Forums > General Industry > Craigslist question

Photographer

MCmodeling

Posts: 749

Sonora, California, US

I posted this ad for models ad it gets flagged. I get an email saying please don't use craigslist for this type of thing. I see a whole lot worse on craigslist ads.

  Here is a copy of the ad. What the heck is wrong with it.

Bikini model needed for waterfall/dirtbike photo shoot

Looking for a model with at least some who is available weekday mornings is late September or into October for a waterfall/ dirt bike outfit themed photo shoot. This is a two part photo shoot. First part is swimsuit short shorts dress depending on what you have. The second part is a dirt bike outfit I have a new helmet, gloves, boots, gloves, top and pants. There wouldn't be a dirt bike at the photo shoot. Both would have implied photos. Here is a link to my portfolio https://www.modelmayhem.com/mcwhinneyphotography

Please email a link to your portfolio or a head shot full length and a couple poses. But really prefer a link to your work.
I can send examples of the type of photos I'm looking for.
Pay 200 plus images

Please include that your available weekday mornings. What outfits you have for the waterfall bikini/dress part of the photo shoot. If your ok with implied. Also that you know where angles camp is.

Jul 26 21 12:16 pm Link

Photographer

SayCheeZ!

Posts: 20636

Las Vegas, Nevada, US

I'm not sure what your question is but several MM photographers including myself have received the same flag and response for model castings...

... meanwhile in my area there's no shortage of castings for Adult Models, Model to "sit on my face", Cam Girls, OnlyFans models, and the typical scammers that remain on CL.

Jul 26 21 12:33 pm Link

Photographer

MCmodeling

Posts: 749

Sonora, California, US

Just trying to figure out what is wrong with the ad. So I can change it and not get flagged. Not a lot of mm models in the area so i thought craiglist would be a good place.

  I see adult work etc on there. I thought mine was pretty tame compared to others.

Jul 26 21 12:55 pm Link

Photographer

The Other Place

Posts: 559

Los Angeles, California, US

The only thing that seems to be wrong with the ad are grammer mistakes and other unclear sentences.


If you paid for the ad and they removed it, dispute the charge with your credit card provider/bank.

Jul 26 21 02:21 pm Link

Photographer

Motordrive Photography

Posts: 7092

Lodi, California, US

I think there are many (possibly other photographers) that just flag
all posts looking for models. Some people are just dicks and
Craigslist is a magnet for them.

Jul 26 21 02:47 pm Link

Photographer

Beyond Boudoir Photo

Posts: 416

Portland, Oregon, US

I put an ad on CL a few weeks ago that was pretty tame and got several responses from local models.  Over half were fine with nude photography after I explained the details in my first private email.   I was happy that the ad was not deleted immediately.

Sadly, it was removed two days later and I got the same message asking me not to place ads like that again.  The message said that my credit card transaction would be refunded as a courtesy.

Since the ad wasn't deleted immediately, I think we can assume that no algorithm or AI was involved in its removal.    Maybe other photographers were responsible, but that seems odd, since we are not very competitive in this area when it comes to hiring models.  We often refer models to each other, in fact.

Like so many other tech platforms, Craigslist remains a mystery to me, something like the Bermuda Triangle.

Jul 26 21 03:18 pm Link

Photographer

MN Photography

Posts: 1432

Chicago, Illinois, US

I used to use CL a lot, but in the past couple of years, it's been my experience that just about any photographer looking for models ads gets flagged. 

I recently posted a totally bare bones ad - no photos or links, just "Photographer looking for models for a paid shoot".  This seemed to stay under the radar and stayed up for the duration.  In addition to a few models, I got one response from someone telling me that photographers are predators and that the police will be watching me.  I also had one model set up a shoot and then back out because "she doesn't know what kind of person I am".

