Forums > Model Colloquy > Would You Shoot a Model who is a Convicted Felon ?

Photographer

Garry k

Posts: 30130

Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada

Would You shoot with a Model who is a convicted Felon and why or why not ?

( Edit ) And if so - then where would you draw the line in terms of accepting whatever crime they had committed ?


Recently I shot with a female model who had just served a 3 year prison sentence for trying to hack her boyfriend to death with a machette

In her defense though - She was /is quite beautiful ( joke )  and well - she reportedly was high on drugs when the crime was committed .Also reportedly she was remorseful in the aftermath of the crime

A couple of my photographer friends were incredulous that I would do a shoot with such a model and questioned my sanity
- To which I replied that I believed in giving most people ( models included ) a second chance in life - if they are truelly remorseful over thier previoous crimintal actions , And also I did not expect any problems from her during the shoot cus my guess was that she is still on parole

Anyways the Shoot went well and We had fun

smile

PS - No I will not identify this model (even though she is not an MM member )

Jun 24 15 03:10 pm Link

Photographer

ontherocks

Posts: 23575

Salem, Oregon, US

what kind of drug makes you want to hack up your boyfriend?

i'm always a bit suspicious when someone blames it on alcohol or drugs. even if the drugs/alcohol contributed did someone force them to take them?

if she did it because he was trying to kill her and it was kill or be killed then more power to her. otherwise i'd pass.

Jun 24 15 03:17 pm Link

Photographer

J O H N A L L A N

Posts: 12221

Los Angeles, California, US

It would totally depend upon what the felony was.
Violent crimes and theft related, it's doubtful I would.

Jun 24 15 03:27 pm Link

Photographer

Images by MR

Posts: 8908

Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada

If they're beautiful why the hell not...    whatever they did is in the past doesn't effect me.

Jun 24 15 03:37 pm Link

Photographer

Risen Phoenix Photo

Posts: 3779

Minneapolis, Minnesota, US

No, not a good idea!

Jun 24 15 03:38 pm Link

Photographer

Keith Moody

Posts: 548

Phoenix, Arizona, US

Generally, yes, I'll photographer her -- but it depends on the crime.

Jun 24 15 07:13 pm Link

Photographer

Garry k

Posts: 30130

Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada

ontherocks wrote:
what kind of drug makes you want to hack up your boyfriend?

i'm always a bit suspicious when someone blames it on alcohol or drugs. even if the drugs/alcohol contributed did someone force them to take them?

if she did it because he was trying to kill her and it was kill or be killed then more power to her. otherwise i'd pass.

I am only reporting on what i read in the newspaper

I suspect there were other factors involved

I have not spoken with the model about any of this

Jun 24 15 07:15 pm Link

Model

Koryn

Posts: 39496

Boston, Massachusetts, US

People engage in violent behaviors for many different reasons, and sometimes you can't really understand why they would act a certain way unless you knew everything about their life at that particular time, the people in it, the nature of their private relationships. Even the circumstances that led up to the violent incident for which they went to jail.

Also, some do become genuinely awful human beings when they are on drugs. A sober mind and a perspective that has been influenced by having a lot of time to sit in a cell, and think and think some more, does change people.

As a result, I think it's best not to judge felons without knowing them first - especially if they have served their time and resumed functional lives in regular society. People change. Even horrible people.

Jun 24 15 07:21 pm Link

Photographer

Garry k

Posts: 30130

Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada

Koryn wrote:
People engage in violent behaviors for many different reasons, and sometimes you can't really understand why they would act a certain way unless you knew everything about their life at that particular time, the people in it, the nature of their private relationships. Even the circumstances that led up to the violent incident for which they went to jail.

Also, some do become genuinely awful human beings when they are on drugs. A sober mind and a perspective that has been influenced by having a lot of time to sit in a cell, and think and think some more, does change people.

As a result, I think it's best not to judge felons without knowing them first - especially if they have served their time and resumed functional lives in regular society. People change. Even horrible people.

Well stated

Jun 24 15 07:23 pm Link

Photographer

Garry k

Posts: 30130

Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada

Futher I believe that most people ( not all ) have more good than bad in them - thus there is a more favorible opportunity for a positive interaction with them than not

Jun 24 15 07:23 pm Link

Photographer

rowanfoto

Posts: 15

Sydney, New South Wales, Australia

Would you photograph a male model who tried to hack his girlfriend to death?

