Forums >
Photography Talk >
Radio slaves?
Do you guys and girls use radio slaves to trigger your lights? I am thinking about getting rid of my sync cables and adapters and replacing them with a radio slave transmitter/receiver setup. Just wondering if anyone has any recommendations? I've been looking at the Speedotron 4 channel system with monoplug receivers. Nice price as I don't want to spend a fortune. Anyone use this system? Thanks! -Rowen Jan 25 07 09:02 pm Link Most people recommend and love the pocket wizards. Probably the most reliable out there, but a bit pricey. There are other cheaper solutions that work well enough for many people, but don't quite compare with pocket wizards in terms of range and reliability. I'm not familiar with the speedotron system. Oh, if you get pocket wizards and use sekonic flash meters, you can get a module to trigger the lights from the meter wirelessly as well. Very nice. Jan 25 07 09:04 pm Link I have not tried the Speedotron radio slaves. However, I've tried several other brands, and have never been satisfied with them. So I finally broke down and spent the money for Pocket Wizards. Yeah, they're expensive, but they really are better than any of the cheaper alternatives I've tried. Jan 25 07 09:09 pm Link I use PW. They work inside and outside. Used Wein IRs and they didn't work outside. Jan 25 07 09:22 pm Link I love my radio slave and use it in most of my shoots. All of the previously mentioned units are nice. You get what you pay for. There is another alternative. I have use these inexpensive radio slaves I found on Ebay. I have purchased two of these types of units. I am very happy with the second upgraded version I found. The first set was only $34. It worked. How ever it didnât work 100% of the time. It had 4 different radio frequencies or channels to choose from. I modified mine by replacing the ¼â inline cable with a custom length inline PC cable. A little Velcro on the side of my SB-800 and SB-28 and I was rocking. I also made a PC to ¼â adaptor so I could still use the slave with my studio lighting set up. -In short, this first unitâs circuitry failed after 6 months of very rigorous use. The second purchase was a similar looking model with many upgrades. -16 different radio frequencies to choose from -Improved battery compartment. -An on and off switch on the receiver -A signal received LED on the transmitter and the receiver (this makes troubleshooting a breeze) For my use, I made the same modifications to the inline ¼â cable to this 16 channel unit as I did to the other. I am very happy with this very inexpensive alternative. I will admit this unit is not 100% but it is very close. More like 98 to 99%. Remember, you get what you pay for. This alternative is not for everyone. It should be thought of as a Pro-sumer product. If you have always wanted a radio slave but couldnât justify the money for the pro units, this is the ticket. If you need 100% reliability and see that it is not worth the extra effort to see if the lesser expensive unit will work for you, by all means, get one of the pro units. You can find these on Ebay by searching for â16 channelâ in the Camera & Photo category. Jan 25 07 10:05 pm Link I use the PWs. And not can't remeber how I got along without them. I use them with Alien Bees, but the PW work with most or all strobes as long as you have the right cable. Jan 25 07 10:23 pm Link Most people I assist use PW's and they're the best. I got calumet's and they seem to pretty good so far. But, I haven't really tested their range yet. Jan 25 07 10:28 pm Link I've used and sold PW and they are great units. I own Quantums. my first one was before they were Quantum but the original QVI units about 20 years old and still work. First unit had two channels the new ones four. The more channesl the less likely to have interference and better operation. I use them all the time now. Jan 25 07 11:03 pm Link Pocket Wizards ROCK! I have 3 of the PW Plus II's and after moving from the AB's to a Profoto lighting setup, the Profoto D4R generator has one built in. So, now, I only use one of them on the camera. I also use the Sekonic 558R meter to trigger them as I meter at the subject's location. So, I am experiencing "Digital Wireless Freedom" DWF exactly as they intended. And I have to say, it is amazing. It always works, 100% of the time, at least so far after 6 months or so. No complaints whatsoever and highly recommended. Don't skimp, save the pennies and go for it. You will not be disappointed. And, they work up to 1,600 feet away!!! Jan 25 07 11:17 pm Link I *LOVE* my radio slave, no cables to fiddle with or trip over -- simply love it. I just purchased one of the cheap ones from ebay and it works wonderfully in my studio. Yes I have a backup incase the 25.00 thing breaks Only 2 complaints, it doesn't handle syncs over 200 and occasionally something else will trigger it when i'm working. Jan 25 07 11:42 pm Link I use the Bowens Pulsar System... Costs $330 AUD but every now and again they decide to behave badly. I am looking into the pocket wizard system but i have no idea where to get them from in Australia Jan 25 07 11:46 pm Link It's called Microsync and it isn't some big R2D2 hanging off your camera! It has 4 channels too and just look at the size difference from all the others. I use it and I love it! Jan 25 07 11:46 pm Link pocket wizards are great. Jan 25 07 11:51 pm Link .... Tamrac microsync.... small.. powerful and easy to use.. Jan 25 07 11:53 pm Link When I bought my radio triggers, I couldn't afford the PocketWizards, so I looked and looked and looked... I found these: LiteLink by Calumet. I haven't had one problem with them. They work inside and out, dark or bright sunshine. And they are far less expensive than PocketWizards... Well, about $100.00 cheaper, anyway. -Major *Edit - The previous link was to the LiteLink with the 5 year warranty. Here is the link to the LiteLink system without the extended warranty. Jan 25 07 11:53 pm Link I have the el