A lot of people are obsessed with murder documentary shows, blogs and podcasts.  There have been a few prominent murder stories where the murderer posed as a photographer to lure their victims.  Some of these stories are 20-40 years old, but they keep being recycled by these murder obsessives, so some people seem to think that models are being murdered left and right by photographers.  CL might be a popular target for online vigilantes.

Jul 26 21 05:45 pm Link

Photographer

AE Photography

Posts: 217

Quartzsite, Arizona, US

It does happen and not just in decades past. A young woman was murdered in a motel in Portland (OR) a few years back. She had an MM profile. I didn't follow the story enough to know the details of the murder.

Jul 26 21 06:08 pm Link

Photographer

SayCheeZ!

Posts: 20636

Las Vegas, Nevada, US

MN Photography wrote:
I also had one model set up a shoot and then back out because "she doesn't know what kind of person I am".

I had the same thing happen to me. except it was right here on MM!
The model agreed to pose for a workshop (with three other models).  Then a month later, with less than a few hours until the event started she sent me a message declining for the same reason that's posted above.

The strange thing is she did a shoot with at least one 'photographer' that's questionable at best (was removed from MM). Meanwhile my MM portfolio is more detailed and has more references and credits shown than most photographers have... and the workshop she was supposed to pose for displayed all of the photographers that were going, including a few she's shot with before.

It worked out fine though, I got a model that never posed before to replace her and she had a blast, and has since contacted me to see if she can come back to LV and do it again.  (She was passing through from Colorado).

Jul 26 21 06:14 pm Link

Photographer

SayCheeZ!

Posts: 20636

Las Vegas, Nevada, US

Ironically, practically every time I do get a post that stays up for awhile on CL, I get a slew of 'catfish' contacting me.

For those that aren't familiar, a Catfish is typically a pathetic lonely masturbating adolescent boy or and equally pathetic lonely older man living vicariously online as an attractive female.  There's many reasons they do this, but it's pretty much because they have terrible social skills and find the need to talk to somebody.

They usually give themselves away by quite rapidly changing the subject from doing a photo shoot to writing about sexual encounters and saying 'how horny they're getting just thinking about modeling'.

I 'll call their bluff immediately.  Yesterday I had a weird thing happen after I called one of them out (not photography related though).  He admitted he was a catfish and was sort of addicted to doing it and wanted to know how to stop.

The cure is simple.  It doesn't require any medications or 12 step programs.  Just getting out of the house, more importantly get away from the computer, and actually go out and do something, whether it be going for a walk, movie, dinner, to the park.... just get out.

Jul 26 21 06:31 pm Link

Photographer

SayCheeZ!

Posts: 20636

Las Vegas, Nevada, US

Beyond Boudoir wrote:
Since the ad wasn't deleted immediately, I think we can assume that no algorithm or AI was involved in its removal...
...Like so many other tech platforms, Craigslist remains a mystery to me, something like the Bermuda Triangle.

That's why CL is so F'd up!
The scammers and spammers will flag every ad they see as competition so that only the ads from scammers and spammers remain, and the good, legitimate people are pretty much banned.

The first time your ad is flagged and removed, you may still have a good chance of putting up another one and having it stick.
If it's flagged again, you're on the radar.  You may still be successful in putting an ad up with similar wording or in a totally different category,   If you're flagged again it's virtually impossible to get an ad to stick in ANY category, at least for a few months.

Best bet is to sign in using a different email account and NOT making ads worded like the previous ones. It's not a guarantee, but it usually works at least for a little while.  VPN's and removing cookies may help or hinder the process.  CL can easily spot most of 'em.

Jul 26 21 06:43 pm Link

Artist/Painter

Hunter GWPB

Posts: 8259

King of Prussia, Pennsylvania, US

MCmodeling wrote:
Here is a copy of the ad. What the heck is wrong with it.

Given your lack of attention to grammar and clarity, I never would have read that ad and expected that a professional was posting it.  I am not saying this to insult you, and I don't think perfect English would be required, but the first indicator that someone is a scammer is bad English.

