exposure and the lights, as well as moving the lights further away. But everything I tried made her blacks fade into the background and lose detail. I settled for slightly over exposed, but now that I am trying to correct it in light room, it's not working. When I pull the highlights down, the image turns a weird grey color and looks flat and odd. Any suggestions for fixing the over exposure without ruining detail of the image?

https://i.imgur.com/10h3QvA.png

Apr 15 15 03:05 pm Link

Retoucher

Marc Damon Retouch

Posts: 651

Biloxi, Mississippi, US

Create a composite image from multiple exposures.
Have a nice day!
smile

Apr 15 15 05:09 pm Link

Retoucher

DevKevin

Posts: 120

Wittenberg, Wisconsin, US

If you want something more like this, all I did was use levels in photoshop and played with the opacity


https://dl-web.dropbox.com/get/10h3QvA%20copy.jpg?_subject_uid=188489117&w=AADLKg6l4OIrcLISyKLCDLrkYO5fHBfYhjOEkkB6omXIOA

Apr 15 15 05:17 pm Link

Photographer

Stecyk

Posts: 365

Calgary, Alberta, Canada

Here's one potential solution.

https://i69.photobucket.com/albums/i76/KStecyk/ModelMayhem/2015_04_Apr/pen-photo.jpg

Notice that your brights are significantly toned down.

What I did was take your image and move into LAB, where luminosity and color are separated in different channels.

Then, I simply adjusted your lightness down. You can try different shaped curves, or increase/decrease the amount or whatever.

https://i69.photobucket.com/albums/i76/KStecyk/ModelMayhem/2015_04_Apr/2015-04-15_20-11-38-pen-lightness.jpg

Next, I wanted the reduced brightness to affect only the brightest parts of your picture. I didn't want to darken the fingers. Perhaps you do. You can examine the mask and delete or adjust the mask to your liking. So for the Lightness layer mask, I performed the following commands.

https://i69.photobucket.com/albums/i76/KStecyk/ModelMayhem/2015_04_Apr/2015-04-15_20-12-21-pen-layerstack.jpg

- Select mask
- Image > Apply Image  (See below)

https://i69.photobucket.com/albums/i76/KStecyk/2015-04-15_20-17-59-pen-applyimage.jpg

(You'll notice that I used "multiply" blend mode. I could have used Normal. I would get the same result in this situation.)

Once I applied the image to the mask, I then blurred the mask at 2 pixels. (Had I blurred at 6-8 pixels, I would have gotten a better result.) Depending on your resolution, I would increase the blur. For a crop or full sized camera, try 20 - 45 pixels on the mask. It will increase the sharpness of your result.

I noticed that your "white" was slightly blue and green by one or two points. So the top layer AB adjust the AB curves one or two points. It is almost unnoticeable. If you bring my result into Photoshop, you'll notice that the white skin is very close to neutral. That is RGB are all nearly equal. It varies slightly depending on where you take your sample.

Flattened the file and went to RGB. Saved the file and showed you the result. Also, you can try NOT flattening the file and going to RGB. Flatten in RGB. See if you like the result better.

I think if you play with this general solution, you'll get the answer you are looking for. Play with the curve, mask, AB channels to adjust colors, if you wish.

I hope this helps. Good luck.

Apr 15 15 07:23 pm Link

Digital Artist

Joe Diamond

Posts: 415

Bucharest, Bucharest, Romania

Post hidden on Apr 16, 2015 08:41 am
Reason: not helpful
Comments:
Please offer some constructive or don't post.

Apr 15 15 09:00 pm Link

Photographer

Stecyk

Posts: 365

Calgary, Alberta, Canada

Joe Diamond wrote:
This is correction smile?

What is your problem? Unless you have something constructive to offer stfu.

I wasn't and am not looking for your critique. Moreover, my post was directed at the other person, and he is free to use it or ignore it. Or, he can modify it.

And was it really necessary to duplicate my entire post?

Apr 15 15 09:32 pm Link

Digital Artist

Joe Diamond

Posts: 415

Bucharest, Bucharest, Romania

I see a lot of frustration here, sending me a private message and q.q for my post and after that posting here, you have a lot of free time smile

If i had something constructive to say that would be probably reshoot in my opinion, but as retouching i dont have the skills or the knowledge to fix this image, therefore i rather guide him where to find some potential solutions instead of thinking that i am a ps guru who offer the best solution.

Apr 16 15 03:06 am Link

Retoucher

ST Retouch

Posts: 393

Amsterdam, Noord-Holland, Netherlands

Penumbra Photography wrote:
I recently had a creepy shoot, and the model was painted all white with dark black features. The white paint was super reflective and kept coming out very over exposed. I tried turning down my exposure and the lights, as well as moving the lights further away. But everything I tried made her blacks fade into the background and lose detail. I settled for slightly over exposed, but now that I am trying to correct it in light room, it's not working. When I pull the highlights down, the image turns a weird grey color and looks flat and odd. Any suggestions for fixing the over exposure without ruining detail of the image?

https://i.imgur.com/10h3QvA.png

Penumbra, nice file and shoot, but here I can see problem with setting -over exposed file.
I don't know which settings you had on shooting , but when you have very bright/ white skin or white dress over solid background , you have to go always with IS0 100 and at least f8 , even in some cases you have to go and up to f14 , it depends from lighting.

It is the best to re-shot file , in case that you can not do it , you can save this file with next steps :

1. Open file in PS
2. Duplicate layer
3. Change blending mode on duplicated layer from normal to mulitply.
4. Merge Layers
5. Again duplicate layer
6. On duplicated layer go to Image-Adjustment- Shadow-Highlights
7. Put Shadow Amount Zero - 0 , and put highlight amount 35 % something like that ( play around until you are satisfied )

You will get something like this for the first time.
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/150416/03/552f90a858b14.jpg

Then you will have to do a lot of cloning. healing, micro D&B steps to retouch skin as well and macro D&B steps to relight model , and to play with curves for better contrast.

If you have raw you can correct exposure in RAW as well.
If you don't have raw , above are the steps to save file with JPG , these are just basic steps later as I wrote you - you  need a lot of micro D&B retouching and macro D&B relighting plus curves ( hours and hours of work but it can be done )

Best of luck
ST

Apr 16 15 03:41 am Link

Photographer

Stecyk

Posts: 365

Calgary, Alberta, Canada

Joe Diamond wrote:
If i had something constructive to say that would be probably reshoot in my opinion, but as retouching i dont have the skills or the knowledge to fix this...

Exactly, you had nothing constructive to say other than to provide another avenue. We agree completely on this point. Even a moderator seems to agree with me. Your prior post has been zapped. 

Everyone is free to provide guidance. Sometimes, one idea creates another.

And if you respectfully disagree with someone else's suggestion, feel free to provide your own. Critiquing another person's suggestion is unhelpful.

Apr 16 15 05:47 am Link

Photographer

Penumbra Photography

Posts: 593

Sacramento, California, US

Thank you all for the suggestions.

Apr 16 15 08:02 am Link