Forums > Photography Talk > Shooting in overcast conditions

Photographer

Jillian Keats

Posts: 1158

Montclair, New Jersey, US

I'm shooting at a park soon and, being the bleak New Jersey winter that it is, I'm not putting all my chips in on the fact that it'll be a nice day.  If there's little sunlight and a flat, white sky, what are some ways I can manipulate the light to get the best shot?

Dec 09 07 12:51 am Link

Photographer

californian

Posts: 524

Los Angeles, California, US

look at helmut newton's outdoor stuff, much of it is shot in overcast conditions he loved. specifically what he shot in berlin. no manipulation, no lights.

Dec 09 07 01:00 am Link

Photographer

Michael R Kihn Studios

Posts: 2559

Erie, Pennsylvania, US

I prefer to shoot in overcast conditions. If I need extra light
I'll bring it.

Dec 09 07 01:05 am Link

Photographer

K E E L I N G

Posts: 39894

Peoria, Illinois, US

Overcast days are what I pray for on location shoots!  Sunny skies mean harsh shadows.  The best light source you can find is the sun with clouds acting like softboxes.

Dec 09 07 01:09 am Link

Photographer

Jillian Keats

Posts: 1158

Montclair, New Jersey, US

Michael R  Kihn Studios wrote:
I prefer to shoot in overcast conditions. If I need extra light
I'll bring it.

Ha, which I don't have. wink

Dec 09 07 01:10 am Link

Photographer

Jillian Keats

Posts: 1158

Montclair, New Jersey, US

Chris Keeling wrote:
Overcast days are what I pray for on location shoots!  Sunny skies mean harsh shadows.  The best light source you can find is the sun with clouds acting like softboxes.

I understand.  I'm trying to focus my shoot around a lot of bright colors and action, though, which I think would actually be enhanced with a bit of hard light—not too much to look unappealing, but it adds a great effect when used correctly.

Dec 09 07 01:12 am Link

Photographer

K E E L I N G

Posts: 39894

Peoria, Illinois, US

Jillian Keats wrote:

Ha, which I don't have. wink

You don't need extra lights.  Overcast days provide plenty of light.  Look at my port, maybe 1 out of probably 70 outdoor shots in my port used and sort of artificial light source.  Pretty much all of them were done by putting the model in proper relation to the sun.  Very few of them did I even use a reflector. 

No crying about can't afford a reflector either.  smile  I go to walmart and spend $3 on white foam board, and then wrap aluminum foil around it.

Dec 09 07 01:13 am Link

Photographer

outthebox

Posts: 169

Sudbury, Massachusetts, US

i prefer overcast days myself no hot spots and just latelty experimenting with my portable white lightning power pack and studio light

Dec 09 07 01:14 am Link

Photographer

K E E L I N G

Posts: 39894

Peoria, Illinois, US

Jillian Keats wrote:
I understand.  I'm trying to focus my shoot around a lot of bright colors and action, though, which I think would actually be enhanced with a bit of hard light—not too much to look unappealing, but it adds a great effect when used correctly.

Again, look at my port, do you see any color problems on my outdoor shots?  I very rarely shoot in harsh sunlight, and never in the middle of the day.  I always shoot when the sun has already sunk in the sky.

Dec 09 07 01:15 am Link

Photographer

Lumigraphics

Posts: 32780

Detroit, Michigan, US

You can shoot different stuff on an overcast day. Try including bright colors or artificial light (neons for example) that wouldn't stand out on a sunny day.

Dec 09 07 01:16 am Link

Photographer

K E E L I N G

Posts: 39894

Peoria, Illinois, US

Jillian Keats wrote:

I understand.  I'm trying to focus my shoot around a lot of bright colors and action, though, which I think would actually be enhanced with a bit of hard light—not too much to look unappealing, but it adds a great effect when used correctly.

Besides, bright sunlight, or any kind of harsh light will wash out bright colors.  You'll get much more color saturation on an overcast day.

