Forums > Critique > Want me to rate you on a scale of 10?

Photographer

Digital Blitz

Posts: 2773

Gaithersburg, Maryland, US

Nor-Cal Photography wrote:
I'll take a chance!  Thanks!  Ouch!!!!!   smile

Nice concepts, room for improvement's in lighting and shadows!

Port: 7.5
Concepts: 8
Lighting: 5
Post production: 6

Overall: 6.5

Mar 25 14 06:31 pm Link

Photographer

Seattle photo

Posts: 199

Seattle, Washington, US

I'd like an opinion

Mar 25 14 06:34 pm Link

Photographer

Digital Blitz

Posts: 2773

Gaithersburg, Maryland, US

Jean Pierre Corleone wrote:
Would love to read your critics I believe critiaicm makes people better at they're craft ! Looking forward to your rating

Jean Pierre:
In spite of your apparent 6 pack abs, you will score little low as you state your vital stats as 0-0-0. I am rating people based on their port alone, and your height will be an issue for ramp modeling. And some variety with different expressions in the port will help your cause. Good Luck!

Port: 6.5
Figure: 6
Looks: 8
Expressions: 6.5
Overall: 6.5

Mar 25 14 06:36 pm Link

Photographer

Digital Blitz

Posts: 2773

Gaithersburg, Maryland, US

Seattle Wes wrote:
I'd like an opinion

Wes:
Its a start - a decent one at that. But you have a few miles to track down before you start getting big ratings.

Port: 5
Camera angles: 7
Lighting: 6.5
Conceptualization: 7

Overall: 6

Mar 25 14 06:39 pm Link

Model

Belajai

Posts: 13

Alexandria, Virginia, US

I love feedback. Bring it. smile

Mar 25 14 06:41 pm Link

Photographer

Digital Blitz

Posts: 2773

Gaithersburg, Maryland, US

Belajai  wrote:
I love feedback. Bring it. smile

Jai:
You are a very beautiful model with a rank amateurish port. As is apparent in your website, you are multi talented as well. So what do we need to do...GET a nice port going - a port that is diverse in nature. You need some help in emoting in front of the camera as well.

Port: 4
Looks: 8
Figure: 8
Expressions: 5

Overall: 6

Mar 25 14 07:05 pm Link

Model

Belajai

Posts: 13

Alexandria, Virginia, US

Thank you! I will take your advice under advisement. I appreciate you taking the time to check out my work!


Digital Blitz wrote:

Jai:
You are a very beautiful model with a rank amateurish port. As is apparent in your website, you are multi talented as well. So what do we need to do...GET a nice port going - a port that is diverse in nature. You need some help in emoting in front of the camera as well.

Port: 4
Looks: 8
Figure: 8
Expressions: 5

Overall: 6

Mar 25 14 07:09 pm Link

Photographer

Seattle photo

Posts: 199

Seattle, Washington, US

Thanks for checking out my port, I appreciate the feedback!

Mar 25 14 08:12 pm Link

Model

AaronG28

Posts: 5

Perth, Western Australia, Australia

Rate me smile New face, modelling smile

Mar 26 14 02:49 am Link

Model

caprediem084

Posts: 7

San Diego, California, US

Down for the get down

Mar 26 14 11:17 am Link

Photographer

Carson S

Posts: 101

Birmingham, Alabama, US

I would appreciate any input smile

Mar 26 14 12:34 pm Link

Photographer

Digital Blitz

Posts: 2773

Gaithersburg, Maryland, US

AaronG28 wrote:
Rate me smile New face, modelling smile

Aaron:
You need a diverse port - you have barely started. Get some more shoots under your belt. Right now the numbers I have for you will be discouraging - and I dont want to do that.
Thanks

Mar 26 14 01:13 pm Link

Photographer

Digital Blitz

Posts: 2773

Gaithersburg, Maryland, US

caprediem084 wrote:
Down for the get down

With just 5 amateurish pictures, I dont want to discourage you with 2s and 3s.
Thanks and good luck!

Mar 26 14 01:14 pm Link

Photographer

Digital Blitz

Posts: 2773

Gaithersburg, Maryland, US

Carson S wrote:
I would appreciate any input smile

Carson - its a start - go ahead and get some more experience under your belt.
Right now the scores are low:

Port: 3.5
Camera Positioning: 5
Conceptualization: 3.5
Lighting: 5
Overall: 4

Mar 26 14 01:17 pm Link

Model

RosieDemise

Posts: 64

Shepperton, England, United Kingdom

yes please x. im new so i would like to know what needs improving etc.
thank you x

Mar 26 14 01:22 pm Link

Photographer

Lachance Photography

Posts: 248

Daytona Beach, Florida, US

I'll play.