Jun 24 15 07:26 pm Link

Photographer

Top Gun Digital

Posts: 1528

Las Vegas, Nevada, US

Garry k wrote:
Would You shoot with a Model who is a convicted Felon and why or why not ?

Recently I shot with a female model who had just served a 3 year prison sentence for trying to hack her boyfriend to death with a machette

In her defense though - She was /is quite beautiful ( joke )  and well - she reportedly was high on drugs when the crime was committed .Also reportedly she was remorseful in the aftermath of the crime

A couple of my photographer friends were incredulous that I would do a shoot with such a model and questioned my sanity

I would have to agree with your friends.  Why would you want to put yourself at risk.  Prisons are full of people that violated their parole so the fact she was on parole isn't much a guarantee she won't commit another crime.  The drug problem is just another reason not to work with her.  With so many hard working professional models out there why would you want to work with a model that tried to commit murder.

Jun 24 15 07:46 pm Link

Photographer

Solas

Posts: 10390

Toronto, Ontario, Canada

How would you know? What if you do a shoot with someone, then find out they did a violent crime later? Would you still use the images or associate with the person? Safety aside, how does the law apply in the case of discrimination ?

If you found out, and you cancelled the shoot because of their history .. would that be considered discrimination ?

How does the law apply (in canada) towards that?

Jun 24 15 07:58 pm Link

Photographer

Garry k

Posts: 30130

Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada

rowanfoto wrote:
Would you photograph a male model who tried to hack his girlfriend to death?

Difficult question for me to answer as I do not shoot males

Jun 24 15 08:04 pm Link

Photographer

martin b

Posts: 2770

Manila, National Capital Region, Philippines

sure, Chris Brown still has top hits after beating Rhianna.  I remember Sharon Osborne defending him.  She and Ozzy used to beat the crap out of each other.  Both of them have been arrested but most of us are never in their position.  I think Chris Brown was endorsed by Opera as a model of a good boy.  Not sure I would agree with that part.

Jun 24 15 08:09 pm Link

Photographer

Peter House

Posts: 888

Toronto, Ontario, Canada

Why not. Photo journalists have been photographing gang members and criminals for ages.

Jun 24 15 08:10 pm Link

Photographer

Solas

Posts: 10390

Toronto, Ontario, Canada

I think it would depend on the crime.. violent crime is fairly broad. You can get an assault charge for flicking someone's hat.

What about a sex crime or a rapist? Would you work with them ?

Jun 24 15 08:15 pm Link

Photographer

gorgeous3mikecasa

Posts: 77

Chicago, Illinois, US

Is it illegal?
Is it immoral?
If both no then yes.... (I sound like a computer programmer) smile

Jun 24 15 08:18 pm Link

Photographer

J O H N A L L A N

Posts: 12221

Los Angeles, California, US

Peter House wrote:
Why not. Photo journalists have been photographing gang members and criminals for ages.

But they're generally not bringing them into their private space (studio) to do that.

Jun 24 15 08:46 pm Link

Photographer

Garry k

Posts: 30130

Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada

Solas wrote:
I think it would depend on the crime.. violent crime is fairly broad. You can get an assault charge for flicking someone's hat.

What about a sex crime or a rapist? Would you work with them ?

Personally I would draw the line at working with any sex offender esp pedos

Jun 24 15 08:57 pm Link

Photographer

Boyde Studio NYC

Posts: 26

Brooklyn, New York, US

Ironically it would be ME insisting on an escort for MY safety! :-)

Jun 24 15 09:06 pm Link

Photographer

Culturally Destitute

Posts: 551

Seattle, Washington, US

Sure. Why not?
I may have shot with a few felons, addicts, whatever. I don't do a background check on models I shoot with.
I just make sure they can model.

Jun 24 15 09:10 pm Link

Photographer

Patrick Walberg

Posts: 45205

San Juan Bautista, California, US

With the large number of people I have photographed, I am absolutely sure that I have already shot with felons and did not know it.  The reason being that I don't care what someone did in the past as long as they've done their time.  How they are at the moment is more important to me.   Let's talk about the "here and now" not the past.  Besides, I don't want to waste time or money on background checks.  Can they model?  Or pay me?