That you were looking for a bikini shoot; dirt bike images without a dirt bike; and that you used the word "implied," there is no way that the post isn't going to be flagged on Craig's List.

Jul 26 21 09:13 pm Link

Photographer

Paolo D Photography

Posts: 11502

San Francisco, California, US

if you remember how craigslist was a decade ago you will enjoy this:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=drANWRQ1exs

i will never understand why people ask on model mayhem; how to book shoots using another website, or complain about another site theyre using unsuccessfully ...which is not designed specifically for booking photoshoots.

if everyone ONLY uses MM to book shoots, then MM will be awesome again and no one will have anything to complain about when it comes to finding talent to collaborate with.

Hunter  GWPB wrote:
That you were looking for a bikini shoot; dirt bike images without a dirt bike; and that you used the word "implied," there is no way that the post isn't going to be flagged on Craig's List.

me want bikini shoot. no bikini will be at shoot.
i take all photos while riding my dirt bike around you in circles.
any use of an actual camera is implied.

photoshop dirt bike in later?

https://p.vitalmx.com/photos/features/5814/title_image/s1600_gomezA_949182.jpg?1518206457

Jul 26 21 10:43 pm Link

Photographer

Patrick Walberg

Posts: 45302

San Juan Bautista, California, US

Paolo D Photography wrote:
if you remember how craigslist was a decade ago you will enjoy this:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=drANWRQ1exs

i will never understand why people ask on model mayhem; how to book shoots using another website, or complain about another site theyre using unsuccessfully ...which is not designed specifically for booking photoshoots.

if everyone ONLY uses MM to book shoots, then MM will be awesome again and no one will have anything to complain about when it comes to finding talent to collaborate with.


me want bikini shoot. no bikini will be at shoot.
i take all photos while riding my dirt bike around you in circles.
any use of an actual camera is implied.

photoshop dirt bike in later?

https://p.vitalmx.com/photos/features/5814/title_image/s1600_gomezA_949182.jpg?1518206457

THIS!!!!!! 

Although I used to use it, I've grown tired of the games dealing with Craigslist.

Jul 26 21 11:12 pm Link

Artist/Painter

Hunter GWPB

Posts: 8259

King of Prussia, Pennsylvania, US

Paolo D Photography wrote:
photoshop dirt bike in later?

Sure.  Photoshop it in later.  But it does limit the posing ability of the model.  "Okay, now put your hand on the handlebar.  No, no, your hand is to high. Now it is to low." 

It isn't the point that it can be done.  The point was about how the ad would sound to someone going down the page and why it would be flagged.  Quoting only a portion of my post changes the context.

Jul 27 21 02:50 am Link

Photographer

Paolo D Photography

Posts: 11502

San Francisco, California, US

Hunter  GWPB wrote:
Sure.  Photoshop it in later. But it does limit the posing ability of the model.  "Okay, now put your hand on the handlebar.  No, no, your hand is to high. Now it is to low."

It isn't the point that it can be done.  The point was about how the ad would sound to someone going down the page and why it would be flagged.  Quoting only a portion of my post changes the context.

uh, yeah it does. what?



p.s. this whole thread belongs in Off-topic.

Jul 27 21 03:03 am Link

Artist/Painter

Hunter GWPB

Posts: 8259

King of Prussia, Pennsylvania, US

Your childishness is on display again.

ps:  If you think it it is in the wrong forum, ask the mods to move it.  Posting a concern about advertising for models is not off topic, except for the petulant.

Jul 27 21 05:03 am Link

Photographer

Abbitt Photography

Posts: 13564

Washington, Utah, US

I’ve used Craigslist almost as long as I’ve used MM, and when the reportnicks aren’t active, I have better luck with CL than I do on MM.   I’ve posted almost identical ads for years.   Sometimes, I can post it several times in a year and it never gets deleted, other times it will be deleted in hours.  Sometimes the most tame ads will get deleted where I live yet in other areas ads clearly asking for adult work stand.    It’s clearly a matter of abusive reporting.   I get the impression some of the reporting is from other photographers and some is from people with high reporting ability who see themselves as the moral police.   