Dec 09 07 01:16 am Link

Photographer

Legacys 7

Posts: 33899

San Francisco, California, US

Overcast is apart of my style when I get the chance to shoot with it.

https://img7.modelmayhem.com/070504/15/463b876a5647c.jpg

Dec 09 07 01:17 am Link

Photographer

K E E L I N G

Posts: 39894

Peoria, Illinois, US

Legacys 7 wrote:
Overcast is apart of my style when I get the chance to shoot with it.

https://img7.modelmayhem.com/070504/15/463b876a5647c.jpg

Very cool shot!  smile

How's this one?

https://i187.photobucket.com/albums/x180/yurphotoguy/Meg/Barking005.jpg?t=1196617438

Dec 09 07 01:20 am Link

Photographer

Jillian Keats

Posts: 1158

Montclair, New Jersey, US

Legacys 7 wrote:
Overcast is apart of my style when I get the chance to shoot with it.

https://img7.modelmayhem.com/070504/15/463b876a5647c.jpg

That's really awesome.

The point of me wanting a sunny day rather than an overcast one is merely to blend with the mood I'm trying to create.  If I plan to add a wide-angle shot that placed the model in front of the sky and I'm trying to convey brightness, I'd like the sky to blend with that. 

But that's neither here nor there.

Dec 09 07 01:21 am Link

Photographer

Legacys 7

Posts: 33899

San Francisco, California, US

Chris Keeling wrote:

Very cool shot!  smile

How's this one?

https://i187.photobucket.com/albums/x180/yurphotoguy/Meg/Barking005.jpg?t=1196617438

Me likes. I've looked at some of your stuff before. I like the paint look. It reminds of an add.

Dec 09 07 01:22 am Link

Photographer

K E E L I N G

Posts: 39894

Peoria, Illinois, US

I think Jillian left us to go to www.weather.com to look for a sunny day to shoot!  smile

Dec 09 07 01:22 am Link

Photographer

K E E L I N G

Posts: 39894

Peoria, Illinois, US

Jillian Keats wrote:

That's really awesome.

The point of me wanting a sunny day rather than an overcast one is merely to blend with the mood I'm trying to create.  If I plan to add a wide-angle shot that placed the model in front of the sky and I'm trying to convey brightness, I'd like the sky to blend with that. 

But that's neither here nor there.

I think what we are trying to say Jillian, is if you shoot in the middle of the day, with harsh sunlight, unless you're extremely creative, or using something huge to diffuse the Sun, your shots are going to come out looking like snapshots.  Control of light is what it's all about.  NOTHING is more important than light in photography.

Dec 09 07 01:26 am Link

Photographer

LeDeux Art

Posts: 50123

San Ramon, California, US

Chris Keeling wrote:
You don't need extra lights.  Overcast days provide plenty of light.  Look at my port, maybe 1 out of probably 70 outdoor shots in my port used and sort of artificial light source.  Pretty much all of them were done by putting the model in proper relation to the sun.  Very few of them did I even use a reflector. 

No crying about can't afford a reflector either.  smile  I go to walmart and spend $3 on white foam board, and then wrap aluminum foil around it.

and the buildings you shoot around act as great reflectors as well, light is truly a marvelous thing but I prefer the sun to pop out of those clouds as i like harsh light and shadows

Dec 09 07 01:26 am Link

Photographer

Lost Coast Photo

Posts: 2691

Ferndale, California, US

Actually, I much prefer to shoot on cloudy days.  My avatar was shot in the rain.

Bright sunlight can be far too harsh, with shadows in the wrong places.  It can also blow out highlights (digital) or leave deep, dark shadows without detail (film).  It's possible to compensate to a point, but takes some experience and skill to do so.

Shooting on cloudy days wil give you nice even light.  On days with thin cloud cover you'll still get plenty of dimensionality, but with heavy overcast it may be a little flat.  Often you'll need to kick up the contrast a little, either in Photoshop or (with film) by overdeveloping 10 percent or so or kicking up the contrast grade of the paper a notch.

