Forums > Off-Topic Discussion > Menstrual Cups - Which is best?

Model

J Jessica

Posts: 2431

Coconut Creek, Florida, US

I'm used to pads for regular days (ie work/class) and tampons for special stuff like shoots and whatnot.

BUT pads feel and create a crinkle sound like diapers (I must wear looser clothing with these), they take up landfill space and tampons have that annoying string.

So i'm wanting to try these cups i've been hearing so much about. smile

There are so many types (disposable, nondisposable), brands, shapes (some with a loop and some with a stick at the end that is pulled) and neon colors (i don't even).

Which is most comfortable and longer lasting (I have heavy irregular periods that last 4 days).

Jul 07 14 06:32 am Link

Photographer

udor

Posts: 25255

New York, New York, US

Here are all kinds of descriptions you might find useful:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Menstrual_cup

Jul 07 14 07:00 am Link

Retoucher

J Strath

Posts: 928

Los Angeles, California, US

I don't understand how those things can possibly be sanitary. Even after washing. At least with a tampon, you can use a brand new, sterile one every time. But that's just my opinion. Before trying something new like this, always research the good AND the bad, and then weigh your options.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=raW3aX_Le88

Jul 07 14 07:03 am Link

Model

P I X I E

Posts: 35440

Toronto, Ontario, Canada

Diva Cup.

They actually are more sanitary than tampons, since the blood never touches your insides when it's in the cup. Unless you are filthy or have an infection, no need to worry about that. The vagina is not sterile. Wash your hands before and after insertion, clean each time you empty it out, and boil it for 20 minutes after your week. The Diva Cup is made of medical-grade silicone, it's not cheaply made.

In the end, it's WAY cheaper than buying tampons and pads all the time. My cup cost me a big whooping $30, and lasts for a year. I can tell you tampons and pads cost WAY more than that. Plus, not a fan of bleached cotton, I'll gladly use a cup instead.

Jul 07 14 04:12 pm Link

Model

J Jessica

Posts: 2431

Coconut Creek, Florida, US

J Strath wrote:
I don't understand how those things can possibly be sanitary. Even after washing. At least with a tampon, you can use a brand new, sterile one every time. But that's just my opinion. Before trying something new like this, always research the good AND the bad, and then weigh your options.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=raW3aX_Le88

I've found mold on my unused/unwrapped pads before and I've read stories of people finding hidden mold in tampons and that scared me because the plastic applicators hide any mold that may or may not be present. yikes And mold scares me.

Her horror story is very interesting and... embarrassing.
If it doesn't work, I could always try a combo of cloth pads and tampons.

Jul 07 14 05:03 pm Link

Model

J Jessica

Posts: 2431

Coconut Creek, Florida, US

P I X I E wrote:
Diva Cup.

They actually are more sanitary than tampons, since the blood never touches your insides when it's in the cup. Unless you are filthy or have an infection, no need to worry about that. The vagina is not sterile. Wash your hands before and after insertion, clean each time you empty it out, and boil it for 20 minutes after your week. The Diva Cup is made of medical-grade silicone, it's not cheaply made.

In the end, it's WAY cheaper than buying tampons and pads all the time. My cup cost me a big whooping $30, and lasts for a year. I can tell you tampons and pads cost WAY more than that. Plus, not a fan of bleached cotton, I'll gladly use a cup instead.

Thanks! big_smile

Jul 07 14 05:04 pm Link

Model

J Jessica

Posts: 2431

Coconut Creek, Florida, US

udor wrote:
Here are all kinds of descriptions you might find useful:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Menstrual_cup

Thanks!

Jul 07 14 05:05 pm Link

Model

Koryn

Posts: 39496

Boston, Massachusetts, US

I could never get them to fit properly, and they were always uncomfortable. The moon cup was big, bulky and ...poked my insides. The exception was Insteads, which I tried in maybe 2001, but I'm not sure if you can get those anymore. I liked those the best, but overall, cups just seemed superfluous, and unnecessary. I bleed so little in general, and my periods are so short, that those things aren't even worth it. It takes me 3 or 4 months to go through a single box of tampons, so there's not even much fluid to...catch. I think they might be more worth it if you have heavier cycles or something, though I'm not sure what's normal for most women, or if something that seems superfluous to me only seems that way to me.

