Forums > Critique > Critiques for you!

Model

E e v a

Posts: 1724

Nashville, Tennessee, US

Just had shoulder surgery this morning. Meaning I am bored. I will critique you based on items you pick below.

Salty Spitoon Critique- I'll be rough and tough. I'll give you a bad critique. Ill give you a bad critique on top of a bad critique.

Weenie hut critique- This is a nice critique that will be helpful. Some good, some bad, weenie.

Weenie Hut Jr Critique- Ill just tell you the pictures I like, and enough nice brown nosing I can stomach.

...or otherwise state a critique/question you want. Would I work with you? What industry you should do? ETC.

GO now!

Jan 25 13 07:44 pm Link

Model

Nicole Nu

Posts: 3981

Toronto, Ontario, Canada

The Salty Spitoon Critique sounds delicious wink

Jan 25 13 07:47 pm Link

Photographer

Steve Wall

Posts: 644

Sydney, New South Wales, Australia

Hi Samantha, could you let me know what impression you get from my profile text & photos? How do I come across? Who do you think I should be pitching to for paid work? Likewise for trade?

hard to get any distance on your own work when you're looking at it all the time

...steve

Jan 25 13 07:51 pm Link

Photographer

Art Silva

Posts: 10064

Santa Barbara, California, US

It's been a long tiring day so I'll go for the Weenie Hut critique...

Hope you have a speedy recovery smile

Jan 25 13 07:52 pm Link

Photographer

Steves Photo works

Posts: 418

Courtenay, British Columbia, Canada

Pass the salt!!

Jan 25 13 08:05 pm Link

Model

julia00

Posts: 57

Rochester, New York, US

wishing you a fast recovery, please feel free to critique however you feel like!

Jan 25 13 08:06 pm Link

Photographer

juliarabkin

Posts: 782

Rochester, New York, US

oh and this account as well wink

thank you
xo

Jan 25 13 08:07 pm Link

Photographer

Rik Williams

Posts: 4005

Melbourne, Victoria, Australia

smile

Weenie hut critique- This is a nice critique that will be helpful. Some good, some bad, weenie.

If its not pushing the friendship too much, which field can you see me entering... If any lol

Thank you, I hope you feel better soon, shoulders are tricky things.

Jan 25 13 08:11 pm Link

Photographer

Joseph William

Posts: 2039

Chicago, Illinois, US

Can I get a salty spittoon, but with a couple sprinkles of weenie to help the medicine go down?

Jan 25 13 08:12 pm Link

Photographer

JAE

Posts: 2207

West Chester, Pennsylvania, US

I am in the mood for a Weenie hut critique smile

Jan 25 13 08:16 pm Link

Model

Boston Artist Model

Posts: 1159

Boston, Massachusetts, US

I'll be brave and go with Salty Spitoon Critique please

Jan 25 13 08:18 pm Link

Photographer

Fotografica Gregor

Posts: 4126

Alexandria, Virginia, US

I wish you thorough healing and recovery

meanwhile give me whatever makes you happy by way of critique

Jan 25 13 08:20 pm Link

Photographer

DAN CRUIKSHANK

Posts: 1786

Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada

I'll take the salty one please! Hope you have a speedy recovery!

Jan 25 13 08:23 pm Link

Model

E e v a

Posts: 1724

Nashville, Tennessee, US

NicoleNudes wrote:
The Salty Spitoon Critique sounds delicious wink

You wanted salty...

https://www.modelmayhem.com/portfolio/pic/28829660
Why is this image here? Your port has such good imagOtes, then this, where a table crops off your foot, you're centered, and the giant flare from the wood paneling loses the image. Plus the fireplace should be on! Maybe I'm crazy because it's so listed, but to me there's others, yes, even the beardy one, that deserve that attention more so.


Otherwise that's all I got. Your port is salty and rough enough for the salty spitoon. You may enter.

Jan 25 13 08:53 pm Link

Photographer

Bernadette Newberry

Posts: 156

Cincinnati, Ohio, US

Weenie Hut for me, please! Haha. smile

Jan 25 13 08:56 pm Link

Model

E e v a

Posts: 1724

Nashville, Tennessee, US

Steve Wall wrote:
Hi Samantha, could you let me know what impression you get from my profile text & photos? How do I come across? Who do you think I should be pitching to for paid work? Likewise for trade?

hard to get any distance on your own work when you're looking at it all the time

...steve

Profile text is professional, yet relaxed. I like that you have an open mind on TF. I like that you listed rates in your portfolio. While some don't, as a model it can save some of us who don't have that money some time. Rates aren't bad either honestly. But as for the rates, keep them consistent with your website, or make a reason for the discount on your page.

