Forums > Critique > I want to critique your photo

Photographer

J O H N

Posts: 564

San Jose, California, US

submit one, I have no room as I am nowhere near perfect, but shoot, it's worth a try... I might be harsh, I might be brutal, I might be flattering or comedic, who's game?

Mar 31 08 11:31 pm Link

Photographer

TONY S TURNER

Posts: 586

Dallas, Texas, US

Sure why not...
https://modelmayhm-8.vo.llnwd.net/d1/photos/080326/14/47ea91ce50e44_m.jpg

Mar 31 08 11:33 pm Link

Photographer

Wiz of Oz Photography

Posts: 316

Davenport, Iowa, US

Go for it...my avatar with the cheezy background.

Mar 31 08 11:35 pm Link

Model

Lindsey Arnold

Posts: 578

New Orleans, Louisiana, US

https://modelmayhm-7.vo.llnwd.net/d1/photos/080212/21/47b25b7f796c2.jpg

Mar 31 08 11:35 pm Link

Photographer

Seabrook Photography

Posts: 256

Orlando, Florida, US

https://modelmayhm-1.vo.llnwd.net/d1/photos/080331/23/47f1abc0c9129_m.jpg


Ok .

Mar 31 08 11:35 pm Link

Photographer

J O H N

Posts: 564

San Jose, California, US

TONY S TURNER  wrote:
Sure why not...
https://modelmayhm-8.vo.llnwd.net/d1/photos/080326/14/47ea91ce50e44_m.jpg

The bottle looks like a cross  between I dream of genie and a molotav (sp?) cocktail - I would lose the green, and make it more of an amber color... also dig how the wristband or bracelet of the guy appears on his wrist - disappears and then reappears again...maybe id lose her top... and get the guy to shave the pointy sideburns

Mar 31 08 11:38 pm Link

Photographer

Andrew C Photo

Posts: 509

Twentynine Palms, California, US

https://modelmayhm-4.vo.llnwd.net/d1/photos/080329/18/47eebda6d64ec_m.jpg

Aside for the tan lines and tattoos that dont really fit the photo, I still have issues with site compression but its my newest photo and I really like it would like an opinion/critique.  Thanks love your port!

Mar 31 08 11:39 pm Link

Photographer

J O H N

Posts: 564

San Jose, California, US

Wiz of Oz Photography wrote:
Go for it...my avatar with the cheezy background.

the eyes look too funky, maybe thats how they really are... but eeh gads, rotate those bad boys so she doesn't look like close encounters of the third kind. As for thee cheesy background... It reminds me of something I would see if i took way too much acid and stared at a loaf of wonderbread and got vertigo as soon as i was done

Mar 31 08 11:41 pm Link

Model

VettyB

Posts: 207

Chicago, Illinois, US

Me too please! My avatar

Mar 31 08 11:41 pm Link

Photographer

JSVPhotography

Posts: 4897

Madison, Wisconsin, US

https://farm4.static.flickr.com/3012/2376758398_6fe6e0b534_o.jpg

Mar 31 08 11:42 pm Link

Photographer

GARY HINDS

Posts: 605

Greenville, South Carolina, US

WHY NOT GO FOR IT

Mar 31 08 11:42 pm Link

Photographer

Craig Allen Studio

Posts: 4307

Tacoma, Washington, US

https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/080325/20/47e998b388efc.jpg

Mar 31 08 11:42 pm Link

Photographer

J O H N

Posts: 564

San Jose, California, US

Seabrook  wrote:
https://modelmayhm-1.vo.llnwd.net/d1/photos/080331/23/47f1abc0c9129_m.jpg


Ok .

It looks like you wanted to show the strength of the model, yet her expression doesn't convey that - it's more of like are we done yet. I would like to see this model in an environment other then what looks to be a seamless... its ok, just doesn't grab ya

Mar 31 08 11:42 pm Link

Model

bombshell

Posts: 93

Calgary, Alberta, Canada

me please, my avatar

Mar 31 08 11:43 pm Link

Model

Miss Bugga

Posts: 8

San Diego, California, US

https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/080330/16/47effbf3526c7_m.jpg
should i take this off my list of photos?
comments on other photos?

