|
I wanted to share and get feedback on the edit work on this image, are there any areas that jump out.   May 19 10 11:12 am Link wrong forum May 19 10 11:21 am Link I wanted feedback about the retouch so thought this would be the best place as this is where retouchers hang out? delete or move if needed May 19 10 11:22 am Link Carl Davis wrote: You are close May 19 10 11:26 am Link doh, didnt even see that as a seperate section. May 19 10 11:39 am Link assuming this will be moved soon: The background replacement looks good to me. The highlights are a bit too strong for my taste and I would smooth the texture of her skin but still its a nice image  May 19 10 11:51 am Link I agree. I buy the comp. I don't like the strong, clipped brights. May 19 10 11:54 am Link thanks, the background I had to use had blown highlights so I thought it best to match them up. And I wanted to leave the skin looking messy so that it looked like she was living rough. Sorry hope this dosnt sound like im argueing against your crits just giving my reasons. Thanks again. is there a way of notifying someone to get this moved? May 19 10 12:10 pm Link Carl Davis wrote: I dont think so. Its an honest and harmless mistake. A mod will see it soon May 19 10 12:25 pm Link Overall, it's very good. A little too burned out for me... and a little too purple in the shadows. But thats just personal taste. As for what I can see at this low rez, the work has been done nicely. May 19 10 12:34 pm Link thanks for the feedback guys, I will look into what I can tweak, if I can bring back detail in the wall I will add more detail back in the arm. I will check the purple cast. larger version to really pull me up on http://carldavis.smugmug.com/photos/871 … DT2-X2.jpg May 19 10 01:13 pm Link Good work  I think this is very well executed.May 19 10 04:48 pm Link |