Mar 26 14 01:28 pm Link

Photographer

Digital Blitz

Posts: 2773

Gaithersburg, Maryland, US

RosieDemise wrote:
yes please x. im new so i would like to know what needs improving etc.
thank you x

Rosie:
For starters, you may wanna get some expressions on your pics. Every photo has you on a half smile. There are several other human emotions - you should be able to reflect them

Looks: 7
Figure: 6
Expressions: 3.5
Port: 6.5

Overall: 5

Mar 26 14 04:25 pm Link

Photographer

Digital Blitz

Posts: 2773

Gaithersburg, Maryland, US

Lachance Photography wrote:
I'll play.

Your port is nice, but your best picture - in my opinion - is in someone else's port (https://www.modelmayhem.com/portfolio/p … 1#33802261). I also would like to check if your camera positioning could be better. Again personal opinion, I like to have the camera positioned at the model;s neck level or lower.

Port: 7
Lighting and shadows: 7
Camera angles: 6
Conceptualizations: 6.5

Overall: 6.5

Mar 26 14 04:32 pm Link

Photographer

Art Silva

Posts: 10064

Santa Barbara, California, US

I quickly scanned through 29 pages of this thread just in case I already posted... didn't see myself anywhere, Soooo Hit Me  wink

note: a lot of my work are scanned analog captures (film) and no post Ps processing other than basic tone, contrast and dodge & burn on Lr to offset possible less desirable scans.

Mar 26 14 06:58 pm Link

Photographer

Digital Blitz

Posts: 2773

Gaithersburg, Maryland, US

Art Silva wrote:
I quickly scanned through 29 pages of this thread just in case I already posted... didn't see myself anywhere, Soooo Hit Me  wink

note: a lot of my work are scanned analog captures (film) and no post Ps processing other than basic tone, contrast and dodge & burn on Lr to offset possible less desirable scans.

Art:
Tu port muchos bonita. You have your own awesome style. But I can't help wondering how you would fare out of your comfort zone - how about putting in couple of different picture just for diversity's sake?

Port: 8
Camera Angles: 8.5
Lighting: 7.5
Post production: 7

Overall: 7.5

Mar 27 14 02:45 pm Link

Photographer

Jarsyl

Posts: 30

Dayton, Ohio, US

Just realized how old this was. I was responding to a post from may. /facepalm

Mar 27 14 02:54 pm Link

Photographer

Kelly R

Posts: 58

Las Vegas, Nevada, US

Me please if you're still playing?

Mar 27 14 06:36 pm Link

Photographer

Lachance Photography

Posts: 248

Daytona Beach, Florida, US

Surprised you like the image so much thought it was okay but never one of my favorites.

Mar 27 14 06:44 pm Link

Photographer

Knight Vision Imaging

Posts: 54

Toronto, Ontario, Canada

I would be interested in hearing your thoughts....  smile

Mar 27 14 06:56 pm Link

Photographer

Art Silva

Posts: 10064

Santa Barbara, California, US

Digital Blitz wrote:

Art:
Tu port muchos bonita. You have your own awesome style. But I can't help wondering how you would fare out of your comfort zone - how about putting in couple of different picture just for diversity's sake?

Port: 8
Camera Angles: 8.5
Lighting: 7.5
Post production: 7

Overall: 7.5

Thanks, but I always believed that your port reflects on your current ventures.
I don't think my photojournalism, sports action, concert, landscapes, street, etc. would be well accepted here on MM.
I did glamour and nude glamour for years but not what I care to shoot (and post) for my art.

Mar 27 14 08:33 pm Link

Photographer

Digital Blitz

Posts: 2773

Gaithersburg, Maryland, US

Jarsyl wrote:
Just realized how old this was. I was responding to a post from may. /facepalm

I loved this picture and some other concepts of yours. Carry on exploring....

Port: 6.5
Lighting: 6.5
Camera angles: 7.5
Conceptualization: 8


Overall: 7

Mar 28 14 03:23 pm Link

Photographer

Digital Blitz

Posts: 2773

Gaithersburg, Maryland, US

kelly melissa wrote:
Me please if you're still playing?

