Forums > Critique > I want to critique your photo

Photographer

J O H N

Posts: 564

San Jose, California, US

Lindsey Arnold wrote:
https://modelmayhm-7.vo.llnwd.net/d1/photos/080212/21/47b25b7f796c2.jpg

THose damn pointy shoes... sorry I have an aversion to pointy shoes... You have so many amazing images in your portfolio! THis isn'tone of them - You look like Velma from Scooby Doo in an incredibly shrinking and tilted Library... It's not flattering nor artistic... If i were you I'd put other images from your portfolio as yer default and toss this one... it says nothing and you have a lot more potential then it is showing

Apr 01 08 12:02 am Link

Model

Lindsey Arnold

Posts: 578

New Orleans, Louisiana, US

lol i changed it. thank u..i was really sad too

Apr 01 08 12:04 am Link

Photographer

J O H N

Posts: 564

San Jose, California, US

Craig Allen Studio wrote:
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/080325/20/47e998b388efc.jpg

Amazing portfolio! Except this one looks like the hairdryers you see at a salon but with dingo balls hanging from them - her expression is that of conceit, or fear of something, like she was asking you if she had any bat's in the cave ( boogers )your other stuff is amazing, I think you knew this wasn't your strongest... your other stuff kicks more ass then Bruce Lee

Apr 01 08 12:04 am Link

Model

Jay Corry

Posts: 8656

Houston, Texas, US

Apr 01 08 12:05 am Link

Photographer

J O H N

Posts: 564

San Jose, California, US

Lindsey Arnold wrote:
lol i changed it. thank u..i was really sad too

If you were sad, Milk that emotion! It looks like yer holding on for dear life cuz yer on the titanic.. and the foot falling towards the camera , i keep starign at it...

Apr 01 08 12:05 am Link

Photographer

J O H N

Posts: 564

San Jose, California, US

JayBC wrote:
https://modelmayhm-3.vo.llnwd.net/d1/photos/070910/23/46e619b3f2fd8_m.jpg

OMG it's tim allen from tool time arh arh arh!

Apr 01 08 12:06 am Link

Model

bombshell

Posts: 93

Calgary, Alberta, Canada

John DeFiora wrote:

First, I'd save up $ and get the rest of the shirt  - secondly... your expression looks like you are going to do an impression of Jim Breuer's "Goatboy" with a different expression, and maybe some separation between your dark outfit, and already dark background It could work, in like an Avengers superhero kinda way

LMAO, thanks

Apr 01 08 12:07 am Link

Photographer

jCveraC

Posts: 195

Richmond, Virginia, US

And this one please... Thank you so much.
jC.
Ps. Not retouching or manipulate it. It's a real photo.

https://modelmayhm-9.vo.llnwd.net/d1/photos/080325/22/47e9ba4861e8a.jpg

Apr 01 08 12:07 am Link

Model

Lindsey Arnold

Posts: 578

New Orleans, Louisiana, US

John DeFiora wrote:

If you were sad, Milk that emotion! It looks like yer holding on for dear life cuz yer on the titanic.. and the foot falling towards the camera , i keep starign at it...

lmao! i thought the unintentional akwardness of it made it stand out 4 the good ..guess not!! thank u

Apr 01 08 12:08 am Link

Photographer

J O H N

Posts: 564

San Jose, California, US

Miss Bugga wrote:
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/080330/16/47effbf3526c7_m.jpg
should i take this off my list of photos?
comments on other photos?

Honestly, I like this... What I would lose is the Big Hair ones, unless you want Teen Wolf Fetishists after you...that and the ear and lips... it doesnt do anything... I can understanding wanting to do funky hair shots... but it's not working... and you have so many amazing images - Hair lips ear , lose them, your portfolio ( and for the love of god, do be one of those numbnuts that says " port "  will be so much stronger

Apr 01 08 12:10 am Link

Photographer

J O H N

Posts: 564

San Jose, California, US

Über Dami wrote:
most normal one i have in my port:

https://img.photobucket.com/albums/v213/uberdami/dancing-2.jpg

you and normal don't go in the same sentence... now by saying that I dont mean that as an insult, meaning, you arent gonna find you buying mama's butt jeans at walmart... although, I would probably take you there to buy clothes for a shoot...

