Forums > Critique > Open critique

Model

sasweets

Posts: 410

Ottawa, Ontario, Canada

Do you think I'm getting stronger or weaker in my photos?

Jun 21 13 05:21 pm Link

Model

Babalon Salome

Posts: 3499

Hamburg, Hamburg, Germany

sasweets wrote:
Do you think I'm getting stronger or weaker in my photos?

You're getting stronger, as you should.

Jun 21 13 05:31 pm Link

Photographer

Duncan Cheng

Posts: 81

Los Angeles, California, US

Which ones are my best and which ones are my worse? Why?

Jun 21 13 05:43 pm Link

Model

Babalon Salome

Posts: 3499

Hamburg, Hamburg, Germany

Duncan Cheng wrote:
Which ones are my best and which ones are my worse? Why?

Your worst (unflattering for the model):
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/120426/06/4f994bf9b2de5_m.jpg

Best (though all of your other work is good):
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/130315/06/514322e547bfc_m.jpg

Jun 21 13 06:08 pm Link

Photographer

Aaron Lewis Photography

Posts: 5217

Catskill, New York, US

I thought we did this already but apparently now.

OK give me best worst

Jun 21 13 07:16 pm Link

Model

Babalon Salome

Posts: 3499

Hamburg, Hamburg, Germany

Aaron Lewis Photography wrote:
I thought we did this already but apparently now.

OK give me best worst

I have critiqued you before.

Best:
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/110417/11/4dab2f7696289_m.jpg

I still think this is truly awful, for the same reasons as before:
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/110918/16/4e767f9be1a4c_m.jpg

Jun 22 13 06:00 am Link

Photographer

Aaron Lewis Photography

Posts: 5217

Catskill, New York, US

Sure, a few things have changed, just wanted to see if your opinion had.

For some reason I really like that shot you hate. I can't bring myself to remove it. Maybe I need to recreated it and do a better job?

Thank you for taking the time again

Jun 22 13 07:01 am Link

Photographer

Marin Photo NYC

Posts: 7348

New York, New York, US

I am still new to shooting models (1yr), how am I doing?

Jun 22 13 07:12 am Link

Model

Babalon Salome

Posts: 3499

Hamburg, Hamburg, Germany

Marin Photography wrote:
I am still new to shooting models (1yr), how am I doing?

You're doing fine.

I don't like this - it's unflattering for the model's face, the pose and expression look awkward, and the cropping (foot cropped off) is weird:
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/130621/23/51c53fe846b57_m.jpg

Jun 22 13 12:47 pm Link

Model

Sunblossom

Posts: 45

Manchester, England, United Kingdom

Hm I might have 2 specific things if it's alright?

Which one (or two) of those I should add, so in other words the strongest?

https://picasaweb.google.com/sunnybloss … directlink

And also the  photos apart from the first 3 are from 1.5/2 years ago. I didn't model for a while and started again only recently, do you think I should keep them for reference or only a few or get rid of them all and start anew? Not sure if it's good to have photos from so relatively long ago when I was literally starting out..  And my faces was younger hehe smile Thaaanks, hope it's not too much!

Jun 22 13 01:29 pm Link

Model

Babalon Salome

Posts: 3499

Hamburg, Hamburg, Germany

Sunblossom wrote:
Hm I might have 2 specific things if it's alright?

Which one (or two) of those I should add, so in other words the strongest?

https://picasaweb.google.com/sunnybloss … directlink

And also the  photos apart from the first 3 are from 1.5/2 years ago. I didn't model for a while and started again only recently, do you think I should keep them for reference or only a few or get rid of them all and start anew? Not sure if it's good to have photos from so relatively long ago when I was literally starting out..  And my faces was younger hehe smile Thaaanks, hope it's not too much!

You could add the first one.

You could keep the old ones for now and gradually replace them with better new work, that's what I'd do.

Jun 23 13 05:35 pm Link

Photographer

Rudy Joggerst

Posts: 396

Las Vegas, Nevada, US

if given the chance, I'd love to work with you.. but I'd like to hear your critique

Jun 23 13 05:37 pm Link

Model

Nicki Micki

Posts: 270

Charleston, South Carolina, US

Okay what about me

Jun 23 13 06:15 pm Link

Model

Raven Blake

Posts: 58

Amundsen-Scott - permanent station of the US, Unclaimed Sector, Antarctica

Would love to hear from you.