One thing I will say is in my experience, ads with links seem to get reported more, I so I always email potential models links instead of posting them in the ad.

Jul 27 21 10:57 am Link

Photographer

SayCheeZ!

Posts: 20636

Las Vegas, Nevada, US

Paolo D Photography wrote:
if you remember how craigslist was a decade ago you will enjoy this:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=drANWRQ1exs

If he gets into any legal trouble he Better Call Saul!!!
   
seems like a take off of Sheffiled Quigley, Professional Myspace Photographer
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hK0r5LCs3DY

Jul 27 21 12:08 pm Link

Photographer

Paolo D Photography

Posts: 11502

San Francisco, California, US

SayCheeZ!  wrote:
seems like a take off of Sheffiled Quigley, Professional Myspace Photographer
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hK0r5LCs3DY

hahaha! thats another one i havent seen in a long time.

Jul 27 21 02:32 pm Link

Photographer

All Yours Photography

Posts: 2731

Lawton, Oklahoma, US

Could be that there is somebody (several somebodies, actually, as one flag won't get a post deleted, just think that all modeling posts are inappropriate.

Jul 27 21 07:00 pm Link

Photographer

SayCheeZ!

Posts: 20636

Las Vegas, Nevada, US

All Yours Photography wrote:
Could be that there is somebody (several somebodies, actually, as one flag won't get a post deleted, just think that all modeling posts are inappropriate.

Al it takes is one person with a VPN where the IP changes with each click of the mouse 'flag' to get a post removed. 
Depending on the setup that could take as little as a few seconds.

After that CL seems to keep traces of the 'offending' post and if anything like it is posted again CL deletes it, often right away before it actually is visible to the users.

CL seems to have a complex algorithm, it's too bad  that it works against legitimate people much more than scammers.

Jul 27 21 09:06 pm Link

Photographer

Scandalous Photo Art

Posts: 1

Phoenix, Arizona, US

Craigslist is HYPER sensitive to being linked to human trafficking and being targeted by the FBI, as Backpage was.  They have gone so overboard with this that even the slightest hint of anything "R Rated" is not wanted.  When you receive the message that says "do not use Craigslist for this purpose", your ad has not been flagged by the community, it has been deleted by Craigslist.. They have algorithms that key on certain words like "nude" "bikini" "nudity" "topless".. etc.   I have always had a MUCH greater response from models on Craigslist than I ever have on Model Mayhem .... My Craigslist ad simply reads "Photographer seeking Female Models" ....... that's it ... I can discuss the particulars with those who reply.   Good Luck in the new age of censorship.

Jul 28 21 09:42 pm Link

Photographer

Aaron Pawlak

Posts: 2850

New York, New York, US

MCmodeling wrote:
"Both would have implied photos"

That was what was wrong with it.

Jul 31 21 05:19 am Link

Photographer

BRIAN D WILLIAMS

Posts: 133

Los Angeles, California, US

Find models using Instagram

Jul 31 21 05:32 pm Link

Photographer

Shot By Adam

Posts: 8098

Las Vegas, Nevada, US

Paolo D Photography wrote:
if you remember how craigslist was a decade ago you will enjoy this:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=drANWRQ1exs

And before he was Saul Goodman, he was Porno Gil

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i9aAmv8F1F0


i will never understand why people ask on model mayhem; how to book shoots using another website, or complain about another site theyre using unsuccessfully ...which is not designed specifically for booking photoshoots.

if everyone ONLY uses MM to book shoots, then MM will be awesome again and no one will have anything to complain about when it comes to finding talent to collaborate with.

Because Craigslist used to be WAY better for booking models than MM for years and years. Even in its prime, I'd run a casting call on here and get maybe 25% of the responses from models that I would on cragislist.

