Forums > Model Colloquy > So a question to you models...

Photographer

David Stone Imaging

Posts: 1032

Seattle, Washington, US

Even though she is getting paid, it sounds like she is vested in a good outcome....as most of us are in whatever we do.  I would suggest letting her know that what you've done comes up short of your original vision, and you think it is best to start over.

I would still pay her for her time even though it seems a loss to you.  I definitely would not ask her to either refund or credit additional modeling sessions.

And as one further comment.  If you do start over, don't toss what you have already done.  Have a look at it again in a few months with fresh eyes.  You just might see things differently.  This happens to me all the time with photos I take.  I pass on the ones that don't match my vision of what I wanted from the shoot...yet some time later when that vision isn't clouding things, I find I'm very much liking some of the passed over ones.

Sep 10 14 03:34 pm Link

Model

Emily Smiles

Posts: 295

Columbia, South Carolina, US

If she's a professional model, she'll understand that those things happen. Just tell her you're starting all over, and compensate her for the additional time.

Sep 10 14 05:38 pm Link

Photographer

Lallure Photographic

Posts: 2086

Taylors, South Carolina, US

Nothing new about that problem. That one has been around for centuries.

Sep 11 14 05:33 pm Link

Artist/Painter

Sid Rodriguez

Posts: 234

Wilmington, Delaware, US

Well...

She came back... there was a few tense moments, but once she realized that I wasn't asking for any more time and the pay was the same... she let it go and we got back to it.

She kept mentioning reasons why it was her fault that the painting wasn't good, but eventually I convinced her... then she got to see the finished painting... (after scraping off the first version)

I think she was moved as she divulged she did not see herself that way... (eating disorder) and I think she was touched...

Anyway.

Thanks

Sep 14 14 08:27 pm Link

Model

Nat has a username

Posts: 3590

Oakland, California, US

Glad there was a happy ending.

You should see some of the failures (me as a model or me as the artist). Sometimes it can't be helped! My art mentor of sorts says that everyone has 10,000 bad drawings in them, a bad one is bound to pop up now and then smile likewise, there are some poses I take that I regret after 10 minutes with 10 minutes to go. Happened recently at a drawing group, I think I may have started a new thing there- double exposure poses lol. All I had to do was shift an arm and kept the rest of the pose the same, and almost everyone just drew in an extra arm.

Some great things happen from messing up!

Sep 14 14 09:36 pm Link

Artist/Painter

Sid Rodriguez

Posts: 234

Wilmington, Delaware, US

a raw muse wrote:
Glad there was a happy ending.

You should see some of the failures (me as a model or me as the artist). Sometimes it can't be helped! My art mentor of sorts says that everyone has 10,000 bad drawings in them, a bad one is bound to pop up now and then smile likewise, there are some poses I take that I regret after 10 minutes with 10 minutes to go. Happened recently at a drawing group, I think I may have started a new thing there- double exposure poses lol. All I had to do was shift an arm and kept the rest of the pose the same, and almost everyone just drew in an extra arm.

Some great things happen from messing up!

I liked what I got out of you when we worked together...

I agree... I never show my sketch books as they are the best and worst of me... they are like love letters... to intimate to share~!

Sep 15 14 04:21 pm Link

Model

Chloe Selene

Posts: 636

Albuquerque, New Mexico, US

I wouldn't think twice if I was the model and you explained the circumstances . . . as long as you have a good working relationship, I'd think she'd be happy to work with you again.  Wanting to give it another go shows that you have high standards, and as others have said, I think the model would appreciate it.

Sep 16 14 07:28 pm Link

Model

Nat has a username

Posts: 3590

Oakland, California, US

Sid Rodriguez wrote:

I liked what I got out of you when we worked together...

I agree... I never show my sketch books as they are the best and worst of me... they are like love letters... to intimate to share~!

Yours is the only bathtub I will nod off in and wake myself up with an echoing fart lol

Sep 16 14 11:21 pm Link

Photographer

Jason Fassnacht

Posts: 437

Sacramento, California, US

From thee greatest Artist who's ever lived/worked/taught/suffered/Hated himself & his Art for NOT being "Good Enough" ...

"True Genius in Art is Eternal Patience.  Designing, Throwing Away & Designing Again.  Art Must Appear To Have Been Created Effortlessly."

~Michelangelo di Lodovico Buonarroti Simon~

It's literally the very thing which allows me to sleep every night ...

Hella hoping it helps ... ;-)

J.

Sep 16 14 11:31 pm Link

Photographer

Jack Cutler

Posts: 1

Reading, Pennsylvania, US

Best bet is truth every time.  If the model has seen your previous work and liked it then she will understand that humans make mistakes. Super Humans admit them.

Just One Man's Opinion
Jack Cutler

Sep 17 14 06:28 am Link

Model

somedelightfullife

Posts: 44

Nashville, Tennessee, US

Honesty is always the best policy. We can have a profession for years and years, but we still make mistakes, we're only human. If you're paying here, it shouldn't matter regardless. Just make sure she knows she isn't the reason you're starting over, because it may kill her confidence.

Sep 17 14 01:12 pm Link

Artist/Painter

Sid Rodriguez

Posts: 234

Wilmington, Delaware, US

a raw muse wrote:

Yours is the only bathtub I will nod off in and wake myself up with an echoing fart lol

That painting is hanging in a gallery as I am typing this... I am super proud of that painting... (the fart was just a bonus!)

This year has been super awesome! I am currently in five shows... (two juried, one museum, a solo in a gallery and a group in another gallery) I won a fellowship and signed a lease for a new studio today!

one of these days I may even sell a couple of them!

