Forums > Model Colloquy > working with minors

Photographer

Jay Farrell

Posts: 13408

Nashville, Tennessee, US

I have grown to dread it, even for starter portfolios......it seems more often than not, they have a controlling or paranoid mom to deal with.....I've had more moms (Dads usually don;t get involved)  come to me and think all photographers are trying to get their 15 or 16 year old daughter to do porn........um, isnt that illegal? Granted there are many creeps out there but that doesn't make all of us that way!

GIMME A FUCKING BREAK! My only reply I know is "Mam, I don't know who you've gone to, but I for one have no interest in ruining my reputation or being arrested and put in jail." Surely you come to me because you have researched my reputation and saw I wasn't that way. I do what you come here to do.

By law a parent needs to be present while shooting, I just need to find a tactful way of saying " you're presence is wanted here, but not to be up our butts, or play art director, or watch so close that your daughter can't "shine"  for the camera because "like oh my God, my Mom is soooo watching, ewwwww" LOL

With those circumstances it is harder for me to bring out the best in those models.....I have had only a very few with parents that know the boundaries and weren't a detriment to the shoot. I'd like models' perspectives on how I can fine tune my approach of creating a bond with the model and at the same time easing apprehensive parents......for those who modeled young, how did you deal with that situation as models, assuming you liked and felt comfortable with the photographer?

Sep 17 05 06:15 am Link

Photographer

area291

Posts: 2525

Calabasas, California, US

I am neither a model nor a parent of a teenage girl.  But if I were and I looked at your portfolio there is nothing that shows your ability to effectively present one at that age.

If teen work is where you wish to travel then I would suggest filling your portfolio with massive amounts of lifestyle images.  Presentation of sexy, swimwear, lingerie or varied forms of nudity should appear as an exception rather than the norm to show both appeal and confidence to parent and model you can produce imaging that will help move the model forward.

Sep 17 05 06:36 am Link

Photographer

Jay Farrell

Posts: 13408

Nashville, Tennessee, US

You misunderstand.....I see your point and appreciate it. But, I don't get many under 18's, nor do I want to really DRAW that market, but when the opportunity comes, I want to sell myself. They are already sold on my work when they contact me. Besides, they do not see this portfolio, this is for existing models. People who find me locally and see www.jayfarrellphotography.com where there is nothing suggestive, and there is a mix of family and model images. I don't take any of the parents' apprehensions personally.....usually once they meet me, we're good. They have either heard horror stories about the industry or have been burned before.....just like how some women feel about going to a mechanic they don't know......My question was about assuring them, and teaching the parent etiquette while we are shooting. Most do not want me using the minor's pictures on the web which I sortof understand, that is why you don't see lifestyle or earlier teen models on my port. I may do a TFP shoot with an experienced younger model so I can build that end of my book.

Sep 17 05 07:23 am Link

Photographer

George ephrem

Posts: 981

Jacksonville, Florida, US

Jay Farrell wrote:
You misunderstand.....I see your point and appreciate it. But, I don't get many under 18's, nor do I want to really DRAW that market, but when the opportunity comes, I want to sell myself. They are already sold on my work when they contact me. Besides, they do not see this portfolio, this is for existing models. People who find me locally and see www.jayfarrellphotography.com where there is nothing suggestive, and there is a mix of family and model images. I don't take any of the parents' apprehensions personally.....usually once they meet me, we're good. They have either heard horror stories about the industry or have been burned before.....just like how some women feel about going to a mechanic they don't know......My question was about assuring them, and teaching the parent etiquette while we are shooting. Most do not want me using the minor's pictures on the web which I sortof understand, that is why you don't see lifestyle or earlier teen models on my port. I may do a TFP shoot with an experienced younger model so I can build that end of my book.