Jun 24 15 09:23 pm Link

Photographer

Solas

Posts: 10390

Toronto, Ontario, Canada

Garry k wrote:
Personally I would draw the line at working with any sex offender esp pedos

Agreed, I know that would be my line as well.

Jun 24 15 09:28 pm Link

Photographer

Personality Imaging

Posts: 2100

Hoover, Alabama, US

I've had models help themselves to expensive props and clothes so I would be suspicious.

Jun 24 15 09:28 pm Link

Photographer

barepixels

Posts: 3195

San Diego, California, US

Once while doing research (googling) a model I am scheduled to shoot, I learned she was busted from trying to rob a gas station with some friends few years back in another state.  I ended up shooting her anyway and had a good time and good pics.  No I never did tell her what I learned.

Jun 24 15 09:43 pm Link

Photographer

udor

Posts: 25255

New York, New York, US

Garry k wrote:
Would You shoot with a Model who is a convicted Felon and why or why not ?

I guess that also depends if she is a career criminal or what the nature of her crime and conviction was.

It is easy in the US to be convicted and sentenced of a crime... it's a systemic issue, since incarceration is a very big business in the US. At 2.7 Million US citizens currently incarcerated... 7.2 Million in the system, which included on probation or parole... resulting that 70 Million US citizens have a criminal record... and private prison companies get often up to 90% occupancy GUARANTEE if they build prisons in their rural areas...  it's no surprise that you would encounter a convicted felon who is modeling for you!

For a sexy, comic relief, just watch this Criminal Woman Strips Levi's Ad from 1995  evilgrin  borat

I have done business with people who were incarcerated... I have a few friends that did time for white collar crimes and are cool as fuck and never screwed me over... always being straight up... so... I judge the individual and his/her actions towards me, and not what a corrupt, greedy system tells me about those people.

Jun 24 15 10:35 pm Link

Photographer

Garry k

Posts: 30130

Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada

udor wrote:

I guess that also depends if she is a career criminal or what the nature of her crime and conviction was.

It is easy in the US to be convicted and sentenced of a crime... it's a systemic issue, since incarceration is a very big business in the US. At 2.7 Million US citizens currently incarcerated... 7.2 Million in the system, which included on probation or parole... resulting that 70 Million US citizens have a criminal record... and private prison companies get often up to 90% occupancy GUARANTEE if they build prisons in their rural areas...  it's no surprise that you would encounter a convicted felon who is modeling for you!

For a sexy, comic relief, just watch this Criminal Woman Strips Levi's Ad from 1995  evilgrin  borat

I have done business with people who were incarcerated... I have a few friends that did time for white collar crimes and are cool as fuck and never screwed me over... always being straight up... so... I judge the individual and his/her actions towards me, and not what a corrupt, greedy system tells me about those people.

Always appreciate your input Udor

Jun 24 15 11:03 pm Link

Photographer

DespayreFX

Posts: 1481

Delta, British Columbia, Canada

I draw the line at "she hacked up her last photographer with a machete". Other than that, bygones. smile But I'm not offering to take her out for drinks after, just in case! smile

Jun 25 15 12:16 am Link

Photographer

Jerry Nemeth

Posts: 33355

Dearborn, Michigan, US

I'll let you shoot all the convicted felons.   big_smile

Jun 25 15 01:04 am Link

Photographer

Peach Jones

Posts: 6906

Champaign, Illinois, US

Garry k wrote:
Would You shoot with a Model who is a convicted Felon and why or why not ?

( Edit ) And if so - then where would you draw the line in terms of accepting whatever crime they had committed ?


Recently I shot with a female model who had just served a 3 year prison sentence for trying to hack her boyfriend to death with a machette

In her defense though - She was /is quite beautiful ( joke )  and well - she reportedly was high on drugs when the crime was committed .Also reportedly she was remorseful in the aftermath of the crime

A couple of my photographer friends were incredulous that I would do a shoot with such a model and questioned my sanity
- To which I replied that I believed in giving most people ( models included ) a second chance in life - if they are truelly remorseful over thier previoous crimintal actions , And also I did not expect any problems from her during the shoot cus my guess was that she is still on parole

Anyways the Shoot went well and We had fun

smile

PS - No I will not identify this model (even though she is not an MM member )

I don't like it when people judge me or don't give me a second chance. I try to extend the same grace to others.