Jul 07 14 05:05 pm Link

Model

P I X I E

Posts: 35440

Toronto, Ontario, Canada

Koryn wrote:
I could never get them to fit properly, and they were always uncomfortable. The moon cup was big, bulky and ...poked my insides. The exception was Insteads, which I tried in maybe 2001, but I'm not sure if you can get those anymore. I liked those the best, but overall, cups just seemed superfluous, and unnecessary. I bleed so little in general, and my periods are so short, that those things aren't even worth it. It takes me 3 or 4 months to go through a single box of tampons, so there's not even much fluid to...catch. I think they might be more worth it if you have heavier cycles or something, though I'm not sure what's normal for most women, or if something that seems superfluous to me only seems that way to me.

I'm kind of 'small', and the Diva Cup never bothered me (I was a bit intimidated at first, but insertion was actually pretty easy). I have a heavy-medium flow though, so I really like not having to change tampons every 3-4 hours. I change my cup every 12 hours, and that's it. Amazing.

Jul 07 14 05:07 pm Link

Model

P I X I E

Posts: 35440

Toronto, Ontario, Canada

J Jessica wrote:

Thanks! big_smile

You're welcome. smile

Jul 07 14 05:09 pm Link

Model

Koryn

Posts: 39496

Boston, Massachusetts, US

P I X I E wrote:

I'm kind of 'small', and the Diva Cup never bothered me (I was a bit intimidated at first, but insertion was actually pretty easy). I have a heavy-medium flow though, so I really like not having to change tampons every 3-4 hours. I change my cup every 12 hours, and that's it. Amazing.

Yeah, I really suspect the nature of your "flow" influences who likes cups and who doesn't care for them. My "heavy" day is literally three hours, on the third morning of my period when I *might* need to change a tampon once. Then, it's pretty much totally over after that, and I can typically go to bed that night with no pad/tampon or anything, and not bleed anymore. I realize that's probably exceptionally rare - so most people probably need a lot more secure, convenient hygiene items than I do, and maybe cups are more geared toward those people.

Jul 07 14 05:16 pm Link

Model

P I X I E

Posts: 35440

Toronto, Ontario, Canada

Koryn wrote:

Yeah, I really suspect the nature of your "flow" influences who likes cups and who doesn't care for them. My "heavy" day is literally three hours, on the third morning of my period when I *might* need to change a tampon once. Then, it's pretty much totally over after that, and I can typically go to bed that night with no pad/tampon or anything, and not bleed anymore. I realize that's probably exceptionally rare - so most people probably need a lot more secure, convenient hygiene items than I do, and maybe cups are more geared toward those people.

Yeah, man, if I had such a light flow, I definitely wouldn't care about the cup. lol But alas, my periods tend to be long (7 days) and a bit heavier than normal, now that I'm off hormonal birth control.

Jul 07 14 06:24 pm Link

Retoucher

J Strath

Posts: 928

Los Angeles, California, US

J Jessica wrote:
I've found mold on my unused/unwrapped pads before and I've read stories of people finding hidden mold in tampons and that scared me because the plastic applicators hide any mold that may or may not be present. yikes And mold scares me.

Her horror story is very interesting and... embarrassing.
If it doesn't work, I could always try a combo of cloth pads and tampons.

Yikes, I've never had that problem before. Apparently, storing them under the bathroom sink is a popular thing to do, but I have a feeling the dark, damp place would be the cause. I don't store mine in the bathroom at all. Not for fears of mold, but if that's a possibility, then I'm glad I keep them in my bedroom. tongue

Jul 07 14 06:33 pm Link

Model

Alabaster Crowley

Posts: 8283

Tucson, Arizona, US

Surprised more men aren't trying to answer.

Jul 07 14 07:54 pm Link

Model

Koryn

Posts: 39496

Boston, Massachusetts, US

Alabaster Crowley wrote:
Surprised more men aren't trying to answer.

I'm amazed there aren't already 3 pages of answers posted by men.

Jul 07 14 08:03 pm Link

Photographer

IrisSwope

Posts: 14857

Dallas, Texas, US

Koryn wrote:
I'm amazed there aren't already 3 pages of answers posted by men.

Well obviously, you should use what they use, and a young model friend told them about what could happen if you don't, and that is all the proof you need.