You have an alternative look, cue the DUH _ with that beign said... I would like to see you in " normal " clothes, your look blends in when you wear stuff that you would usually wear... I'd like to see you in more mainstream clothing, liek a 50's dress, suzy homemaker style... or  abusiness suit, as a housewife with lil kiddies around, think LaChapelle... When you have the other stuff its alternative... but be more diverse... you have potential to do some killer stuff... Take the shot you have as your avatar, and run with it

Apr 01 08 12:14 am Link

Photographer

J O H N

Posts: 564

San Jose, California, US

bombshell wrote:

LMAO, thanks

I dunno, this avatar you have now, makes me want to work with you more haha

Apr 01 08 12:14 am Link

Photographer

Craig Thomson

Posts: 13462

Tacoma, Washington, US

https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/071210/01/475ce02f53b92.jpg

Apr 01 08 12:14 am Link

Photographer

CEEKuno

Posts: 3168

Atlanta, Georgia, US

https://modelmayhm-2.vo.llnwd.net/d1/photos/080331/21/47f18fd2c0cd8.jpg
my newest shot

Apr 01 08 12:17 am Link

Model

Mary Geraldine

Posts: 1697

Valdese, North Carolina, US

That bad huh??

Apr 01 08 12:19 am Link

Photographer

Craig Allen Studio

Posts: 4307

Tacoma, Washington, US

John DeFiora wrote:

Amazing portfolio! Except this one looks like the hairdryers you see at a salon but with dingo balls hanging from them - her expression is that of conceit, or fear of something, like she was asking you if she had any bat's in the cave ( boogers )your other stuff is amazing, I think you knew this wasn't your strongest... your other stuff kicks more ass then Bruce Lee

Hahahaha, thank you for the sense of humor and the smiles.

Thank you for the compliment on the other work, some of which is published from the first shoot I did in this style.

Apr 01 08 12:19 am Link

Photographer

J O H N

Posts: 564

San Jose, California, US

Mary Geraldine wrote:
https://modelmayhm-2.vo.llnwd.net/d1/photos/080321/01/47e349fe4bb33_m.jpg

Please and thank you.

You have a gun, and you have big hair, but what else... it's like a senior portrait gone wrong... You could pull this off, with a different environment... make a story, why do i have this big hair and what looks to be a shotgun - make it sin city or Grand Theft Auto... like a destroyed car or barren wasteland... or Mad Max(ine)

honestly, I think you look better without the Hawk... but thats just personal... if you are gonna do the hair, make it like an editorial, otherwise they just scream " hey look, its me and i have big hair "

Apr 01 08 12:19 am Link

Model

Mary Geraldine

Posts: 1697

Valdese, North Carolina, US

John DeFiora wrote:

You have a gun, and you have big hair, but what else... it's like a senior portrait gone wrong... You could pull this off, with a different environment... make a story, why do i have this big hair and what looks to be a shotgun - make it sin city or Grand Theft Auto... like a destroyed car or barren wasteland... or Mad Max(ine)

honestly, I think you look better without the Hawk... but thats just personal... if you are gonna do the hair, make it like an editorial, otherwise they just scream " hey look, its me and i have big hair "

Thank you much. Although I don't know what you mean "without the hawk". You mean styled differently than in the fan?

Apr 01 08 12:23 am Link

Model

Jay Corry

Posts: 8656

Houston, Texas, US

John DeFiora wrote:

OMG it's tim allen from tool time arh arh arh!

pretty original

Apr 01 08 12:25 am Link

Photographer

J O H N

Posts: 564

San Jose, California, US

toyalovelace wrote:
please do me
https://modelmayhm-5.vo.llnwd.net/d1/photos/071216/03/4764dfbf9fbc8_m.jpg

thanks

Wow, i thought I saw everything... then i saw your port and , well,,, i have no words... but i will try and muster a few... you managed to have 2 cliched shots right next to each other... graveyard and train tracks... You need to have more diversity other then you spewing up white stuff from whatever protein shake you had at the frat party the night before... You could do so much better, alternative may be your thing... but In my opinion you need diversity... Have a couple of GQ esque things in there other then you with wings, wait now thats 3 cliches... You can still have those kind of images... but I dunno, they just dont say anything to me othe rthen shcok value, and after that , thats it... just shock value

Apr 01 08 12:25 am Link

Photographer

J O H N

Posts: 564

San Jose, California, US

Mary Geraldine wrote:
That bad huh??

