Forums > Model Colloquy > Whats wrong with a thong???

Retoucher

ANA_Retouching

Posts: 285

Minneapolis, Minnesota, US

James_Cessna wrote:
I have talked to serveral models before shoots to dicuss their outfits for the shoot. Some of them will not wear a swimsuit thong or lingerie thong. Some will. I feel that wearing a thong bottom is almost standard now for glamour modeling. I've also talked with some who will wear a two piece swimsuit but will not wear lingerie. What's the difference? They show the same amount. So my question to you is

1. Would you wear a thong? Why or why not? and
2. Is there a difference between a 2 piece swimsuit and a lingerie set?

All answers respected (because everyone is different) and appreciated.

I know I'm not a model, I'm not at all very suave in front of a camera... But if I were I would be far more hesitant over modeling lingerie versus a bikini. A beach shoot in a two piece bathing suit and not a thong bottom is often looked at differently than a shoot with the model wearing lingerie. I know for a fact that if lingerie photos showed up of me and my bosses saw them I wouldn't get nearly as many patients as I do, if they kept me on staff at all [I'm a home hospice nurse for geriatrics] whereas I would not suffer the same consequences from a swimsuit image.

Jul 06 10 10:10 am Link

Photographer

Jonas Gunn

Posts: 3531

Birmingham, England, United Kingdom

you very rarely come across a legally adult model here who doesnt shoot lingerie, the sexual connotation thing coming through makes me smile too. much like japan, it doesn't surprise me at all that some of the worlds filthiest porn comes out of a nation with such acute sensibilities. i also find it amazing that the fact someones pantied buttocksmight ruin their career somehow.. crazy old thing is contradiction.

Jul 06 10 10:13 am Link

Model

Malin_

Posts: 3902

New York, New York, US

James_Cessna wrote:

Why so? Why does that go out the window. Aren't the principles still the same?

You have GOT to be kidding me....

Catalog shoot for VS = great money, awesome photos, great credit/accomplishment.

Thong/lingerie pics with GWC from Model Mayhem = .... do I even need to explain?

Jul 06 10 10:37 am Link

Photographer

INKEDividuals

Posts: 4023

Seattle, Washington, US

Jenn Whitten-Hancock wrote:

Aw, but some people just like to cuddle and hold hands. That's super fun, too. *Cough*

Jenn,

This is a little "edgy" for me, but I'm willing to give it a try ;-)

Jul 06 10 11:21 am Link

Model

May Sinclair

Posts: 1147

Los Angeles, California, US

A bikini doesn't imply anything. Lingerie implies that you're getting ready to seduce.

Would you rather have a picture of yourself/your daughter/wife/mother/whatever on facebook in a bikini or lingerie? (though neither is probably a good idea...)

Jul 06 10 12:16 pm Link

Model

-Jen-

Posts: 46880

Howell, Michigan, US

James_Cessna wrote:
I have talked to serveral models before shoots to dicuss their outfits for the shoot. Some of them will not wear a swimsuit thong or lingerie thong. Some will. I feel that wearing a thong bottom is almost standard now for glamour modeling. I've also talked with some who will wear a two piece swimsuit but will not wear lingerie. What's the difference? They show the same amount. So my question to you is

1. Would you wear a thong? Why or why not? and
2. Is there a difference between a 2 piece swimsuit and a lingerie set?

All answers respected (because everyone is different) and appreciated.

I'd wear a thong if I had to, but I'd rather not.  They chafe.  I'll end up spending my time trying to yank them out of my ass. 
I'd rather wear cheekers panties, a g-string is fine too.

lingerie sets are typically see-through.

bikini's are not.

Regardless I'd wear either one for a shoot, doesnt matter to me.

smile

Jul 06 10 12:39 pm Link

Model

Isobel Wren

Posts: 1536

Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, US

James_Cessna wrote:

But don't they though, because I've seen some bikinis that are very revealing and generate sexual thoughts. I understand your example about the 15yr perfectly, but I mean in a modeling aspect. Like a 27yr old person difference.