(That didn't make nearly as much sense once I re-read it)

Jul 07 14 08:09 pm Link

Photographer

Ken Warren Photography

Posts: 933

GLENMOORE, Pennsylvania, US

Koryn wrote:

I'm amazed there aren't already 3 pages of answers posted by men.

I know what my wife used before she hit menopause, but I don't think you care. smile

Jul 07 14 08:11 pm Link

Model

Alabaster Crowley

Posts: 8283

Tucson, Arizona, US

EDIT DERP I READ SOMETHING WRONG

carry on

But yeah I thought about the cup, but I hardly have much of a period anyway.

Jul 07 14 08:12 pm Link

Model

Laura UnBound

Posts: 28745

Toronto, Ontario, Canada

J Strath wrote:
I don't understand how those things can possibly be sanitary. Even after washing. At least with a tampon, you can use a brand new, sterile one every time. But that's just my opinion. Before trying something new like this, always research the good AND the bad, and then weigh your options.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=raW3aX_Le88

so basically you dont understand how soap works?

tampons aren't sterile


OP: you're probably going to wind up trying a few - all vaginas are different and all that stuff, just like pads/tampons you're going to find something that you prefer over others.

My advice is that whenever you decide to try one, either do it on a day when you can be at home (but make yourself plenty active) or to wear a pad with it, just in case you put it in wrong.

Jul 07 14 08:30 pm Link

Model

Alabaster Crowley

Posts: 8283

Tucson, Arizona, US

J Strath
No gender

Interesting.

Jul 07 14 08:33 pm Link

Photographer

MerrillMedia

Posts: 8736

New Orleans, Louisiana, US

Alabaster Crowley wrote:
Surprised more men aren't trying to answer.

I was debating. After all, what do I know about having a menstrual cycle? I guess what I will say to the ladies is, "my hat is off to you for the things you have to deal with." I am very happy to have been born a boy child.

Jul 07 14 08:34 pm Link

Retoucher

J Strath

Posts: 928

Los Angeles, California, US

Alabaster Crowley wrote:

Interesting.

Lol I'm listed that way because I feel it's irrelevant to my job as a retoucher. ;D I assumed my posts would give me away though.

Jul 07 14 08:45 pm Link

Model

Alabaster Crowley

Posts: 8283

Tucson, Arizona, US

J Strath wrote:

Lol I'm listed that way because I feel it's irrelevant to my job as a retoucher. ;D I assumed my posts would give me away though.

I actually have no idea. Haven't seen that many posts of yours.

Jul 07 14 08:48 pm Link

Retoucher

J Strath

Posts: 928

Los Angeles, California, US

Laura UnBound wrote:

so basically you dont understand how soap works?

tampons aren't sterile


OP: you're probably going to wind up trying a few - all vaginas are different and all that stuff, just like pads/tampons you're going to find something that you prefer over others.

My advice is that whenever you decide to try one, either do it on a day when you can be at home (but make yourself plenty active) or to wear a pad with it, just in case you put it in wrong.

Yeah I just realized they weren't sterile after my post, I was under the assumption they were. However, it's not like this is your favorite shirt or something casual like that, which can be washed with simple soap and water and it be good for years. This is something that's used in a very delicate area that can easily become imbalanced from varying PH balances and bacteria. The point of my post was to help the OP be aware of possible downsides. I'm sure most women who try this have no problems, but it's always good to research all aspects.

Also, it's worth considering, it's recommended that these be replaced after a year. And while you can supposedly wear them for up to 8 hours, there's things to consider of what happens if you're out in public, how comfortable is this to change and wash in a setting like a public restroom? If those aren't problems, then yay! But like I said, they're things worth considering.

Jul 07 14 08:51 pm Link

Retoucher

J Strath

Posts: 928

Los Angeles, California, US

Alabaster Crowley wrote:

I actually have no idea. Haven't seen that many posts of yours.

I think I will keep it a mystery! big_smile Yeah I don't post too much, I happen to just be having a slow weekend.