Jay what i usually do with any model, is to arrange a meeting at the local mall food court, to have a "break-the ice-meeting" with the model and friend, if she is under 18, she MUST have mom with her at the meeting. Sometimes that is not feasible, do to travel distance and we just have to "cold " shoot. but mom is always there.
No exceptions! At least maybe try and talk to the mom on the phone before the shoot.
I recently had a shoot with a 14 yr old, met with her and mom, and her friend and mom, at the mall. When we finally got to  do a shoot, one of the gilrs mom wouldn't show with her daughter. I said, no mom, no shoot.
I did shoot with the one girl, all was fine, i used mom to hold a second flash and also a reflector.(we were out doors)
Well maybe try it and hope all goes well for you

Sep 17 05 07:41 am Link

Photographer

Timecatcher Photography

Posts: 179

Minneapolis, Minnesota, US

I agree with George.  Have a parent there if you are going to meet with a minor.  I also suggest simply not going in any direction that even comes close to suggestive work with teenagers.  Even if they say they're 18, be careful. There are 18 year old women.........but there are also 18 year old girls.........simply too immature to bother with.  As a general rule, I dont' shoot nudes with anyone under 19. Why bother with all that teenage nonsense?

Sep 17 05 07:47 am Link

Photographer

ChristerArt

Posts: 2861

Cambridge, England, United Kingdom

Patrick Michael wrote:
I agree with George.  Have a parent there if you are going to meet with a minor.  I also suggest simply not going in any direction that even comes close to suggestive work with teenagers.  Even if they say they're 18, be careful. There are 18 year old women.........but there are also 18 year old girls.........simply too immature to bother with.  As a general rule, I dont' shoot nudes with anyone under 19. Why bother with all that teenage nonsense?

Ummm - isn't a 19 year old girl a teenager?..=*^)

Myself - I've had mothers email and call me wanting me to shoot their daughters - which always surprise the heck out of me considering that I am mainly known for "Sensual and Erotic" images. If they are in Europe, no problem as long as they are 15 - here in the States. unless they are 18 I won't even talk to them...=*^)

Seriously, I tell them my concerns and reasons I won't and ask them to come back when their daughters turned 18. They invariably tell me they will.=*^)

Sep 18 05 01:16 am Link

Photographer

photosbydmp

Posts: 3808

Shepparton-Mooroopna, Victoria, Australia

cringe, cringe, slinks away and welds up the door at the studio at  this thought.

Sep 18 05 01:23 am Link

Photographer

- null -

Posts: 4576

I don't ever want to see a miner naked.

https://recollectionbooks.com/bleed/images/labor/lee_hipshire.jpg

Sep 18 05 02:23 am Link

Photographer

Glamour Boulevard

Posts: 8628

Sacramento, California, US

Jay Farrell wrote:
I have grown to dread it, even for starter portfolios......it seems more often than not, they have a controlling or paranoid mom to deal with.....I've had more moms (Dads usually don;t get involved)  come to me and think all photographers are trying to get their 15 or 16 year old daughter to do porn........um, isnt that illegal? Granted there are many creeps out there but that doesn't make all of us that way!

GIMME A FUCKING BREAK! My only reply I know is "Mam, I don't know who you've gone to, but I for one have no interest in ruining my reputation or being arrested and put in jail." Surely you come to me because you have researched my reputation and saw I wasn't that way. I do what you come here to do.

By law a parent needs to be present while shooting, I just need to find a tactful way of saying " you're presence is wanted here, but not to be up our butts, or play art director, or watch so close that your daughter can't "shine"  for the camera because "like oh my God, my Mom is soooo watching, ewwwww" LOL

With those circumstances it is harder for me to bring out the best in those models.....I have had only a very few with parents that know the boundaries and weren't a detriment to the shoot. I'd like models' perspectives on how I can fine tune my approach of creating a bond with the model and at the same time easing apprehensive parents......for those who modeled young, how did you deal with that situation as models, assuming you liked and felt comfortable with the photographer?

I am lucky to have never had any problems with mom being there(I do find it odd that Fathers have never come along to any of their daughters shoots considering how protective they are). I always talk to them before we meet, by phone and then again before the shoot to let them know that this is in fact my shoot and that if mom has any objections to any outfits/poses,etc to please speak up and the photograph will not be taken. The moms I have had along with their girls have actually been a total blast to have around. In a couple cases mom being there actually helped me bring the daughter out of her shell a little easier.
Two of my favorite shoots were of two girls, one 15, the other 17(face shot in my portfolio , blonde hair, fence in background looking like squares.And the girl by the neon sign with the colors reflecting on her skin, and the shot in black against the cement brick wall).I have more of them which I will be displaying later or could give links to those interested.
In one case mom asked if she should say or go if it would make her girl nervous. I wanted her to stay of course and we all had a lot of fun.
Just explain to the parent that they are there because they feel you can do great shots of their girl or they would not be there and to please let it happen. But of course if they have any objections tell them you insist they speak up about it immediately.
I happen to enjoy shooting the younger models sometimes more than the older experienced ones. To me they seem less jaded, they don`t watch clocks, and seem to be more interested in trying more creative things just for the heck of it and like to go with the flow more,imo.

