Forums > Critique > Want me to rate you on a scale of 10?

Photographer

Federico Gioco

Posts: 6

Manchester, England, United Kingdom

Digital Blitz wrote:

You have the eyes of a graphic designer - maybe it is early for you to venture out of that field. I like your camera angles. But you have a few miles to go as far as total package is concerned. Building a port will be a start.

Port: 5
Camera angles: 7.5
Lighting: 6
Concepts: 5

Overall: 5

thanks for answering, interesting advice.
Actually I already have a portfolio even though it's not focused on fashion, it's in my description.

Nov 02 14 09:44 am Link

Photographer

Gary Winterholler

Posts: 20

Vancouver, Washington, US

Sure, I like the constructive nature of your critique. Go for it.

Nov 02 14 09:57 am Link

Model

Colette Stone

Posts: 9

New York, New York, US

Sure smile

Nov 02 14 12:22 pm Link

Photographer

Digital Blitz

Posts: 2773

Gaithersburg, Maryland, US

Gary Winterholler wrote:
Sure, I like the constructive nature of your critique. Go for it.

Continue building your port in MM. I would take a few indoors as well. DO you wanna check on the lighting and shadows. Using reflectors on the subject of photography gives very good results.

Port: 5
Camera Positioning: 7
COnceptualization: 5.5
Lighting and Shadows: 5.5

Overall: 5.5

Nov 02 14 12:49 pm Link

Photographer

Digital Blitz

Posts: 2773

Gaithersburg, Maryland, US

Colette Stone wrote:
Sure smile

Beautiful port - maybe a little weeding by showcasing the best will serve better.
I love your capability of going for different moods.

Port: 8.5
Looks: 8
Figure: 8.5
Expressions: 9

Overall: 8.5

Nov 02 14 12:52 pm Link

Photographer

ShiggidyShaq Photos

Posts: 32

Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, US

What would you rate my port?

Nov 02 14 03:58 pm Link

Photographer

Gary Winterholler

Posts: 20

Vancouver, Washington, US

Digital Blitz wrote:

Continue building your port in MM. I would take a few indoors as well. DO you wanna check on the lighting and shadows. Using reflectors on the subject of photography gives very good results.

Port: 5
Camera Positioning: 7
COnceptualization: 5.5
Lighting and Shadows: 5.5

Overall: 5.5

Thank you. I'll keep at it.

Cheers!

Nov 02 14 08:03 pm Link

Photographer

unexpected captures

Posts: 272

San Francisco, California, US

still at it by chance? would like to read your thoughts.
thanks much.

Nov 02 14 08:08 pm Link

Model

kaydooms

Posts: 79

Toronto, Ontario, Canada

Rate me smile
Im 21 in December, don't deny a December baby!

Nov 02 14 09:30 pm Link

Photographer

Digital Blitz

Posts: 2773

Gaithersburg, Maryland, US

kaydooms wrote:
Rate me smile
Im 21 in December, don't deny a December baby!

Remind me in December smile

Nov 03 14 11:37 am Link

Photographer

Digital Blitz

Posts: 2773

Gaithersburg, Maryland, US

Shaquille McFadden wrote:
What would you rate my port?

SHaq:
Build your port - the numbers I have for you will be discouraging. Come back when you have some more pictures.

Nov 03 14 11:39 am Link

Photographer

Digital Blitz

Posts: 2773

Gaithersburg, Maryland, US

unexpected captures wrote:
still at it by chance? would like to read your thoughts.
thanks much.

Love your POV and camera angles. Conceptualization is also commendable.
Port: 7.5
Camera angles: 9
Conceptualization: 8.5
Lighting: 8

Overall: 8

Nov 03 14 11:44 am Link

Photographer

Duncan Cheng

Posts: 81

Los Angeles, California, US

Oh i'm really curious

Nov 05 14 04:06 am Link

Model

BlondeBailey

Posts: 14

Cincinnati, Ohio, US

Sure:)

Nov 06 14 02:48 pm Link

Photographer

Digital Blitz

Posts: 2773

Gaithersburg, Maryland, US

BlondeBailey wrote:
Sure:)

Blonde:
As I said in the other forum - you need to seriously work on your expressions and a little on the port. You are beautiful, nice figure. You should be going places.


Port: 6.5
Looks: 8.5
Figure: 8
Expressions: 6

Overall: 7.5

Nov 08 14 04:32 am Link

Photographer

Digital Blitz

Posts: 2773

Gaithersburg, Maryland, US

Duncan Cheng wrote:
Oh i'm really curious

Duncan:
Simply said - you are good. Love your concepts and series. Very inspiring. But I am not 100% sure about your lighting and exposure.

Port: 8
Conceptualization: 9
Lighting: 6.5
Camera angles: 8

Overall: 8

Nov 08 14 04:35 am Link

Photographer

Anna Kalina

Posts: 3

New York, New York, US

And here too:)

Nov 08 14 08:09 am Link

Photographer

Kelly R

Posts: 58

Las Vegas, Nevada, US

Me please?

Nov 10 14 03:02 am Link

Photographer

RFlowersPhoto

Posts: 6

North Kingstown, Rhode Island, US

Lets do this

Nov 10 14 12:42 pm Link

Photographer

Digital Blitz

Posts: 2773

Gaithersburg, Maryland, US

Anna Kalina wrote:
And here too:)

Your conceptualizations are nice - execution can be better. Port needs work.

Port: 6
COnceptualization: 8.5
Lighting and shadows: 6
Camera Angles: 7.5

Overall: 6.5

Nov 13 14 04:38 am Link

Photographer

Digital Blitz

Posts: 2773

Gaithersburg, Maryland, US

kelly melissa wrote:
Me please?