That's the thing though, the example, well, exemplifies why some models feel lingerie isn't appropriate while bikini is. It doesn't matter how old the model is in this case, the example says, "you wouldn't put a kid in one, whereas you could put a kid in the other" 

Regardless of age the model feels that it's inappropriate for some kinds of people to wear the lingerie because of the message that lingerie would send about the person.

Jul 06 10 01:07 pm Link

Photographer

A M Johnson

Posts: 8024

Las Vegas, Nevada, US

Sophistocles wrote:
I don't understand.

If you're doing a shoot that calls for a particular wardrobe and a model won't shoot in it, you move on to the next model.

Why the controversy?

That sir, is the correct answer.

Jul 06 10 01:09 pm Link

Filmmaker

ByeBye100000

Posts: 3548

Los Angeles, California, US

Tom Rinard Photography wrote:
I agree.  I can't get models to wear thongs.  And I also have models that will shoot in two piece swimsuits but not bra and panties.  I'm very interested to see the responses!

I agree, I can't get them to wear them also...they just want to run around naked!  ;-)

Jul 06 10 01:12 pm Link

Photographer

Richard Allen Photo

Posts: 3663

Milwaukee, Wisconsin, US

Val Reese wrote:
It's pretty standard for me... 

I always wear a thong when I shoot.

I used to, but then the models told me it looked like a rubber band on an egg...

~~shrugs~~

Jul 06 10 01:22 pm Link

Model

Bonnie H.

Posts: 300

Nashville, Tennessee, US

K I C K H A M wrote:

I won't pose nude.

And if I decided to pose nude, it sure as heck wouldn't be for playboy.

+1.

Jul 06 10 02:39 pm Link

Model

Belle du Jour

Posts: 42

San Francisco, California, US

Michelle Mignonne wrote:

Damn straight big_smile

If someone were to ask a photographer if they were willing to spend a week camping in the bone dry desert heat to get some shots they would probably say no until National Geographic comes calling for shoot in the desert, or Victoria's Secret for that matter.

Jul 06 10 02:47 pm Link

Photographer

Jonas Gunn

Posts: 3531

Birmingham, England, United Kingdom

Bella del Giorno wrote:

If someone were to ask a photographer if they were willing to spend a week camping in the bone dry desert heat to get some shots they would probably say no until National Geographic comes calling for shoot in the desert, or Victoria's Secret for that matter.

actually, they probably wouldn't.

Jul 06 10 03:20 pm Link

Model

Stellaluna

Posts: 50

Denver, Colorado, US

maybe some models have funny tan lines from regular swim suits and they dont want that showing up in a photo. I sure do, haha

Jul 06 10 04:19 pm Link

Model

liindsay ann

Posts: 1861

Cleveland, Ohio, US

James_Cessna wrote:

Why so? Why does that go out the window. Aren't the principles still the same?

if you were as well known as "victorias secret" you wouldnt have a problem either.. its the concept that your pushing your limits for something unimaginable rather than pushing your limits with someone named "James Cessna"..   

not trying to be offensive at all!

Jul 06 10 04:32 pm Link

Model

Babalon Salome

Posts: 3499

Hamburg, Hamburg, Germany

James_Cessna wrote:
I have talked to serveral models before shoots to dicuss their outfits for the shoot. Some of them will not wear a swimsuit thong or lingerie thong. Some will. I feel that wearing a thong bottom is almost standard now for glamour modeling. I've also talked with some who will wear a two piece swimsuit but will not wear lingerie. What's the difference? They show the same amount. So my question to you is

1. Would you wear a thong? Why or why not? and
2. Is there a difference between a 2 piece swimsuit and a lingerie set?

All answers respected (because everyone is different) and appreciated.

1. Yes.
2. No, not to me.

(European.)

Jul 06 10 04:36 pm Link

Model

Mischa Marie

Posts: 7892

Sacramento, California, US

Maybe some women dont want their ass cheeks flopping around?

Jul 06 10 04:39 pm Link

Photographer

Nicole Nygaard

Posts: 795

Sacramento, California, US

Thongs in my opinion aren't undies, just a piece of string.
It's all about the boyshorts!