Mar 31 08 11:43 pm Link

Model

Mary Geraldine

Posts: 1697

Valdese, North Carolina, US

https://modelmayhm-2.vo.llnwd.net/d1/photos/080321/01/47e349fe4bb33_m.jpg

Please and thank you.

Mar 31 08 11:44 pm Link

Model

Uber Dami

Posts: 5551

New Haven, Connecticut, US

most normal one i have in my port:

https://img.photobucket.com/albums/v213/uberdami/dancing-2.jpg

Mar 31 08 11:44 pm Link

Model

toyalovelace

Posts: 203

Eugene, Oregon, US

please do me
https://modelmayhm-5.vo.llnwd.net/d1/photos/071216/03/4764dfbf9fbc8_m.jpg

thanks

Mar 31 08 11:45 pm Link

Photographer

J O H N

Posts: 564

San Jose, California, US

Devotchka Productions wrote:
https://modelmayhm-4.vo.llnwd.net/d1/photos/080329/18/47eebda6d64ec_m.jpg

Aside for the tan lines and tattoos that dont really fit the photo, I still have issues with site compression but its my newest photo and I really like it would like an opinion/critique.  Thanks love your port!

In my opinion, out of all your shots, this had the most potential, you have an assignment from me to you, go back to this location... lay off the heavy vignette... and make sure its sharp this time ( if you want to give it an 1800s feel which i almost got from it ) clone tool her tats out this one conveys a mood, go back, revisit it

Mar 31 08 11:45 pm Link

Photographer

jCveraC

Posts: 195

Richmond, Virginia, US

Here is mine... Thank you.
https://modelmayhm-9.vo.llnwd.net/d1/photos/080301/22/47ca2559e217a.jpg

Mar 31 08 11:46 pm Link

Photographer

Wiz of Oz Photography

Posts: 316

Davenport, Iowa, US

John DeFiora wrote:

the eyes look too funky, maybe thats how they really are... but eeh gads, rotate those bad boys so she doesn't look like close encounters of the third kind. As for thee cheesy background... It reminds me of something I would see if i took way too much acid and stared at a loaf of wonderbread and got vertigo as soon as i was done

haha...YES, that is how her eyes REALLY are and that is EXACTLY how I feel about the background!  Bravo!

Mar 31 08 11:46 pm Link

Model

Lindsey Arnold

Posts: 578

New Orleans, Louisiana, US

you skipped me sad

Mar 31 08 11:47 pm Link

Photographer

HarveyT

Posts: 491

Sacramento, California, US

https://modelmayhm-8.vo.llnwd.net/d1/photos/071208/03/475a5147ee699_m.jpg

Mar 31 08 11:47 pm Link

Photographer

J O H N

Posts: 564

San Jose, California, US

Lavette wrote:
Me too please! My avatar

This pic reminds me of a shoot I did a few months ago, every few seconds, the models eyes would be bug eyed like in your avatar... I would chose a similar shot from this series but with less eye... close them for  alil bit, have the photographer tell a joke...its like chris tuckers in "Friday", right before he said " You just got Knocked the %&^% out! "

Mar 31 08 11:48 pm Link

Photographer

J O H N

Posts: 564

San Jose, California, US

JSVPhotography wrote:
https://farm4.static.flickr.com/3012/2376758398_6fe6e0b534_o.jpg

You are like me in your style, it seems you have a lot of different kinds... this isn't your strongest image... It could be made better if it was an ad for a local theater company with the right font of text of whatever play it was and stuff like that... It doesn't stand on its own  as an image, but in conjunction with text, it would be phenomenal, great portfolio by the way

Mar 31 08 11:51 pm Link

Model

Lindsey Arnold

Posts: 578

New Orleans, Louisiana, US

Lindsey Arnold wrote:
https://modelmayhm-7.vo.llnwd.net/d1/photos/080212/21/47b25b7f796c2.jpg

why was I skipped ='(

Mar 31 08 11:51 pm Link

Photographer

Andrew C Photo

Posts: 509

Twentynine Palms, California, US

John DeFiora wrote:

In my opinion, out of all your shots, this had the most potential, you have an assignment from me to you, go back to this location... lay off the heavy vignette... and make sure its sharp this time ( if you want to give it an 1800s feel which i almost got from it ) clone tool her tats out this one conveys a mood, go back, revisit it

Thank you very much!  This one was taken at my house so reshooting will be easy wife just got teeth pulled so it will be a couple days but I plan on shooting it again.  I'll let you know when I do it.  The original was just her stepping out of the shower in a towel and I was like "hey sit down for a sec and put your hands on the keys" took about 5 or 6 shots and that was the end result.  Funny how that works huh?