Good, decent, nice. Try to make them, wow!, great, awesome, inspiring etc. I am not too sure about your lighting and shadows - personal opinion.

Port: 6
Concepts: 6.5
Camera angles: 7.5
Lighting and shadows: 6

Overall: 6

Mar 28 14 03:26 pm Link

Photographer

Digital Blitz

Posts: 2773

Gaithersburg, Maryland, US

Knight Vision Imaging wrote:
I would be interested in hearing your thoughts....  smile

Again just my thoughts...

Your port has some good pictures along with many rank outsiders and they need to be weeded out. Lighting also is a challenge.

Port:5
Camera Angles: 8
Lighting: 5
Conceptualization: 7

Overall: 6

Mar 28 14 03:30 pm Link

Photographer

Digital Blitz

Posts: 2773

Gaithersburg, Maryland, US

Art Silva wrote:

Thanks, but I always believed that your port reflects on your current ventures.
I don't think my photojournalism, sports action, concert, landscapes, street, etc. would be well accepted here on MM.
I did glamour and nude glamour for years but not what I care to shoot (and post) for my art.

Good Luck!

Mar 29 14 07:59 am Link

Model

Sim Ulacra

Posts: 10

Madrid, New Mexico, US

me please smile

Mar 29 14 10:28 am Link

Photographer

Digital Blitz

Posts: 2773

Gaithersburg, Maryland, US

Sim Ulacra wrote:
me please smile

Pretty face, awesome hourglass figure with very limited facial expressions. So here goes:

Looks: 7.5
Figure: 8
Expressions: 4.5
Port:6

Overall: 6.5

Mar 29 14 11:27 am Link

Photographer

Digital Blitz

Posts: 2773

Gaithersburg, Maryland, US

Art Silva wrote:

Thanks, but I always believed that your port reflects on your current ventures.
I don't think my photojournalism, sports action, concert, landscapes, street, etc. would be well accepted here on MM.
I did glamour and nude glamour for years but not what I care to shoot (and post) for my art.

Noted. Thanks

Apr 01 14 07:15 pm Link

Artist/Painter

Painter123

Posts: 22

Austin, Texas, US

Mines an art portfolio but would love some feedback.

Apr 01 14 07:23 pm Link

Photographer

NAZM0

Posts: 63

Cape Town, Western Cape, South Africa

Been shooting for 3 months now and added some new pics, took some old ones out.
So why not tongue

Apr 02 14 02:42 am Link

Model

Malina van Leuven

Posts: 86

Brussels, Brussels, Belgium

I am game, just did a bit of an update.
Thx!

Apr 02 14 07:53 am Link

Model

Malina van Leuven

Posts: 86

Brussels, Brussels, Belgium

I am game, just did a bit of an update.
Thx!

Apr 02 14 08:40 am Link

Photographer

Digital Blitz

Posts: 2773

Gaithersburg, Maryland, US

ashstone wrote:
Mines an art portfolio but would love some feedback.

Some very nice work. But your presentation could have been better. Like in this picture https://www.modelmayhem.com/portfolio/pic/34734295 - we dont need to see your face. So I shall give you low marks on Port.

Port: 5.5
Concepts: 8
Execution: 8

Overall; 6.5

Apr 03 14 02:19 am Link

Photographer

Digital Blitz

Posts: 2773

Gaithersburg, Maryland, US

Nazmo wrote:
Been shooting for 3 months now and added some new pics, took some old ones out.
So why not tongue

Very nice port and awesome conceptualizations.

Port: 8
Post production: 8.5
Lighting: 6.5
Conceptualization: 7.5

Overall: 7.5

Apr 03 14 02:22 am Link

Photographer

Digital Blitz

Posts: 2773

Gaithersburg, Maryland, US

Malina van Leuven wrote:
I am game, just did a bit of an update.
Thx!

Nice expressive face. Your FB picture named Redline is outstanding. But er are limiting our ratings to MM here.

Port: 7
Looks 8.5
Figure: 5.5
Expressions: 8

Overall: 7

Apr 03 14 02:27 am Link

Photographer

Digital Blitz

Posts: 2773

Gaithersburg, Maryland, US

Lachance Photography wrote:
Surprised you like the image so much thought it was okay but never one of my favorites.

It is not the best - but better than quite a few in your port.

Apr 07 14 03:52 am Link