Forums > Critique > 2 Pro Photographers - Honest & Constructive crits

Photographer

kielinski

Posts: 30

Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, US

Get back to work.

Apr 08 08 01:59 pm Link

Photographer

jeffreyLEESERphoto

Posts: 307

PONTE VEDRA BEACH, Florida, US

sosdezign wrote:
Nugget me!!!!!!  Nice body of work you guys have  .  .  .

SOS

NUGGETS AWAY!!!!!!

great shot
https://modelmayhm-5.vo.llnwd.net/d1/photos/080212/21/47b2570d5ab21_m.jpg

My impression of your work - you are def into angles & light, you love skewing the models into the frame of the photo. very rarely doing a straight on shot. nice & consistent in your approach, and it shows up in the location shots inside & outside.

Your avat shot has this, and #4, 7, 9, 14, 19 - all very nice shots!


#11 & 20 are my least fav - the point of view of #11 is kind of flat, nothing jumps out.
And #20 the background is too bright for the model in the shade, she is pretty and wearing red - she should pop out much more.


Great work, best of luck!

Apr 08 08 01:59 pm Link

Photographer

CEEKuno

Posts: 3168

Atlanta, Georgia, US

:::sigh::: c'mon...I'll take my medicine

-Ceek

Apr 08 08 02:00 pm Link

Photographer

S A Martin Photography

Posts: 1337

Portland, Oregon, US

If you are still doing it I'm curious....

Apr 08 08 02:01 pm Link

Photographer

jeffreyLEESERphoto

Posts: 307

PONTE VEDRA BEACH, Florida, US

Lots of replies in the works - we will get to everyone soon!!!

Break time for Jeff & Johnny

back in 20....

Apr 08 08 02:01 pm Link

Photographer

Erica Velasco Photog

Posts: 162

Phoenix, Arizona, US

I'm in!

Apr 08 08 02:02 pm Link

Photographer

steve prue

Posts: 785

Brooklyn, New York, US

oo!  interesting.  love to hear what y'all got to say about my images.  thanks in advance!

Apr 08 08 02:04 pm Link

Model

Rebeca Christina

Posts: 177

Floral Park, New York, US

im in dire need of photographers, with only 3 professional shoots ... please critique me

Apr 08 08 02:06 pm Link

Photographer

Khaos Productions

Posts: 531

North Las Vegas, Nevada, US

i'd love to get some feedback on how we're doing so far...before it gets to a point where i look back and go..."i've been taking shitty photos for five years"

Apr 08 08 02:09 pm Link

Photographer

PM White

Posts: 242

Asheville, North Carolina, US

Please smile

Apr 08 08 02:11 pm Link

Photographer

sospix

Posts: 23798

Orlando, Florida, US

jeffreyLEESERphoto wrote:

NUGGETS AWAY!!!!!!

great shot
https://modelmayhm-5.vo.llnwd.net/d1/photos/080212/21/47b2570d5ab21_m.jpg

My impression of your work - you are def into angles & light, you love skewing the models into the frame of the photo. very rarely doing a straight on shot. nice & consistent in your approach, and it shows up in the location shots inside & outside.

Your avat shot has this, and #4, 7, 9, 14, 19 - all very nice shots!


#11 & 20 are my least fav - the point of view of #11 is kind of flat, nothing jumps out.
And #20 the background is too bright for the model in the shade, she is pretty and wearing red - she should pop out much more.


Great work, best of luck!

Thanx for the look, and the words  .  .  .  continued success!!!!!

SOS

Apr 08 08 02:17 pm Link

Photographer

John-Anthony

Posts: 395

New York, New York, US

I like feedback especially from pros

Apr 08 08 02:18 pm Link

Photographer

ShaolinTiger

Posts: 244

Kuala Lumpur, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia

Do me and do me hard!

Apr 08 08 02:24 pm Link

Photographer

JIC Photography

Posts: 177

Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, US

Waddle Photography wrote:
please feel free to critique my work

Your stuff seems like you just do this as a hobby.. I really cant comment much more as there is really no subject or style to these.. I would try using some flash or getting some outdoor shooting books..

JOHN

Apr 08 08 02:33 pm Link

Photographer

jeffreyLEESERphoto

Posts: 307

PONTE VEDRA BEACH, Florida, US

Ray Vincent Photography wrote:
Feedback pleaseeeee

https://modelmayhm-3.vo.llnwd.net/d1/photos/080319/23/47e1d58fe62dd_m.jpg
My fav

Great triptych - I like the 3 different framing styles of the subject. The last shot on your page has this same style and is also nice & effective.

I'm not so much into the one where the chainsaw just pops out, could be more fun as a stand alone shot
I think the dancer leap shot with the window in the background also works better as a stand alone shot.