Also, I don't like how so many photos are in your profile. My computer is a garbage machine, and many others are like me, and it will slow down loading of your page, and could lose potential clients. I'd cut it down. Plus its too much scrolling!

As for your photos, you are good enough to where I'd pay your rates. I think your best work is your editorial work, and that story telling ability could help. On Modelmayhem pitching to models is smart, but also consider pitching to make up artists/hair stylists, and designers. Never limit rates to just one party.

Jan 25 13 09:04 pm Link

Model

Maria Susanti

Posts: 546

Banyuwangi, Jawa Timur, Indonesia

Weenie hut critique pleasee

Jan 25 13 09:25 pm Link

Model

Nicole Nu

Posts: 3981

Toronto, Ontario, Canada

Samantha Emme wrote:

You wanted salty...

https://www.modelmayhem.com/portfolio/pic/28829660
Why is this image here? Your port has such good imagOtes, then this, where a table crops off your foot, you're centered, and the giant flare from the wood paneling loses the image. Plus the fireplace should be on! Maybe I'm crazy because it's so listed, but to me there's others, yes, even the beardy one, that deserve that attention more so.


Otherwise that's all I got. Your port is salty and rough enough for the salty spitoon. You may enter.

Thanks! And I totally agree with you.
It's still up because I'm working on getting more glamour nude images before I can replace it with something else.

Jan 25 13 09:55 pm Link

Model

Lela Jesse

Posts: 1148

Shasta Lake, California, US

I'll take salty spittoon Critique please!
( By the way, I love love love that you are doing Spongebob based critiques! "I slipped on an ice cube and got covered in boo boo's! " "Boo boo's eh? I think you want that hospital!")

Jan 25 13 10:05 pm Link

Photographer

Jorge Kreimer

Posts: 3716

San Cristóbal de las Casas, Chiapas, Mexico

Salty spittoon, please.

Jan 25 13 10:14 pm Link

Model

Dominique Banner

Posts: 58

Edmonton, Alberta, Canada

Weenie hut. New model so need something nice for a change

Jan 25 13 10:17 pm Link

Model

Cole Morrison

Posts: 3958

Portland, Oregon, US

I need a Salty Spitoon Critique to go please.

Jan 25 13 10:42 pm Link

Photographer

Art of the nude

Posts: 12067

Grand Rapids, Michigan, US

Samantha Emme wrote:
Just had shoulder surgery this morning. Meaning I am bored. I will critique you based on items you pick below.

Salty Spitoon Critique- I'll be rough and tough. I'll give you a bad critique. Ill give you a bad critique on top of a bad critique.

Weenie hut critique- This is a nice critique that will be helpful. Some good, some bad, weenie.

Weenie Hut Jr Critique- Ill just tell you the pictures I like, and enough nice brown nosing I can stomach.

...or otherwise state a critique/question you want. Would I work with you? What industry you should do? ETC.

GO now!

Whatever you feel like.  smile

Jan 25 13 10:56 pm Link

Model

Miluna V

Posts: 14

Dayton, Ohio, US

Weenie hut critique, Plus what industry? smile

Jan 25 13 11:38 pm Link

Photographer

Folly Photographe

Posts: 61

Montreal, Quebec, Canada

I already critique your port saying what was your best and worst on an other thread. Go as you feel, don't be afraid to hurt of to be kind, I can manage both.

Jan 25 13 11:50 pm Link

Model

Miluna V

Posts: 14

Dayton, Ohio, US

Mistake Please delete this post

Jan 25 13 11:54 pm Link

Model

_eMMe_

Posts: 866

Florence, Toscana, Italy

Weenie hut wiil be great, I need to know my flawless, but what work too!

Jan 26 13 12:46 am Link

Model

E e v a

Posts: 1724

Nashville, Tennessee, US

Art Silva Photography wrote:
It's been a long tiring day so I'll go for the Weenie Hut critique...

Hope you have a speedy recovery smile

Thank you!

The good:

Your art nudes are ahhhmazzinnngggg

https://www.modelmayhem.com/portfolio/pic/20827118

Especially this one. Awesome location. Awesome model. Well done!


