Forums > Critique > Serious Critique > Experienced? Please Critique my portfolio

Model

Phaedra Etheria

Posts: 56

Tempe, Arizona, US

I am a very passionate model and I realize that in order to grow I must adapt and change. I recognize that in order to grow one must identify their weaknesses and improve. Also recognize their strengths in order to develop them further.

Please feel free to provide feedback, constructive criticism, honest opinions. 

I would like to know what you feel my strengths are and weaknesses as well.

I would be open to critique of specific pictures, specific sets, or over all portfolio.

You are even welcome to critque my profile itself if you desire and feel it may help me to grow.

I am looking for feedback from experienced photographers and models please.

Thank you to those who do stop by and review my portfolio and thank you VERY much to those who also drop a bit of feedback. smile

Be Well

Phaedra Etheria

Jan 27 10 08:49 pm Link

Photographer

Decadence Photography

Posts: 21

Adelaide, South Australia, Australia

Ok I'm just going to pick the best shot from each album and tell you what I like about it

http://modelmayhm-7.vo.llnwd.net/d1/pho … f800bc.jpg

This one is very good I like it I love the pose and the concept everything about it just screams sexy the outfit the pose the look I love it definitely one of your best.


http://modelmayhm-7.vo.llnwd.net/d1/pho … f29e41.jpg

I really like this one the best out of this gallery as the artistic nude looks really good and it is made even better by your over the shoulder glance it's almost like you're leading people and looking back to see if they're still following you a very good shot and great location.


http://modelmayhm-7.vo.llnwd.net/d1/pho … 55415d.jpg

All I can say is WOW!!! I really love the colours and the lighting it definitely looks very sensual and sexy a very erotic image but at the same time very classy and tasteful very good shot.


http://modelmayhm-7.vo.llnwd.net/d1/pho … 87f4e0.jpg

I really love this one I love the outfit and the pose and the lighting again it screams out sexy but at the same time it also screams out tasteful and elegant just another gorgeous piece of erotic art.


http://modelmayhm-7.vo.llnwd.net/d1/pho … 80c926.jpg

This one caught my eye the most I love the mask I love the outfit and the pose and the lighting, I really love how all the colours compliment each other very beautiful.


http://modelmayhm-7.vo.llnwd.net/d1/pho … ce21c9.jpg

This one was the best out of the album I like the background and how it makes you stand out even more and the colours you're wearing are complimented even more by the background very cute smile and great pose and very sexy outfit.


http://modelmayhm-7.vo.llnwd.net/d1/pho … 7d2c7f.jpg

I really love this one the best I love the colours of this one and the pose is really good and i love the lighting and how it compliments the red and black and your hair looks really vibrant in this image and really stands out a lot another great sensual image.


http://modelmayhm-7.vo.llnwd.net/d1/pho … 7e2875.jpg

This one grabbed my attention the most I love the black and white as it really compliments the entire image the pose is very good and just the whole photograph looks very well composed.



Now for the ones I thought were your worst shots


http://modelmayhm-7.vo.llnwd.net/d1/pho … 8f0d_m.jpg

This one I really didn't like as I don't think it suits you at all especially the pose it does not compliment your figure at all you have a very good figure use it more in your images this one definitely takes a lot away from your figure.


http://modelmayhm-7.vo.llnwd.net/d1/pho … 9a09f7.jpg

Again I don't like this one for the same reason I don't think your figure is being used as I said you have a very beautiful figure it should be used and accentuated a lot more and this image does not do that.


And that is about it overall you have a lot of very good looking images there were only two I thought did not compliment you at all and they are as above but other than that very nice work I love your folio.

And if you could critique my work as well that would be much appreciated.