Sep 17 14 06:48 pm Link

Artist/Painter

Sid Rodriguez

Posts: 234

Wilmington, Delaware, US

somedelightfullife wrote:
Honesty is always the best policy. We can have a profession for years and years, but we still make mistakes, we're only human. If you're paying here, it shouldn't matter regardless. Just make sure she knows she isn't the reason you're starting over, because it may kill her confidence.

My wife coached me not to mention anything about it not being about her... as she said that as soon as I say it wasn't you... she would stop hearing anything else I had to say and assume I was lying! Ha Ha

She showed up. I said that I messed up and that I wanted to start over. (I had told her that I had messed up during the first sitting) I told her that I thought we could still get it done in the scheduled time and I wanted to make the painting great... not just okay!

of course she started in on all the reasons she was responsible for my messing up... we cleared that up and went to work!

I think she was touched by the results.

Sep 17 14 06:51 pm Link

Model

Goodbye4

Posts: 2532

Los Angeles, California, US

Sep 21 14 04:28 pm Link

Photographer

Hijacked Productions

Posts: 79

Minneapolis, Minnesota, US

Learn detachment scrap it and start over. Maybe your trying too hard it is just a painting

Sep 21 14 04:31 pm Link

Model

Figuremodel001

Posts: 342

Chicago, Illinois, US

Sid Rodriguez wrote:
I am usually a honesty is the best policy kind of guy.

What are your thoughts?

This is not the time to change. Especially true if you are not paying for the model's time but that really doesn't matter.

Sep 22 14 08:47 am Link

Model

Holly Harlott

Posts: 41

Toronto, Ontario, Canada

I'm sure if you're willing to pay her to do a second sitting she won't mind. She'll want great results from this project that you're both investing your time in and the extra money doesn't hurt!

Sep 24 14 10:15 pm Link

Model

Nadia Ruslanova

Posts: 465

Tampa, Florida, US

Sid Rodriguez wrote:
Saturday night I had a model come pose for me. She was great... her poses were good, everything was good from her perspective.

We have the second sitting booked so I can finish the painting....

So here is the dilemma.

The painting sucks. for some reason I got distracted and I did not follow my normal progression on how I paint... and the results so far are hideous!

So bad that I would prefer to scrap the painting and start again. The composition, the setting, everything about it is what I want to paint... just not what I have so far.

So how would you as models feel if the artists said he was going to scrap what you both worked three hours on and wants to start again?

Should I make something up like the painting got smeared and ruined and we need to start again... or do I admit that in the 25 years of painting... I don't want to finish my first painting!?

I am usually a honesty is the best policy kind of guy.

What are your thoughts?

depends on what the deal is.

if its paid, honestly... she probably doesnt mind too much. and wont be too bummed at the opportunity to get booked more if you re-start. but i do hope she has some sympathy and can give you some sort of a break in rates/time... otherwise its just a bit much pressure on you

if its trade, i can imagine her being upset, but again, i hope she understands and is patient

Sep 24 14 10:26 pm Link

Photographer

nudeXposed

Posts: 1154

Shanghai, Shanghai, China

huh?

Oct 01 14 08:02 am Link

Model

Nat has a username

Posts: 3590

Oakland, California, US

nudeXposed wrote:
huh?

Sometimes, an artist doesn't get a painting right in the first session. Sometimes they have to start from scratch. If you're not used to seeing people angrily tear up the page they are drawing on or pace back in forth in front of their canvas, you can take it personally as a model and maybe start to internalize the issue.

neutral

Oct 01 14 08:15 am Link

Model

V I C T O R I A

Posts: 13981

Los Angeles, California, US

Two Pears Studio wrote:
I think the given is... the model is coming back.

the question is... do you tell her the truth about why you are starting over... or do you make some excuse and start over!

Just be honest! That kind of stuff happens all the time. I've had tons of artists and photographers tell me that things didn't turn out how they wanted for a variety of technical reasons. She won't think any less of you! I feel like it's bound to happen now and then and par for the course.

Oct 01 14 10:17 am Link

Artist/Painter

Two Pears Studio

Posts: 3632

Wilmington, Delaware, US

a raw muse wrote:

Sometimes, an artist doesn't get a painting right in the first session. Sometimes they have to start from scratch. If you're not used to seeing people angrily tear up the page they are drawing on or pace back in forth in front of their canvas, you can take it personally as a model and maybe start to internalize the issue.

neutral

thanks

Oct 01 14 05:04 pm Link

Artist/Painter

Hunter GWPB

Posts: 8188

King of Prussia, Pennsylvania, US

Sid Rodriguez wrote:
Saturday night I had a model come pose for me. She was great... her poses were good, everything was good from her perspective.

We have the second sitting booked so I can finish the painting....

So here is the dilemma.

The painting sucks. for some reason I got distracted and I did not follow my normal progression on how I paint... and the results so far are hideous!

So bad that I would prefer to scrap the painting and start again. The composition, the setting, everything about it is what I want to paint... just not what I have so far.

So how would you as models feel if the artists said he was going to scrap what you both worked three hours on and wants to start again?

Should I make something up like the painting got smeared and ruined and we need to start again... or do I admit that in the 25 years of painting... I don't want to finish my first painting!?

I am usually a honesty is the best policy kind of guy.

What are your thoughts?

Oct 04 14 07:00 pm Link

Model

- Auroraa -

Posts: 178

Salt Lake City, Utah, US

As long as I get paid, I will happily work with you through the whole process again, again and again.

Just be honest with the model.

Oct 05 14 05:27 pm Link