Forums > Critique > 2 Pro Photographers - Honest & Constructive crits

Photographer

DollFactory Studios

Posts: 16

Seattle, Washington, US

jeffreyLEESERphoto wrote:

Saw Witken do a speech once - he has a story from his childhood that is an "11" on the creep-out meter.
But great work!

yeah but supposely the decapitated head story is untrue, though either way joel-peter witkin is a photo god!

Apr 08 08 05:16 pm Link

Photographer

Black Eagle Studios

Posts: 99

Why not?  Go on, hit me with your best shot.

Apr 08 08 05:20 pm Link

Model

Shabay

Posts: 1139

West Hollywood, California, US

PLEASE

Apr 08 08 05:21 pm Link

Photographer

Vegas Valley Pictures

Posts: 231

Las Vegas, Nevada, US

why not, have fun!

Apr 08 08 05:23 pm Link

Photographer

Duke Morse

Posts: 943

Dallas, Texas, US

Hit me with it smile

Apr 08 08 06:08 pm Link

Photographer

Lanya B

Posts: 1825

Boston, Massachusetts, US

I'd love to hear your thoughts.

Apr 08 08 07:35 pm Link

Photographer

NewPhotograph

Posts: 249

San Diego, California, US

Please have at it.  Thanks!

Apr 08 08 07:36 pm Link

Photographer

JIC Photography

Posts: 177

Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, US

bombshell wrote:
me please if you have time

I must say you look great.. Your height may be a problem for you in the long run but that should not stop you.. The top of your page is way stronger than the last few shots.. I would say keep shooting and try and work with the best photogs you know.. Stay away from the GWC's, and try and work more with MUA's and hairstylist..

all the best

JOHN

Apr 08 08 08:20 pm Link

Photographer

JIC Photography

Posts: 177

Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, US

Jordan K wrote:
have at me guys.

Hey Jordan.. you have a great look to you.. Very different, in a great way.. You seem to be working and with the rite people.. Keep shooting and i would book you for a job .. Nothing to negative to say..

JOHN

Apr 08 08 08:22 pm Link

Model

crystalking

Posts: 1353

Murfreesboro, Tennessee, US

i'd love to hear your words of wisdom...

Apr 08 08 08:27 pm Link

Model

Rachel Dersham

Posts: 117

San Diego, California, US

I'd love to have not one but TWO professional photographers' advice. smile

Apr 08 08 08:29 pm Link

Photographer

JIC Photography

Posts: 177

Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, US

Melissa Wiggins wrote:
I would love some!!! Thanks!

Melissa

Hey Melissa.. I would say you are off to a good start... I like the last 5 or so shots in your portfolio... They are so much more professional and pleasing to look at than the rest.. You look great the shots are just ok.. Your face and smile are wonderful, and you have a great body no doubt and I am sure you know this or get that all the time.LOL. the only thing i would say is that you should try and work with more pro photogs and be selective to what you shoot,you have the body and look to be that way. I would say you should work more on your facial expressions as in the end I feel that it is the face that makes the shot. Be more engaging to the camera. I wish you all  the best..


JOHN

Apr 08 08 08:30 pm Link

Photographer

Timeless Photos

Posts: 170

Chicago, Illinois, US

Sigh... gimme a go...  Be gentle...

Apr 08 08 08:30 pm Link

Photographer

WANDER AGUIAR

Posts: 490

Las Vegas, Nevada, US

LETS PLAY !

Apr 08 08 08:31 pm Link

Model

JessicaHeidi

Posts: 92

San Diego, California, US

i'm ready, do mine if you get the chance =]

Apr 08 08 08:32 pm Link

Photographer

PhotoSeven

Posts: 1194

Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, US

I'm a willing victim, if you are still offering.

Apr 08 08 08:35 pm Link

Photographer

JIC Photography

Posts: 177

Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, US

IHB Photography wrote:
hit me - no studio here.

Hi..

I cant really comment to much as your type of photography has its place.. I get a feeling like this is a side job or hobby for you. Some of the photoshop work is bad in my opinion, and I am just being honest. I think you know how to take a better than average picture and are good at that.

All the best

JOHN

Apr 08 08 08:35 pm Link

Photographer

JIC Photography

Posts: 177

Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, US

Heather LeStabbityDeath wrote:
I like critiques!

HI Heather..

  I like your look, not what i normally would shoot, but love tats as I have some myself. I think you could do other type of work besides these Goth, Tat, Alt style shots, as you have a great face . The third shot in your portfolio is beautiful 13 and 15 are also very nice and stunning to me.. Keep up the shooting and dont be afraid to try diff styles of work...