Jul 06 10 04:39 pm Link

Photographer

Nicole Nygaard

Posts: 795

Sacramento, California, US

Mischa M wrote:
Maybe some women dont want their ass cheeks flopping around?

Amen

Jul 06 10 04:40 pm Link

Photographer

starkfauxto

Posts: 1241

Rancho Cucamonga, California, US

Jenn Whitten-Hancock wrote:
Swimwear ------> Swimming

Lingerie -------> Sexy time

yep!

Jul 06 10 04:42 pm Link

Photographer

Good Egg Productions

Posts: 16713

Orlando, Florida, US

I think thongs peaked in the 90's and have gone out of style since.  G-strings are even further out.

It would be nice to think that we've progressed beyond the idea that the tiniest string of material covering the naughty bits is hot.  For me, it's about a very pretty pair of panties on a woman that compliments her curves.  THAT'S lingerie.  Not a 6 piece maid costume with a crotchless string "covering" her vulva and anus.

I've recently run into a model who wanted to do a shoot that was nude, but she didn't want to be nude for it.  So I suggested tiny thong and bikini top.  She didn't want to wear that little either.  So I told her she couldn't do the shoot. 

I've got 4 other women interested in doing this series who have no problem wearing the required wardrobe for it (none).


Bottom line is shoot what you want, and keep looking for models who will pose for your idea.  The sea is huge, and there's a lot of fish in it.

Jul 06 10 04:49 pm Link

Photographer

Lumigraphics

Posts: 32780

Detroit, Michigan, US

Ms Selina K wrote:
I do a fair amount of lingerie work, but I take issue with thongs because I hate the damn things. In my opinion there's nothing sexy or glamorous about them, and well your ass is hanging out so not much of a pair of "bottoms" really. I don't even wear them for my fiance (and like myself he's all about the lingerie and me dressing up).

Lingerie and swim wear are different in the regard that lingerie is intimate wear. It implies sexuality more so than a swimsuit, even though they both may show the same amount of skin. It's about the purpose, not the amount of material.

We should do a lingerie shoot smile

Jul 06 10 04:50 pm Link

Photographer

Bella Erotic Imagery

Posts: 188

Dallas, Texas, US

Thongs IMHO are tacky for photo shoots UNLESS it is being modeled for sell. I wont allow even my clients to wear them if it was meant to be seen

Difference between lingerie' and swimsuits is this

Lingerie'- Is intimate wear. Its under wear. Not meant to be seen by the general public in normal conditions.

Swimsuits- No matter how skimpy, is accepted to be worn in public

Jul 06 10 04:54 pm Link

Model

Dekilah

Posts: 5236

Dearborn, Michigan, US

James_Cessna wrote:
I have talked to serveral models before shoots to dicuss their outfits for the shoot. Some of them will not wear a swimsuit thong or lingerie thong. Some will. I feel that wearing a thong bottom is almost standard now for glamour modeling. I've also talked with some who will wear a two piece swimsuit but will not wear lingerie. What's the difference? They show the same amount. So my question to you is

1. Would you wear a thong? Why or why not? and
2. Is there a difference between a 2 piece swimsuit and a lingerie set?

All answers respected (because everyone is different) and appreciated.

1. I'll wear a thong, no problem as long as it's clean/new or one of mine. Umm... I would because sometimes it works for the shot. I'll also wear ruffly panties, g-strings, bloomers, or whatever else, or nothing at all.

2. To me the only difference is that I can wear a swimsuit (with a full, non-thong bottom) out in public where I live, whereas I can't do that with lingerie. Otherwise my comfort level doesn't change.

However, to me there are three levels:
1. Fully clothed (as in something I could wear in public)
2. Covered, but not publicly acceptable (sheers, lingerie, etc)
3. Nude
Those aren't my limits, I really don't care if I'm nude or not, but they do mean different things for where I can pose and where the photos can be displayed (for my own ports).