Play with it, and look at the tonal range of photos taken in sunny and cloudy conditions.  See if you've got detail in both darks and lights.  You'll learn if you really look closely.

Dec 09 07 01:27 am Link

Photographer

K E E L I N G

Posts: 39894

Peoria, Illinois, US

Legacys 7 wrote:

Me likes. I've looked at some of your stuff before. I like the paint look. It reminds of an add.

Thanks, and likewise!  I've known about the image you posted here for quite awhile, it's VERY cool!

Dec 09 07 01:28 am Link

Photographer

K E E L I N G

Posts: 39894

Peoria, Illinois, US

LeDeux Art wrote:

and the buildings you shoot around act as great reflectors as well, light is truly a marvelous thing but I prefer the sun to pop out of those clouds as i like harsh light and shadows

Yeah, but your Jonathan Ledeux, and you know things the rest of us just don't know!  smile

Dec 09 07 01:29 am Link

Photographer

Legacys 7

Posts: 33899

San Francisco, California, US

Jillian Keats wrote:

That's really awesome.

The point of me wanting a sunny day rather than an overcast one is merely to blend with the mood I'm trying to create.  If I plan to add a wide-angle shot that placed the model in front of the sky and I'm trying to convey brightness, I'd like the sky to blend with that. 

But that's neither here nor there.

Thank you. Your reason for the sunlight is the exact same reason why I like overcast, moods. I think that you are out of luck during the winter season over in the east coast. During the summer season here, the sun is plenty, but I try to avoid it. Thank god for the fog that we have here. But the sun can be your friend too if you use flash to over power the sun. It can give you a surreal look. I haven't used this technique yet. I do have a shot of a model in my port that was taken on a bright sunny day. I didn't like the bright conditions, but I used it to my advantage. The shadow complimented the model and location.

Dec 09 07 01:29 am Link

Photographer

LeDeux Art

Posts: 50123

San Ramon, California, US

Legacys 7 wrote:

Me likes. I've looked at some of your stuff before. I like the paint look. It reminds of an add.

this is my fave of Chris latest work, its perfect in every way

Dec 09 07 01:29 am Link

Photographer

c_d_s

Posts: 7771

Lubbock, Texas, US

You're getting, for free, not the biggest soft box in the world, but a soft box bigger than the world.

What's not to like?

Dec 09 07 01:31 am Link

Photographer

Lumigraphics

Posts: 32780

Detroit, Michigan, US

Jillian Keats wrote:
That's really awesome.

The point of me wanting a sunny day rather than an overcast one is merely to blend with the mood I'm trying to create.  If I plan to add a wide-angle shot that placed the model in front of the sky and I'm trying to convey brightness, I'd like the sky to blend with that. 

But that's neither here nor there.

Chris Keeling wrote:
I think what we are trying to say Jillian, is if you shoot in the middle of the day, with harsh sunlight, unless you're extremely creative, or using something huge to diffuse the Sun, your shots are going to come out looking like snapshots.  Control of light is what it's all about.  NOTHING is more important than light in photography.

I'm not sure I would go that far. Maybe its my experience as a landscape shooter but a good photographer should be able to get something usable in pretty much any light. There is no way I'm gonna drive for hours to shoot someplace only to bag it because of direct sunlight.

https://www.lumigraphics.com/models/images/chuck_golfing_XXXVI-600.jpg

Direct sunlight, around 11am. I can't see how a cloudy day would have helped this image. I did use a Sunpak 622 for fill though smile

Dec 09 07 01:32 am Link

Photographer

Legacys 7

Posts: 33899

San Francisco, California, US

Chris Keeling wrote:

You don't need extra lights.  Overcast days provide plenty of light.  Look at my port, maybe 1 out of probably 70 outdoor shots in my port used and sort of artificial light source.  Pretty much all of them were done by putting the model in proper relation to the sun.  Very few of them did I even use a reflector. 