I also like shot #3, 6, 13.

The family shot - on the fence about that, kind of cute - but not really in line with the other work - especially the piercings and all that.
A couple shot could go - just not as strong as others.
4, 5, 9 (similar to the one below it) and 13.


best of luck

Apr 08 08 02:34 pm Link

Photographer

Chanel Rene

Posts: 6780

Huntington Beach, California, US

JIC Photography  wrote:

Your studio skillz are great and lighting is good to. I only wish you would go outside and to locations some more.. Your two outside shots are good but not as strong as your other stuff.. Play with lighting and the outdoors and i think you will find something you have been missing for a bit.. All in all a great port and keep shooting shooting and shooting..

JOHN

Thank you!
I'm soooo scared of shooting outdoors. I feel like I'd be wasting the model/mua/stylists time if the photos come out bad. lol
But I'll practice with my son, if I can get him to sit still long enough! wink

Apr 08 08 02:36 pm Link

Photographer

JIC Photography

Posts: 177

Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, US

chrystal Owen wrote:
I would love a few minutes of your time...Thanks in advance!

HI Crystal..

You have a great body, and smile.. Your shots are not the best and not that great. By this i mean try and work with better photographers.. You are good they are bad.. Once you do this i really think you will have a better port.. Dont stop just be more selective in who and what you shoot..

JOHN

Apr 08 08 02:36 pm Link

Model

PamWhite

Posts: 397

Dallas, Texas, US

Pretty please smile

Apr 08 08 02:37 pm Link

Photographer

JIC Photography

Posts: 177

Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, US

KSA photography wrote:
I'll join the line

thanks in advance

You know how to take a good picture. Your subjects and settings could use some work.. If you can concentrate on refining your interaction with the models and get better locations, or more interesting studio shots then you will be on the rite path to a great body of work... all the best

JOHN

Apr 08 08 02:39 pm Link

Photographer

jeffreyLEESERphoto

Posts: 307

PONTE VEDRA BEACH, Florida, US

Svetlana83 wrote:
don't be too harsh, still a newbie smile

Very strong portfolio so far for a "newbie"

Great shots:
https://modelmayhm-5.vo.llnwd.net/d1/photos/080203/14/47a613eb305eb_m.jpg
https://modelmayhm-5.vo.llnwd.net/d1/photos/080308/20/47d33efd6251a_m.jpg

My advice - keep doing what you are doing - keep adding the variety of styles & looks.
Maybe a couple outside, natural light images thrown in - photographers look at the natural shots often to get a feel for how someone looks, before all the MU & Styling & photoshop.

I think you already have some very nice fashion looks, and as someone that shoots a lot of editorial/commercial - you are great for these fields as well.


I know a great chicago photographer - I will PM you his info - check him out!

later, !

Apr 08 08 02:40 pm Link

Photographer

JIC Photography

Posts: 177

Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, US

Emily Rose B wrote:
Me too. I've just got a couple of shoots under my belt so far...

You have an amazing Profile angle to your face.. Soft cheeks and face.. It seems you have a mix of pro and not so pro shots in your port.. The top is alot stronger than the last few shots.. Keep shooting and try to get more pro looking shots up to replace the others.. That can turn photographers off when they see that kinda stuff.. But you have a great face and body and could really do some great work in the correct hands of a talented photog..


JOHN

Apr 08 08 02:41 pm Link

Photographer

Fizzybubbly

Posts: 824

New York, New York, US

ooo do me please smile

Apr 08 08 02:44 pm Link

Model

Svetlana83

Posts: 378

Mundelein, Illinois, US

jeffreyLEESERphoto wrote:

Very strong portfolio so far for a "newbie"

Great shots:
https://modelmayhm-5.vo.llnwd.net/d1/photos/080203/14/47a613eb305eb_m.jpg
https://modelmayhm-5.vo.llnwd.net/d1/photos/080308/20/47d33efd6251a_m.jpg

My advice - keep doing what you are doing - keep adding the variety of styles & looks.
Maybe a couple outside, natural light images thrown in - photographers look at the natural shots often to get a feel for how someone looks, before all the MU & Styling & photoshop.

I think you already have some very nice fashion looks, and as someone that shoots a lot of editorial/commercial - you are great for these fields as well.


I know a great chicago photographer - I will PM you his info - check him out!

later, !

Wow, thanks so much! smile

Apr 08 08 02:44 pm Link

Model

Emily Rose B

Posts: 216

Shanghai, Shanghai, China

JIC Photography  wrote:

You have an amazing Profile angle to your face.. Soft cheeks and face.. It seems you have a mix of pro and not so pro shots in your port.. The top is alot stronger than the last few shots.. Keep shooting and try to get more pro looking shots up to replace the others.. That can turn photographers off when they see that kinda stuff.. But you have a great face and body and could really do some great work in the correct hands of a talented photog..


