Forums > Photography Talk > how do i get or make FAKE "MILK"

Photographer

Taryn True

Posts: 1875

Union City, New Jersey, US

i need about 5 gallons of "milk" for a shoot i'm doing in a week.
what can i use/mix/buy to get thick and very white looking milk?

no puns please. lol

edit: usually milk is too transparent/clear i DO NOT want it to be transparent, which means i dont want to  water it down or use too many gallons of actual milk if theres a cheaper way to do it.

Jun 05 08 12:54 am Link

Photographer

Vito

Posts: 4581

Brooklyn, New York, US

uh...milk, maybe 5 gallons of it.

Jun 05 08 12:55 am Link

Photographer

Taryn True

Posts: 1875

Union City, New Jersey, US

Vito wrote:
uh...milk, maybe 5 gallons of it.

milk is kind of transparent/clear actually.

Jun 05 08 12:59 am Link

Photographer

EL Perdido

Posts: 9401

TERLINGUA, Texas, US

yogurt

Jun 05 08 12:59 am Link

Photographer

remerrill

Posts: 3880

Arcata, California, US

try the following...

water
gelatin
powdered milk

I did this for a shoot of my own.

mix water and gelatin first... then add powdered milk

edit:
I just saw that your looking for something opaque...
I would try mixing in a package of pudding mix

Jun 05 08 01:00 am Link

Model

Kess M

Posts: 8464

Brooklyn, New York, US

fooorrrrr the cereal?

Jun 05 08 01:00 am Link

Photographer

Carlton Primm

Posts: 304

Dallas, Texas, US

If  you're going to use it in a tub.  You'd be amazed if you get one or two gallons of milk.  It will turn all of the water milky white.  One gallon will do it, two will ensure it.

Jun 05 08 01:00 am Link

Photographer

Taryn True

Posts: 1875

Union City, New Jersey, US

Carlton Primm wrote:
If  you're going to use it in a tub.  You'd be amazed if you get one or two gallons of milk.  It will turn all of the water milky white.  One gallon will do it, two will ensure it.

swimming pool. about 5 gallon kiddie pool. shooting the model from waist up.
she posted on this thread actually. lol

Jun 05 08 01:02 am Link

Photographer

Thomas Andrew

Posts: 372

Boulder, Colorado, US

so why not just USE milk?

I've done that.... just have to clean up after if it is in a studio... (oh the model was spilling the milk or course...)

Jun 05 08 01:02 am Link

Photographer

Taryn True

Posts: 1875

Union City, New Jersey, US

remerrill wrote:
try the following...

water
gelatin
powdered milk

I did this for a shoot of my own.

mix water and gelatin first... then add powdered milk

edit:
I just saw that your looking for something opaque...
I would try mixing in a package of pudding mix

cool thank, ill try a small amount first and see how it works.
so talea, how do you feel about laying in gelatin wink

Jun 05 08 01:03 am Link

Photographer

Alex MacPherson

Posts: 840

Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada

You could make a mixture of milk and white flour. The mix ratio should be 2 tablespoons flour to 1 cup milk. It is sort of like making a big white sauce. ;-)

Jun 05 08 01:03 am Link

Photographer

Taryn True

Posts: 1875

Union City, New Jersey, US

Dolce Moda Photography wrote:
You could make a mixture of milk and white flour. The mix ratio should be 2 tablespoons flour to 1 cup milk. It is sort of like making a big white sauce. ;-)

yuck, wont that smell and damage the clothes? lol

Jun 05 08 01:04 am Link

Photographer

Unknown Profile

Posts: 90

New York, New York, US

None

Jun 05 08 01:04 am Link

Photographer

remerrill

Posts: 3880

Arcata, California, US

TarilynQuinn wrote:
swimming pool. about 5 gallon kiddie pool. shooting the model from waist up.
she posted on this thread actually. lol

TaleaCo wrote:
fooorrrrr the cereal?

so are you the cereal?

Jun 05 08 01:04 am Link

Photographer

Mark M Gong

Posts: 358

New York, New York, US

Everyone is making this way too difficult.  Just go to your local supermarket and get powdered milk in a box...add water...bam.  Should be no more than a 4 dollars.  To get the same amount of milk, you're looking at well over 20-30 gallons. 
 

here's my version of girl in milk with this formula.

https://www.markmgong.com/img/book1_16.jpg

Jun 05 08 01:06 am Link

Photographer

Taryn True

Posts: 1875

Union City, New Jersey, US

remerrill wrote:

TarilynQuinn wrote:
swimming pool. about 5 gallon kiddie pool. shooting the model from waist up.
she posted on this thread actually. lol

so are you the cereal?

shes gonna be my lil' fruitloop!