No crying about can't afford a reflector either.  smile  I go to walmart and spend $3 on white foam board, and then wrap aluminum foil around it.

ditto. I didn't use any light here.

Dec 09 07 01:33 am Link

Photographer

Legacys 7

Posts: 33899

San Francisco, California, US

Chris Keeling wrote:

Thanks, and likewise!  I've known about the image you posted here for quite awhile, it's VERY cool!

Thank you.

Dec 09 07 01:33 am Link

Photographer

Legacys 7

Posts: 33899

San Francisco, California, US

LeDeux Art wrote:

this is my fave of Chris latest work, its perfect in every way

yes it is. looks like an ad for a style magazine.

Dec 09 07 01:34 am Link

Photographer

LeDeux Art

Posts: 50123

San Ramon, California, US

Legacys 7 wrote:

Thank you. Your reason for the sunlight is the exact same reason why I like overcast, moods. I think that you are out of luck during the winter season over in the east coast. During the summer season here, the sun is plenty, but I try to avoid it. Thank god for the fog that we have here. But the sun can be your friend too if you use flash to over power the sun. It can give you a surreal look. I haven't used this technique yet. I do have a shot of a model in my port that was taken on a bright sunny day. I didn't like the bright conditions, but I used it to my advantage. The shadow complimented the model and location.

thats so true , I use the sun as a fixed light and adjust my model accordinly and then use whatever strobe I have handy to get the mood I want, generally the pop up flash which is not ideal but works for me

Dec 09 07 01:35 am Link

Photographer

K E E L I N G

Posts: 39894

Peoria, Illinois, US

Lumigraphics wrote:

Jillian Keats wrote:
That's really awesome.

The point of me wanting a sunny day rather than an overcast one is merely to blend with the mood I'm trying to create.  If I plan to add a wide-angle shot that placed the model in front of the sky and I'm trying to convey brightness, I'd like the sky to blend with that. 

But that's neither here nor there.

I'm not sure I would go that far. Maybe its my experience as a landscape shooter but a good photographer should be able to get something usable in pretty much any light. There is no way I'm gonna drive for hours to shoot someplace only to bag it because of direct sunlight.

https://www.lumigraphics.com/models/images/chuck_golfing_XXXVI-600.jpg

Direct sunlight, around 11am. I can't see how a cloudy day would have helped this image. I did use a Sunpak 622 for fill though smile

I can still get something out of harsh sunlight, but it's a bear to do.  The OP has already stated she doesn't have artificial light to work with like you did.  The following was done in the middle of a bright sunny day, with no flash.  Just a reflector being held just out of the frame on camera left.

https://modelmayhm-8.vo.llnwd.net/d1/photos/071103/21/472d1d3d9ab02.jpg

Dec 09 07 01:36 am Link

Photographer

LeDeux Art

Posts: 50123

San Ramon, California, US

Legacys 7 wrote:

yes it is. looks like an ad for a style magazine.

definatley, time  or life or somthing, its great

Dec 09 07 01:36 am Link

Photographer

LeDeux Art

Posts: 50123

San Ramon, California, US

Chris Keeling wrote:

Lumigraphics wrote:

Jillian Keats wrote:
That's really awesome.






https://modelmayhm-8.vo.llnwd.net/d1/photos/071103/21/472d1d3d9ab02.jpg

this rocks, thats the way to use the sun on a clear day

Dec 09 07 01:37 am Link

Photographer

Legacys 7

Posts: 33899

San Francisco, California, US

Lumigraphics wrote:

Jillian Keats wrote:
That's really awesome.

The point of me wanting a sunny day rather than an overcast one is merely to blend with the mood I'm trying to create.  If I plan to add a wide-angle shot that placed the model in front of the sky and I'm trying to convey brightness, I'd like the sky to blend with that. 

But that's neither here nor there.