Its not bad, it just doesnt tell a story... and when i refer to the hair,,, im referring you look so much different in the " this is what I really look like " shots , in my opinion, better...

Apr 01 08 12:26 am Link

Model

Miss Bugga

Posts: 8

San Diego, California, US

John DeFiora wrote:

Honestly, I like this... What I would lose is the Big Hair ones, unless you want Teen Wolf Fetishists after you...that and the ear and lips... it doesnt do anything... I can understanding wanting to do funky hair shots... but it's not working... and you have so many amazing images - Hair lips ear , lose them, your portfolio ( and for the love of god, do be one of those numbnuts that says " port "  will be so much stronger

Thank you.
Its nice to recieve some honesty.
I agree with the rest of your comment, just waiting for some new photos to replace them.

Apr 01 08 12:27 am Link

Photographer

J O H N

Posts: 564

San Jose, California, US

JayBC wrote:

pretty original

You have the potential for rugged stuff and you seem to be physically fit, you need to find photographers near you that can emphasize it... try some different things... break the mold of older guy with the jacket tossed behind his back...

Apr 01 08 12:28 am Link

Model

Mary Geraldine

Posts: 1697

Valdese, North Carolina, US

John DeFiora wrote:

Its not bad, it just doesnt tell a story... and when i refer to the hair,,, im referring you look so much different in the " this is what I really look like " shots , in my opinion, better...

I have only had a few photo shoots so far. I am working on having my hair styled differently for each. It's still a mohawk though. Even in my "real" pics. Just pulled back. I am actually going to pull it back in a few weeks for a shoot. Maybe you should check back then. (^_^) Thanks again.

Apr 01 08 12:29 am Link

Model

Laura Doll

Posts: 52

Morgan Hill, California, US

I would love to hear what you have to say. smile

Apr 01 08 12:29 am Link

Model

bombshell

Posts: 93

Calgary, Alberta, Canada

John DeFiora wrote:

I dunno, this avatar you have now, makes me want to work with you more haha

are you being sarcastic?

Apr 01 08 12:31 am Link

Photographer

J O H N

Posts: 564

San Jose, California, US

Devotchka Productions wrote:

Thank you very much!  This one was taken at my house so reshooting will be easy wife just got teeth pulled so it will be a couple days but I plan on shooting it again.  I'll let you know when I do it.  The original was just her stepping out of the shower in a towel and I was like "hey sit down for a sec and put your hands on the keys" took about 5 or 6 shots and that was the end result.  Funny how that works huh?

sometimes those are the best ones... the ones i like most is when i am testing the lighting ( which im not always doing, but i say that so they dont put the i have to pose face on, and those are the ones which i think are the keepers, as opposed to the models ) i want to see you redo it... and when you do , message me... try that technique of just grabbing her at odd moments, even if she makes a fuss... they will be the most honest images...

Apr 01 08 12:31 am Link

Photographer

J O H N

Posts: 564

San Jose, California, US

bombshell wrote:

are you being sarcastic?

No im being serious... It looks like an album cover, if i saw that and you were local, id say lets collaborate

Apr 01 08 12:32 am Link

Photographer

J O H N

Posts: 564

San Jose, California, US

Mary Geraldine wrote:

I have only had a few photo shoots so far. I am working on having my hair styled differently for each. It's still a mohawk though. Even in my "real" pics. Just pulled back. I am actually going to pull it back in a few weeks for a shoot. Maybe you should check back then. (^_^) Thanks again.

Message me when you do... I would like to see it...

Apr 01 08 12:32 am Link

Model

bombshell

Posts: 93

Calgary, Alberta, Canada

ok wasn`t sure...thank you smile

Apr 01 08 12:33 am Link

Photographer

J O H N

Posts: 564

San Jose, California, US

jCveraC wrote:
Here is mine... Thank you.
https://modelmayhm-9.vo.llnwd.net/d1/photos/080301/22/47ca2559e217a.jpg

the image is something I wouldnt print... unless i moved the camera to the right more and had the bars of the crib make some statement in the way they were aligned in the frame of a cute baby in what looked to be  a cage/prison... i mean, you really cant go wrong with baby pictures, but i know you are capable of better

Apr 01 08 12:34 am Link

Photographer

J O H N

Posts: 564

San Jose, California, US

jCveraC wrote:
And this one please... Thank you so much.
jC.
Ps. Not retouching or manipulate it. It's a real photo.

https://modelmayhm-9.vo.llnwd.net/d1/photos/080325/22/47e9ba4861e8a.jpg

It's funny, I came across this image the other day whilst surfing MM... so i saw this before you posted, I love light painting... Go with it, master it, then after awhile, drop it and do something new.... make  a series of it, I will be a fan!