Jul 06 10 06:21 pm Link

Model

Frances Jewel

Posts: 9149

Dayton, Ohio, US

swinsuit vs lingerie....doesn't matter to me!

thing vs other panties....other panties all the way!! I refuse to wear thongs in my day to day life...so I will not wear them for shoots. They are unsanitary and uncomfortable!

Jul 06 10 06:25 pm Link

Photographer

MLRPhoto

Posts: 5766

Olivet, Michigan, US

Bella Erotic Imagery wrote:
Thongs IMHO are tacky for photo shoots UNLESS it is being modeled for sell. I wont allow even my clients to wear them if it was meant to be seen

Difference between lingerie' and swimsuits is this

Lingerie'- Is intimate wear. Its under wear. Not meant to be seen by the general public in normal conditions.

Swimsuits- No matter how skimpy, is accepted to be worn in public

K I C K H A M wrote:
Why is it acceptable for a girl to walk around outside in a swimsuit but not lingerie? There is clearly a difference-- and that difference is social connotation.

I won't shoot in these-- but I am also not a glamour model.

Just out of curiosity, what's the "social connotation" of this outfit?

https://modelmayhm-2.vo.llnwd.net/d1/photos/100628/12/4c28fb03ad8f5_m.jpg

It's not a thong, and I'll leave it to the viewer whether it's lingerie or a swimsuit.  What's important is, she looks great.

Jul 06 10 11:08 pm Link

Photographer

MLRPhoto

Posts: 5766

Olivet, Michigan, US

Sophistocles wrote:
You wanna be? Let's pretend for an afternoon and see what happens! wink

K I C K H A M wrote:
Is someone going to let me borrow boobs?

I don't consider boobs, or at least any particular size of boobs, essential for a nude shoot.  I suspect he feels the same.  But, how about you pretend he doesn't and come give it a try with me.  tongue

Jul 06 10 11:15 pm Link

Model

K I C K H A M

Posts: 14689

Los Angeles, California, US

MikeRobisonPhotos wrote:

Bella Erotic Imagery wrote:
Thongs IMHO are tacky for photo shoots UNLESS it is being modeled for sell. I wont allow even my clients to wear them if it was meant to be seen

Difference between lingerie' and swimsuits is this

Lingerie'- Is intimate wear. Its under wear. Not meant to be seen by the general public in normal conditions.

Swimsuits- No matter how skimpy, is accepted to be worn in public

Just out of curiosity, what's the "social connotation" of this outfit?

https://modelmayhm-2.vo.llnwd.net/d1/photos/100628/12/4c28fb03ad8f5_m.jpg

It's not a thong, and I'll leave it to the viewer whether it's lingerie or a swimsuit.  What's important is, she looks great.

I can't really see the outfit, actually, so I couldn't tell you.

Jul 06 10 11:17 pm Link

Photographer

MLRPhoto

Posts: 5766

Olivet, Michigan, US

Miss_May_ wrote:
A bikini doesn't imply anything. Lingerie implies that you're getting ready to seduce.

Would you rather have a picture of yourself/your daughter/wife/mother/whatever on facebook in a bikini or lingerie? (though neither is probably a good idea...)

I've shot maybe 40 to 50 models in lingerie.  Perhaps 1/3 at most implied that they were "getting ready to seduce."

I looked; there are 6 images in this port, and one in my "commercial" port with a model in lingerie.  I don't consider any of them seductive.

Jul 06 10 11:18 pm Link

Photographer

MLRPhoto

Posts: 5766

Olivet, Michigan, US

K I C K H A M wrote:
I can't really see the outfit, actually, so I couldn't tell you.

It's a link to the larger picture, which might help.

But, here  (this is even bigger, she should have it):
https://farm5.static.flickr.com/4140/4737933230_36e0b4b127_b.jpg

Jul 06 10 11:23 pm Link

Model

K I C K H A M

Posts: 14689

Los Angeles, California, US

MikeRobisonPhotos wrote:

It's a link to the larger picture, which might help.

But, here  (this is even bigger, she should have it):
https://farm5.static.flickr.com/4140/4737933230_36e0b4b127_b.jpg

Honestly, that looks more like swimsuit than lingerie to me.

