Forums > Critique > Want me to rate you on a scale of 10?

Photographer

IMAGE ULTRA

Posts: 7

Fontana, California, US

Hey DB, I'd love a critique on some of my photos.. Thank you

Dec 12 17 12:55 pm Link

Model

sydneeg

Posts: 11

Newport Beach, California, US

I'm in!

Dec 12 17 02:06 pm Link

Photographer

Digital Blitz

Posts: 2773

Gaithersburg, Maryland, US

Select Models wrote:
Cool... absent for a few years... plus LOADS of new additions... wink

Port: 6.5 (only because you have way too many - please trim it down)
Lighting: 8
Conceptualization: 7.5
Execution:9

Overall: 7.5

Dec 13 17 11:58 am Link

Photographer

Digital Blitz

Posts: 2773

Gaithersburg, Maryland, US

IMAGE ULTRA wrote:
Hey DB, I'd love a critique on some of my photos.. Thank you

Port: 6.5
Lighting & Shadows: 7.5
Execution: 8.5
Conceptualization: 7

Overall: 7.5

Dec 13 17 12:00 pm Link

Photographer

Digital Blitz

Posts: 2773

Gaithersburg, Maryland, US

sydneeg wrote:
I'm in!

No you are not...Read the OP

Dec 13 17 12:01 pm Link

Photographer

Worlds Of Water

Posts: 37732

Rancho Cucamonga, California, US

Digital Blitz wrote:
Port: 6.5 (only because you have way too many - please trim it down)
Lighting: 8
Conceptualization: 7.5
Execution:9

Overall: 7.5

Thanks... but really can't trim it down... over 400 groupshoots (and other events) of work in the past 25+ years... could actually use MORE image slots... 1000 would be great and I'd fill them up quick... you can never have too many hot babe pics... borat

So that puts my 'Overall' at around 8+... right?... lol

Dec 13 17 03:14 pm Link

Photographer

phantom of the light

Posts: 114

Albuquerque, New Mexico, US

Since you're still at this, I would like a go.  (I'm waaaay over 21

Dec 13 17 03:52 pm Link

Photographer

Duncan Cheng

Posts: 81

Los Angeles, California, US

Okay.

Dec 29 17 08:02 pm Link

Photographer

Digital Blitz

Posts: 2773

Gaithersburg, Maryland, US

phantom of the light wrote:
Since you're still at this, I would like a go.  (I'm waaaay over 21

Your conceptualization is awesome. Port needs some work to make it marketable.

Port:5.5
Lighting: 8
Conceptualization: 8.5
Camera Angles: 8

Overall:7.5

Dec 31 17 04:37 pm Link

Photographer

Pete Checchia Photography

Posts: 50

Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, US

Rate me please : )

Dec 31 17 05:00 pm Link

Model

CharlesBarkho

Posts: 2

Atlanta, Georgia, US

first post here give it to me!

Jan 04 18 02:02 pm Link

Photographer

Krishan Patel

Posts: 1

Rushden, England, United Kingdom

Me smile

Jan 06 18 12:49 pm Link

Photographer

Digital Blitz

Posts: 2773

Gaithersburg, Maryland, US

Krishan Patel wrote:
Me smile

Your conceptualization is great but lack a few notches in execution. Also your over dependence  on post production manipulation is taking art out of the photography.  A course in lighting will also help you to reduce hue.

Conceptualization: 8
Lighting: 5
Camera angles: 7
Post production: 6
Port: 5

Overall: 5.5

Jan 07 18 01:44 pm Link

Photographer

Digital Blitz

Posts: 2773

Gaithersburg, Maryland, US

CharlesBarkho wrote:
first post here give it to me!

First of all - your port sucks. All amateurish pics.

Port: 3
Looks: 7
Expressions: 4
Figure: 6

Overall: 5

Jan 07 18 01:46 pm Link

Photographer

Digital Blitz

Posts: 2773

Gaithersburg, Maryland, US

Pete Checchia Photography wrote:
Rate me please : )

Pete,
There is no doubt that  you are talented and accomplished. But your port needs some serious work. You got some great ones with some rank bad ones. Weed them out. It is effecting the general interest of anyone coming into your port.

Port: 6
COnceptualization:7.5
Execution: 8
Lighting: 8
Camera Angles: 8

Overall: 7.5

Jan 07 18 01:52 pm Link

Photographer

Digital Blitz

Posts: 2773

Gaithersburg, Maryland, US

Duncan Cheng wrote:
Okay.

Duncan,
I like this pic - https://www.modelmayhem.com/portfolio/pic/42935827 .... But I am not wowed by any of your other pictures. Lets work on building your port.

Port: 6
Conceptualization:6
Camera Angles:6
Lighting: 6.5

Overall; 5.5

Jan 07 18 01:54 pm Link

Photographer

Pete Checchia Photography

Posts: 50

Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, US

Digital Blitz wrote:

Pete,
There is no doubt that  you are talented and accomplished. But your port needs some serious work. You got some great ones with some rank bad ones. Weed them out. It is effecting the general interest of anyone coming into your port.

Port: 6
COnceptualization:7.5
Execution: 8
Lighting: 8
Camera Angles: 8

Overall: 7.5

Thanks I agree DB, my port needs work. I tend to over publish, not enough editing and too many similar images. Thanks for the feedback!
I need to figure out how to use the album and port settings better on here.
Come visit my tumblr sometime. http://petesartworkwithmodels.tumblr.com/

Jan 07 18 07:27 pm Link

Model

Parker_NYC85

Posts: 16

Dayton, Ohio, US

sounds fun! come check out my port.. I would like a professional to critique my work.. Thank you..