All the best

JOHN

Apr 08 08 08:42 pm Link

Photographer

ML Weston

Posts: 879

Seneca, Missouri, US

I'm in if you have time to get to me.

Apr 08 08 08:44 pm Link

Photographer

JIC Photography

Posts: 177

Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, US

SiriTangen wrote:
I think you skipped me...

I think you have a unique look.. I would try and work with better photographers and deff a MUA. You look sleepy in some shots. Also try and work on your face and how you work on connecting to the camera..

All the best

JOHN

Apr 08 08 08:45 pm Link

Photographer

jeffreyLEESERphoto

Posts: 307

PONTE VEDRA BEACH, Florida, US

tigerfist wrote:
ok

You do a lot of series comps, with 3-4 pix. Not sure why you stopped - if that is your thing, might as well do it for all of them.

This is the most effective use of the series comp, you take the viewer on a little story ride.
https://modelmayhm-4.vo.llnwd.net/d1/photos/080407/16/47fa81577486d_m.jpg

I like this one too - not sure if it is supposed to be heresy - but i like to think that it is - yay heresy!!!!
https://modelmayhm-4.vo.llnwd.net/d1/photos/080407/16/47fa83429338a_m.jpg

The newer shots are solo shots, which could be a good change for you, but the images themselves are not a dramatic style shift - so they just feel kind of alone with out their little series friends.

I like #5 too - would like to see more shots of your models, get in closer like that one. Use that camera to make a connection to the model - does not always have to be about the scene.

later!

Apr 08 08 08:47 pm Link

Photographer

JIC Photography

Posts: 177

Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, US

CAMARTINPHOTOGRAPHY wrote:
Hi, I would love your feedback.
Thank you

Man! Come on!! You know you got some skillz!! I love your portfolio. Locations, lighting, models, post work.....Love it all!! Keep it up.. Nothing else to say my friend..

JOHN

Apr 08 08 08:48 pm Link

Photographer

JIC Photography

Posts: 177

Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, US

iHartPhotos wrote:
Hit me!

Sweet stuff.. I think you are a master of your craft and i would continue what you are doing and never stop!!! You have amazing ideas, models and you lighting is amazing.. Your post work is clean and perfect.. Good Things!!!! My fav is # 5 and 10....

all the best

JOHN

Apr 08 08 08:52 pm Link

Photographer

JIC Photography

Posts: 177

Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, US

Now on page 3. Sorry for the long wait all

Apr 08 08 08:53 pm Link

Photographer

jeffreyLEESERphoto

Posts: 307

PONTE VEDRA BEACH, Florida, US

Mark Hanson wrote:
What doesn't kill me only makes me stronger... hit me

Hitting Mark now....

Apr 08 08 08:55 pm Link

Photographer

JIC Photography

Posts: 177

Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, US

dreslin photography wrote:
I can always use one

Fav's are # 10, 12 , and 19...


  I think you are good and have an eye, and have a great set of models you work with, but i see a lack of creativity in your work. I think for me it would be the lighting. Dont be afraid to try diff styles of lighting. Lighting is what photography, and you are good at it dont get me wrong, but just try some different things.

All the best
JOHN

Apr 08 08 09:00 pm Link

Photographer

jeffreyLEESERphoto

Posts: 307

PONTE VEDRA BEACH, Florida, US

jeffreyLEESERphoto wrote:

Hitting Mark now....

Mark,
Really really solid work my man.
Some high stylin' going on, some cinematic role playing, and some good body shots too.
Great variety - the way it should be in a portfolio.

KILLER >
https://modelmayhm-6.vo.llnwd.net/d1/photos/080324/19/47e8343bd7c71_m.jpg

SPOT ON >
https://modelmayhm-6.vo.llnwd.net/d1/photos/080403/13/47f51906d7981_m.jpg

and you look dapper in the vest & tie too.
Some close up shots, basic 3/4 shots, and some pull backs where you work the setting - and work it with other models too.
#2, 4, 7 are all really nice.

If I had to pick a weak shot too axe - it would be #15 - good to show off the back, but the shot does not have the image quality in line with the others - does nothing to add to your page.

Rock on!