Jul 06 10 11:24 pm Link

Model

Amy Rivard

Posts: 19

Los Angeles, California, US

I like thongs. I like my bum. I like them in photo.

Jul 07 10 12:50 am Link

Photographer

Fashion Photographer

Posts: 14388

London, England, United Kingdom

MikeRobisonPhotos wrote:
Just out of curiosity, what's the "social connotation" of this outfit?

https://modelmayhm-2.vo.llnwd.net/d1/photos/100628/12/4c28fb03ad8f5_m.jpg

It's not a thong, and I'll leave it to the viewer whether it's lingerie or a swimsuit.  What's important is, she looks great.

I'm not quite sure what your point is, but that's clearly not lingerie.
The social connotation of it is 'I'm about to jump in a pool'.

This is lingerie: http://www.agentprovocateur.com/lingeri … nders.html

Jul 07 10 05:41 am Link

Model

Maja Stina

Posts: 3622

Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, US

James_Cessna wrote:
I have talked to serveral models before shoots to dicuss their outfits for the shoot. Some of them will not wear a swimsuit thong or lingerie thong. Some will. I feel that wearing a thong bottom is almost standard now for glamour modeling. I've also talked with some who will wear a two piece swimsuit but will not wear lingerie. What's the difference? They show the same amount. So my question to you is

1. Would you wear a thong? Why or why not? and
2. Is there a difference between a 2 piece swimsuit and a lingerie set?

All answers respected (because everyone is different) and appreciated.

Glamour models that won't wear a thong? You're joking, right? Heh.

1. Yes, I'd wear a thong. Not for a glamour shoot, as I don't shoot glamour. I want to be an alternative/fetish model. I'm open to ideas.

2. Yes. Swimsuits have the weird material by your va-jay jay!

Jul 07 10 05:59 am Link

Photographer

Trevor Martin

Posts: 518

Sydney, New South Wales, Australia

It's a female thing.

My wife would happily sit watching me edit through bikini shoots but has an aversion to a similar lingerie shoot.
I found out eventually that it is the "feeling" or theme being portrayed, and it was the fact that the lingerie models had CFM looks in most of the poses. By making the lingerie shots more fun and playful changes the whole "feeling".

Jul 08 10 12:34 am Link

Model

V Laroche

Posts: 2746

Khowmeyn, Markazī, Iran

I would rather be shot nude than with a string flossing my bum. Thongs are trashy and unsexy.

Jul 16 10 04:08 pm Link

Model

Alisyn Carliene

Posts: 11756

San Bernardino, California, US

Hire a nude, implied nude or one that wears thongs smile
I will wear thongs, I love thongs!

Jul 16 10 04:27 pm Link

Photographer

Bill Mason Photography

Posts: 1856

Morristown, Vermont, US

James_Cessna wrote:
I have talked to serveral models before shoots to dicuss their outfits for the shoot. Some of them will not wear a swimsuit thong or lingerie thong. Some will. I feel that wearing a thong bottom is almost standard now for glamour modeling. I've also talked with some who will wear a two piece swimsuit but will not wear lingerie. What's the difference? They show the same amount. So my question to you is

1. Would you wear a thong? Why or why not? and
2. Is there a difference between a 2 piece swimsuit and a lingerie set?

All answers respected (because everyone is different) and appreciated.

I heard a fashion critic say that the thong was on its way out. And that was several months ago.

Jul 16 10 04:29 pm Link

Model

Alisyn Carliene

Posts: 11756

San Bernardino, California, US

valentinesbaby wrote:
I would rather be shot nude than with a string flossing my bum. Thongs are trashy and unsexy.

Hmm. I hate when people say that.. Like one model said I was unclassy cause I model thongs. I think thongs can be presented in a classy way.

Jul 16 10 04:32 pm Link

Model

Christina Connor

Posts: 21

Atlanta, Georgia, US

I'm not a glamour model but I think it's because swimsuits are something you wear in public to swim. lingerie is something you wear for....sexy time. They have different meanings

Jul 16 10 04:34 pm Link