JOHN

Thank you! I've just started pursuing this semi-seriously, so I've got some more shoots coming up that will add quality and variety. smile

Apr 08 08 02:44 pm Link

Photographer

JIC Photography

Posts: 177

Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, US

KillerShotz Photography wrote:
me please

Don't be too hard only 3 months shooting

For 3 months shooting not to bad... The major issue i have with your work is the models. There is no connection between them and the camera, which means you are not getting them in the mood of the shoot or making them see what you are seeing.. Some shots you could just do with out, and i am sure you know the ones i mean.. Keep shooting, look at other peoples work, and get some how to books.. They help... All the best and keep shooting ..

JOHN

Apr 08 08 02:45 pm Link

Photographer

Image Designers

Posts: 1740

San Francisco, California, US

I would love to hear it.  It would be refreshing and I do have thick skin. 

Thanks,
  Romel

Apr 08 08 02:46 pm Link

Model

Jordan K

Posts: 5523

Toronto, Ontario, Canada

have at me guys.

Apr 08 08 02:46 pm Link

Photographer

jeffreyLEESERphoto

Posts: 307

PONTE VEDRA BEACH, Florida, US

Michael Barrett wrote:
I'm in...

Hey Michael

My fav for your page
https://modelmayhm-9.vo.llnwd.net/d1/photos/080324/23/47e86ee7e734e_m.jpg

Other shots I like - 6, 14, 17, 18, 19

A def theme here, lovely ladies.
Nothing wrong with that.

But a few too many of the stone wall style backgrounds, and a lot of shots with the same framing - 3/4 shots cropped above the knees.

A few like that is fine, but too many and they blend together.
Toss in some tight close ups, maybe some abstract body images, face portraits and some full frame images.

2, 4, 12, 13 - the weaker shots.
If you have more to add, maybe swap these out.

My 2 cents.


takecare!

Apr 08 08 02:47 pm Link

Photographer

JIC Photography

Posts: 177

Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, US

julie-christine wrote:
I would love to hear your honest opinion!

I think you look good in most of your shots.. You could do with out some of these in your portfolio, but you have a great face smile, and your body shot is my favorite, so a great body as well.. I would keep shooting and try and find a style you work best for and work with that for a bit. You have a great lifestyle commercial feel so try and push that.. I would also try and find a little bit more of a pro photographer to work with even if it costs
some$ you will see the diff that can make.. All together great look and images, just be selective to what you use in the end.....

JOHN

Apr 08 08 02:49 pm Link

Model

Alexis2

Posts: 249

Orlando, Florida, US

me please smile

Apr 08 08 02:51 pm Link

Photographer

JIC Photography

Posts: 177

Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, US

Zandrea wrote:
OKies!

WoW... I love your look and movement in all your shots. You have an amazing face and body and look stunning in some of your images.. I would not change a dam thing you are doing, and great choice of photographers you have worked with.. Keep shooting and if you ever get the Philadelphia area hit me up...

JOHN

Apr 08 08 02:52 pm Link

Model

bombshell

Posts: 93

Calgary, Alberta, Canada

me please if you have time

Apr 08 08 02:52 pm Link

Model

Melissa LeEllen

Posts: 18

Atlanta, Georgia, US

I would love some!!! Thanks!

Melissa

Apr 08 08 02:53 pm Link

Photographer

JIC Photography

Posts: 177

Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, US

Patrick Shipstad wrote:
Sure thanks :-)

Come on Man!!! You know your stuff is hot... Great Models, location, lighting etc... Nothing i can say.. All Amazing... If i am ever in Cali i would love to be on a shoot with you....

John...

Apr 08 08 02:55 pm Link

Photographer

IHB Photography

Posts: 502

Queen Creek, Arizona, US

hit me - no studio here.

Apr 08 08 02:55 pm Link

Model

Heather LeStabbityDeath

Posts: 22617

Alexandria, Virginia, US

I like critiques!

Apr 08 08 02:55 pm Link

Model

Blablablabla

Posts: 166

Bergen, Hordaland, Norway

I think you skipped me...

Apr 08 08 03:08 pm Link

Photographer

CMartinPhotography

Posts: 2127

Edinburgh, Scotland, United Kingdom

Hi, I would love your feedback.
Thank you

Apr 08 08 03:08 pm Link

Photographer

tigerfist photography

Posts: 2100

Toronto, Ontario, Canada

ok

Apr 08 08 03:11 pm Link

Photographer

iHartPhotos

Posts: 1263

Calgary, Alberta, Canada

Hit me!

Apr 08 08 03:31 pm Link