Apr 08 08 09:01 pm Link

Model

Jake Ro

Posts: 4

Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, US

Go for it!
:-)

Apr 08 08 09:02 pm Link

Photographer

jeffreyLEESERphoto

Posts: 307

PONTE VEDRA BEACH, Florida, US

Martina Goodman-Withers wrote:
I'm in smile

This shot is sick - just lovely, would make a great fashion spread.
https://modelmayhm-2.vo.llnwd.net/d1/photos/071126/14/474b1d58c1824_m.jpg

And this is a stand out, much more casual and happy then the others - nice to see you can do light & cheer as well as the dark & dour (which you do quite well.)
https://modelmayhm-2.vo.llnwd.net/d1/photos/080404/13/47f660edaabd2_m.jpg


You have a really consistent look in your work, very high quality. And you come as someone that gets into the vision of the photographer and helps create - not just pose.
Who can ask for more than that.

#4, 11 & 12 are also big Favs of mine from the page.

to sum up - some hauntingly beautiful images - cheers!

Apr 08 08 09:04 pm Link

Photographer

JIC Photography

Posts: 177

Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, US

Eric Paul Owens wrote:
Hit me.

I think you have great design and post skillz.. Your port is great, but there are some images that i wonder why you put them in.. 8, 16, and 18?? The rest are great. Keep up the great work man.

JOHN

Apr 08 08 09:06 pm Link

Photographer

Digital Vinyl

Posts: 1174

Sydney, New South Wales, Australia

Knock yourself out. More critique the better

Apr 08 08 09:08 pm Link

Photographer

Natalia Eiras

Posts: 885

Red Bank, New Jersey, US

Can I have one please smile

Apr 08 08 09:09 pm Link

Photographer

JIC Photography

Posts: 177

Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, US

Michelle Webb wrote:
hellooooo, i have not done this in a wile  take a look at mine what should i change? add? get rid of?

I would say that your work is tight, and if you were in the states i would hire you.. NUmber 17 is the only one that does nothing for me.. All of your other work is so perfect and beautiful that this just takes away from the rest . Lose it...I am sure you have something to replace it with.

All the best

John

Apr 08 08 09:09 pm Link

Photographer

JIC Photography

Posts: 177

Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, US

I am out for the night. See you tomorrow at work Jeff.. and Get back to you all tomorrow..


JC...

Apr 08 08 09:12 pm Link

Photographer

jeffreyLEESERphoto

Posts: 307

PONTE VEDRA BEACH, Florida, US

Back for more NUGGETS of beauty in 30 min........

Apr 08 08 09:13 pm Link

Photographer

KinspinPhotography

Posts: 87

STATEN ISLAND, New York, US

I`m in

Apr 08 08 09:43 pm Link

Photographer

Chad Alan

Posts: 142

Apple Valley, California, US

If you guys are still doing this, I'd love to know what you think.

Apr 08 08 09:43 pm Link

Photographer

tigerfist photography

Posts: 2100

Toronto, Ontario, Canada

jeffreyLEESERphoto wrote:
You do a lot of series comps, with 3-4 pix. Not sure why you stopped - if that is your thing, might as well do it for all of them.

This is the most effective use of the series comp, you take the viewer on a little story ride.
https://modelmayhm-4.vo.llnwd.net/d1/photos/080407/16/47fa81577486d_m.jpg

I like this one too - not sure if it is supposed to be heresy - but i like to think that it is - yay heresy!!!!
https://modelmayhm-4.vo.llnwd.net/d1/photos/080407/16/47fa83429338a_m.jpg

The newer shots are solo shots, which could be a good change for you, but the images themselves are not a dramatic style shift - so they just feel kind of alone with out their little series friends.

I like #5 too - would like to see more shots of your models, get in closer like that one. Use that camera to make a connection to the model - does not always have to be about the scene.

later!

thank you so much! the comps were a nice little way of getting in more than 20 images into my port :-D

i appreciate and agree with your advice about getting in closer :-D

(oh and the pope like costumes, it's from an anime/manga erm, tv show/comic book called tokyo babylon. the female artists who draw these characters always choose elaborate costumes such as the ones photographed above.)

Apr 08 08 09:54 pm Link

Model

purtgfgfghyuhfghffghfgh

Posts: 100

Canberra, Australian Capital Territory, Australia

Would love to know what you think of me and what I can improve on...pretty new to modeling and need some good advise! Thanks -Meg

Apr 08 08 10:08 pm Link

Photographer

Tiffany S Photography

Posts: 418

Toronto, Ontario, Canada

I have lots to learn, so I'd love some feedback! smile

Apr 08 08 10:11 pm Link