Aug 01 21 12:41 pm Link

Photographer

Tony Lawrence

Posts: 21526

Chicago, Illinois, US

The OP indicates on his profile he has Parkinson.   Maybe the grammar policeman can cut him a break.   Grammar aside his post seems a bit confused but my guess its not why it was flagged.   There are a lot of CL trolls who spend their days flagging even the most innocuous of posts.   Going forward consider having a friend look over you ad before you post.   Check for misspelled words and try to be as clear as possible for what you want.   Personally I'd make the ad very simple and explain to potential  models exactly what you want in an email or text.

Aug 01 21 05:51 pm Link

Photographer

PhotoMike

Posts: 18

Chicago, Illinois, US

I have posted several ads on Craigslist explicitly stating that I am looking for female models for boudoir and nude photo shoots and have never been flagged.

Sep 03 21 01:02 pm Link

Photographer

PhotoMike

Posts: 18

Chicago, Illinois, US

Paola D Photography wrote wrote:
i will never understand why people ask on model mayhem; how to book shoots using another website, or complain about another site theyre using unsuccessfully ...which is not designed specifically for booking photoshoots.

if everyone ONLY uses MM to book shoots, then MM will be awesome again and no one will have anything to complain about when it comes to finding talent to collaborate with..

Probably because many models on MM do not respond.  I was on here for one year before I got my first reply to a photo shoot request from a model

Sep 03 21 01:06 pm Link

Photographer

robotimpurity

Posts: 3

Tucson, Arizona, US

EZRider wrote:
I have posted several ads on Craigslist explicitly stating that I am looking for female models for boudoir and nude photo shoots and have never been flagged.

I'm mystified by whatever triggers it. Before the pandemic, I posted my ad in Seattle's talent gigs specifically saying I do artsy nude photos and it was up for a  month, generating tons of great responses and I ended up having a half dozen fantastic shoots before Covid ruined everything

I have since moved to another city and posted the exact same ad with exact same wording and had it removed by Craigslist. It's very inconsistent and hard to decipher the pattern...especially when ads looking for actual adult work stay up.

Sep 08 21 02:53 pm Link

Photographer

Abbitt Photography

Posts: 13564

Washington, Utah, US

robotimpurity wrote:

I'm mystified by whatever triggers it. Before the pandemic, I posted my ad in Seattle's talent gigs specifically saying I do artsy nude photos and it was up for a  month, generating tons of great responses and I ended up having a half dozen fantastic shoots before Covid ruined everything

I have since moved to another city and posted the exact same ad with exact same wording and had it removed by Craigslist. It's very inconsistent and hard to decipher the pattern...especially when ads looking for actual adult work stay up.

I think much of that comes from user flagging. One market might have other photographers flagging to get rid of their competition and/or moral high grounders flagging anything they think is immoral.   Another CL areas may not.  My area varies.  I’ve had years where an add would get flagged in minutes and years where the same add would run till expired.

I know some people say to avoid words like boudoir, nude, figurative art, etc.  My last ad had boudoir in the title and wasn’t flagged.

Sep 08 21 04:36 pm Link

Photographer

Fred Gerhart

Posts: 747

San Antonio, Texas, US

Craigslist is full of the "woke" generation of keyboard warriors. This just happened to me and before I got the note my advert had ran for three days without any issues.

Some stupid idiotic people that confuse art and porn are simply flagging every advert they see with trigger words.

The really sad thing is Craigslist does not even bother to look at the advert to see if the flagging is justified and to add further insult to injury Criagslist refuses to answer their phone. Therefore preventing a request for a review by Craigslist staff.

I am changing my advert to simply read models wanted. When the email pops in my inbox I will then send them to my website which has the wording for the casting call.

It is what it is.

Sep 16 21 05:14 am Link

Photographer

Fred Gerhart

Posts: 747

San Antonio, Texas, US

Patrick Walberg wrote:
THIS!!!!!! 