Jun 26 13 05:45 pm Link

Model

Becky Nill

Posts: 3

Lakewood, Colorado, US

I would love your opinion as well!
Can you please tell me what you think I am missingwhat you think is best and, what you think is the worst/should be deleted?
Thank you!

Jun 26 13 09:46 pm Link

Photographer

Timothy Bell

Posts: 472

North Richland Hills, Texas, US

your opinion please

Jun 26 13 11:38 pm Link

Model

Paige Alison

Posts: 13

Toronto, Ontario, Canada

please critique-I value your comments.

Jun 27 13 04:38 am Link

Model

Babalon Salome

Posts: 3499

Hamburg, Hamburg, Germany

Rudy Joggerst wrote:
if given the chance, I'd love to work with you.. but I'd like to hear your critique

Your work is tasteful, some of it indeed lovely, but what you could improve on is your image selection. In most of your collages I would only have chosen one picture each.

These are the two weakest images in your port imo, they drag it down:

https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/120815/23/502c91316d31a_m.jpg

https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/120903/21/504580ff8ac8f_m.jpg

I'd probably work with you, too, depending on the concept.

Jun 30 13 06:38 pm Link

Model

Babalon Salome

Posts: 3499

Hamburg, Hamburg, Germany

Nicki Micki wrote:
Okay what about me

"I don't like to pretend to be someone I am not in-front of a camera" - that's fine if you're planning on being a hobbyist working with other hobbyists only.

"High Fashion- I have always been that girl who watched America's Next Top Model, so I know what it takes to be a high fashion model." - I'd take that out of your bio. The show is an industry joke and as any seasoned real model will tell you for every useful piece of info you get - and they are there - you get one piece of BS.

The only image in your port I like is your avatar, I'd gradually replace the rest with better work.

Practice more, work with better photographers, learn better expressions, take care of your hair, improve your make-up technique.

Jun 30 13 07:04 pm Link

Model

Julian Reyes

Posts: 5

Anaheim, California, US

Athlete. NPC Fitness Physique. Model..Book Julian Reyes now @juliusrayz (instagram)

Jun 30 13 07:06 pm Link

Photographer

Jorge Kreimer

Posts: 3716

San Cristóbal de las Casas, Chiapas, Mexico

Sure!

Jun 30 13 07:12 pm Link

Model

Babalon Salome

Posts: 3499

Hamburg, Hamburg, Germany

Raven Blake wrote:
Would love to hear from you.

You're a pretty girl and could potentially do well as an art model. If you enjoy posing for painters or sculptors, there is steady paid work to be had there.

These images are technically sound and you look very pretty here but the pose gives you a double chin, you need to watch out for that:
18+
https://www.modelmayhem.com/portfolio/pic/32965602
https://www.modelmayhem.com/portfolio/pic/32965594

Practice posing, work with better photographers.

Jun 30 13 07:19 pm Link

Model

Babalon Salome

Posts: 3499

Hamburg, Hamburg, Germany

Becky Nill wrote:
I would love your opinion as well!
Can you please tell me what you think I am missing what you think is best and, what you think is the worst/should be deleted?
Thank you!

What you miss is professional images. A good full body shot of you standing, a good headshot.

For now this is your best picture:
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/130626/21/51cbc177d153e_m.jpg

I'd gradually replace the rest with pictures from better photographers.

For example this doesn't make sense at all, it's a snapshot that only shows your nose:
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/130623/23/51c7e38a34f33_m.jpg

Jun 30 13 07:26 pm Link

Model

Babalon Salome

Posts: 3499

Hamburg, Hamburg, Germany

Timothy Bell wrote:
your opinion please

You could improve on lighting, editing and composition.

The editing here is overkill, the model looks like a plastic doll:
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/130626/01/51caa8bfaa12f_m.jpg

Snapshot, bad lighting (flash?):
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/130508/23/518b3f784c55d_m.jpg

Bad lighting (flash?), expression and make-up are unflattering for the model:
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/130508/23/518b3fbfb2b31_m.jpg

Jun 30 13 07:33 pm Link

Model

Babalon Salome

Posts: 3499

Hamburg, Hamburg, Germany

Paige Alison wrote:
please critique-I value your comments.