Feb 11 18 01:16 am Link

Photographer

Digital Blitz

Posts: 2773

Gaithersburg, Maryland, US

wideoutparker wrote:
sounds fun! come check out my port.. I would like a professional to critique my work.. Thank you..

Great physique, well toned muscles and well defined Jawline. You could potentially rule the ramp. Unfortunately a wooden expression will be more useful in a game of poker rather than as a print model. Thoughts?

Expressions: 4.5
Looks: 8.5
Figure: 9
Port: 8

Overall: 7

Feb 14 18 05:15 am Link

Model

Alasdair Glimfeather

Posts: 6

Dayton, Ohio, US

I'm super new to this, but I'd love your professional opinion. Anything I can use to learn and grow (/◕ヮ◕)/

Feb 14 18 11:31 am Link

Model

lesleyroxane

Posts: 14

Monroe, Louisiana, US

I'm curious to see what your opinion is, especially since I'm very new to this website.

Gracias

Feb 22 18 11:43 pm Link

Photographer

Digital Blitz

Posts: 2773

Gaithersburg, Maryland, US

lesleyroxane wrote:
I'm curious to see what your opinion is, especially since I'm very new to this website.

Gracias

Senora LesleyRoxane
None of your pictures show your face well. It simply not marketable. From what I can see I am trying to give you some points. But it probably can get better by putting in some better pictures

Port: 4
Looks: 5
Figure: 7
Overall: 5

Mar 06 18 05:52 pm Link

Model

Dkemp45

Posts: 3

Lincoln, Nebraska, US

I'm just starting out and I would love feedback. Thank you

Mar 06 18 06:20 pm Link

Model

David Lassiter 1

Posts: 1

New York, New York, US

Critique me.

Mar 07 18 08:14 am Link

Model

Pauline Yee

Posts: 406

Calgary, Alberta, Canada

I have changed my port significantly since you rated me. Please rate me again smile

Mar 07 18 03:31 pm Link

Model

Joannee

Posts: 96

Freehold, New Jersey, US

me please!

Mar 08 18 06:00 am Link

Photographer

Digital Blitz

Posts: 2773

Gaithersburg, Maryland, US

Joannee wrote:
me please!

Joanee - You look astounding for someone 53. You are an inspiration.

Port: 7
Looks: 8
Physique: 7
Expressions: 7

Overall: 7.5

Mar 21 18 09:54 am Link

Photographer

Digital Blitz

Posts: 2773

Gaithersburg, Maryland, US

David Lassiter 1 wrote:
Critique me.

David - this is a promising photo...Otherwise I was going to advise you not to quit your day time job.

Port:3
Looks: 7
Physique:8
Expressions: 4

Overall: 5

Mar 21 18 09:56 am Link

Photographer

Digital Blitz

Posts: 2773

Gaithersburg, Maryland, US

Dkemp45 wrote:
I'm just starting out and I would love feedback. Thank you

Your stats of Neck: 0" Sleeve: 0" Chest: 0" brings your score down. Also get your prot created by taking some professional shoots.

Port: 3
Looks: 6
Physique: 4
Expressions: 6

Overall: 4

Mar 21 18 09:58 am Link

Photographer

Prime Shot Photography

Posts: 22

Dothan, Alabama, US

Me Please!

Mar 25 18 07:00 am Link

Model

Alasdair Glimfeather

Posts: 6

Dayton, Ohio, US

I'm super new to this, but I'd love your professional opinion. Anything I can use to learn and grow (/◕ヮ◕)/

Apr 04 18 03:47 pm Link

Photographer

Digital Blitz

Posts: 2773

Gaithersburg, Maryland, US

Prime Shot Photography wrote:
Me Please!

Good port - a little diversity will make it better

Port: 6
Lighting: 8.5
Camera angles: 6.5
Conceptualization: 6
Post Production: 8

Overall: 7.5

May 07 18 06:52 pm Link

Photographer

thirdfoots

Posts: 109

Melbourne, Victoria, Australia

Ok I’m up for this one as well 😁

May 10 18 05:27 pm Link

Photographer

Santiagopph

Posts: 6

Miami Beach, Florida, US

Just starting but please, do me!

May 16 18 07:57 am Link

Model

Thaiii

Posts: 1

Milton Keynes, England, United Kingdom

Rate me

May 16 18 02:27 pm Link

Model

peter vic

Posts: 57

Toronto, Ontario, Canada

sure, thanks ph

May 21 18 05:52 pm Link

Photographer

CITM Photography

Posts: 1

Austin, Texas, US

Haven't had as much time lately to work on my port but please rate on what i have already. Please and thank you

May 27 18 03:26 pm Link

Photographer

Rik Williams

Posts: 4005

Melbourne, Victoria, Australia

Go for it Mr Blitz

Jun 01 18 03:12 am Link

Photographer

Eagle Rock Photographer

Posts: 1286

Los Angeles, California, US

GO FER' IT!

Jun 01 18 10:41 am Link

Photographer

DSphotography

Posts: 7

Montreal, Quebec, Canada

Hey DB, your thoughts about my fitness photography? Thank you!

Jun 04 18 06:32 am Link