Retoucher

Oana T

Posts: 220

Deva, Hunedoara, Romania

Hi,

Which photo looks better?

https://i58.tinypic.com/2i7lh5e.jpg

Thank you!

Feb 18 14 06:36 am Link

Retoucher

Mike Needham Retouching

Posts: 385

Cheltenham, England, United Kingdom

I prefer the hair vibrancy, especially at the ends on the first image and the more muted tones of the skin in the second image smile

Feb 18 14 07:51 am Link

Photographer

2M1 Fotograf

Posts: 270

Montreal, Quebec, Canada

The right 1

Feb 18 14 07:56 am Link

Retoucher

Whitney Minthorn

Posts: 96

Pendleton, Oregon, US

Right. Look at the hand and left cheek in the left, lots off red from too much saturation smile

Feb 22 14 02:10 am Link

Artist/Painter

MainePaintah

Posts: 1892

Saco, Maine, US

The left one is my favorite! 

I moved the photos up on my monitor so that I was looking from just the wrist on down, and I compared the color on the arms. The photo on the right had too much of a blue cast for my taste!

Feb 22 14 03:02 am Link

Retoucher

Ovidiu Oltean

Posts: 179

Sibiu, Sibiu, Romania

Both look too retouched on the skin , i would lower the skin work.

Mar 02 14 07:09 am Link

Retoucher

efeRT

Posts: 11

Buenos Aires, Buenos Aires, Argentina

The one on the left (first one).
Skin looks a little bit more realistic I guess.

Mar 07 14 07:38 am Link

Photographer

WCR3

Posts: 1414

Houston, Texas, US

I prefer the overall warmer color cast of the one on the left.

Mar 10 14 06:57 pm Link

Photographer

Worlds Of Water

Posts: 37732

Rancho Cucamonga, California, US

Ovidiu Oltean wrote:
Both look too retouched on the skin , i would lower the skin work.

Would agree with this... too much skin blur.  You also lost too much detail in the white shaw in the image on right.  And the one on the left is too 'red saturated'... I'd re-edit from scratch... wink

Mar 12 14 01:01 pm Link

Retoucher

ML Retouching

Posts: 82

New York, New York, US

Mike Needham Retouching wrote:
I prefer the hair vibrancy, especially at the ends on the first image and the more muted tones of the skin in the second image smile

I've just wanted to write this smile The left one is good as well if skin tones would have been less pink I think.

Mar 14 14 03:07 pm Link

Retoucher

v i k t o r

Posts: 1696

Los Angeles, California, US

Prefer the one on the left

Mar 16 14 01:56 am Link

Photographer

Danny DD

Posts: 347

Baarle-Hertog, Antwerp, Belgium

Eyes and hair are better on the first, skin tone is better on the second.

Mar 16 14 02:06 am Link