Sep 18 05 02:41 am Link

Photographer

Jay Farrell

Posts: 13408

Nashville, Tennessee, US

Thanks for the great replies....Glamour Boulevard, you have some great points. I enjoy working with younger models sometimes, because as you say a new found energy and plus it keeps me more rounded. I would make sure the mom is there as well, and in a couple cases, the relationship between mother and daughter was comfortable enough for the shoot to be productive and the girl not feel uncomfortable. I just hate it when they come to me with a giant wall up, like everyone's out to shoot porn with their daughter. All I can do is assure them that's not why I am here, and if you keep that mindset, it will only hurt your daughter's shoot and modeling career, until she turns 18. Maybe as you say, a meeting before the shoot is good, and then we discuss what looks and wardrobe we will do, and if any objection, speak now or forever hold your peace.

Sep 18 05 08:05 am Link

Photographer

Jay Farrell

Posts: 13408

Nashville, Tennessee, US

Speaking of, I met a 16 year old model yesterday and her mom, and they will be great to work with I believe! I see them feeding off one another at the shoot and the mom seems to understand that me and her daughter must form a bond while shooting. It helps that she seems like a good mom, her daughter certainly seems wise and mature beyond her years, acorn / tree. It's nice to see that the mom can differentiate between a legitimate photographer and a sleezebag, and that she believes in her daughter enough to know that she can be trusted to model and make some judgement calls, instead of being her finger puppet. Yet mom's right there is she needs her......now that is ideal! Can't get any better!

Totally the opposite of another very tragic case I had back in March. Exchanged many e mails with a local 15 year old girl new to modeling, she had the look for sure, and she liked my work, and needed help putting together a portfolio. She really understood how it works that she must have that, gain experience and pay her dues while she still has her age on her side. She just had such a bubbly and energetic personality, and was looking forward to working with her. BUT, mom was the problem and the road block....she was the type that only wanted to meet up when totally convenient for her, and too bad about how important this was to her daughter.....very selfish and controlling woman I could tell already.....we meet up and she definitely had her walls up, and I answered her questions best I could patiently. She still didn't seem to accept what her role was to be when we actually shoot.....be there, but please give us some space. She always thought there was an ulterior motive. And I was out to objectify her daughter.....gimme a break. Her daughter was as sweet as could be and was very upset and embarrased by her mother's behavior, ( I havent given all details), but she was even suggesting that I could get a nipple slip, or her underwear or buttcrack popping out while posing, whatever, on camera and sell it on the internet, yada yada....I laughed and I said I was starting to feel like we weren't making progress at that point if meeting me face to face, seeing my work, and me offering references doesn;t account for something. I asked, do you see anything in the work ou have seen that suggests I am that way? No comment.....I asked the daughter to excuse us for a moment, I told her, I know it is tough as a parent, but you have to realize that she wants to do this for herself, not for you. You should try being more open minded and supportive of her dreams and of those who are legitimate and are trying to help her. It seems that you have no trust in her to make any decisions and use her own creativity, and our conversation doesn't show me that you can effectively use your own discretion. Keep in mind earlier in the conversation I offered to give her my references. Your daughter has unlimited potential, and do you want to be the only force holding her back? The daughter hugged me and was fighting back tears (which mom was not happy about LOL) I told her it's ok honey, I will never be mad at you, or your mom, it's business, and I hope one day you can work with me, I am here to help you.  Needless to say we didn't shoot, which was fine by me. The daughter e mailed me and said she was so pissed at her mom and was so sorry, etc.....I just said well she is doing the best she can, she just doesn't understand and maybe she needs time. Please don't give up on your dream, and please remember me when you turn 18, worst case scenerio and can make this happen for yourself.

Needless to say, the good experiences like yesterday and a few in between made up for that one huge tragedy, though it still makes me a little paranoid when talking to a minor. I'm learning to take it on a per case basis a little better now that time has passed.

Sep 18 05 08:31 am Link