Thank you

~D~
Michael

Jan 27 10 09:33 pm Link

Photographer

DG at studio47

Posts: 2365

East Ridge, Tennessee, US

I am interested in reviewing your profile and portfolio. I prefer to send you a private message. I have spent over 5 years on an international post/critique site. That doesn't make me a good or bad critic, just experienced. I have a BG in multimedia, graphic art, and custom fetish furniture--all of which have been displayed [and sold] in local galleries. My portfolio here represents a fraction of the 109,000 images I shot over a period of 18 months. My career BG was 30 years in medicine including teaching radiology on a college level.  My work includes [although not posted here] quite a bit of work with alternative models, fetish, bondage, horror, fetish furniture, and in addition, a year of work shooting drag queens--performance [club] and studio.I am writing all this drivel so that you will have some idea other than my small portfolio who is looking at your work and what their BG is.
Ted

Jan 27 10 09:53 pm Link

Model

Phaedra Etheria

Posts: 56

Tempe, Arizona, US

Firstly I would like to say that I TRULY appreciate all of the time you took and true attention that you put into my critique.  It means alot to me, especially here on MM where its like pulling teeth to get good feedback sometimes wink

I am happy to return the favor.

Firstly with your Lust is Decadent

https://modelmayhm-5.vo.llnwd.net/d1/photos/100127/20/4b610f4c2f6f2_m.jpg

This image evokes such strong emotion.  To be able to convey that amount of emotion through a silouhette to me speaks volumes of your artistic image and photographic ability.  This is my favorite from this set.  It demonstrated to me that you have a vivid vision which you work to manifest in each image.


https://modelmayhm-5.vo.llnwd.net/d1/photos/100127/20/4b610eccba109_m.jpg

From this set my least favorite was also still an image I really appreciated at the same time however the reason i had to say it was my least favorite was because it caused me to notice a considerable blur in some of the images in that set. *mind you i recognize that the model in the backround of this shot was meant to be blurred but i noticed that the other pics in the set also had the same blur close up* It was slightly distracting but it did not completely detract from the feel of the set because the lighting, the concept, the modeling and everything else still works for me.  I guess even though im not a photographer a little more clarity in these images might have made them even more impressive.

From your Rap Star Set:

https://modelmayhm-5.vo.llnwd.net/d1/photos/100104/17/4b4296dc9e829_m.jpg

For me this was was the obvious star of the set.  Such a strong pose, perfect framing, wonderful natural lighting, and such authenticity of the concept.  I also love that there is so much color, and that you managed to capture the smoke coming from his mouth perfectly without blocking his face.  On the whole the image just POPS and screams out, look at me im fierce.

https://modelmayhm-5.vo.llnwd.net/d1/photos/100127/21/4b6125fe2fb8f_m.jpg

Although i LOVE that you captured the sunbeams in this shot from this angle the models body is just a little ackward maybe not the most flattering angle for his body.  But none the less its not a bad image just maybe not the strongest of the bunch.

From your What About the Earth Set:

https://modelmayhm-5.vo.llnwd.net/d1/photos/091213/05/4b24eaa5aca05_m.jpg

This is my favorite.  The compliation of images are strong, and polished, looks very professional.  The concept itself is beautiful and natural, the model although inexperienced *it seems* did a pretty good job of conveying her genuine emotions, maybe a little more confidence behind her poses might have benefited the image however at the same time i love how natural and voyeuristic in effect the images are.  Beautiful and surreal, i can really appreciate the natural beauty captured in each shot.

https://modelmayhm-5.vo.llnwd.net/d1/photos/091215/03/4b2774ca2a1b3_m.jpg

This shot unfortunately for me was probably the weakest in the port.  The reason i say that is because unfortunately the models expression is very weak, she kind of looks well....like she just woke up, or had a hang over.  I hope no offense is taken there.  The other problem i have is the clarity again the image is blurred. I think thats probably my only qualm with your overall photographic performance.



I would like to add that it is obvious that you are very talented and have an artistic image.  I believe that perhaps with an even better camera you may be able to fix the blur issue, and that as you continue working with new models and devloping your port that you will only continue to produce stronger images.  Your work has a bit of a commerical edge to it but at the same time i can see the deeply artistic vision that you are trying to convey overall and are succesfully conveying in alot of your pics.


I hope you like my review.  I tried to be thorough and was completely honest.  I hope my feedback is well received as was yours for me.

Phaedra

Jan 27 10 10:42 pm Link

Photographer

Decadence Photography

Posts: 21

Adelaide, South Australia, Australia

Phaedra Etheria wrote:
Firstly I would like to say that I TRULY appreciate all of the time you took and true attention that you put into my critique.  It means alot to me, especially here on MM where its like pulling teeth to get good feedback sometimes wink

I am happy to return the favor.