The bad:
https://www.modelmayhem.com/portfolio/pic/20768446

While the location is nice, the angle could be a bit more flattering.

Jan 26 13 08:49 am Link

Model

Alixx Rose

Posts: 225

Atlanta, Georgia, US

Salty spitoon! Gimme your meanest..
well don't TRY to hurt my feelings..
=]

Jan 26 13 08:57 am Link

Model

E e v a

Posts: 1724

Nashville, Tennessee, US

New Image Creations wrote:
Pass the salt!!

Salt it is.

Your beauty album frustrates me. SO much potential. Such good make up work. And then there's no playup of the eyes, and the lighting is flat. Also no more cropping off tops of heads! ADD some drama! Its like almost there too.

but with that said, your nude album was lovely. bring everything else to that standard

Jan 26 13 09:48 am Link

Model

Vivant

Posts: 14

Boston, Massachusetts, US

Me, please!  Whatever you're in the mood for!

Jan 26 13 10:11 am Link

Model

E e v a

Posts: 1724

Nashville, Tennessee, US

julia00 wrote:
wishing you a fast recovery, please feel free to critique however you feel like!

Thank you!

You have a very lovely face and great eyes.

https://www.modelmayhem.com/portfolio/pic/31401084
this picture needs to be uploaded a better quality. same with the others like this.

I'd love to see some high end beauty shots from you. Maybe with some bold red lipstick.

Jan 26 13 10:15 am Link

Photographer

TDSImages

Posts: 1017

Salt Lake City, Utah, US

Salty, spitoon sounds about right...

Jan 26 13 10:23 am Link

Model

julia00

Posts: 57

Rochester, New York, US

Samantha Emme wrote:

Thank you!

You have a very lovely face and great eyes.

https://www.modelmayhem.com/portfolio/pic/31401084
this picture needs to be uploaded a better quality. same with the others like this.

I'd love to see some high end beauty shots from you. Maybe with some bold red lipstick.

thank you!

Jan 26 13 10:35 am Link

Model

E e v a

Posts: 1724

Nashville, Tennessee, US

JuliaRabkindotcom wrote:
oh and this account as well wink

thank you
xo

I've critiqued this portfolio without change, so I'll post favorite and least favorite:

Favorite:
https://www.modelmayhem.com/portfolio/pic/31003481
this shot is well balanced, well composed, with excellent lighting.


Least:
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/1 … 72e9d7.jpg
While this is a good shot, it doesn't sell to me as a model. It was all I could pick lol

Jan 26 13 06:00 pm Link

Photographer

dd photography

Posts: 944

San Diego, California, US

HI!

Hit me hard.

Jan 26 13 06:03 pm Link

Model

Kess M

Posts: 8464

Brooklyn, New York, US

salty! bunny

Jan 26 13 06:20 pm Link

Model

E e v a

Posts: 1724

Nashville, Tennessee, US

Rik Image wrote:
smile

Weenie hut critique- This is a nice critique that will be helpful. Some good, some bad, weenie.

If its not pushing the friendship too much, which field can you see me entering... If any lol

Thank you, I hope you feel better soon, shoulders are tricky things.

Thank you!
Alright, Weenie hut it is.

Overall your port is very strong. I see good consistent lighting, good crops, good angles.  It definitely shows you have a strong talent for this. I believe you could do well in multiple genres. You could do fashion or art nudes, or switch to a sole classy glamour, and be successful.

I can't say too much in the ways of bad, but delete these two shots:
https://www.modelmayhem.com/portfolio/pic/30139540 (18+)
Because it just isn't as strong and seems a port filler.
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/1 … aa45f2.jpg
I remember someone else mentioning the nose being washed out. I agree with it.

Jan 26 13 06:23 pm Link

Model

narie

Posts: 102

Sydney, New South Wales, Australia

Weenie hut critique~

2months on MM...that being said... I have multiple images from the same shoot up right now because I can't tell which is the best, but I'd like to round it down to 1 pic per shoot... well I struggle to look at myself objectively, so feel free to axe most of my portfolio

Jan 26 13 07:24 pm Link

Model

Evie Wolfe

Posts: 1201

Nottingham, England, United Kingdom

If you have the time and inclination, I would appreciate a salty critique smile
I hope you recover soon, having had issues with a shoulder myself I know how frustrating it can be! I really hope you aren't in too much pain xx

Jan 26 13 07:30 pm Link