Mar 31 08 11:51 pm Link

Photographer

David Kirk

Posts: 4852

Ottawa, Ontario, Canada

https://modelmayhm-8.vo.llnwd.net/d1/photos/080320/19/47e2f0cad5af1_m.jpg

Mar 31 08 11:52 pm Link

Model

VettyB

Posts: 207

Chicago, Illinois, US

John DeFiora wrote:

This pic reminds me of a shoot I did a few months ago, every few seconds, the models eyes would be bug eyed like in your avatar... I would chose a similar shot from this series but with less eye... close them for  alil bit, have the photographer tell a joke...its like chris tuckers in "Friday", right before he said " You just got Knocked the %&^% out! "

Yeah. Unfortunately for me, unless there's direct sunlight, my eyes are really really big. All the time. It's a little straining.

Mar 31 08 11:53 pm Link

Model

Autumn Elizabeth

Posts: 44

Grand Rapids, Michigan, US

I'm game =]

https://modelmayhm-9.vo.llnwd.net/d1/photos/080324/12/47e7d199d9ca1_m.jpg

Mar 31 08 11:54 pm Link

Photographer

JSVPhotography

Posts: 4897

Madison, Wisconsin, US

John DeFiora wrote:
You are like me in your style, it seems you have a lot of different kinds... this isn't your strongest image... It could be made better if it was an ad for a local theater company with the right font of text of whatever play it was and stuff like that... It doesn't stand on its own  as an image, but in conjunction with text, it would be phenomenal, great portfolio by the way

Thanks!

Mar 31 08 11:54 pm Link

Photographer

J O H N

Posts: 564

San Jose, California, US

Mar 31 08 11:54 pm Link

Photographer

J O H N

Posts: 564

San Jose, California, US

GARY HINDS wrote:
WHY NOT GO FOR IT

I am not happy with the crop... I wanna see more elbow and the top of her head, i know there arent any rules... but if i want to see an expressionless girl amongst balloons, i might as well see all of her... could be a novel idea with the balloons, maybe if you could backlight them, bump up the saturation or get  a model that actually looks like she breathes  - try fart noises, they work like a charm on any shoot

Mar 31 08 11:55 pm Link

Photographer

Greg Knapp

Posts: 260

Hollywood, Florida, US

Im game...
https://modelmayhm-2.vo.llnwd.net/d1/photos/071019/23/47197a83c09af_m.jpg

-G

Mar 31 08 11:56 pm Link

Photographer

FemQua Productions

Posts: 353

Atlanta, Georgia, US

https://modelmayhm-4.vo.llnwd.net/d1/photos/080303/00/47cb8f7d4ccd3_m.jpg

Mar 31 08 11:57 pm Link

Photographer

J O H N

Posts: 564

San Jose, California, US

bombshell wrote:
me please, my avatar

First, I'd save up $ and get the rest of the shirt  - secondly... your expression looks like you are going to do an impression of Jim Breuer's "Goatboy" with a different expression, and maybe some separation between your dark outfit, and already dark background It could work, in like an Avengers superhero kinda way

Mar 31 08 11:57 pm Link

Model

Lindsey Arnold

Posts: 578

New Orleans, Louisiana, US

wow sad

Mar 31 08 11:58 pm Link

Photographer

J O H N

Posts: 564

San Jose, California, US

Lavette wrote:

Yeah. Unfortunately for me, unless there's direct sunlight, my eyes are really really big. All the time. It's a little straining.

try closing them for  a few seconds and then opening them, or maybe hide it with a hand for a few shots so it doesnt draw as much attention, like the " i'm looking out over the veranda kinda thing "

Mar 31 08 11:59 pm Link

Photographer

J O H N

Posts: 564

San Jose, California, US

Lindsey Arnold wrote:
wow sad

I'm gettin to ya.... yer next!

Mar 31 08 11:59 pm Link

Model

Lindsey Arnold

Posts: 578

New Orleans, Louisiana, US

John DeFiora wrote:

I'm gettin to ya.... yer next!

k *whiping tears*

Apr 01 08 12:01 am Link