I am not 100% sure about your brightness and contrast level manipulations. But great potentials.

Camera ANgles: 8.5
Port: 7
COnceptualization: 6
Lighting: 6.5

Overall: 7

Nov 13 14 04:45 am Link

Photographer

Digital Blitz

Posts: 2773

Gaithersburg, Maryland, US

RFlowersPhoto wrote:
Lets do this

Very nice start - some of the pictures in your port is better than the ones you have here in MM. Explore other genres as well.

Port: 7
Conceptualization: 6
Lighting: 8
Camera Angles: 7.5

Overall: 7.5

Nov 13 14 04:48 am Link

Photographer

Robert Hare Photography

Posts: 81

Worcester, Massachusetts, US

I'm Game

Nov 13 14 12:46 pm Link

Photographer

Digital Blitz

Posts: 2773

Gaithersburg, Maryland, US

Robert Hare Photography wrote:
I'm Game

Love your port - especially the Beauty album. If I may, can I caution about going overboard on the photoshop manipulation on a few pictures?

Port: 8.5
Lighting: 8
Conceptualization: 7.5
Camera angles: 8

Overall: 8

Nov 18 14 03:25 am Link

Photographer

EAS PHOTOGRAPHY

Posts: 118

Boston, Massachusetts, US

Yes please!

Nov 18 14 11:37 am Link

Photographer

Robert Hare Photography

Posts: 81

Worcester, Massachusetts, US

Much appreciated. Thanks for the feedback.  I have recently changed my editing style to use a Frequency Separation technique.  Still working through this styling change but hope it will retain a clean look while maintaining detail in the skin. Thanks again.

Nov 18 14 01:20 pm Link

Model

Sarah_Elisabeth

Posts: 278

Sydney, New South Wales, Australia

Me?

Nov 18 14 05:22 pm Link

Model

Divided Duchess

Posts: 34

Springfield, Missouri, US

Please

Nov 18 14 11:22 pm Link

Model

LivingInToronto

Posts: 3

Toronto, Ontario, Canada

Would be nice. Thank you in advance smile

Nov 19 14 03:14 am Link

Model

kellyk

Posts: 3

Odessa, Texas, US

Oh please do...

Nov 27 14 10:43 pm Link

Model

Pauline Yee

Posts: 406

Calgary, Alberta, Canada

I have posted here 6 months ago, but my port has changed quite a bit. Would you mind looking at it again?

Nov 27 14 11:07 pm Link

Photographer

Digital Blitz

Posts: 2773

Gaithersburg, Maryland, US

EAS PHOTOGRAPHY wrote:
Yes please!

I admire your conceptualization and this is an awesome manipulation - https://www.modelmayhem.com/portfolio/pic/37381027

but I see some significant room for improvement in lighting area. What say?

Port: 7.5
Lighting: 6.5
Camera angles: 7
Conceptualization: 8.5

Overall: 7

Dec 09 14 06:20 pm Link

Photographer

Digital Blitz

Posts: 2773

Gaithersburg, Maryland, US

Sarah_Elisabeth wrote:
Me?

Sarah: You must be one of the prettiest in the other side of the hemisphere. I love your looks. Have you tried the ramp?

Looks: 8.5
Figure: 8
Expressions: 7.5
Port: 6

Overall: 8

Dec 09 14 06:24 pm Link

Photographer

Digital Blitz

Posts: 2773

Gaithersburg, Maryland, US

Divided Duchess wrote:
Please

Duchess:
You are very pretty - need to work on your expressions a  little though -

Port: 7
Looks: 8.5
Figure: 8
Expressions: 7

Overall: 7.5

Dec 09 14 06:32 pm Link

Photographer

Digital Blitz

Posts: 2773

Gaithersburg, Maryland, US

LivingInToronto wrote:
Would be nice. Thank you in advance smile

Looks: 7
Figure: 7
Expressions: 7
Port: 6.5

Overall: 6.5

Dec 09 14 06:34 pm Link

Photographer

Digital Blitz

Posts: 2773

Gaithersburg, Maryland, US

kellyk wrote:
Oh please do...

You are just beautiful. Dont look your age.

Port: 7
Looks: 8
Figure: 7.5
Expressions: 7

Overall: 7.5

Dec 09 14 06:37 pm Link

Model

Ian Z Richards

Posts: 14

Chicago, Illinois, US

Whatcha think?

Dec 12 14 01:56 pm Link

Photographer

EAS PHOTOGRAPHY

Posts: 118

Boston, Massachusetts, US

Digital Blitz wrote:

I admire your conceptualization and this is an awesome manipulation - https://www.modelmayhem.com/portfolio/pic/37381027

but I see some significant room for improvement in lighting area. What say?

Port: 7.5
Lighting: 6.5
Camera angles: 7
Conceptualization: 8.5

Overall: 7

http://www.easphotography.net  check out my website

Dec 20 14 05:52 pm Link

Photographer

Digital Blitz

Posts: 2773

Gaithersburg, Maryland, US

EAS PHOTOGRAPHY wrote:

http://www.easphotography.net  check out my website

You definitely have a few better pictures in your website than in MM

Dec 24 14 04:13 am Link

Photographer

Digital Blitz

Posts: 2773

Gaithersburg, Maryland, US

Ian Z Richards wrote:
Whatcha think?

Looks: 7
Figure: 7
Expressions: 7.5
Port: 6

Overall: 7

Dec 24 14 04:15 am Link