Jul 07 14 08:52 pm Link

Model

Laura UnBound

Posts: 28745

Toronto, Ontario, Canada

J Strath wrote:
Yeah I just realized they weren't sterile after my post, I was under the assumption they were. However, it's not like this is your favorite shirt or something casual like that, which can be washed with simple soap and water and it be good for years. This is something that's used in a very delicate area that can easily become imbalanced from varying PH balances and bacteria. The point of my post was to help the OP be aware of possible downsides. I'm sure most women who try this have no problems, but it's always good to research all aspects.

Also, it's worth considering, it's recommended that these be replaced after a year. And while you can supposedly wear them for up to 8 hours, there's things to consider of what happens if you're out in public, how comfortable is this to change and wash in a setting like a public restroom? If those aren't problems, then yay! But like I said, they're things worth considering.

if you're out in public you take it out, empty it, either wash it and other women in the women's restroom just deal with the fact that you're a woman too and are menstruating…or you put it back in without washing it and you take care of it when you get home. It doesnt have to be disinfected to go back in. (Its your blood, if you're wearing a pad some of it sits inside your vagina for hours and hours and hours before leaking out, and then it sits in the pad pressed up against your vag for hours and hours. Old blood won't kill you.) And then you wipe your hands off and go wash them.

its no more dangerous to leave in for 8 or more hours than a tampon is, pads and even non-cotton underwear throw off your pH and can be cause for bad bacteria.  at worst you get an infection but most of the time it corrects itself with little to no discomfort and unless you're deeply acquainted with your insides every day (which many women are not) you dont even know anything happened. TSS is incredibly rare (and can be caught by anyone, vaginas or not)

Its perhaps an awkward transition from pads or tampons, but theres nothing inherently safer or less safe about it. people are more likely to screw their ph up with some cheap lube

Jul 07 14 09:06 pm Link

Model

Alabaster Crowley

Posts: 8283

Tucson, Arizona, US

Laura UnBound wrote:
if you're out in public you take it out, empty it, either wash it and other women in the women's restroom just deal with the fact that you're a woman too and are menstruating…or you put it back in without washing it and you take care of it when you get home.

I've heard some women carry water bottles in their purses to rinse it out in the stall.

I'd probably just bring that bitch with me to the sink and be like YEP I HAVE A UTERUS.

Jul 07 14 09:10 pm Link

Photographer

udor

Posts: 25255

New York, New York, US

P I X I E wrote:
In the end, it's WAY cheaper than buying tampons and pads all the time. My cup cost me a big whooping $30, and lasts for a year. I can tell you tampons and pads cost WAY more than that. Plus, not a fan of bleached cotton, I'll gladly use a cup instead.

I hear that they are also multipurpose.

In "off-season" (the rest of the month) they can double as emergency drinking cups, e.g. when the little paper-cups at the water-cooler in your office are gone. You can wear them as a little funny party hats and even as a clown nose at kid's birthday parties.

They are basically the Swiss Army knife of female hygiene and survival!  evilgrin

Indeed... a great investment!!!  borat

Jul 07 14 09:14 pm Link

Retoucher

J Strath

Posts: 928

Los Angeles, California, US

Laura UnBound wrote:

if you're out in public you take it out, empty it, either wash it and other women in the women's restroom just deal with the fact that you're a woman too and are menstruating…or you put it back in without washing it and you take care of it when you get home. It doesnt have to be disinfected to go back in. (Its your blood, if you're wearing a pad some of it sits inside your vagina for hours and hours and hours before leaking out, and then it sits in the pad pressed up against your vag for hours and hours. Old blood won't kill you.) And then you wipe your hands off and go wash them.

its no more dangerous to leave in for 8 or more hours than a tampon is, pads and even non-cotton underwear throw off your pH and can be cause for bad bacteria.  at worst you get an infection but most of the time it corrects itself with little to no discomfort and unless you're deeply acquainted with your insides every day (which many women are not) you dont even know anything happened. TSS is incredibly rare (and can be caught by anyone, vaginas or not)

Its perhaps an awkward transition from pads or tampons, but theres nothing inherently safer or less safe about it. people are more likely to screw their ph up with some cheap lube

Like I said, they're just things to consider. These are just my reasons why I enjoy the convenience of a tampon despite what others would consider disadvantages.

Jul 07 14 09:18 pm Link

Retoucher

J Strath

Posts: 928

Los Angeles, California, US

udor wrote:

I hear that they are also multipurpose.