Apr 01 08 12:36 am Link

Photographer

J O H N

Posts: 564

San Jose, California, US

Craig Thomson wrote:
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/071210/01/475ce02f53b92.jpg

I swear i spend too much time on this site, so much so, i read in the forum a long time ago the story behind this image and how she braved the cold.... I give you props for doing so, and getting the model to do so , and pulling a unique image out of the moment... now do it again cuz i wanna see more

Apr 01 08 12:38 am Link

Photographer

J O H N

Posts: 564

San Jose, California, US

CEEKuno wrote:
https://modelmayhm-2.vo.llnwd.net/d1/photos/080331/21/47f18fd2c0cd8.jpg
my newest shot

You have a gift... the gift is elliciting emotions from your subject, whether it be real or contrived, I get a feeling of who each one of these people are, and what their attitudes and innerselves might be like... The one where the model is in the lotus position and the one of the tree above the head are my favorites, as well as the profile with the beard hanging down - id like to see you do a down to earth, mother nature , spiritual soulful series... the women with the buttshots and what not, does nothing... the angles are bad, and unflattering... the shots of the OG lookin dude, well - show him more in an environment ( if you want to go that rought look up Dave Hill ) but you are somebody I would want to shoot alongside in just to see how different are images would be whilst walking through a town or city

Apr 01 08 12:43 am Link

Photographer

RC Images

Posts: 1242

Silver Spring, Maryland, US

Here's something a little different
https://home.comcast.net/~coffeeboiler/IMG_5270-A07R%20web.jpg

Apr 01 08 12:44 am Link

Photographer

FemQua Productions

Posts: 353

Atlanta, Georgia, US

FemQua Productions wrote:
https://modelmayhm-4.vo.llnwd.net/d1/photos/080303/00/47cb8f7d4ccd3_m.jpg

skipped??

Apr 01 08 12:46 am Link

Photographer

J O H N

Posts: 564

San Jose, California, US

Autumn Elizabeth wrote:
I'm game =]

https://modelmayhm-9.vo.llnwd.net/d1/photos/080324/12/47e7d199d9ca1_m.jpg

The colors amazinf, the racoon eyes, meh, i would have told u to lift your head upa lil bit higher to bask your face in the light more

I am not  abig fan of nudes, but you have several interesting ones... id lose the one where yer in the archway, its unflattering and makes you look wider then you are in real life, yer skinny as hell, and its not showing it... which by all conventional means doesnt have to, but you have more to you then that... add more clothed shots... and tell the photographer he has sensor dust, theres a lil speck in the bottom half of the image... the color though grabs the viewer, try a variation of poses and expressions...

Apr 01 08 12:47 am Link

Photographer

Shades Of Gray

Posts: 1054

Colorado Springs, Colorado, US

Okay, let er rip.

https://modelmayhm-6.vo.llnwd.net/d1/photos/080331/17/47f1579225b3c_m.jpg

Thanks

Apr 01 08 12:47 am Link

Photographer

David Kirk

Posts: 4852

Ottawa, Ontario, Canada

Skipped me??

https://modelmayhm-8.vo.llnwd.net/d1/photos/080320/19/47e2f0cad5af1_m.jpg

Apr 01 08 12:49 am Link

Photographer

Craig Thomson

Posts: 13462

Tacoma, Washington, US

John DeFiora wrote:

I swear i spend too much time on this site, so much so, i read in the forum a long time ago the story behind this image and how she braved the cold.... I give you props for doing so, and getting the model to do so , and pulling a unique image out of the moment... now do it again cuz i wanna see more

Hahaha, I like you John.

That is xJezabelx ( 80136 ) from our first shoot that day, yes it snowed. My camera started to slow a bit so I kept a second set of batteries in my pants pocket to warm them.

From the second shoot that day.
https://modelmayhm-6.vo.llnwd.net/d1/photos/071208/23/475b76260f478_m.jpg

Apr 01 08 12:50 am Link