cheepo from eBay with an old Quantum II as backup. Some of the inexpensive ones get nervous when you put the transmitter and reciever too close and tend to fire on their own. I guess for a quarter the price of a PW you could get several of the cheap ones and just throw them away when they start getting flakey. Converted a Radio Shack remote control car into one once. Worked for a while. Jan 26 07 12:39 am Link PW's do the job for me. Jan 26 07 12:43 am Link I have a rather large 20 year old Quantum Radio trigger that never failed. I replaced it with 3 of the cheap ones on Ebay mentioned above. Missfired when you first connected them one of of 5 times. But after you got them seated properly no more missfires. that was with my Olympus Evolt 330. Now with my Nikon D200 that problem is gone and so far 100% fires. I bought 2 of the kind that take power off the flash for the receiver and one that has a battery in the receiver so I could use it to move my on camera flash unit (Olympus 50 and Nikon SB800) off and still fire it remotely. Had them 9 months so far BUT I don't shoot as much as a pro does. A lot for each session but only a few session a month. And maybe a couple of 3 tests. Jan 26 07 12:49 am Link The MicroSync is very disappointing. Very elegant design, but it didn't work as advertised. They are supposedly rated at max sync speed of 160th second. However, in practice, they don't sync reliably at anything faster than 100th second. In my studio the transmitter fell apart 3 times in less than a year. The battery cover on the receiver falls off all the time. It is a great looking design. The transmitter, especially, is much smaller than the bulky Pocket Wizard. But it barely works and is not very durable at all. And isn't all that much savings off Pocket Wizards. Thumbs down on MicroSync. Jan 26 07 12:50 am Link Thanks to all of you for replying! I have been edumacated! -Rowen Jan 26 07 12:57 am Link Digital Basement Studio wrote: I just bought that 16 channel radio trigger set up for $25 off of ebay from Qiqowo. Came all the way from Shanghai, China. Works like a champ so far and you can't beat the price. Jan 26 07 01:02 am Link Since everyone is talking about PW. Is there a way I can connect PW from my on camera (550ex) flash to trigger off camera flash? Thank you. Jan 26 07 02:26 am Link Yes, get a Wein hotshoe that has the right sized female for the PW's synch cord and you're pretty much done. I do it all the time. Jan 26 07 10:51 am Link Micro synch - AWESOME! Under industrial conditions, it still works like a charm! Jan 26 07 10:53 am Link The main reason I heart my PWs is the 1/200 sync speed. It works every time without fail. Jan 26 07 10:56 am Link Save your money and buy two sets of the cheap ones on EBay. I use them all the time and have no problems. I would get the kind where the receiver integrates with the power cord. I think I paid $8 for the a unit and $20 for shipping. Best deal in town. Jan 26 07 10:57 am Link Scott Aitken wrote: I know what you are talking about with the battery cover coming off when pushing the reciever into the plug on the power box but it's just a dumb design issue. I have never had any problems with sync speed or reliability or anything else and I use mine every week!! Jan 26 07 10:58 am Link Michael Kirst wrote: I use this unit as well, and have had no problems with it. It did take a $12 adapter to make it work with my ABs Jan 26 07 11:04 am Link I read from a AB owner that their newest wireless remotes are very good. The transmitter sits on top of your camera and the reciever plugs into the strobe unit. Jan 26 07 11:25 am Link Legacys 7 wrote: These are what I use. I have of there Alien Bee transmitters and a reciever for each of my three AB800's. I use both my digital and film camera side by side and both can trigger the stroes. I stick a receiver on every light to eliminate others from triggering my strobes if ai am in a shared studio or doing wedding where others have cameras. Jan 28 07 10:02 pm Link minutephotos wrote: I read another user stating the samething. AB seem to be pretty consistent as far as quality of thier stuff minus the softboxes from what I've read. I'll purchase a set. I want the Pocket Wizards, but if these are effective, that's all that I need. Jan 28 07 10:16 pm Link pocket wizards. incredible. Jan 28 07 10:18 pm Link Thermogenic Photography wrote: I bought one of these. I do not recommend them for critical applications! I've stopped using mine altogether. Why? Jan 28 07 10:26 pm Link Stephen Melvin wrote: i find the same thing happens with my Bownen Pulsars every now and again... Jan 28 07 11:06 pm Link I use Quantum Radio Slave 4i. After tripping over sync cords for many years, I haven't been without a radio slave for 12 years. Jan 31 07 04:36 pm Link PWs baby Jan 31 07 04:40 pm Link Digital Basement Studio wrote: well, this advice is for other amateurs out there on thin budgets. Seems like every month I have a new expense... new lens, new lights, new stands, new backgrounds, and on and on and on... i figured the last thing I'd spring for was a wireless trigger and then I found these $25 units on Ebay. If you're an amateur, if you don't have to work under deadline pressures... I've found it works great! i never imagined I'd be able to have the freedom of wireless in my small 15'x20' studio space but i'm glad to report that for $25 I now do. If your job depends on it, probably want to save your money and go with the PW. Jan 31 07 04:48 pm Link Only problem with the cheap Ebay triggers is the interference they cause. i noticed on my camera that there is a very visiable band of noise in the shadows when I use the triggers i bought from ebay. I guess you get what you pay for. Jan 31 07 09:56 pm Link Yeap...just got me a pair of the PW's...money well spent!! Jan 31 07 10:00 pm Link Bought the cheaper radio triggers. Wore out three sets of them. Now I shoot Pocket wizards plus Should have spent the money the first time Cheers Grant Jan 31 07 11:01 pm Link |