Although I used to use it, I've grown tired of the games dealing with Craigslist.

Sorry but MM Is pretty much dead.  Models demanding pay when they only have a five-image portfolio is way too frequent.  And then there is the model that refuses to let things drop. I just had one of those. They answered my casting call and when I replied back that the rate they wanted was not the rate I was willing to pay they started email after email trying to educate me on what a model should be paid.

Models are paid what the photographer can afford. If that's not good enough then they need to move on to agency representation.

Part of the problem is photographers. Some of us are paying way too much for models. I can see $200 an hour and up if you have a rock-solid commercial gig and you are flying someone in but let's be real here.  Most of us don't have that type of work on our calendar or at least I don't. I am shooting for possible art sales. Note the word possible.

Sorry for the rant. I did not  mean to thread jack.

Sep 16 21 05:22 am Link

Photographer

PhotoMike

Posts: 18

Chicago, Illinois, US

SayCheeZ!  wrote:

I had the same thing happen to me. except it was right here on MM!
The model agreed to pose for a workshop (with three other models).  Then a month later, with less than a few hours until the event started she sent me a message declining for the same reason that's posted above.

The strange thing is she did a shoot with at least one 'photographer' that's questionable at best (was removed from MM). Meanwhile my MM portfolio is more detailed and has more references and credits shown than most photographers have... and the workshop she was supposed to pose for displayed all of the photographers that were going, including a few she's shot with before.

It worked out fine though, I got a model that never posed before to replace her and she had a blast, and has since contacted me to see if she can come back to LV and do it again.  (She was passing through from Colorado).

I had on here that I booked for a boudoir and nude shoot.  About a month or so before the shoot she freaked out and cancelled on me through an Instagram post.  The next day she messaged me on Instagram apologizing for the night before and asked if it would be okay to do the shoot but only boudoir.  I told her that that was fine and everything seemed good.  The night before the shoot she messaged me on Instagram cancelling the shoot then blocked me.

Go figure.

Sep 21 21 01:37 pm Link

Photographer

Abbitt Photography

Posts: 13564

Washington, Utah, US

Fred Gerhart wrote:
Models are paid what the photographer can afford. If that's not good enough then they need to move on to agency representation.

Part of the problem is photographers. Some of us are paying way too much for models. I can see $200 an hour and up if you have a rock-solid commercial gig and you are flying someone in but let's be real here.  Most of us don't have that type of work on our calendar or at least I don't. I am shooting for possible art sales. Note the word possible.

Sorry for the rant. I did not  mean to thread jack.

Similar to my situation.  I simply don’t need agency models for my purposes and it certainly makes no sense to pay agency rates for an inexperienced amateur model.    I used to get a lot of TF takers on CL.  More recently I offer moderate rates mostly so I can advertise in gigs and not get flagged.   

I do get a fair number of inquiries that don’t pan out, but at least I get responses on CL, and it’s rare I post an ad and don’t get at least one shoot out of it, often a few.

Sep 21 21 02:01 pm Link

Photographer

Modelphilia

Posts: 1035

Hilo, Hawaii, US

SayCheeZ!  wrote:
That's why CL is so F'd up!

Actually, it's the Feds who f'd it up for CL. They were getting the same sort of flack as the famed old "Backpage" for all the ads seeking/advertising sex. They reluctantly complied and removed all sex-related ads (supposedly). I've been using CL since the mid-90's, and have found houses, girlfriends, cars, lots of work, casual massage-partners, etc, but have more of less given up on finding any models there. I do see some ads for models creeping back in locally here in Hawaii. Not sure how long their ads stay up.

And Craig himself is "the best" – idealistic, effective, and a great contributor to the society at large. Just remember all of the good that he has brought to your life. I've corresponded with him on occasion, and learned that he was answering about 500 emails per day at that time.

Oct 14 21 10:42 pm Link