Jun 25 15 01:08 am Link

Photographer

martin b

Posts: 2770

Manila, National Capital Region, Philippines

I would love to shoot with Mike Tyson.  My former President, Gloria Macapagal Arroyo (life imprisonment).

Jun 25 15 02:02 am Link

Photographer

Rob Photosby

Posts: 4810

Brisbane, Queensland, Australia

Why not?

I have known a couple of murderers and one or two others who had spent time detained at Her Majesty's pleasure.

One was an assistant at my work. I never enquired about the circumstances of the murder, but he did his work well and never caused a problem.  Another was a neighbour whom I knew well and was a perfect gentleman until he killed his wife and his father and then killed himself.

None were models, but, had they been models, there was nothing in their behaviour that would have made me uncomfortable to photograph them.

Jun 25 15 05:12 am Link

Photographer

A-M-P

Posts: 18465

Orlando, Florida, US

I don't judge people for their past or personal lives. IF they have the look yes I would photograph them.

Jun 25 15 07:12 am Link

Photographer

A-M-P

Posts: 18465

Orlando, Florida, US

J O H N  A L L A N wrote:

But they're generally not bringing them into their private space (studio) to do that.

If you are not comfortable shooting her in the studio you can always shoot them on location.

Jun 25 15 07:14 am Link

Artist/Painter

Hunter GWPB

Posts: 8197

King of Prussia, Pennsylvania, US

Models shoot with me on a regular basis and I have been found guilty of a traffic violation, once.  Not the same? 

I would have to say, if I felt safe, then yes.  If I didn't, then probably not, but not definitely not.  If I didn't feel safe, there would probably be more to it than the hacking.  Not everybody that has been to jail wants to go back.  They very much do not want to go back.  But society pushes to send them back by refusing them housing, jobs, opportunities, peace.  How is that civilized?  How is in nonjudgmental?  How is it even reasonable?  And for a model shoot, it isn't like you must invite the person into your home every day while you aren't there.

It could be a good opportunity to do a shoot with someone that knows how to use a machete.  But then again, she failed, so maybe she doesn't.

If you got caught up in something, paid a price; would you want people to give you a chance?  Or shall we just make every sentence life without parole so we don't have to deal ever again?

Jun 25 15 07:16 am Link

Photographer

udor

Posts: 25255

New York, New York, US

Hunter  GWPB wrote:
Models shoot with me on a regular basis and I have been found guilty of a traffic violation, once.

You are so hardcore!!!  evilgrin

Hunter  GWPB wrote:
If you got caught up in something, paid a price; would you want people to give you a chance?  Or shall we just make every sentence life without parole so we don't have to deal ever again?

America is supposed the land of second chances... unfortunately... the realities of the laws after a criminal convictions are so harsh that you will be barred from certain jobs for life, because you screwed up decades ago.

Good example (and excellent article!) is Mark Wahlberg's situation and him being denied restaurant licenses, because he was sentenced to 3 months in prison, 25 years ago:

"But his criminal record has prevented him from getting restaurant licenses in some states, and made him unable to conduct philanthropic work with at-risk youth. This is why Wahlberg is asking the governor of Massachusetts to pardon his convictions,"

Jun 25 15 09:54 am Link

Photographer

Chuckarelei

Posts: 11271

Seattle, Washington, US

Images by MR wrote:
If they're beautiful why the hell not...    whatever they did is in the past doesn't effect me.

Jodi Arias?

Jun 25 15 10:09 am Link

Photographer

Brian Scanlon

Posts: 838

Encino, California, US

Lizzy Model took an ax
gave her MUA forty wacks
when she had seen what she had done
she gave her photographer forty one

Jun 25 15 10:22 am Link

Photographer

SoftLights

Posts: 5426

New Orleans, Louisiana, US

I would guess that a large percentage of those who have served time do not want to return therefore they would be very careful not to do anything that would violate there parole. I once shot with a model who was on parole and she would not agree to do a location shoot 50 miles from her home without consulting with her parole officer. I would shoot with someone with this background of I felt it were safe.

Would also guess that the boyfriend was a drug user as well and who knows what the circumstances of the attack were.

If this is a real concern remove all edged weapons from the shoot sight and have her tested for drugs.

Another old mans worthless opinion.

Jun 25 15 10:44 am Link