Relax your mouth and eyes!! I had no idea there were models who literally only had one expression, but you do.

Do you really need to tan? It doesn't suit you imo and doesn't seem to do your skin good.

There is no reason to have the same image in your port twice, even if one is in black and white.

Apart from that the technical quality of your port is pretty good.

Jun 30 13 07:40 pm Link

Model

Babalon Salome

Posts: 3499

Hamburg, Hamburg, Germany

Julian Reyes wrote:
Athlete. NPC Fitness Physique. Model..Book Julian Reyes now @juliusrayz (instagram)

No, thank you.

Whatever.

Jun 30 13 07:41 pm Link

Model

Babalon Salome

Posts: 3499

Hamburg, Hamburg, Germany

Jorge Kreimer wrote:
Sure!

Awesome work. Anything specific you'd like to know?

Jun 30 13 07:43 pm Link

Photographer

Sstillphotography

Posts: 1

Edmonton, Alberta, Canada

i would love a critique

Jun 30 13 08:11 pm Link

Model

E L I N

Posts: 199

Montreal, Quebec, Canada

Am I off to a good start? Thanks!

Jun 30 13 08:36 pm Link

Model

Babalon Salome

Posts: 3499

Hamburg, Hamburg, Germany

Sstillphotography wrote:
i would love a critique

Crediting models as "X (real name) aka Y (stage name)" is unbelievably bad form - we have stage names for a reason, you know? (We have day jobs and many of us would like to be able to get jobs in the future. Also some of us have trouble with potential stalkers.) That alone discourages me from working with anyone.

Apart from that, I don't feel that I can say much about your work.

Jun 30 13 09:01 pm Link

Model

Babalon Salome

Posts: 3499

Hamburg, Hamburg, Germany

Gabrielle Ann  wrote:
Am I off to a good start? Thanks!

You are. I'll just tell you what I don't like.

I don't like the editing here, also it's not very flattering for your face:
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/130625/09/51c9c82936a3c_m.jpg

This doesn't do anything for you, also not very flattering for your face:
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/130416/08/516d6ba5c5305_m.jpg

Your port needs a better full body shot of you standing.

Jun 30 13 09:05 pm Link

Model

Becky Nill

Posts: 3

Lakewood, Colorado, US

Babalon Salome wrote:

What you miss is professional images. A good full body shot of you standing, a good headshot.

For now this is your best picture:
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/130626/21/51cbc177d153e_m.jpg

I'd gradually replace the rest with pictures from better photographers.

For example this doesn't make sense at all, it's a snapshot that only shows your nose:
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/130623/23/51c7e38a34f33_m.jpg

Thank you! I am definitely working on getting pictures but it is a slow process..but thanks again for your opinion! It is appreciated! (:

Jul 02 13 04:27 pm Link

Photographer

Timothy Bell

Posts: 472

North Richland Hills, Texas, US

Babalon Salome wrote:

Timothy Bell wrote:
your opinion please

You could improve on lighting, editing and composition.

The editing here is overkill, the model looks like a plastic doll:


I've re-edited this image, your thoughts on it?

https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/130703/09/51d457fb8e1f7_m.jpg

Jul 03 13 10:07 am Link

Model

Margot Jeanine

Posts: 13

Toronto, Ontario, Canada

Hi,

I'm very new to modelling and none of the photos on my portfolio were shot by professionals but I'm interested in hearing what you have to say about them nonetheless. Like you I have large, natural breasts and I'm curious for your opinion on the opportunities and difficulties they present in the industry. And I would love any other advice.

Moving on to my portfolio, do you find any of the photos to be useless and what do you think it's missing (beyond fetish work which I'm aware of and working on). I'm sure that there's a lot missing but what is a priority? What, in your opinion, are my strengths and  weaknesses? Are there any photos that you really like and why? Finally, what do you think I could do as far as modelling goes (or is it too early to say)?

Thanks for your time and help. Sorry for all the questions.

Sincerely,
Margot

Jul 03 13 11:04 am Link

Model

ARTaylor1

Posts: 6

Santa Barbara, California, US

Hello, would you be willing to take a look at my photos and tell me what you think?
thank you!

Jul 04 13 01:04 am Link

Model

Jhomel

Posts: 180

Singapore, Singapore, Singapore

Looking forward to your critiques.