In "off-season" (the rest of the month) they can double as emergency drinking cups, e.g. when the little paper-cups at the water-cooler in your office are gone. You can wear them as a little funny party hats and even as a clown nose at kid's birthday parties.

They are basically the Swiss Army knife of female hygiene and survival!  evilgrin

Indeed... a great investment!!!  borat

You can also attach a ball to it by a string to keep yourself occupied with hours of fun! big_smile

Jul 07 14 09:22 pm Link

Photographer

udor

Posts: 25255

New York, New York, US

udor wrote:
I hear that they are also multipurpose.

In "off-season" (the rest of the month) they can double as emergency drinking cups, e.g. when the little paper-cups at the water-cooler in your office are gone. You can wear them as a little funny party hats and even as a clown nose at kid's birthday parties.

They are basically the Swiss Army knife of female hygiene and survival!  evilgrin

Indeed... a great investment!!!  borat

J Strath wrote:
You can also attach a ball to it by a string to keep yourself occupied with hours of fun! big_smile

See! It's an ingenious device... practical fun for a year for only $30.00!!! lol

Jul 07 14 09:34 pm Link

Model

Laura UnBound

Posts: 28745

Toronto, Ontario, Canada

Alabaster Crowley wrote:

I've heard some women carry water bottles in their purses to rinse it out in the stall.

I'd probably just bring that bitch with me to the sink and be like YEP I HAVE A UTERUS.

yeah. i really just couldn't give a fuck. I'm in the womens bathroom. I'm doing woman things. around people i probably dont know and will probably never see again so what the fuck ever with what they think of my woman things I'm doing

Jul 07 14 09:36 pm Link

Model

Alabaster Crowley

Posts: 8283

Tucson, Arizona, US

Laura UnBound wrote:

yeah. i really just couldn't give a fuck. I'm in the womens bathroom. I'm doing woman things. around people i probably dont know and will probably never see again so what the fuck ever with what they think of my woman things I'm doing

That's why we love you.

Jul 07 14 09:48 pm Link

Model

fluffycakes

Posts: 446

Chicago, Illinois, US

P I X I E wrote:
Diva Cup.

They actually are more sanitary than tampons, since the blood never touches your insides when it's in the cup. Unless you are filthy or have an infection, no need to worry about that. The vagina is not sterile. Wash your hands before and after insertion, clean each time you empty it out, and boil it for 20 minutes after your week. The Diva Cup is made of medical-grade silicone, it's not cheaply made.

In the end, it's WAY cheaper than buying tampons and pads all the time. My cup cost me a big whooping $30, and lasts for a year. I can tell you tampons and pads cost WAY more than that. Plus, not a fan of bleached cotton, I'll gladly use a cup instead.

+1! what my mom uses.

I cant bring myself to, im a puss:/ but it definitely is the smarter option

Jul 07 14 10:19 pm Link

Photographer

udor

Posts: 25255

New York, New York, US

fluffycakes wrote:
I cant bring myself to, im a puss:/ but it definitely is the smarter option

... but... but... but isn't exactly that what those funny lil' hats are for???   lol   evilgrin

Jul 07 14 10:25 pm Link

Model

fluffycakes

Posts: 446

Chicago, Illinois, US

udor wrote:

... but... but... but isn't exactly that what those funny lil' hats are for???   lol   evilgrin

ohhhoho you're so funny!

Jul 07 14 10:28 pm Link

Photographer

udor

Posts: 25255

New York, New York, US

fluffycakes wrote:

ohhhoho you're so funny!

Thank you... thank you!

I am gonna be here all week! big_smile

Jul 07 14 10:29 pm Link

Photographer

Cherrystone

Posts: 37171

Columbus, Ohio, US

Laura UnBound wrote:

yeah. i really just couldn't give a fuck. I'm in the womens bathroom. I'm doing woman things. around people i probably dont know and will probably never see again so what the fuck ever with what they think of my woman things I'm doing

Where's a trophy? You win the internet today. lol

Jul 07 14 10:31 pm Link

Jul 08 14 05:31 am Link

Model

J Jessica

Posts: 2431

Coconut Creek, Florida, US

I went to Target today... They didn't have any. Darn you Target!
You were my hero, Target. sad

Jul 09 14 03:31 pm Link