Forums > Critique > First 10 get their worst critiqued by a nobody

Photographer

Jorge Kreimer

Posts: 3716

San Cristóbal de las Casas, Chiapas, Mexico

GSin Photography wrote:
these:

https://www.modelmayhem.com/portfolio/2 … #/42623194

was my nephew playing with your phone? he found a filter that will do something very similar to this.  i was impressed that he could do that at 8. youre not 8.  what does this tell me about your work? everything about this shot would be more interesting if it was the real shot.

Is that the best you've got? I'm disappointed! tongue

Nov 21 18 04:22 pm Link

Photographer

Jeffrey M Fletcher

Posts: 4861

Asheville, North Carolina, US

Something nasty then...

Nov 21 18 05:47 pm Link

Photographer

Garry k

Posts: 30130

Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada

GSin Photography wrote:
these:

https://www.modelmayhem.com/portfolio/2 … #/42623194

was my nephew playing with your phone? he found a filter that will do something very similar to this.  i was impressed that he could do that at 8. youre not 8.  what does this tell me about your work? everything about this shot would be more interesting if it was the real shot.

Interesting ....I recognized right away who the Model was

So that says something smile

When I visit You in LA next time I am down - I hope that you can introduce me to her Jorge

She is Amazing

Nov 23 18 12:46 am Link

Photographer

Philip Brown

Posts: 568

Long Beach, California, US

(me) wrote:
... I might agree with his pick on this one Gary.

EDIT....

WHOOPS!
I saw the "same" pic in someone else's portfolio. Got confused, and came back to check.
Turns out, I clicked on the wrong link somehow!
So, I retract my prior agreement :-}

Jan 07 19 03:04 pm Link

Photographer

Rik Williams

Posts: 4005

Melbourne, Victoria, Australia

Philip Brown wrote:

lol.

While I dont agree with his... odd.. attitude... I might agree with his pick on this one Gary.
I dont think that shot is up to your usual standards. The plain concrete (and maybe the angle) makes it look a bit creepy I think.

Is this an invitation for unsolicited critiques on your own work Mr Brown

Jan 08 19 03:43 am Link