Jul 04 13 06:22 am Link

Model

Babalon Salome

Posts: 3499

Hamburg, Hamburg, Germany

Timothy Bell wrote:
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/130703/09/51d457fb8e1f7_m.jpg

I'm sorry to day that I don't see much of a difference.

Jul 06 13 12:23 am Link

Model

Babalon Salome

Posts: 3499

Hamburg, Hamburg, Germany

Margot Jeanine wrote:
I'm very new to modelling and none of the photos on my portfolio were shot by professionals but I'm interested in hearing what you have to say about them nonetheless. Like you I have large, natural breasts and I'm curious for your opinion on the opportunities and difficulties they present in the industry. And I would love any other advice.

Moving on to my portfolio, do you find any of the photos to be useless and what do you think it's missing (beyond fetish work which I'm aware of and working on). I'm sure that there's a lot missing but what is a priority? What, in your opinion, are my strengths and  weaknesses? Are there any photos that you really like and why? Finally, what do you think I could do as far as modelling goes (or is it too early to say)?

Having very large breasts is like any other extreme physical attribute, it will make you desirable for one kind of work and undesirable for another.
Generally being plus sized you have to work a lot harder, be better, you have to have an edge of some kind on all the gorgeous straight sized girls you're competing with. You have to be a good poser, take excellent care of yourself (skin, hair, nails), be able to do your own make-up and styling, have your own wardrobe and conduct yourself professionally in everything you do in order to be somewhat competitive.
If you want to model clothed at all (and not shoot art nudes only) you will have to build your own wardrobe. Having your own wardrobe is absolutely necessary because stylists and photographers typically won't have or be able to pull anything that will fit you.
Since your body type is most suited to fetish and possibly glamour, I suggest (waist) corsets, high heels, lingerie, stockings, and a few basic latex pieces.

Priority - get a good headshot and a good full body-shot of you standing.

Your profile and the way you write make you sound mature and professional, which is great (!). As for posing, I think you have the potential to be quite graceful, you just don't have the experience.

Delete this right away: https://www.modelmayhem.com/portfolio/pic/33167622
It doesn't make any sense, also that isn't modeling, it looks like you're falling down drunk. Up the nose shots are rarely flattering in any case.

It looks like your hand is growing out of your head. The image seems to be out of focus, the make-up is rather bad, the expression vacant, and overall it's unflattering for you and of horrible quality:
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/130629/09/51cf097be10fc_m.jpg

For now, I would only keep 1, 2, 5, 6, 8, 9 and 11, and replace all of them with better work by better photographers asap. Once you have more shoots under your belt, there really is no need to include more than one image per look in your port.

What you could do - fetish, art nudes, and live art modeling for painters/sculptors. You could possibly pick up some glamour work here and there, but glamour is very competitive, and the look you have to have for it, is, well, glamourous - small waist (corsets are your friend), dreamy hair, perfect nails, perfect glamourous make-up etc.

Some excellent bigger-than-straight-size, large breasted models for your to check out:
https://www.modelmayhem.com/36768
https://www.modelmayhem.com/339758
https://www.modelmayhem.com/6081
https://www.modelmayhem.com/1724292
https://www.modelmayhem.com/94499

Jul 06 13 02:25 am Link

Model

Babalon Salome

Posts: 3499

Hamburg, Hamburg, Germany

ARTaylor1 wrote:
Hello, would you be willing to take a look at my photos and tell me what you think?
thank you!

Cute look. Most of your work is quite neat.

These don't do much for you, I'd delete them:

https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/130703/22/51d50b256a51b_m.jpg

https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/111231/10/4eff4f8b0510a_m.jpg

https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/111010/22/4e93d473ef848_m.jpg

https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/111004/22/4e8bf17acf437_m.jpg

https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/111003/21/4e8a8554a4c6c_m.jpg

https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/110912/15/4e6e8bf186e1d_m.jpg

Jul 06 13 02:44 am Link

Model

Babalon Salome

Posts: 3499

Hamburg, Hamburg, Germany

Jhomel wrote:
Looking forward to your critiques.

All very neat images, but your port needs a good headshot. Maybe get a serious one and a more commercial (smiling) one?

Jul 06 13 02:46 am Link