Firstly with your Lust is Decadent

https://modelmayhm-5.vo.llnwd.net/d1/photos/100127/20/4b610f4c2f6f2_m.jpg

This image evokes such strong emotion.  To be able to convey that amount of emotion through a silouhette to me speaks volumes of your artistic image and photographic ability.  This is my favorite from this set.  It demonstrated to me that you have a vivid vision which you work to manifest in each image.


https://modelmayhm-5.vo.llnwd.net/d1/photos/100127/20/4b610eccba109_m.jpg

From this set my least favorite was also still an image I really appreciated at the same time however the reason i had to say it was my least favorite was because it caused me to notice a considerable blur in some of the images in that set. *mind you i recognize that the model in the backround of this shot was meant to be blurred but i noticed that the other pics in the set also had the same blur close up* It was slightly distracting but it did not completely detract from the feel of the set because the lighting, the concept, the modeling and everything else still works for me.  I guess even though im not a photographer a little more clarity in these images might have made them even more impressive.

From your Rap Star Set:

https://modelmayhm-5.vo.llnwd.net/d1/photos/100104/17/4b4296dc9e829_m.jpg

For me this was was the obvious star of the set.  Such a strong pose, perfect framing, wonderful natural lighting, and such authenticity of the concept.  I also love that there is so much color, and that you managed to capture the smoke coming from his mouth perfectly without blocking his face.  On the whole the image just POPS and screams out, look at me im fierce.

https://modelmayhm-5.vo.llnwd.net/d1/photos/100127/21/4b6125fe2fb8f_m.jpg

Although i LOVE that you captured the sunbeams in this shot from this angle the models body is just a little ackward maybe not the most flattering angle for his body.  But none the less its not a bad image just maybe not the strongest of the bunch.

From your What About the Earth Set:

https://modelmayhm-5.vo.llnwd.net/d1/photos/091213/05/4b24eaa5aca05_m.jpg

This is my favorite.  The compliation of images are strong, and polished, looks very professional.  The concept itself is beautiful and natural, the model although inexperienced *it seems* did a pretty good job of conveying her genuine emotions, maybe a little more confidence behind her poses might have benefited the image however at the same time i love how natural and voyeuristic in effect the images are.  Beautiful and surreal, i can really appreciate the natural beauty captured in each shot.

https://modelmayhm-5.vo.llnwd.net/d1/photos/091215/03/4b2774ca2a1b3_m.jpg

This shot unfortunately for me was probably the weakest in the port.  The reason i say that is because unfortunately the models expression is very weak, she kind of looks well....like she just woke up, or had a hang over.  I hope no offense is taken there.  The other problem i have is the clarity again the image is blurred. I think thats probably my only qualm with your overall photographic performance.



I would like to add that it is obvious that you are very talented and have an artistic image.  I believe that perhaps with an even better camera you may be able to fix the blur issue, and that as you continue working with new models and devloping your port that you will only continue to produce stronger images.  Your work has a bit of a commerical edge to it but at the same time i can see the deeply artistic vision that you are trying to convey overall and are succesfully conveying in alot of your pics.


I hope you like my review.  I tried to be thorough and was completely honest.  I hope my feedback is well received as was yours for me.

Phaedra

Thank you for your positive feedback I enjoyed reading your review and yes your feedback was well received and I quite enjoyed reading it. And thank you for your positive comments about me and my artistic vision I have always had creative and artistic tendencies but I've never really used them to their full potential.

~D~

Feb 01 10 07:14 pm Link

Photographer

Jag Images

Posts: 129

Tampa, Florida, US

I am not going to do an in depth review mainly because what your doing is not really my area I do not shoot nudes nor am I interested in doing so, but what I will say is weed down to your best rather than multiples of same look locations. (I realize I have multiples but they will be coming down as I shoot more, I just got back into the game after 6 years out of it)  And please no selective coloring it is trite and usually used to make mediocre appear artistic. I do really like your avatar and think you should shoot more fashion looks your thin body would make excellent lines!
Less is more.. 15 great better than 25 blahs and 15 greats the bad detracts from the good.

Just my .02

Feb 02 10 02:21 am Link