Jun 05 08 01:06 am Link

Photographer

Taryn True

Posts: 1875

Union City, New Jersey, US

Mark M Gong wrote:
Everyone is making this way too difficult.  Just go to your local supermarket and get powdered milk and a box...add water...bam. 

here's my version of girl in milk with this formula.

https://www.markmgong.com/img/book1_16.jpg

oh wow! magnificent! how did i never come across your work before! wowowowow

Jun 05 08 01:07 am Link

Photographer

remerrill

Posts: 3880

Arcata, California, US

Mark M Gong wrote:
Everyone is making this way too difficult.  Just go to your local supermarket and get powdered milk in a box...add water...bam.  Should be no more than a 4 dollars.  To get the same amount of milk, you're looking at well over 20-30 gallons.

I agree... my reason for adding something (the gelatin) was that I kept getting blownout highlights... don't know why, but the gelatin did the trick for me

Jun 05 08 01:11 am Link

Photographer

Mr Joshua

Posts: 82

Los Angeles, California, US

Dolce Moda Photography wrote:
You could make a mixture of milk and white flour. The mix ratio should be 2 tablespoons flour to 1 cup milk. It is sort of like making a big white sauce. ;-)

Just add model, and you have paper mache!  Better clean her up before she dries!

Jun 05 08 01:11 am Link

Photographer

Mark M Gong

Posts: 358

New York, New York, US

No worries, and good luck.  They might be hard to find since most employees will just refer you to the baby formulas section.  Try looking at lower shelves near the sugar isle if you can't find it. 

Remerill, I'll def try the gelatins next time.  I wonder if it reflects light a bit differently.

Jun 05 08 01:12 am Link

Photographer

Maciej

Posts: 369

Toronto, Ontario, Canada

From a synthetic cow.

Jun 05 08 01:13 am Link

Photographer

Simply Shervin

Posts: 238

Arlington, Georgia, US

https://ecx.images-amazon.com/images/I/318Z6NS2VJL._AA280_.jpg

Jun 05 08 01:15 am Link

Photographer

Mister Kittens

Posts: 255

Santa Monica, California, US

for food, elmers as the guy above me said.  you can get a VAT of it at sams cheap :]]

Jun 05 08 01:29 am Link

Photographer

Brand Design

Posts: 34

Los Angeles, California, US

you could add white poster paint to water.  Or even white latex paint.  I found the latex sorta settled out a bit....but it didn't smell milky.

You could also try white cake mix.

Jun 05 08 02:23 am Link

Photographer

karenjerzykphotography

Posts: 1756

Boston, Massachusetts, US

Milkshakes.


Mylanta.


Yogurt.

Jun 05 08 02:25 am Link

Photographer

GdV

Posts: 254

Los Angeles, California, US

Powdered milk mixed with water. I bought out a supermarket of the stuff once to fill a pool with milk with baby alligators swimming, then a matte was pulled for a film effects shot. Worked great.

Jun 05 08 02:31 am Link

Photographer

Darland Photography

Posts: 216

Dallas, Texas, US

i saw the actual got milk ad recipe one day on martha stewart,she was talking about doing the got milk ad,but i can't remember what it was i think it was thinned out glue,, but i'm not sure, if you just want a bath tub full or something,i'd say use the real thing and some water with maybe cornstarch in it

Jun 05 08 02:34 am Link

Photographer

tenrocK photo

Posts: 5486

New York, New York, US

Since you want it thicker than milk I'd suggest heavy cream instead. Same look but clings to the skin much better.

Or with the powdered milk, use a different ratio of water and powder?

Jun 05 08 02:40 am Link

Photographer

Taryn True

Posts: 1875

Union City, New Jersey, US

im gonna go with the powered milk and water. wink  thanks guys!

Jun 05 08 11:20 am Link

Photographer

Chanel Rene

Posts: 6780

Huntington Beach, California, US

tenrocK photo wrote:
Since you want it thicker than milk I'd suggest heavy cream instead. Same look but clings to the skin much better.

Or with the powdered milk, use a different ratio of water and powder?

Whew! Heavy cream is expensive....

Jun 05 08 11:29 am Link