I'm not sure I would go that far. Maybe its my experience as a landscape shooter but a good photographer should be able to get something usable in pretty much any light. There is no way I'm gonna drive for hours to shoot someplace only to bag it because of direct sunlight.

https://www.lumigraphics.com/models/images/chuck_golfing_XXXVI-600.jpg

Direct sunlight, around 11am. I can't see how a cloudy day would have helped this image. I did use a Sunpak 622 for fill though smile

Yes of course a good photographer can do this. But for some of us, it boils down to preference and style. I can use both to compliment my style. This will depend on my vision. The example that I put up is one of the 3 that is part of my work.

Dec 09 07 01:37 am Link

Photographer

Legacys 7

Posts: 33899

San Francisco, California, US

LeDeux Art wrote:

thats so true , I use the sun as a fixed light and adjust my model accordinly and then use whatever strobe I have handy to get the mood I want, generally the pop up flash which is not ideal but works for me

Exactly. A soft box will do the trick.

Dec 09 07 01:39 am Link

Photographer

Legacys 7

Posts: 33899

San Francisco, California, US

This is the image that I was taking about above.^ I used the light to my advantage.

https://img7.modelmayhem.com/070502/00/4638113c92a99.jpg

Dec 09 07 01:41 am Link

Photographer

Lumigraphics

Posts: 32780

Detroit, Michigan, US

Yeah, not having a decent flash really blows in direct sun. I prefer shooting models in overcast though, even though I work in whatever weather conditions I have.

Hopefully the OP will take the opportunity to learn from this shoot!

Dec 09 07 01:42 am Link

Photographer

LeDeux Art

Posts: 50123

San Ramon, California, US

the sun is lighting the model from the left, the truck offers lots of fill and I poped a strobe in her face

https://modelmayhm-2.vo.llnwd.net/d1/photos/071117/18/473f782c7a805.jpg
here I used a very harsh sun to back light the model and used a strobe to balance the shot
https://modelmayhm-2.vo.llnwd.net/d1/photos/071208/02/475a49384250b.jpg

Dec 09 07 01:42 am Link

Photographer

K E E L I N G

Posts: 39894

Peoria, Illinois, US

This is the only other harsh sunlight image I could find.  I just don't get my camera out in the daytime, LoL!

Meg was in bright overhead sunshine, and the ruins behind her were in bright sunshine, but everything inbetween her and the ruins was in deep shadows from the trees.  There was no way to line up this shot right without putting her in a spot that casts BAD shadows on her face.  I used an external flash attached to the camera to try and soften the shadows, but the sun was just to harsh, and I couldn't overpower it.  What you see is about 2 days of dodging and burning in Photoshop to make it look this way, and I'm still not happy with it.  I just love the shot so much, I have to use it, LoL!

https://modelmayhm-8.vo.llnwd.net/d1/photos/070926/12/46fa84d69a152.jpg

Dec 09 07 01:43 am Link

Photographer

Legacys 7

Posts: 33899

San Francisco, California, US

Chris Keeling wrote:

I can still get something out of harsh sunlight, but it's a bear to do.  The OP has already stated she doesn't have artificial light to work with like you did.  The following was done in the middle of a bright sunny day, with no flash.  Just a reflector being held just out of the frame on camera left.

https://modelmayhm-8.vo.llnwd.net/d1/photos/071103/21/472d1d3d9ab02.jpg

that's pretty good considering that you didn't have to use the flash. The sun can be very harsh on pale skin.

Dec 09 07 01:43 am Link

Photographer

K E E L I N G

Posts: 39894

Peoria, Illinois, US

LeDeux Art wrote:
the sun is lighting the model from the left, the truck offers lots of fill and I poped a strobe in her face

https://modelmayhm-2.vo.llnwd.net/d1/photos/071117/18/473f782c7a805.jpg
here I used a very harsh sun to back light the model and used a strobe to balance the shot
https://modelmayhm-2.vo.llnwd.net/d1/photos/071208/02/475a49384250b.jpg

She's positioned perfectly!  The shadows fall on her just right.  Where the heck did you find this girl JL, her legs are killing me!  smile

Dec 09 07 01:45 am Link